Audit Reports
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Audit Reports
The annual audit reports prepared by the Kerala State Audit Department (KSAD) are given below, year-wise.
Select a year to view its complete Audit Report

Government of Kerala
Kerala State Audit Department
www.ksad.kerala.gov.in
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Audit Report
2024-2025
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone : 0487-2331249
(Registered with acknowledgement due)
No: K.S.A.T.S.R.(P.12)1494/2025
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
Date: 19/02/2026
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone: 0487-2331249
Deputy Director
President (through the Secretary)
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Sir,
Subject: Regarding the Audit Report of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2024-2025.
In accordance with the provisions of Section 13 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, Rule 18 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996, and Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, the Audit Report resulting from the examination of the Annual Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2024-2025 is herewith forwarded for further action as prescribed under Rule 23(1) of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996.
Attention is invited to the paragraphs in Part 1 of this report. Immediately on receipt of this report, the persons responsible for the irregularities mentioned therein shall be informed of the same, along with copies of the relevant paragraphs.
Within one month of receiving this report, a special meeting shall be convened to discuss the Audit Report in detail, and copies of the Audit Report and the decision taken thereon shall be published for public information. (See Rules 14 and 15 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules.)
Within two months of receiving the report, necessary action shall be taken to remove the audit remarks/objections contained herein, and a report to that effect shall be sent to this office within the said period. (See Local Fund Audit Act Section 15(1), Rules 20, 23, and Rule 21(1)(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules, 1997.)
Yours faithfully,
Deputy Director
Copy to:
1) The Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Thiruvananthapuram (for information),
2) The Joint Director, Department of Local Self Government, Thrissur.
3) Office copy.
No: K.S.A.T.S.R.(P.12)1494/2025
Date: 19/02/2026
Audit Report on the Annual Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, for the financial year 2024-2025.
(1994 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, Section 13 , 1996 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, Rule 18, (1994 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act - Section 215(4)) issued in accordance with the above provisions.)
The Annual Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, for the financial year 2024-2025 was subjected to audit. The collection of money under various heads made by the institution from 02-04-2024 to 27-10-2025 and its remittance, as well as the withdrawal of money from various accounts made from 01-04-2024 to 31-03-2025, were also examined.
The irregularities noticed in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Of the 40 audit enquiries issued, replies have been received for 13. The institution shall take further action on the audit enquiries not included in this report.
The irregularities noticed in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Although 40 audit enquiries were issued, no reply has been received.
This report has been prepared on the basis of the registers, records, information and explanations made available by the institution. Only the important observations remaining after the audit remarks were presented at the audit concluding meeting held on 03-11-2025 and the replies thereto were considered have been included in the Audit Report. The Kerala State Audit Department shall bear no responsibility whatsoever for any analyses and observations included in this report that are based on incorrect information or details furnished by the institution, nor for any irregularities subsequently detected by another audit agency/inspection wing on the basis of records not made available to audit by the institution.
(A) Details of Audit Conducted
Officer in charge of audit:
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rafi John | Deputy Director | 28-10-2025 | 03-11-2025 |
Time spent on audit:
| Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|
| 28-10-2025 | 03-11-2025 |
Officers who conducted the audit:
Meera T. (Audit Officer)
Honey K.S. (Audit Officer)
Sharfudheen S.H. (Assistant Audit Officer)
Sivaprasad M. (Assistant Audit Officer)
Joyson C.J. (Senior Grade Auditor)
Ramya K.K. (Auditor)
(B) Implementing Authorities
| Name | Official Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Muraleedharan P.K. | President | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Sreejith K.R. | Secretary-in-Charge | 01-04-2024 | 01-04-2024 |
| Thankamani P.A. | Secretary | 02-04-2024 | 25-05-2024 |
| Sreejith K.R. | Secretary-in-Charge | 26-05-2024 | 04-08-2024 |
| Thankamani P.A. | Secretary | 05-08-2024 | 10-09-2024 |
| Devadas P.S. | Secretary-in-Charge | 11-09-2024 | 03-10-2024 |
| Sindhu K.R. | Secretary | 04-10-2024 | 08-01-2025 |
| Mallika R. | Secretary-in-Charge | 09-01-2025 | 19-01-2025 |
| Devadas P.S. | Secretary-in-Charge | 20-01-2025 | 26-01-2025 |
| Mallika R. | Secretary-in-Charge | 27-01-2025 | 04-02-2025 |
| Devadas P.S. | Secretary-in-Charge | 05-02-2025 | 23-02-2025 |
| Mallika R. | Secretary-in-Charge | 24-02-2025 | 31-03-2025 |
Implementing Officers
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sreejith K.R. | Assistant Secretary | 01-04-2024 | 09-08-2024 |
| Devadas P.S. | Assistant Secretary (In-charge) | 10-08-2024 | 31-08-2024 |
| Sreejith K.R. | Assistant Secretary | 01-09-2024 | 10-09-2024 |
| Devadas P.S. | Assistant Secretary (In-charge) | 11-09-2024 | 22-09-2024 |
| Anitha A.C. | Assistant Secretary | 23-09-2024 | 16-10-2024 |
| Saliha T.A. | Assistant Secretary | 17-10-2024 | 26-12-2024 |
| Mallika R. | Assistant Secretary | 27-12-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Anu A.J. | Fisheries Officer | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Dr. Joby C.L. | Medical Officer (F.H.C.) | 01-04-2024 | 21-02-2025 |
| Dr. Sheryl Benny K. | Medical Officer (F.H.C.) | 22-02-2025 | 31-03-2025 |
| Divya Unni T. | ICDS Supervisor | 01-04-2024 | 17-05-2024 |
| Dr. Siji S. | ICDS Supervisor | 18-05-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Ashok Kumar K.A. | Assistant Engineer | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Dr. Sujith M.S. | Senior Veterinary Surgeon | 01-04-2024 | 23-07-2024 |
| Dr. Jomy John | Senior Veterinary Surgeon | 24-07-2024 | 15-09-2024 |
| Dr. Smisha L. | Senior Veterinary Surgeon | 16-09-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Dr. Blessy K. Dickson | Medical Officer (Ayurveda) | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Dr. Juvel M.S. | Medical Officer (Homeo) | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Jisha K.G. | Dairy Farm Instructor | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Girija K. | Headmistress (G.L.P.S., Pazhayannur) | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Krishna V.R. | Agricultural Officer (In-charge) | 01-04-2024 | 30-04-2024 |
| Ramya K. | Agricultural Officer | 01-05-2024 | 09-06-2024 |
| Krishna V.R. | Agricultural Officer (In-charge) | 10-06-2024 | 09-10-2024 |
| Sreelakshmi K.B. | Agricultural Officer (In-charge) | 10-10-2024 | 23-10-2024 |
| Anand C.V. | Agricultural Officer | 24-10-2024 | 12-12-2024 |
| Anjali | Agricultural Officer (In-charge) | 13-12-2024 | 26-12-2024 |
| Bishara K. | Agricultural Officer (In-charge) | 27-12-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Suchithran P.G. | V.E.O. (Elanad Circle) | 01-04-2024 | 31-03-2025 |
| Suchithran P.G. | V.E.O. (H.Q. Circle) | 01-04-2024 | 20-01-2025 |
| Shuhair Abdul Rahman C.P. | V.E.O. (H.Q. Circle) | 21-01-2025 | 31-03-2025 |
| Sajika K. | V.E.O. (Pazhayannur Circle) | 01-04-2024 | 11-02-2025 |
| Shuhair Abdul Rahman C.P. | V.E.O. (Pazhayannur Circle) | 12-02-2025 | 31-03-2025 |
Contents
| Sl. No. | Part 1 | Paragraph Number |
|---|---|---|
| Part 2 | ||
| Part 3 | ||
| Part 4 | ||
| Annexure | ||
| 1 | Audit Certificate | 1-1 |
| 2 | Loan amount -- amount to be repaid is not accurate as per the Annual Accounts and the Loan Register | 1-1-1 |
| 3 | "Prior Period item" - approved vouchers or worksheets not maintained | 1-1-2 |
| 4 | The receipts and expenditure figures as per the MGNREGS register do not tally with the receipts and expenditure figures in the Annual Financial Statement. | 1-1-3 |
| 5 | The unspent grant balances and the closing balance as per the bank/treasury accounts in which they are deposited do not tally | 1-1-4 |
| 6 | Investment Register is not written up and certified | 1-1-5 |
| 7 | Amounts given as advance have not been settled as expenditure. | 1-1-6 |
| 8 | Audit does not certify the accuracy of the Cash Flow Statement | 1-1-7 |
| 9 | Not all statements required under the Accounting Rules have been included in the Annual Accounts. | 1-1-8 |
| 10 | Authentic certified vouchers and worksheets should be maintained for journals | 1-1-9 |
| 11 | Discrepancies in the Bank Account Reconciliation Statement | 1-1-10 |
| 12 | Property Tax - Annual Accounts and DCB Register do not tally | 1-1-11 |
| 13 | Asset Register - accuracy of assets could not be verified | 1-1-12 |
| 14 | Deposit Register, Advance Register and ACR are not written up and certified. | 1-1-13 |
| 15 | Budget | 1-2 |
| 16 | Fund Utilisation | 1-3 |
| 17 | Plan Review | 1-4 |
| 18 | MGNREGS | 1-5 |
| 19 | Welfare Schemes | 1-6 |
| 20 | Cash Balance Verification | 1-7 |
| 21 | Internal Control | 1-8 |
| 22 | Irregularities in collection of Profession Tax | 1-9 |
| 23 | Grant of licences to trades and industries - irregularities | 1-10 |
| 24 | Rent - irregularities | 1-11 |
| 25 | Auction irregularities | 1-12 |
| 26 | Entertainment Tax - accuracy of receipts could not be ascertained | 1-13 |
| 27 | Mobile Tower - property tax should be assessed and collected | 1-14 |
| 28 | Unauthorised construction should be regularised | 1-15 |
| 29 | Building Workers' Welfare Fund Cess and one-time tax have not been collected | 1-16 |
| 30 | Post-occupancy audit has not been conducted; follow-up action on Government Order (G.O.(MS) 77/2023/LSGD dated 22.3.2023) has not been taken | 1-17 |
| 31 | Medicines and equipment required for palliative care patients have not been made available | 1-18 |
| 32 | Details of individual benefits given to persons facing physical and mental challenges | 1-19 |
| 33 | Purchase procedures -- Government Orders are not being complied with. | 1-20 |
| 34 | Utilisation details have not been furnished | 1-21 |
| 35 | Scholarship amount not credited to the account has not been recovered | 1-22 |
| 36 | Scholarship for students facing physical and mental challenges - amount in excess of entitlement was sanctioned. | 1-23 |
| 37 | Project implemented in an incorrect manner | 1-24 |
| 38 | Transfer of Student Police funds - Government Order not complied with | 1-25 |
| 39 | LIFE Mission - house construction not completed | 1-26 |
| 40 | Project expenditure not incorporated in Sulekha | 1-27 |
| 41 | Although construction of buildings built for the She Lodge and Pakal Veedu (Day Care Centre) has been completed, the intended objective has not been achieved | 1-28 |
| 42 | The soil removed from the pond has not been auctioned to date | 1-29 |
| 43 | Shortfall in collection of SLI (State Life Insurance) subscription | 1-30 |
| 44 | Use of vehicles - deficiencies | 1-31 |
| 45 | Buy-back offer was not taken into account while purchasing new stores | 1-32 |
| 46 | Advance has not been settled to date | 1-33 |
| 47 | Grama Panchayat forfeited the second instalment of CFC Tied Fund | 1-34 |
| 48 | Purchase of medicines for the Government Homeo Dispensary - medicines have not been fully received to date against the amount given as advance | 1-35 |
| 49 | Installation of solar plant at Pazhayannur Veterinary Hospital - completion certificate has not been received. | 1-36 |
| 50 | Keralotsavam - advance amount has not been settled | 1-37 |
| 51 | Installation of video conferencing system in the Panchayat Conference Hall | 1-38 |
| 52 | Health Grant - Review | 1-39 |
| 53 | Jal Jeevan Mission - Review | 1-40 |
| --- No records found --- | ||
| --- No records found --- | ||
| 1 | MEDISEP Premium - verification regarding remittance | 4-1 |
| 2 | Utilisation of funds received for joint projects | 4-2 |
| 3 | Mobilisation Advance | 4-3 |
| 4 | Details of amounts given for Deposit Works | 4-4 |
| 5 | Loan / Loan Repayment | 4-5 |
| 6 | Fixed Deposits | 4-6 |
| 7 | Audit Recovery | 4-7 |
| 8 | Details of Paragraphs included in the Consolidated Report | 4-8 |
| 9 | Details of Charge/Surcharge Proceedings | 4-9 |
| 10 | Audit Retrospect | 4-10 |
| 11 | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | 4-11 |
| 1 | Audit Certificate | |
| 2 | Utilisation Certificate of Grants | |
| 3 | Summary of Annual Accounts | |
Part - 1
General Overview
1-1 Audit Certificate
1) Under Section 215(4) of the Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, and in accordance with the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, KSAD Audit Manual Chapters 4.2.1 & 11.3, and the guidelines and compliance instructions issued from time to time by the State Government/Central Government, Finance Commission and other funding agencies, I have audited the financial statements of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the year ended March 2025 -- comprising the Receipts & Payments Statement, the Income & Expenditure Statement, and the Balance Sheet as on 31.03.2025 -- prepared as per Committee Decision No. 1(1) dated 31.07.2025 and submitted along with supporting forms on 02.08.2025. Preparation of these accounts is the responsibility of the management of the Panchayat Raj Institution. My responsibility is to express an opinion on these accounts based on the financial audit.
2) I have conducted my financial audit in accordance with the auditing standards issued by the C&AG of India and the guidelines for financial audit of Panchayat Raj Institutions issued by the C&AG. These standards/guidelines require that I plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance as to whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement. An audit includes examining the evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and the significant estimates made, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the accounts. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
On the basis of the information and explanations that were necessary and that I received, and on the basis of the best information and explanations obtained by me as a result of the financial audit of the accounts, and subject to my observations in the accompanying report, I hereby certify as follows.
Qualified Opinion
Except for the matters described in the basis for qualified opinion in the accompanying report, and subject to the other observations therein, the Annual Financial Statements of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the year 2024-25 present a true and fair view of the financial result and financial position.
Place: Thrissur
Date: 19.02.2026
Deputy Director
1-1-1 Loan amount -- amount to be repaid is not accurate as per the Annual Accounts and the Loan Register
As the two instalments deducted from the SCP Grant as per Government Order have not been correctly deducted in the Loan Register, the balance amount payable in the Loan Account is not accurate. As per the Annual Accounts and the Loan Register, only Rs. 2,10,167 has been deducted from the SCP Grant. However, as per the Government Order, Rs. 4,72,667 has been deducted.
Details are given below.
| Annual Financial Statement | As per Register | Correct amount | |
| Opening Balance | 2,45,13,784 | 24,513,784 | 24,513,784 |
| Development Fund General | 32,00,888 | 32,00,888 | 32,00,888 (deducted as per Government Order) |
| Development Fund (SCP) | 2,10,167 | 2,10,167 | 472667 (deducted as per Government Order) |
| Development Fund (TSP) | 7,000 | 7,000 | 7000 (deducted as per Government Order) |
| Amount payable for repayment in the Loan Account | 2,10,95,729 | 2,10,95,729 | 2,08,33,229 |
1-1-2 "Prior Period item" - approved vouchers or worksheets not maintained
As per the Income & Expenditure Account (I-18, I-19), approved vouchers, or worksheets supporting the entries, have not been made available to audit for the amounts written off through journal vouchers, the amounts adjusted as income, and the correction entries in the following ledgers. Hence it has not been possible to ensure that the entries as per the ledgers listed below are lawful or accurate.
| Head (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-18, I-19) | As on 31.3.2025 Ledger Balance |
| 290800401-Prior period Expenses-Interest and finance charges | 63310 |
| 190100101-Prior period income-Property tax | 3036 |
1-1-3 The receipts and expenditure figures as per the MGNREGS register do not tally with the receipts and expenditure figures in the Annual Financial Statement.
The receipts and expenditure figures as per the MGNREGS register do not tally with the receipts and expenditure figures in the Annual Financial Statement. Details are given below.
| Annual Financial Statement | As per Register | |
| Receipts | 3,45,89,000 | 3,71,38,000 |
| Expenditure | 3,45,89,000 | 3,52,95,920 |
| Opening Balance | 1 | 32 |
As per Schedules B-4 and B-17 of the Annual Financial Statement, the closing balances entered under this head are Rs. 18,69,304 and Rs. 19,27,225 respectively.
Details of the receipts and expenditure figures as per the MGNREGS register are given as Paragraph 1-5.
1-1-4 The unspent grant balances and the closing balance as per the bank/treasury accounts in which they are deposited do not tally
As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-4, the closing balance of unspent amounts out of funds received for specific-purpose schemes should be equal to the closing balance of the bank accounts in which those amounts are held. However, for the specific-purpose grants listed below, the closing balance as per Schedule B-4 does not tally with the closing balance of the bank accounts of those funds as per Schedule B-17. Details are given below.
| Head | Schedule Closing balance as per B-4 | Bank Account | Schedule B-17 Closing balance as per |
| 320200104-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Basic Tax | 28,05,962 | 450210101- Punjab National Bank CFC PFMS (A/c 4335000100085560) | 1,26,48,058 |
| 320200113-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Tied Fund | 96,37,256 | ||
| Total | 1,24,43,218 |
1-1-5 Investment Register is not written up and certified
As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-12 of the Annual Financial Statement, there is an investment of Rs. 3,51,45,926. As the Investment Register is not written up and certified, it has not been possible to verify the accuracy of the balance amount in the Annual Financial Statement for the financial year 2024-25.
1-1-6 Amounts given as advance have not been settled as expenditure.
In this year, an advance of Rs. 2,20,000/- has been given for pre-monsoon cleaning expenses of the institutions concerned. Details of the advance given are furnished below.
| Name of Implementing Officer | Amount given as advance |
| Medical Officer, Family Health Centre, (Pre-monsoon expenses) | 2,20,000 |
As per the above ledger, the amount given as advance has not been settled as expenditure. Since the advance amounts have not been recorded as expenditure in the Annual Accounts, an excess balance remains under the asset heads.
1-1-7 Audit does not certify the accuracy of the Cash Flow Statement
As the Cash Flow Statement submitted along with the Annual Accounts contains the deficiencies noted below, audit does not certify its accuracy. As per the Cash Flow Statement, the "Net increase in cash and cash equivalents" for the period 2024-25 is recorded as Rs. 1,25,72,348/-. However, in the same statement, the "Net cash generated by Operating+Investing+Financing Activity" for the period 2024-25 is recorded as Rs. 2,52,59,531/-. As per accepted accounting standards, these two amounts should tally; however, the two amounts in the statement submitted by the Panchayat do not tally.
1-1-8 Not all statements required under the Accounting Rules have been included in the Annual Accounts.
Basic ratios and notes have not been included in the Annual Financial Statement.
A) Rule 62 E - Notes on Accounts - significant accounting policies, contingent liabilities, grant reports, etc.
B) Rule 62 F - Basic ratios.
1-1-9 Authentic certified vouchers and worksheets should be maintained for journals
Transactions not connected with Cash or Bank/Treasury accounts should be recorded in the Journal Book. (Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 7) Authentic certified vouchers and worksheets should be maintained and certified for all vouchers including journal vouchers. At present, journal entries are being recorded without any such control. No vouchers whatsoever are maintained for journal entries made mainly to write off and adjust collection, balance, advance, arrear demand, arrear collection and arrear balance under Property Tax, to manually reconcile with the amount in the DCB Register as per the Sanchaya software, and to increase the advance amount. Authentic certified vouchers and worksheets should be maintained and certified for all journal vouchers.
1-1-10 Discrepancies in the Bank Account Reconciliation Statement
Amounts have been withdrawn from the following bank accounts under the head "Directly debited by Bank". If the amount is one debited by the bank on its own but to which the Grama Panchayat is entitled, steps should be taken to recover the same.
| Voucher No. | Voucher Date | Instrument Number | Instrument Date | Amount (₹) | |
| CANARA BANK-OWN FUND PAZHAYANNUR ( 4667101002064 ) | 1240108813 | 26-03-2025 | 182296 | 29-03-2025 | 293.00 |
| 01-10-2024 | 01-10-2024 | 43,390.00 | |||
| 21-02-2025 | 21-02-2025 SERVICE CHARGE | 36.00 | |||
| 18-02-2025 | 89680 | 18-02-2025 | 7,500.00 | ||
| 19-02-2025 | 19-02-2025 SERVICE CHARGE | 42.00 | |||
| 18-02-2025 | 18-02-2025 SERVICE CHARGE | 118.00 |
1-1-11 Property Tax - Annual Accounts and DCB Register do not tally
The property tax demand amount obtained from the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the Property Tax Demand Register, is entered as demand in the "Finance Module of ILGMS", the software used to prepare the accounts. Collection of property tax and issue of receipts, as well as preparation of ledgers, are done using the "Finance Module of the ERP called ILGMS". The receipt collection recorded therein is automatically posted to the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the Property Tax Demand Register. Since they are prepared in this manner, the amounts under demand, collection and balance as per the DCB Register should tally with those as per the statements in the Annual Accounts. However, the year-end summary amounts as per the DCB Register for Property Tax and Library Cess prepared in the "Sanchaya" software do not tally with the amounts in the Annual Accounts prepared in the "Finance Module of ILGMS". In the above circumstances, the reason for the Annual Accounts and the DCB Register not tallying should be identified and rectified.
Arrears
Property Tax - Residential
| Demand | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 423077 | 148449 |
| As per various statements in the Annual Accounts | 416473 | 148864 |
| (Balance Sheet for 2023-24 Schedule B-15) | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) |
Property Tax - Non-Residential
| Demand | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 2360965 | 20,59,453 |
| As per various statements in the Annual Accounts | 2365016 | 20,59,800 |
| (Balance Sheet for 2023-24 Schedule B-15) | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) |
1-1-12 Asset Register - accuracy of assets could not be verified
The Asset Register is not prepared in a manner that enables verification of the existence and value of the fixed assets referred to in the Balance Sheet.
1-1-13 Deposit Register, Advance Register and ACR are not written up and certified.
As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-7 of the Annual Financial Statement, there is a closing balance of Rs. 1,31,06,003, and as per B-18, Rs. 86,99,247. Deposit Register, Advance Register and Appropriation Control Register (ACR) are not written up and certified, it has not been possible to verify the accuracy of the amounts as per Schedules B-7, B-18 and RP 30 of the Annual Financial Statement for the financial year 2024-25.
1-2 Budget
| Date of passing | 15.02.2024 | |
| Committee Decision | 1(1) | |
| Anticipated Receipts and Expenditure | Receipts | Expenditure |
| 46,26,70,992 | 45,88,46,813 | |
| Revised Budget | ||
| Date of passing | 21.03.2025 | |
| Committee Decision | 1(1) | |
| Anticipated Receipts and Expenditure | Receipts | Expenditure |
| 45,54,86,990 | 37,39,43,248 | |
1-3 Fund Utilisation
| Fund Head | O.B. | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Closing Balance/ Lapsed amount |
| 1. Development Fund-General (as per Grant Statement) | 3,66,85,223 | 3,66,85,223 | 3,10,46,061 | 56,39,162** | |
| 2. Development Fund-SCP (as per Grant Statement) | 1,62,46,000 | 1,62,46,000 | 1,25,89,537 | 36,56,463** | |
| 3. Development Fund-TSP (as per Grant Statement) | 11,13,777 | 11,13,777 | 2,17,325 | 8,96,452** | |
| 4. Maintenance, Road (as per Grant Statement) | 2,99,22,000 | 2,99,22,000 | 2,19,22,576 | 79,99,424** | |
| 5. Maintenance, Non-Road (as per Grant Statement) | 69,23,000 | 69,23,000 | 58,01,521 | 11,21,479** | |
| 6) Central Finance Commission Grant - Basic Grant - Bank | 24,95,269 | 67,21,641 | 92,16,910 | 64,10,948 | 28,05,962 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - Basic Treasury | 49,23,432 | 49,23,432 | 45,07,650 | 4,15,782 | |
| 7) Central Finance Commission Grant - Tied Fund | 1,03,53,563 | 94,21,000*** | 1,97,74,563 | 1,01,37,307 | 96,37,256 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - Performance Grant | 33,91,385 | 33,91,385 | 27,49,748 | 6,41,637 | |
| 8. Relief Fund | - | 38,721 | 38,721 | 38,721 | - |
| 9. ICDS | 21,29,838 | 17,41,039 | 38,70,877 | 17,96,328 | 20,74,549 |
| 10. Health Grant - Diagnostic Infrastructure (320100202) | 14,42,723 | 5,52,777 | 19,95,500 | 2,02,567 | 17,92,933 |
| 11. Health Grant - Buildingless Sub-centres (320100203) | 84,16,501 | 2,65,587 | 86,82,088 | 55,56,064 | 31,26,024 |
| 12. Health Grant - Health and Wellness Centre (320100204) | 5,08,967 | 7,93,226 | 13,02,193 | 4,92,755 | 8,09,438 |
| 13. Jalanidhi | 11,81,205 | 787 | 11,81,992 | 0 | 11,81,992 |
| 14. Jeevadhara | 26,520 | 0 | 26,520 | 0 | 26,520 |
| 15. Total Sanitation | 3,14,870 | 0 | 3,14,870 | 0 | 3,14,870 |
*** Central Finance Commission Grant - Tied Fund - the second instalment has not been received by the Grama Panchayat. This has been included as Paragraph 1-35.
1-4 Plan Review
Approved (Number) | Approved Plan Outlay Amount | Implemented (Number) | Expenditure Amount of Implemented Schemes | Percentage of Implemented Scheme Amount | Percentage of Number of Implemented Projects |
| 282 | 24,20,46,576 | 187 | 13,34,09,045 | 55 | 66 |
1-5 MGNREGS
| Item | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Closing Balance |
| Administrative Expenses | 32 | 19,00,000 | 19,00,032 | 57,920 | 18,69,304 |
| Paid directly to beneficiaries | 0 | 3,46,58,000 | 3,46,58,000 | 3,46,58,000 | 0 |
| Material Cost | 0 | 5,80,000 | 5,80,000 | 5,80,000 | 0 |
| Total | 32 | 3,71,38,000 | 3,71,38,032 | 3,52,95,920 | 18,69,304 |
The receipts and expenditure figures of MGNREGS do not tally with the Annual Financial Statement. This has been included as Paragraph 1-1-3.
1-6 Welfare Schemes
| Name of Scheme | Expenditure Amount | Number of Beneficiaries |
| Agricultural Labourer Pension | 99,37,000 | 595 |
| Widow Pension | 2,94,45,100 | 1925 |
| Old Age Pension | 5,66,49,200 | 3934 |
| Disability Pension | 75,99,600 | 472 |
| Pension for unmarried women above 50 years of age | 35,78,000 | 224 |
1-7 Cash Balance Verification
The cash balance verification under Section 6(4) of the Local Fund Audit Act, 1994 was conducted on 29.10.2025 at 3:00 PM in the presence of the Accountant of the Panchayat. On verification, the accuracy of the cash balance of Rs. 14,196 was confirmed.
1-8 Internal Control
The deficiencies in internal control have been included in various paragraphs in Part 1 of this report.
1-9 Irregularities in collection of Profession Tax
Under Section 204 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, profession tax may be levied on any institution transacting business within a Panchayat area for not less than sixty days in total during a half-year, and on any person who is engaged in a profession, art or employment, or who carries on business, or who holds a public or private appointment, within the Panchayat area or, while residing within the Panchayat area, outside it.
1. As per verification of the Profession Tax Register for the financial year 2024-25, profession tax has not been collected from the employees of the following institutions.
| Sl. No. | Details of Institution | Half-year |
| 1 | Perfect Earthings SIDCO, Pazhayannur | 1st & 2nd |
| 2 | Colour Metal Coat SIDCO, Pazhayannur | 1st & 2nd |
| 3 | M.C. Metro Foundation, Pazhayannur | 2nd |
| 4 | Lakshmi Rubber Industries | 1st |
| 5 | Annapoorna Supermarket | 1st & 2nd |
| 6 | Tell Us H.P. Gas Agency, Pazhayannur | 2nd |
| 7 | M.F.T.C. Limited, Pazhayannur | 1st |
| 8 | Sree Medicals | 2nd |
2. Profession tax has not been collected from contractors
As per records available from the Local Infrastructure Department & Engineering Wing, profession tax has not been collected from the following contractors who undertook various civil works within the Panchayat area during the financial year 2024-25.
| Sl. No. | Name of Contractor |
| 1 | Asker Ali |
| 2 | Krishnadas P.K. |
| 3 | Ayoob K.M. |
| 4 | Prakashan K.V. |
| 5 | Shiju M.T. |
| 6 | Muhammed Ali K.M. |
| 7 | Akbar K.H. |
| 8 | Shijulal |
| 9 | Venkittaramanan P.S. |
| 10 | Unni K. |
| 11 | Muhammed Basheer K.A. |
| 12 | Prasad T.N. |
| 13 | Rajan C. |
| 14 | Rasheed P.M. |
| 15 | Ravi R. (second half-year not collected) |
| 16 | Roy K.M. |
| 17 | Shameer K.M. |
| 18 | Biju M. Mathew |
| 19 | Hakeem N. |
| 20 | Hamsa K.M. |
3. Profession tax has not been collected at the revised rate
The Local Self Government Department, vide Order No. 1149/2024/LSGD, G.O.(Rt.) dated 27.06.2024, revised the profession tax slabs of the panchayats as recommended by the Sixth State Finance Commission. The revised profession tax rates have come into effect from October 1, the commencement of the second half-year of 2024. However, as per the profession tax register, profession tax at the revised rates has not been collected from the employees listed below.
| Sl. No. | Name and details of institution/employee | Second half-yearly income | Tax collected | Tax that ought to have been collected | Shortfall | Receipt No./Date |
| A | CHC, Pazhayannur Government Hospital | 1240107030/ 01.03.2025 | ||||
| 1 | Aparna | 51,000 | 450 | 750 | 300 | |
| 2 | Year | 34,000 | 300 | 600 | 300 | |
| B | Credit Access Grameen Limited, Pazhayannur | 1240107772/ 14.03.2025 | ||||
| 1 | Reshma P.R. | 59401 | 450 | 750 | 300 | |
| 2 | Sajna T.Y. | 59127 | 450 | 750 | 300 | |
| 3 | Cletus P.L. | 38064 | 300 | 600 | 300 | |
| 4 | Haritha K. | 45645 | 450 | 750 | 300 | |
| Sl. No. | Name and details of institution/employee | First half-yearly income | Tax collected | Tax that ought to have been collected | Shortfall | Receipt No./Date |
| C | ESAF Swasraya Multi-State Agro Co-operative Society & Small Finance, Pazhayannur | 1240000756/ 30.09.2024 | ||||
| 1 | Babu T. | 67,704 | 450 | 600 | 150 | |
| Total | 3,000 |
4. As per the Licence Register for the financial year 2024-25, institution profession tax has been collected in advance from institution owners whose licences were granted/renewed. From institution owners from whom profession tax was collected at the rates of Rs.300, Rs.450 and Rs.600 for the first half-year, the profession tax for the second half-year has also been collected at the same rates. The increased tax under the revision that was to be implemented in the second half-year as per the above order has not been collected from the institution owners. Although tax may be collected either under Rule 3 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Profession Tax) Rules, 1996, or, under Rules 5 and 6, on the basis of turnover, no records regarding the income for fixing the profession tax slab have been furnished to audit.
In reply to the audit enquiry (No. 08/30.10.2025) issued seeking a reply to the above irregularities, it has been intimated that steps will be taken to collect the profession tax of employees of institutions as per Sl. No. (1), the profession tax of contractors as per Sl. No. (2), and the revised profession tax of employees as per Sl. No. (3). Records of the profession tax so collected should be produced to audit. Documents evidencing income should be obtained from the institution owners referred to in Sl. No. (4), the profession tax revision implemented, and tax revenue ensured. The Grama Panchayat should take effective steps to accurately assess profession tax, and to demand and collect the assessed tax amount, based on the Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 and the Profession Tax Rules, 1996.
1-10 Grant of Licence to Trades and Industries - Irregularities
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act and the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trading Establishments, Industrial Undertakings and Other Services) Rules, 1996, none of the items included in the schedule to the said Rules shall be operated within the panchayat limits without the permission of the panchayat.
1. Traders' list has not been prepared
During the financial year 2024-25, a ward-wise traders' list of establishments liable to licence has not been prepared in any of the 15 wards of the panchayat. In the absence of an accurate database and traders' list, it has not been possible to verify whether all the commercial and industrial establishments in buildings on which the panchayat has assessed tax for commercial/industrial purposes are covered within the scope of licensing.
2. The Haritha Karma Sena of the Grama Panchayat has carried out 100% field inspection, completed the data survey, and details of the establishments affixed with the Haritha Mithram QR code are given below.
| 1 | Trading establishments | 687 |
| 2 | Private Hospitals/Health Care establishments | 28 |
| 3 | Auditorium | 3 |
| 4 | Poultry/Slaughter/Fish Stall | 14 |
| 5 | Hotel/Food Court | 47 |
| 6 | Saloon/Spa | 33 |
| 7 | Office buildings | 112 |
| Total | 924 | |
However, on verification of the licence register, it is seen that the panchayat has collected licence fee from only 586 establishments during the financial year 2024-25. A discrepancy exists between the figures for establishments to which licences have been granted and the commercial/trading/industrial establishments shown in the Haritha Mithram application.
In reply to the audit enquiry (No. 27/01.11.2025) issued seeking information on whether action has been taken during the financial year 2024-25 against the above irregularities and against establishments functioning within the panchayat without a licence, it has been intimated that a ward-wise traders' list will be prepared and that urgent action will be taken against establishments functioning without licence.
It shall be ensured that all commercial establishments functioning within the panchayat area, which are covered under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 and the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trading Establishments, Industrial Undertakings and Other Services) Rules, 1996, are brought within the scope of licensing; a ward-wise traders' list shall accordingly be prepared; and licence fee shall be collected from all establishments liable to pay it.
1-11 Rent - Irregularities
The irregularities noticed on verification of the rent register for the financial year 2024-25 are given below.
1. As per the rent register, 20 of the 83 shop-rooms belonging to the panchayat are seen lying vacant during the financial year 2024-25. These shop-rooms have not been put to auction. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Room No. | Building No. | Location |
| 1 | 6 | Bus Stand Shopping Complex | |
| 2 | 104 | 22/856 D | Bus Stand Shopping Complex |
| 3 | 110 | 22/856 J | Bus Stand Shopping Complex |
| 4 | 112 | 22/856 L | Bus Stand Shopping Complex |
| 5 | 7 | 4/345 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 6 | 8 | 4/346 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 7 | 10 | 4/348 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 8 | 11 | 4/349 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 9 | 12 | 4/350 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 10 | 15 | 19/736 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 11 | 16 | 19/737 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 12 | 17 | 19/738 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 13 | 18 | 19/739 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 14 | 19 | 19/740 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 15 | 20 | 19/741 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 16 | 22 | 19/743 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 17 | 24 | 19/745 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 18 | Upstairs | 19/747 | Ambalanada Complex Upstairs |
| 19 | Upstairs | 19/748 | Ambalanada Complex Upstairs |
| 20 | 1 South Block | 19/751 | Ambalanada Complex South Block |
2. Rent amounting to Rs.65,677 for the financial year 2024-25 in respect of a few shop-rooms owned by the panchayat remains uncollected till date. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Name of shopping complex | Room No. | Building No. | Name of tenant | Monthly rent | Total rent |
| 1 | Bus Stand Shopping Complex | 16, 17, 18 | Ashraf, Akkarapparambil, Kumbalakode | 9825 X 1 | 9,825 | |
| 2 | 103 | 22/856-C | Anitha P. | 2440 X 1 | 2,440 | |
| 3 | 116 | Jubail Yousuf, Kumbalakode | 2440 X 3 | 7.320 | ||
| 4 | 114 | Muhammed Muhsin, Hira Manzil | 2440 X 1 | 2,440 | ||
| 6 | Ambalanada Shopping Complex | 23 | 19/744 | Supriya Gopinath, Pazhayannur | 2825 X 10 | 28,250 |
| 7 | 10 | 19/732 | Sabeena M.M., Moochikkal, Thozhuppadam | 4240 X 1 | 4,240 | |
| 8 | Excise Inspector, Pazhayannur | 2162 X 1 | 2,162 | |||
| Take A Break | 2/1 A | Girish, Cheerakuzhi | 1500 X 6 | 9,000 | ||
| Total amount | 65,677 |
3. No action has been taken so far to recover the previous year's rent arrears of Rs.45,494.
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (07/30.10.2025) issued in this regard. As part of increasing the panchayat's own revenue, the panchayat shop-rooms mentioned in Sl. No. (1) should be put to auction, and as per Sl. Nos. (2) and (3), revenue recovery proceedings should be initiated to collect, together with GST, the rent arrears of the panchayat shop-rooms for the current and previous years; the amount that still remains to be collected from tenants should be collected in full and records produced to audit.
1-12 Auction - Irregularities
1. On verification of the auction register for the financial year 2024-25, it is seen that Shri Mohanan, Padinjare Kuruppath, Kallepadam, has taken Room No. 110 in the panchayat-owned Bus Stand Shopping Complex on auction for Rs.1,05,000. However, though Rs.50,000 out of the above amount has been remitted vide Receipt No. 1230106389 dated 14.03.2024, the details of remittance of the balance amount of Rs.55,000 to the panchayat have not been recorded in the auction register. Further, the file relating to the above-mentioned auction (File No. SC2/6799/24) and the Governing Body decision have not been furnished. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No. 06/29.10.2025) issued seeking clarification on the above irregularity. Details of receipt items should be recorded accurately and completely and maintained in the auction register, and the amount of the auctioned items should be collected immediately and records produced to audit.
2. As per Decision No. 12(1) of the Grama Panchayat Governing Body dated 20.11.2024, and as per Letter No. D3-3182/2024 dated 1.11.2024 of the Executive Engineer, Local Self Government Department, the valuation amount of Rs.172,028 approved after verifying the survey report for demolishing the old building of Thrikkanaya Government U.P. School in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat was discussed at the meeting. It was accordingly decided to authorise the Secretary to take auction proceedings for demolishing and removing the building.
3. As per Decision No. 12(2) of the Grama Panchayat Governing Body dated 20.11.2024, and as per Letter No. D3-3180/2024 dated 1.11.2024 of the Executive Engineer, Local Self Government Department, the valuation amount of Rs.80,173 approved after verifying the survey report for demolishing the old building of Pazhayannur Government L.P. School in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat was discussed at the meeting. It was accordingly decided to authorise the Secretary to take auction proceedings for demolishing and removing the building.
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.28/01.11.2025) issued seeking information on the follow-up action taken on the above decisions.
The auctions mentioned in Sl. Nos. (2) and (3) should be conducted immediately, the amount collected, and records produced to audit.
1-13 Entertainment Tax - Accuracy of Income Could Not Be Ensured
As per G.O.(Rt.) No.112/2019/LSGD dated 31.08.2019, the Government has granted permission to local self-government institutions to collect entertainment tax and has fixed the tax rate. Accordingly, the tax rate is 5% for tickets priced below Rs.100 and 8.5% for tickets priced above Rs.100. It has also been directed that, until e-ticketing comes into effect, tax shall be paid in accordance with the number of tickets on which Goods and Services Tax is paid. Government guidelines regarding the implementation of e-ticketing in theatres have been issued vide G.O.(Rt.) No.101/2020/LSGD dated 04.01.2020. As per this, information including the Daily Collection Report (DCR) of tickets sold through the Government's e-ticketing software is required to be transferred online to the local self-government institutions.
The panchayat has an income of Rs.4,71,636 towards entertainment tax for the year 2024-25 from Shadow Cinemas, Pazhayannur, a theatre functioning within the limits of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat. Although the amount collected towards entertainment tax, in accordance with the number of tickets on which GST is paid, is required to be remitted to the local self-government institution by the 3rd of the following month, the month-end GST statement has not been produced for verification. Although entertainment tax is currently remitted on the basis of the month-end report prepared by the theatre, the amount has not been remitted within the above-mentioned date. The panchayat is not seen to have taken action to ensure the authenticity of the report furnished by the theatre. In the absence of the month-end GST statement, it has not been possible to verify the accuracy of the income under this head.
In reply to the audit enquiry (No. 29/01.11.2025) issued in connection with the above matter, it has been intimated that steps will be taken to obtain the month-end GST return statement. Information including the Daily Collection Report (DCR) and the month-end GST return statement should be obtained, and, on that basis, entertainment tax should be collected and records produced to audit.
1-14 Mobile Tower - Property Tax Should Be Assessed and Collected
1. As part of promoting the 5G network, the Government has amended the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules, 2019, vide Gazette Notification dated 19.01.2023 (Order No. G.O.(P) 10/2023/LSGD dated 19.01.2023). As per the above rule amendment, permit from local self-government institutions has been dispensed with for the construction of mobile towers. If the intimation in the prescribed format (Annexure A5), together with connected documents including a legally compliant plan, is submitted to the panchayat, and the fee prescribed by the rules is remitted, the mobile tower can be constructed without the permission of the panchayat. The completion report after completion of construction should be submitted along with the intimation submitted before the commencement of construction, and the Secretary shall inspect the site and ensure that the construction is in accordance with law, and grant occupancy on that basis. Intimation has been submitted to the Grama Panchayat for constructing the mobile telephone tower given below.
| Application No. | Amount | Ward | Plan submitted Area of tower as per (sq.m.) | Applicant |
| 3077/24 | 10,000 | 08 | 14.77 | Indus Towers Limited |
On site inspection conducted on 01.11.2025 in the presence of panchayat officials, it was confirmed that construction of the said mobile tower has been completed and operations have commenced. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.37/3.11.25) issued seeking information as to whether the completion report of this mobile telecommunication tower has been submitted to the panchayat, and, if a building number has been allotted and property tax collected, information regarding the same. Hence, property tax should be collected from the date on which construction of this mobile tower was completed and operation commenced, and information communicated along with records.
2. On site inspection conducted on 01.11.2025 in the presence of panchayat officials, it was confirmed that two mobile towers are functioning in Ward No. 8. One mobile tower is functioning at Elanad Centre and the other near Potta Thottupalam Centre. As per the Panchayat's Sanchaya software, the building number of the mobile tower in Ward No. 8 is 8/464, which is more than 15 years old. What was found on site inspection are newly constructed mobile towers. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.37/3.11.25) issued seeking, for verification, if these mobile towers have been constructed lawfully, the application submitted for construction permission, the building number and records of property tax payment.
Hence, field inspection should be conducted in all the wards of the Grama Panchayat to identify towers functioning unauthorisedly, and steps taken to regularise them and to assess and collect property tax.
1-15 Unauthorised Construction Should Be Regularised
1. Shri Abbas K., Kottupurackal House, Potta, Pazhayannur, had submitted an application for construction permission, vide No. SC1-5329/24 dated 22.08.2024, for constructing a poultry shed with an area of 630.66 sq.m. A notice intimating the deficiencies has been sent to the applicant vide Secretary's Letter No.400686/BPL103/GPO/2024/5329 dated 22.08.24. Construction permission has not been granted to the applicant by the Grama Panchayat. On site inspection conducted by the audit team on 01.11.2025, it was confirmed that the applicant has carried out unauthorised construction and is operating a poultry farm. Two sheds were found. The first has a length of 46.90 m and a width of 5.70 m. The second shed has a length of 38 m and a width of 5.70 m. The total area of both sheds comes to about 484 sq.m. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.40/3.11.25) issued seeking, if an application has been submitted for regularising the building, the relevant records for verification. Hence, steps should be taken to regularise these sheds and to collect property tax.
2. Shri Abhijith, Sreevihar, Cheruthuruthy, had submitted an application, vide Application No. SC1-4505/24 dated 20.07.2024, for construction permission for an extension of a cinema theatre with an area of 422.73 sq.m.
The areas of the building as per the plan submitted by the applicant are given below
| Existing area (sq.m.) | Manner of use | |
| GF(Exisisting) | 343.02 | Restaurant |
| GF(Exisisting) | 266.57 | Cinema theatre |
| FF(Exisisting) | 546.95 | Cinema theatre |
| FF(Exisisting) | 246.30 | Cinema theatre |
| FF(Exisisting) | 109.70 | Cinema theatre |
| Proposed | 422.73 | |
| Total (Existing) Total (Proposed) | 1512.54 422.73 |
However, the area of the building as per the panchayat's Sanchaya records is given below.
| Existing area (sq.m.) | Manner of use | |
| 4/417A | 932.7 | Cinema theatre |
| 4/417B | 40 | Restaurant |
| 4/417C | 36 | Restaurant |
| Total | 1008.7 |
That is, it is confirmed that an excess area of 1512.54(Exist)-1008.7=503.84 sq.m. has been constructed. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.40/3.11.25) issued seeking, if an application has been submitted for regularising this area, the relevant records for verification. Steps should be taken to regularise the additional construction (503.84 sq.m.) under Section 235W of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, and to collect property tax on the building's additional construction (503.84 sq.m.) under Section 235AA(1) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, from the financial year in which the additional construction was carried out and operation commenced.
1-16 Building and Other Construction Workers' Welfare Cess and One-Time Tax Have Not Been Collected
1. As per the Building and Other Construction Workers' Welfare Cess Act, 1996 and the Rules of 1998, it has been directed, vide Circular No. 8/RD1/2018 of the Local Self Government Department dated 12.11.2019, that for all construction activities other than residential buildings with a construction cost below Rs.10 lakh, an amount equal to 1% of the total construction cost shall be remitted as building cess to the Kerala Building and Other Construction Workers' Welfare Board, and that Secretaries of the respective local self-government institutions shall furnish a copy of the occupancy certificate granted for buildings to which cess is applicable, to the concerned Labour Officer. Permission has been granted for the Building Construction Workers' Welfare Fund Cess to be collected through local self-government institutions from April 2024, and an order to that effect has been issued as G.O.(Rt.) No. 23/2024/LSGD dated 14.02.2024. It has been provided in this order that the Secretaries of the concerned local self-government institutions shall ensure that the cess payable under the Building and Other Construction Workers' Welfare Cess Act, 1996 (Central Act No. 28) and the Central Rules of 1998 is collected fully, in a single instalment, before granting the occupancy certificate, and that 1% of the amount collected as cess shall be charged as collection charge.
2. As per Government Order G.O.(MS) 231/15/LSGD dated 9.7.15, it has been directed that while allotting the building number, a certificate of payment of one-time tax from the Village should also be obtained and kept on record.
It is seen that, during the financial year 2024-25, building numbers have been allotted for the following buildings without the Building Construction Workers' Welfare Fund Cess and the certificate of payment of one-time tax from the Village.
| File No. | Building No./Manner of use | Area (sq.m.) |
| SC1-481/25 dated 23/1/25 | 19/343A to D Commercial | 197.50 |
| SC1-7033/24 dated 20/11/24 | 19/343A to B Commercial | 153.35 |
| SC1-1787/25 dated 13/03/25 | 4/246E,H Godown | 464.25 |
| SC1-2878/24 dated 04/05/24 | 19/781A Industry | 113.36 |
| SC1-985/24 dated 15/02/24 | 20/89A Petrol Pump | 291.11 |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No. 35/3.11.25) issued seeking, for verification, records of payment or collection of cess. Hence, it should be verified whether all the certificates directed above are available in respect of all applications on which building numbers have been allotted during the financial year 2024-25, and, where certificates are not available, action as per the rules should be taken.
1-17 Post-Occupancy Audit Has Not Been Conducted; Follow-up Action on Government Order (G.O.(Rt.) 77/2023/LSGD dated 22.3.2023) Has Not Been Taken
1). Rule 21 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Building Construction) Rules, 2019 stipulates that post-occupancy audit should be conducted. It is provided in the said rule that, in respect of buildings other than residential buildings up to two floors, commercial buildings up to 50 sq.m., buildings used for worship, and Group G1, G2 and I occupancies, the Secretary shall conduct post-occupancy audit within two years of grant of the occupancy certificate, and that post-occupancy audit may be conducted at any time after two years from the grant of the occupancy certificate. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.36/2.11.25) issued seeking a reply as to whether post-occupancy audit has been conducted.
2). Subject to the provisions of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax, Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, the Government, vide Order G.O.(Rt.)77/2023/LSGD dated 22.3.2023, had granted permission to waive the penalty and accept information from owners of buildings who have not intimated in writing changes made by the building owner, or occurring on their own, in the plinth area, manner of use, or in respect of any component or type of component of a building, after the property tax of the building has been assessed. Further, the Government had also directed that, irrespective of whether the building owner furnishes the information or not, persons possessing a qualification not below Diploma (Civil Engineering), ITI Draughtsman (Civil), or ITI Surveyor be engaged to conduct field inspection and update building details in the Sanchaya software, and that, subject to the decision of the respective local self-government institution, an amount not exceeding Rs.30 per building number be utilised from the Own Fund for this purpose. Hence, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No. 36/2.11.25) issued seeking a reply as to whether action as per G.O.(Rt.)77/2023/LSGD dated 22.3.2023 has been taken. The wage rate for conducting field-level inspection in connection with property tax revision has been raised, as per Decision No. 3.12 of the Decentralised Planning Coordination Committee dated 06.06.2024, to Rs.50 for buildings with an area up to 100 sq. metres, Rs.60 for buildings with an area between 100 and 300 sq. metres, and Rs.75 for buildings with an area exceeding 300 sq. metres. Hence, follow-up action as per G.O.(Rt.)77/2023/LSGD dated 22.3.2023 should be taken and information communicated.
1-18 Medicines and Equipment Required for Palliative Patients Have Not Been Made Available
The Medical Officer, CHC, has implemented the following projects for making available medicines and equipment required for palliative patients. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Project Number and Name | Proforma Invoice No./Date | Voucher No. Date. | Fund | Value of medicines received so far | Value of medicines yet to be received |
| 1. | 111/25 To Elanad FHC | 2516/29.5.24 | 42401148/31.3.25 3,469 | Finance Commission Award | 3,469 | 0 |
| 2267/2.12.24 | 42401081/28.3.2025 6,25,437 | 2,38,291 1.475/13.5.25 - 58,879 2.968/17.6.25- 60,669 3.1819/22.8.25- 1,18,743 | 3,87,146 | |||
| 21626/3.1.25 | 42401087/30.3.25 59,794 | 59,794 KL00907/FP00046/ 24.25 7/1/25 | 0 | |||
| 15032 n/2025/1/21.1.25 | 42401076/27.3.2025 53,091 | 53,091 C12152/18.3.25 | 0 | |||
| 4563/19.3.25 | 42401504/ 31.3.25 58,209 | 58,209 | ||||
| Value of medicines yet to be received | 4,45,355 | |||||
| 2 | 79/25 Santhwana | 1.3005/17.1.25 2.3293/29.1.25 | 29,999 42401350/6.2.2025 38,437 42401355/13.2.2025 | Finance Commission Award | 25,219 12,530 | 4,780 25,907 |
| Balance Value of equipment yet to be received | 30,687 | |||||
Medicines worth Rs.4,45,355 and equipment required for palliative patients, such as wheelchairs, air beds, etc., worth Rs.30,687, have not yet been made available. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.18/31.10.25) issued in connection with the matter.
Steps should be taken to make available the medicines and equipment, and, as and when received, they should be taken into stock and records produced to audit.
1-19 Details of Individual Benefits Given to Persons Facing Physical and Mental Challenges
It has been specified in G.O.(Rt.) No. 1360/2011/LSGD dated 04-06-2011 that at least three per cent of the beneficiaries of projects providing individual benefit should belong to the category of persons facing physical and mental challenges. As per the direction in the above order, at least three per cent of the beneficiaries of all individual livelihood/enterprise projects implemented by local self-government institutions, including cattle rearing, egg-laying poultry rearing, etc., and of family-based infrastructure development projects such as housing, house repair, house wiring, sanitary latrines, drinking water wells, etc., shall compulsorily be persons facing physical and mental challenges. In the case of infrastructure development projects, a family with at least one member facing physical and mental challenges may be treated as a reserved beneficiary family.
The reply furnished to the audit enquiry (No.5/28.10.2025) issued seeking information as to whether, in the beneficiary list for the year 2024-25, at least 3 per cent of beneficiaries facing physical and mental challenges have been included as per the direction in the above order, and information on individual benefits given for house construction, house renovation, sanitary toilets and drinking water wells, is given below.
"In projects connected with the panchayat's Annual Plan requiring beneficiary selection, if persons facing physical and mental challenges have submitted applications for the said projects, priority is fixed for such persons and steps are taken to include them in the project beneficiary list."
Care should be taken to devise projects in such a manner that benefits reach all sections of the people, in compliance with Government orders.
1-20 Purchase Procedures - Government Orders Are Not Complied With
Various Implementing Officers of the panchayat have not complied with Government orders while purchasing furniture for the implementation of projects.
Furniture was purchased by obtaining quotations from accredited agencies (ARTCO, SIDCO).
Details are given below.
| Implementing Officer | Project | Voucher No., Amount | Items purchased/Invoice No. | Agency |
| Secretary | 240/25 - Purchase of chairs for front office | 42400857/05.01.2025 – 1,17,351 | 5 airport chairs (EKM/24-25/189/13.12.24) | SIDCO |
| Head mistress, G.L.P.S., Pazhayannur | 231/25 - Furniture for Scheduled Caste students | 42401459/ 25.03.2025 -- 5,97,800 | Table, Chair (2024-25 TSR/494/25.3.25 ) | ARTCO, Thrissur |
| ICDS Supervisor | 134/25 - Cots for the elderly, General | 42401456/ 25.03.2025- 2,08,750 | 50 cots ((EKM/24-25/428/25.3.25) | SIDCO |
| Assistant Secretary | 126/25 - Cots for the elderly, SC (Spillover) | 42401461/ 25.03.2025 -- 2,08,750 | 50 cots ((EKM/24-25/429/ 25.3.25) | SIDCO |
| Assistant Secretary | 314/25 - Cots for the elderly, ST | 42401462/ 25.03.2025 - 79,325 | 19 cots ((EKM/24-25/430/ 25.3.25) | SIDCO |
The Procurement Guideline paragraph 3.2 of Order G.O.(P) No.259/2010/LSGD dated 08.11.2010, applicable to local self-government institutions, has clearly specified that only purchases up to Rs. 25,000 may be made by resorting to quotation procedure. For purchases with an estimated value above Rs. 25,000 and below Rs. 1,00,000, limited tender procedure was to be adopted, and for purchases with an estimated value above Rs. 1,00,000, open tender procedure was to be adopted. Purchases above Rs. five lakh shall follow e-tender procedures. As per G.O.(Printing) No.7/19/SPD dated 26.04.2019, all Government departments shall compulsorily procure goods and services above Rs. 25,000 through GeM. ARTCO is a rate contract establishment supplying steel and wooden furniture at fixed rates for a fixed period as per Government-approved specifications (Government Order (Ordinary) No.30/2024/SPD dated 07.03.2024).
None of the conditions stated above have been complied with in connection with the various purchase processes of the Panchayat. Government orders shall be complied with while making purchases in future.
(Audit Enquiry 10/30.10.2025)
1-21 Utilisation particulars not furnished
The receipt for the amount and the utilisation particulars for the amounts transferred as per the projects noted below have not been furnished.
1. Implementing Officer -- Secretary
| Project | Estimate | Voucher No., Amount | Agency that received the amount |
| 3/25 - IKM - Payment of Grama Panchayat share | 2,50,000 Development Fund (General Sector) | 42401172/5.7.24 - 174050 | Executive Director, IKM |
| 1/25 - IKM - Payment of Grama Panchayat share | 5,00,000 Development Fund (General Sector) | 42401191/12.7.24- 5,00,000 | Block Programme Coordinator, SSK |
2. Implementing Officer: ICDS Supervisor
Project: 302/25 - Sruthitharangam Scheme - transfer of amount
Estimate: 50,000 (Own Fund)
Expenditure: 50,000
Voucher No./Date, Amount - 42401113/30.03.2025 - 50,000
As per the above project, Rs. 50,000 has been transferred to the State Health Agency for cochlear implantation maintenance for the beneficiary Anwarsha, Veluthavalappil, Chelakkode. As per Circular No. DA1/284/2023/LSGD dated 09.11.2023, the cochlear implantation maintenance amount is to be transferred to the bank account of the State Health Agency, and action is to be taken to obtain the Utilisation Certificate. However, the Utilisation Certificate for the same has not been obtained from the State Health Agency to date.
(Audit Enquiry No.9/30.10.2025)
The receipt of amount and the utilisation certificate shall be furnished.
1-22 Scholarship amount that was not credited to the account has not been recovered back
In the project 'Scholarship for persons facing physical and mental challenges' (130/25) implemented by the ICDS Supervisor, Rs. 4,800 (Block share) belonging to the beneficiary Aneesh Radhakrishnan had to be corrected twice as the account was inactive, but was not credited to the beneficiary's account and instead went back to the head account. The same amount has been given again to the Supervisor for disbursing it to the beneficiary.
Although a letter was issued to the Block level Implementing Officer to get back the amount that had gone back to the head account, it has not been recovered back to date. Action shall be taken to recover the amount and the records furnished to audit.
(Audit Enquiry No. 22/01.11.2025)
1-23 Scholarship to students facing physical and mental challenges - amount in excess of eligibility sanctioned.
As per the project mentioned below, scholarship amount in excess of the amount eligible as per G.O.(Rt) No.115/2022/LSGD dated 28.05.2022 paragraph 7.1.6 B has been sanctioned to students facing physical and mental challenges. Details are given below.
| Name and number of the project | Scholarship for students facing physical and mental challenges (130/25) |
| Implementing Officer | ICDS Supervisor |
| Estimate | 20,00,000 (12,00,000 - Development Fund - General, 6,00,000 - Block Panchayat, 2,00,000 - District Panchayat share) |
| Expenditure | 15,74,900 (11,74,900 - Development Fund - General, 4,00,000 - Block Panchayat) |
| Voucher No./Date | 42401268/ 02.11.2024 – 4,00,000 42401378/10.03.2025 - 4,00,000 |
Details of the amount sanctioned in excess as scholarship to the following students facing physical challenges as per the above project are given below.
| Sl. No. | Name of the student | Course of study | Amount that can be given | Amount given | Difference |
| 1 | Dilmaria James | +2 Computer Science | 8,000 | 11, 800 | 3,800 |
| 2 | Chrisbic | Class IV | 5,300 | 9,500 | 4,200 |
| 3 | Anirudh K | Class VI | 6,600 | 10,600 | 4,000 |
| 4 | Dilshan K M | Class IX | 8,000 | 11,800 | 3,800 |
| 5 | Devika N S | Class VI | 6,600 | 8,100 | 1,500 |
| 6 | Yuvaraj T S | First year degree | 13,000 | 15,000 | 2,000 |
In the reply furnished to the audit enquiry (No.11/30.10.2025) issued seeking a response for having given the excess amount as above, the Implementing Officer has stated that the excess amount given will be adjusted next year.
Until the amount is adjusted next year and the records furnished to audit, the excess amount given, Rs. 19,300, is held under objection.
1-24 Project implemented in a wrong manner
Implementing Officer -- Headmistress, G.L.P.S., Pazhayannur
Project -- 123/25 - Cultural - Dance School
Estimate -- 1,00,000 (Own Fund)
Expenditure -- 97,500
Voucher No. -- 42400516/15.10.2024 - 47,500
42400795 /23.12.2024 – 30,000
42401069 /27.03.2025 – 20,000
This project was conceived to start a dance school for imparting artistic skills to the people of the Panchayat. Jayasree K P, Kerala Kalalayam, Vadakkethara, Pazhayannur, was appointed to provide dance training at a monthly wage of Rs. 10,000 as per Decision No. 15 dated 21.10.2023 of the Panchayat Governing Body, and wages have been paid as per the above vouchers.
Deficiencies in the implementation of the project
1. Out of the total expenditure, Rs. 30,000 has been entered as expenditure under the head "Arts-Culture-Sports And Youth Welfare- Band Instruments For Sc/St Youths" and Rs. 47,500 under the head "Promotion Of Arts-Culture-Sports-Cultural Activities wages of dance teacher for April, May, June, July, August".
2. Implementing the project in this manner has not been provided for in either the Plan Guidelines (G.O.(Rt) No.84/2022/LSGD dated 19.4.2022) or the Subsidy Guidelines (G.O.(Rt) No.115/2022/LSGD dated 28.05.2022).
3. The project does not specify how the beneficiaries required for the project are to be selected.
In reply to Audit Enquiry (No.12/30.10.2025), it has been stated that the project was implemented since, as per paragraph 7.7.9 of G.O.(Rt) No.115/2022/LSGD dated 28.05.2022, which deals with honorarium for those who have received the State Government's Vajra Jubilee Fellowship, projects necessary for utilising the skills of the artistes referred to therein within the local self-government institution's area may be undertaken, and that 70 persons have given dance debut performances (arangettam).
However, details of the dance teacher having received the Vajra Jubilee Fellowship in respect of the above project have not been furnished. It shall be ensured that Government orders are complied with while implementing projects.
1-25 Transfer of Student Police amount - Government Order not complied with
Implementing Officer -- Secretary
Project -- 271/25 - Transfer of Student Police amount
Estimate -- 50,000 (Own Fund)
Expenditure - 50,000
Voucher No. - 42401065/21.03.2025
The amount as above was transferred to Pazhayannur G.H.H.School (Account No. - 67243544550, IFSC code -- SBIN0070921).
As per Government Order (RT) No.1151/2024/LSGD dated 27.06.2024, a maximum of Rs. 50,000, combining the shares of the District Panchayat and the Grama Panchayat, is to be utilised in rural areas. It has been clarified that District Panchayats shall transfer their share to the Grama Panchayats in whose area the schools are situated, so that the total share of the District Panchayat and the Grama Panchayat for a school does not exceed Rs. 50,000, and the project shall be implemented jointly.
Neither has the project been implemented jointly as per the Government Order, nor has the District Panchayat share been ensured. The utilisation particulars of the amount transferred have not been furnished.
(Audit Enquiry No.13/30.10.2025)
It shall be ensured that Government orders are complied with while implementing projects.
1-26 LIFE Scheme -- house construction not completed
As per the LIFE Scheme implemented by the V.E.O., Rs. 4,00,000 each is given to beneficiaries for house construction. The details of beneficiaries who received financial assistance in previous years but have not completed the work to date are given below. The details given are as per the financial assistance disbursement register, of those who have neither carried out work nor received the amount during the current year.
| Of the beneficiary Name | Amount | Date | Current status |
| Nirmala, Thalakkulam, Kallepadam, Pazhayannur | 40,000 40,000 1,60,000 1,00,000 | 20.3.23 5.7.23 6.7.23 26.12.23 | Roofing has been completed. |
| Mani, Payattuparambil, Kallepadam, Pazhayannur | 40,000 1,00,000 1,60,000 | 18.3.23 26.12.23 20.2.24 | Roofing has been completed. |
Sajitha T.U. Punchappadam Colony Kumbalakode, Pazhayannur | 40,000 | 18.3.23 | The Ward Member has spoken to the contractor and taken steps to complete the work. |
| Kamalam, Vendokkilparambu | 40,000 | 15.7.23 | Steps have been taken to recover the amount. |
Vijayalakshmi, Thiruthippully Parambil, Kallepadam | 40,000 | 5.9.23 | The plinth has not been built at the site for which the permit for plinth construction was given. A letter has been issued. |
Anitha Nampathadi Colony Elanad | 40,000 | 20.2.24 | Plinth work has been completed. |
Sheeja, Kanasseri, Elanad | 40,000 | 11.7.24 | Steps have been taken to recover the amount. |
Khadeeja Menakathu Kallamkulam | 40,000 1,60,000 1,00,000 60,000 | 17.3.22 15.12.22 8.2.23 24.6.23 | Roofing has been completed. |
Steps shall be taken to complete the house construction of the beneficiaries. The amount shall be obtained from the beneficiaries against whom action has been taken to recover it, and re-credited to the same head under which the fund was spent, and the records furnished to audit.
(Audit Enquiry No. 24/01.11.2025)
1-27 Project expenditure not included in Sulekha
Project -- 322/25 - Making uninhabitable houses habitable - SC
Implementing Officer - V.E.O., Elanad Circle
Estimate --- 75,00,000 (Development Fund -- General Sector -- 21,00,400, Development Fund -- SCP - 25,72,250, Own Fund -- 28,27,350)
Expenditure -- 5,25,000 (Development Fund -- SCP)
Voucher No. -- 42401206/26.3.25
As per Sulekha, the expenditure in this project is Rs. 5,25,000. However, as per the project file, a further Rs. 2,62,500 has been spent.
The amount of Rs. 2,62,500 has not been included in the Sulekha expenditure statement or in the annual accounts.
In reply to Audit Enquiry (No.20/1.11.25), the Implementing Officer has stated that the above amount was spent by including it under Project No.105/25 'Making houses habitable - Scheduled Caste category', and that this project was later dropped in a project amendment. It has also been replied that this expenditure occurred due to a technical error.
All project expenditures, in whatever manner incurred, shall be included in the Sulekha expenditure statement and in the annual accounts.
1-28 Though the construction of the buildings built for the She Lodge and Pakal Veedu (Day Care Centre) was completed, the intended objective was not achieved
1) She Lodge
Electrification of the She Lodge building completed in previous years was also completed during the financial year 2024-25. Details of the amount spent on electrification are given below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher number |
| 63/25, Providing basic infrastructure for She Lodge | ₹20,00,000 (Development Fund - General) | ₹249,047 Development Fund - General) | 42401390/11.03.2025 |
Even though the building construction and electrification have been completed, the building has not been put to use for the purpose of a She Lodge to date.
2) Pakal Veedu (Day Care Centre)
The Pakal Veedu completed in previous years, along with the associated works of construction of a compound wall and paving around the building, have been completed. Details of the amount spent by taking up a project for electrification of the Pakal Veedu in 2024-25 are given below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher number |
| 77/25, Enhancing the basic infrastructure of the Pakal Veedu | ₹3,00,000 (Development Fund - General) | ₹1,60,887 Development Fund - General) | 42401403/ 14.03.2025 |
Even though the building, compound wall, yard paving and electrification were completed, taking several years, the intended objective of a Pakal Veedu has not been achieved to date.
No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry (No.34/01.11.2025) issued seeking information on the steps taken to achieve the objective for which the above buildings were constructed. Hence steps shall be taken to make the building operational at the earliest. The attention of the Governing Body is invited to this.
1-29 Soil removed from the pond has not been auctioned to date
Details of the soil removed as part of the project 'Protection of the side of Neelachirakulam pond' implemented by the Assistant Engineer, stacked and kept without being auctioned, are given below.
| Number/name of the project | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher No./Date |
| 222/25, Jalaraksha Jeevaraksha - Protection of side of Neelachirakulam pond (Spill over) (eMbook No.92395) | 20,00,240 (Finance Commission Grant) | 19,99,475 (Finance Commission Grant) | 42401468/ 31.03.2025 |
As part of protecting the side of the pond with a retaining wall in the above work, 7950.8 m3soil has been removed from the pond and stored in a stack nearby. Although the Grama Panchayat Secretary was informed to take steps to remove the soil stacked as part of the project, the soil has not been auctioned and credited to the Own Fund to date. No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry (No.33/01.11.2025) issued regarding the steps taken for auctioning.
The soil removed from the pond shall be auctioned and the amount credited to the Own Fund.
1-30 Shortfall in recovery of SLI subscription
As per Government Order (P) No.159/2021/Finance dated 30.11.2021, the rate of the State Life Insurance policy has been revised. The S.L.I. premium amount is to be fixed by calculating 1.5 percent of the monthly income, being the total of basic pay, dearness allowance, personal pay and grade pay of the employees, and rounding it upward to the nearest multiple of 100.
On scrutiny of the salary bill of the Panchayat employees for February 2025, it was found that only an amount less than that prescribed in the above Government Order has been recovered as premium.
Details are given below
| Name | Basic Pay + Dearness Allowance | Premium to be recovered | Premium recovered |
Mallika R Assistant Secretary | 59300+ 7116 = 66,416 | 1000 | 200 |
Devadas P S Head Clerk | 51400+6168= 57,568 | 900 | 800 |
Ullas U Senior Clerk | 36500+4380= 40,880 | 700 | 500 |
Sindhu P S Clerk | 30300+ 3636= 33,936 | 600 | 600 |
| Laija K C, Office Attendant | 32900+3948= 36,848 | 600 | 500 |
(Audit Enquiry No. 26/01.11.2025)
It shall be ensured that Government orders are complied with while making statutory recoveries from the salary of employees.
1-31 Use of vehicles - deficiencies
On scrutiny of the log book of the vehicle KL-48 S-3421 (Marazzo) in use in the Grama Panchayat, the following deficiencies are noticed.
1) Fuel filled in the vehicle is not correctly recorded in the log book. It is not certified by the officer concerned. Filling of the tank to full is not certified.
2) The officer travelling does not sign the log book correctly. The custodian of the vehicle does not certify the trips.
3) The monthly summary regarding vehicle usage, as required by Circular No. 41/2008/Fin dated 2.8.08, is not recorded in the log book.
4) The Vehicle Register, Fuel Register and Repair Register are not maintained.
5) The certificate of the fuel efficiency test of the vehicle has not been entered in the log book.
6) The instructions under G.O.(MS) No.170/07/LSGD dated 30.06.2007 regarding the maintenance of the Panchayat's vehicles have not been complied with.
Government orders shall be complied with in the use of vehicles.
(Audit Enquiry No. 14/30.10.2025)
1-32 Buyback offer not taken into account when purchasing new stores
New tyres have been purchased for two vehicles during the current year. Details are given below.
1. Voucher No. -- 22400692/12.11.24 - 26,200
4 tyres for the Panchayat's ambulance KL48-Q 9163 were purchased at a cost of Rs. 26,200 as per the above voucher from Meenakshi Tyres, Vadakkanchery. (Invoice No. MT24/01391/21.9.24)
2. Voucher No. -- 42400894/17.01.2025 - 42,000
Four tyres for the Panchayat's vehicle KL48-S 3421 were purchased at a cost of Rs. 42,000 as per the above voucher from Pachilakattil Wheels, Pazhayannur. (Invoice No. 154/26.12.24)
Deficiencies
1. The buyback offer was not taken into account when purchasing the tyres in this manner.
As per G.O.(P) No.3/2013/SPD dated 21.6.2013, paragraph 18.1, when it is decided to replace existing old stores with new and better ones, the old ones may be sold. Appropriate conditions shall be included for this purpose in the tender enquiry documents. A condition shall be included that interested tenderers will be permitted to inspect the old stores earmarked for sale. Relevant information, taking into account the value of the old stores to be sold, shall also be included in the tender document (paragraph 18.2). It is not seen that the old tyres were sold when the new tyres were purchased.
2. Details of the auction of the old tyres, or of their entry in the Unserviceable Goods Stock Register, have not been furnished.
3. The requirement certificate of the Executive Engineer, PWD Mechanical Sub Division, has not been furnished.
Government orders shall be complied with while selling old stores.
(Audit Enquiry No. 19/01.11.2025)
1-33 Advance not settled to date
Although years have passed since advances were given to the implementing agencies/individuals listed below as per the Advance Register, they have not been settled to date.
| Voucher No. | Agency/Individual | Amount | Purpose |
| 22301011/12.2.24 | ANERT | 31,00,000 | Installation of 50 KV solar plant (Project 33) |
| 22300978/ 13.3.24 | ANERT | 4,00,000 | Installation of 50 KV solar plant (Project 33) |
| 22300154/ 30.5.23 | Medical Officer, FHC | 2, 20,000 | Pre-monsoon cleaning |
22301182/ 26.3.24 | PWD Electronic Division | 1,30,000 | 296/24 – CCTV maintanance |
22200465/ 14.9.23 | Chairman and Convener Clean Pazhayannur Green Pazhayannur | 3,00,000 | Solid Waste Management |
22300457/ 12.9.23 | Chairman and Convener Clean Pazhayannur Green Pazhayannur | 5,00,000 | Solid Waste Management |
Rs. 3,00,000 has been given to the agency 'Chairman and Convener, Clean Pazhayannur, Green Pazhayannur' under the head 460500399 -- Advance to Authorised Agency, and Rs. 5,00,000 under the head 460100199 -- Other Advance. The circumstances for giving the amount under different heads in this manner shall be clarified. It is not clear for what purpose the amount was given to this agency.
The reason for the advance amounts not having been settled to date shall be intimated.
(Audit Enquiry No. 25/01.11.2025)
1-34 Grama Panchayat lost the second instalment of CFC Tied Fund
During the financial year 2024-25, Rs. 46,72,500 was sanctioned as the second instalment of the CFC Tied Fund to Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat as per Order No.9266/24/Fin dated 12.12.2024. However, the second instalment of Rs. 46,72,500 due to be received into the CFC Tied Fund in December 2024 was not credited to the Grama Panchayat's CFC Tied Fund deposit account (PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK - CFCPFMS: 4335000100085560). No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry (No.38/3.11.25) issued seeking a reply regarding the second instalment not having been received by the Grama Panchayat.
As certified by the Chelakkara Sub Treasury Officer, the Grama Panchayat Secretary submitted the bill (Bill No.(BRN): 24131252011501719431 dt 26.03.2025) to the Treasury only at 4.20 p.m. on 26.03.2025. The Chelakkara Sub Treasury Officer has intimated the Grama Panchayat Secretary in writing that the bill ought to have been passed before 17.12.2024, and that since the bill was submitted only on 26.03.2025 and the amount exceeded the Government's ways and means limit, though contact was made with the Treasury Directorate over the phone, the bill could not be passed. Hence urgent steps shall be taken to obtain the second instalment of the CFC Tied Fund that was lost during the financial year 2024-25.
1-35 Purchase of medicines for the Govt. Homeo Dispensary - full medicines not received to date against the advance given
| Project No./Name | 82/25 - Purchase of medicines required for Pazhayannur Govt. Homeo Dispensary |
| Implementing Officer | Medical Officer (Homeo) |
| Estimate | 2,50,000/- (Maintenance Fund - Road category) |
| Expenditure | 2,50,000/- (Voucher No. 42400813/27.12.2024) |
| Proforma Invoice No./Date | PF-311/26.09.2024 |
The Medical Officer (Homeo), the Implementing Officer, transferred Rs. 2,50,000/- during 2024-25 to the account (a/c no. 34306403911) of the Managing Director, Kerala State Homeopathic Co-operative Pharmacy Limited, for purchasing medicines for the Govt. Homeo Dispensary. However, only medicines worth Rs. 1,98,958 have been received to date. Details are given below.
| Invoice No./Date | Amount (₹) |
| LF-2807/05.03.2025 | 1,00,556 |
| LF-702/10.07.2025 | 8,256 |
| LF-1665/06.10.2025 | 90,146 |
| Total | 1,98,958 |
Medicines worth the remaining Rs. 51,042 were not received. Steps shall be taken to obtain the same.
(Audit Enquiry No. 30/01.11.2025)
1-36 Installation of solar plant at Pazhayannur Veterinary Hospital - completion certificate not received
Details of the advance given for the project 'Installation of solar plant at Pazhayannur Veterinary Hospital', implemented by the Veterinary Surgeon, are given below.
| Sl. No. | Project | Fund | Estimate (₹) | Expenditure (₹) | Voucher Number/Date | Officer who received the amount |
| 1 | 135/25 - Installation of solar plant at Pazhayannur Veterinary Hospital | Mainte- nance Grant - Road category | 11,35,000 | 8,36,000 | 42401419 /20.03.2025 | District Engineer, ANERT, Thrissur |
ANERT had prepared the following project cost for installing a hybrid solar power plant of 5 kWp capacity on the roof of the office building of the Govt. Veterinary Hospital, Pazhayannur.
| Sl. No. | Item | Amount |
| 1 | Amount to be spent on installation of the power plant | 6,75,000 |
| 2 | Amount to be provided for preparing the electrical scheme and for the fee for the permission to be obtained from KSEB | 10,000 |
| 3 | Amount to be provided for the additional structure, ladder, cable and other expenses required for installation of the power plant | 75,000 |
| Total amount to be spent on installation of the 5 kWp power plant | 7,60,000 | |
| ANERT's service charge (10%) for carrying out the deposit work | 76,000 | |
| Total | 8,36,000 | |
As per Decision No. 8/7 dated 14.03.2025 of the Governing Body, Rs. 8,36,000 has been transferred to ANERT for the above project.
The deficiencies relating to the implementation of the project are given below.
1) Records of having entered into an agreement with the institution were not produced.
2) Bills relating to the work are not available in the project file.
3) Details of receipt of the subsidy given by the Government for installing the solar panel are not available in the file.
4) Details of completion of the work and the utilisation certificate are not available in the file.
No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry (15/31.10.25) issued seeking a reply to the above deficiencies.
If the subsidy given by the Government for installing the solar panel has been received, it shall be verified and adjusted as and when the final bill for the work is submitted.
1-37 Keralotsavam - advance amount not settled
| Project | 292/25 Keralotsavam |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
| Fund | Own Fund |
| Estimate, Expenditure | 1,50,000 |
| Voucher No., Amount | 1.22400837/09.12.24 -1,00,000 2.22400871/16.12.24 - 50,000 |
| Cheque No. | 089650/30.11.24-1,00,000 089650/11.12.24-50,000 |
As per the above voucher, the above amount was sanctioned as advance to Sri. Hamza, Chairman of the Panchayat's Health and Education Standing Committee, for conducting Keralotsavam. However, this advance amount has not been settled to date. As per Article 99 (1, 2, 3), Chapter 5, Vol 1 of the Kerala Financial Code, the advance is to be settled within three months after the prescribed date for submitting the advance bill, failing which it shall be recovered back together with 18% penal interest. The amount shall be recovered with interest and audit intimated.
(Audit Enquiry No.17/31.10.25)
1-38 Installation of video conferencing system in the Panchayat Conference Hall
Four projects have been implemented for installing a video conferencing system in the Panchayat Conference Hall, with the Secretary as Implementing Officer, using Own Fund. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Project | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher No., Date, Amount |
| 1 | 243/25 Panchayat Conference Projector for the Hall | 6,50,000 | 6,04,631 | 5,38,000 42400963/14.2.2025 |
| 2 | 245/25 For Panchayat Conference Hall Installation of video conferencing facility | 4,00,000 | 3,67,756 | 3,26,100 42401117/30.3.25 |
| 3 | 260/25 For Panchayat Conference Hall Purchase of audio video receivers | 4,00,000 | 3,64,302 | 3,23,168 42401133/31.3.25 |
| 4 | 261/25 Purchase of suitable speakers for Panchayat Conference Hall | 4,90,000 | 4,33,879 | 3,82,676 42400964/14.2.25 |
Based on the Grama Panchayat Secretary's request to the PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur (Letter No. SC2-5193/2024/25.10.2024) for obtaining technical sanction for the above four works, the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur (Letter No. EEELC-DVOTSR/960/2024-AB5-PWD/18.12.2024) prepared the estimate as given below and granted technical sanction. Details of the same are given below.
| Sl. No. | Work | Administrative sanction | Technical sanction | Technically sanctioned amount | Period of completion | Estimated PAC | Centage charge (of the Estimated PAC 13.78%) | Estimate amount (including 18% GST) |
| 1. | 243/25 Projector for Panchayat Conference Hall | 6(1)/23.7.2024 | TS/19554/2024 711/17.12.2024 | 6,38,000 | 4 months | 483532.45 | 66630.77 | 6,38,000 |
| 2 | 245/25 Installation of video conferencing facility in Panchayat Conference Hall | 6(1)/23.7.2024 | TS/19554/2024 721/17.12.2024 | 3,99,000 | 4 months | 302291.99 | 41655.84 | 3,99,000 |
| 3 | 260/25 Audio video for Panchayat Conference Hall Purchase of receivers | 6(1)/23.7.2024 | TS/19554/2024 732/17.12.2024 | 394000 | 4 months | 298505.50 | 41134.06 | 394000 |
| 4 | 261/25 Purchase of suitable speakers for Panchayat Conference Hall | 6(1)/23.7.2024 | TS/19554/2024 743/17.12.2024 | 490000 | 4 months | 371575.46 | 51203.10 | 490000 |
Details of challan remitted to the PWD Electronics Division account head
| Sl. No. | Challan No./Date | Head of Account | Treasury | Amount |
| 1 | KL028877071202425M/ 11.12.24 | 0059-80-103-99-00-centage charge | Sub Treasury, Chelakkara | 66,631 |
| 2 | KL028879656202425M/ 11.12.24 | 0059-80-103-99-00-centage charge | Sub Treasury, Chelakkara | 41,656 |
| 3 | KL028879793202425M /11.12.24 | 0059-80-103-99-00-centage charge | Sub Treasury, Chelakkara | 41,134 |
| 4 | KL028878230202425M /11.12.24 | 0059-80-103-99-00-centage charge | Sub Treasury, Chelakkara | 51,203 |
| Total | 2,00,624 |
Based on the technical sanction received from the Kerala PWD Electronics Division, the Grama Panchayat invited tenders, and the Governing Body approved the tender of the establishment Legendary Distributors Private Limited, Ernakulam, which had quoted the lowest rate among the three tenders received for all four works; the Grama Panchayat Secretary entered into an agreement with the establishment on 17.12.2024.
The establishment supplied to the Panchayat the equipment required for video conferencing, such as speaker, projector, camera and monitor, and installed the video conferencing system in the Panchayat Conference Hall. It has also been verified and certified whether the same is in accordance with the estimate of the PWD Electronics wing.
The centage charge (13.78%) levied by the PWD Electronics Wing for carrying out the Video Conferencing System in local self-government institutions as deposit work has also been calculated and charged for other works, and the amount has been remitted to the Grama Panchayat's sub-treasury. In cases where the work was not carried out on a PMC basis, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.31/1.11.25) issued asking that, if orders are available from the PWD Electronics Wing permitting levy of centage charge at the rate of 13.78% for preparation of estimates, the same be produced. The order No.DB 6/8463/2020/CE/LSGD dated 12.3.2021 of the Chief Engineer, Local Infrastructure Development & Engineering Wing also directs the Implementing Officer to ensure that the total consultancy fee for preparing a detailed estimate does not exceed 2.33% of the estimate amount. A letter may be issued requesting production of the orders under which the Kerala PWD Electronics Division was permitted to levy centage charge at the rate of 13.78%, and the possibility of the Panchayat getting this amount refunded may be explored.
Further information shall be furnished to audit.
1-39 Health Grant - Review
Review of the amount allotted through Health Grant to Pazhayannur Family Health Centre, a constituent institution of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Introduction
Chapter 7 (Empowering Local Governments) of the final report of the Fifteenth Central Finance Commission has recommended awarding Rs. 4,27,911 crore to local self-government institutions from 2021-22 to 2025-26. Of this, Rs. 70,051 crore has been earmarked for improving primary health care facilities. The Union Ministry of Finance, vide No. 15(2) FC-XV/FCD/2020-25 dated 16.07.2021, has issued an operational guideline for implementing the recommendations of the Fifteenth Finance Commission relating to health sector grants. The award amount for the rural sector has mainly been apportioned among the following 4 schemes given below. The grant is being allotted for the years from 2021-22 to 2025-26.
| Sl. No. | Name of the scheme under which the grant is allotted |
| 1 | Building-less Sub Centres, PHC, CHC |
| 2 | Block Level Public Health Unit |
| 3 | Support to Diagnostic Infrastructure in the Primary Health Care Facilities (i) Sub Centres (ii) PHC |
| 4 | Conversion of Rural PHC & Sub Centres into Health and Wellness Centre |
Transactions of the grant for each scheme are carried out through separate bank accounts linked with PFMS.
The total population of the Grama Panchayat is 40256 persons in 13869 houses. The Family Health Centre situated in Ward 15 of the Grama Panchayat has 6 sub centres.
1. Elanad Sub Centre (Ward 13) - new
2. Vennur Sub Centre (Ward 9)
3. Kallepadam Sub Centre (Ward 3),
4. Pott Sub Centre (Ward 8),
5. Thrikkanaya Sub Centre (Ward 14)
6. Pazhayannur Sub Centre (Ward 4)
Only the sub centres at Elanad, Vennur, Kallepadam and Pott are functioning in their own buildings. A summary of the amounts received under Health Grant in the Grama Panchayat from the year 2021-22 onwards and their utilisation is as given below.
Health Grant Scheme 1 Assistance for construction of buildings for Family Health Sub Centres without buildings.
| Sl. No. | Health Grant year | Amount allotted | Amount spent |
| 1 | 2021-22 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 | 2022-23 | 0 | 0 |
| 3 | 2023-24 | 84,16,501 | 0 |
| 4 | 2024-25 | 2,65,587 | 27,81,064 +27,75,000 (amount remitted back to NHM) |
| 86,82,088 | 55,56,064 | ||
| Balance | 31,26,024 | ||
Health Grant Scheme 3 - Setting up of diagnostic facilities in health institutions in rural areas
| Sl. No. | Health Grant year | Amount allotted | Amount spent |
| 1 | 2021-22 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 | 2022-23 | 5,01,508 | |
| 3 | 2023-24 | 12,48,794 | 3,07,579 |
| 4 | 2024-25 | 5,52,777 | 202567 |
| Total 23,03,079 | 5,10 ,146 | ||
| Balance | 17,92,933 | ||
Scheme 4 - Implementation of Health & Wellness activities in Family Health Centres and Sub Centres in rural areas
| Sl. No. | Health Grant year | Amount allotted | Amount spent |
| 1 | 2021-22 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 | 2022-23 | 2,81,095 | 0 |
| 3 | 2023-24 | 5,05,669 | 2,77,797 |
| 4 | 2024-25 | 7,93,226 | 4,92,755 |
| Total 15,79,990 | 7,70,552 | ||
| Balance | 8,09,438 | ||
Details of the grant balance remaining as on 31.03.2025 (including interest)
| Grant item | Account No. | Balance |
| Support for Diagnostic Infrastructure to the Primary Health Care Facilities | 110045214291 | 1792933 |
| Conversion of Rural PHC & Sub Centres into Health and Wellness Centre | 110045214311 | 809438 |
| Health Grant Building | 110045214248 | 3126024 |
The Panchayat has been able to make efficient interventions in the health sector using the Health Grant received. The possibility of utilising the Health Grant for construction of buildings for sub centres that do not have their own buildings should be examined. Steps should be taken to spend, in a time-bound manner and in accordance with the guidelines, the balance amount remaining unspent out of the amount received so far under the grant.
1-40 Jal Jeevan Mission - Review
In connection with the implementation of the Jal Jeevan Mission scheme in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, the Kerala Water Authority had submitted a proposal. However, as per Decision No.4(2) of the Governing Body dated 24.02.2023, it was decided that the Jal Jeevan Mission scheme need not be implemented in the Grama Panchayat, and as per Decision No.10(1) of the Governing Body dated 17.05.2023, it was assessed that drinking water had been made available to almost all households in the Panchayat even without the Jal Jeevan Mission scheme, and the scheme 'Har Ghar Jal' was declared in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat. (Audit enquiry No.1/28.10.2025)
Part -2
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the receipt side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(1) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -3
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the expenditure side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(2) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -4
General information and audit review
4-1 Scrutiny relating to remittance of MEDISEP premium
1. Remittance of MEDISEP premium (regular employees)
| Number of employees during the audit year* | Amount collected towards MEDISEP premium | Amount remitted towards MEDISEP premium | Amount remaining to be remitted | Remarks |
| 12 | 81,500 | 81,500 | 0 | 14 persons served for 8 months, and 15, 13, 11 and 12 employees respectively served in each of the (remaining) months. |
*Excluding those who joined service between 01-04-2024 and 31-03-2025
2. Remittance of MEDISEP premium (regular employees who joined service between 01-04-2024 and 30-06-2024)
| Number of employees | Month of joining service | Amount collected towards MEDISEP premium (including arrears from 07/2022 or 07/2023)** | Amount remitted towards MEDISEP premium | Amount remaining to be remitted | Remarks |
| None. | |||||
3. Remittance of MEDISEP premium (regular employees who joined service on 01-07-2024)
| Number of employees | Month of joining service | Amount collected towards MEDISEP premium (including arrears from 07/2022 or 07/2024)** | Amount remitted towards MEDISEP premium | Amount remaining to be remitted | Remarks |
| 1 | 07/2024 | 6500 | 6500 | 0 | --- |
4. Remittance of MEDISEP premium (regular employees who joined service between 01-08-2024 and 31-03-2025)
| Number of employees | Month of joining service | Amount collected towards MEDISEP premium (including arrears from 07/2022 or 07/2024)** | Amount remitted towards MEDISEP premium | Amount remaining to be remitted | Remarks |
| 1 1 | 09/2024 03/2025 | 7000+ 1000 | 7000+ 1000 | 0 | --- |
4-2 Utilisation of funds received for joint projects
None
4-3 Mobilisation Advance
None
4-4 Details of amount given for deposit work
| Sl. No. | Implementing Agency | Project number and name | Voucher Number/Date | Amount given as advance | Fund Head | Amount spent | Amount remaining to be spent |
| 1 | ANERT | 135/25 Pazhayannur Veterinary Hospital - Solar Plant installation | 42401419/20.3.25 | 8,36,000 | Maintenance Grant (Non-Road) | 0 | 8,36,000 |
4-5 Loan / Loan repayment
Details of the loan taken during the audit year and the loan amount remaining to be repaid at the end of the year
| Name/purpose of the loan | Order No./ | Amount remaining to be repaid at the beginning of the year | Loan taken during the current year | Total | Amount repaid during the current year | Amount remaining to be repaid at the end of the year | |
| Principal | Interest | ||||||
| HUDCO LIFE Scheme | - | 2,45,13,784 | 0 | 2,45,13,784 | 34,18,055 | 0 | 2,10,95,729 |
The amount remaining to be repaid at the end of the year and the amount actually required to be repaid differ. This has been included as Paragraph 1-1-10.
4-6 Fixed Deposits
| Fixed deposit existing at the beginning of the year | 35108240 | |||
| Amount deposited during the current year | 0 | |||
| Total | 35108240 | |||
| Amount withdrawn during the current year | 0 | |||
| Fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year | 38017490 (Rs.969750/- and 1939500/- also accumulated along with principal amount) | |||
Details of the fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year (interest amount 74485 and 63310 credited to SB account. Interest regardingFDreceipt433500 Bank letter produced) | of the deposit Details | Opening Balance 2024-25 | Interest | Closing Balance |
1)256007 2)256073 3)101140010143569 4)101140010143570 5)433500 | 500000 969391 10775000 21550000 1313849 Total 35108240 | 74485 63310 969750 1939500 82940 | 500000 969391 11744750 23489500 1313849 Total 38017490 | |
There is a difference between the amount at B12 of the Balance Sheet in the Annual Financial Statement and the above amount furnished by the Grama Panchayat. The amounts stated above have neither been entered and attested in the Investment Register nor have all the authentic records been made available for verification. Hence the authenticity of the above amounts could not be verified. The discrepancy has been included as Paragraph 1-1-11.
4-7 Audit Recovery
Details of the amount received under this head during the current year.
| Report year | Part/ Paragraph | Amount recovered | Name and designation of the person who remitted | Receipt No./date |
| 2019-20 | 1-46 | 7,341 | ASSISTANT ENGINEER, LID&EW | 1240100405 dtd: 18.04.2024 |
| 2020-21 | 2-2 | 5,000 | MANAGER, NILA METALS | 1240101639 Dtd:18.06.2024 |
| 2019-20 | 2-2 | 9,680 | MANAGER, NILA METALS | 1240101640 Dtd:18.06.2024 |
| 2019-20 | 2-2 | 450 | MANAGER, PERFECT EARTHING, PAZHAYANNUR | 1240101746 Dtd:24.06.2024 |
| 2019-20 | 2-1 | 18,280 | MANAGER, RAJ REGENCY (Prof. Tx) | 1240000389 Dtd:04.07.2024 |
| 2019-20 | 2-1 | 300 | Principal, SANJOS CENTRAL SCHOOL,PAZHAYANNUR | 1240102092 dtd:18.06.2024 |
| 2019-20 | 250 | NYAYADHIKARI, Gramanyayalaya,Pazhayannur | 1240102209 dtd:31.07.2024 | |
| 2019-20 | 2-1 | 2,730 | Principal, Narayana EM School | 1240101800 Dtd:05.07.2024 |
| 2020-21 | 2-2 | 500 | MS ANGELS FORMS, Pazhayannur | 1240101649 dtd:18.06.2024 |
| 2023-24 | 1-33 | 4,237 | HAMSA K M, Contractor | 1240103442 dtd:05.11.2024 |
| 2023-24 | 1-33 | 8,891 | SHIYAD S, Contractor | 1240103445 Dtd:02.11.2024 |
| 2023-24 | 1-33 | 4,237 | PRASAD T N, Contractor | 1240103323 Dtd: 26.10.2024 |
| 2023-24 | 1-34 | 5,508 | SURENDRAN R, Contractor | 1240103271 dtd:21.10.2024 |
4-8 Details of paragraphs included in the Consolidated Report
Given below are the details of the paragraphs, included in the Consolidated Report under Section 23 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act in the Panchayat's previous years' audit reports, that remain to be settled.
| Audit Report Year | Paragraph | Consolidated Report year | Paragraph | Subject | Current status |
| 1999-00, 2001-02 | 8 | 2004-05 | 3.8.I.10.1 | Excess amount paid to the contractor | The Committee recommended dropping the remark |
| 2006-07 | 3.7 | 2010-11 | 5.6.5 | Mobilisation advance given - work not completed | The Committee recommended dropping the remark |
| Performance review | 2013-14 | 5.1, Annexure -7 | of water sources protection and drinking water schemes | Considered by the Committee without any special remark | |
| Performance review | 2013-14 | 5.1.5(4) | of water sources Protection of Water Sources and Drinking Water Schemes - Public wells in local self-government institutions are not being protected | The remark continues to hold. | |
| Performance review | 2013-14 | 5.1.5 (11) | of water sources Protection of Water Sources and Drinking Water Schemes - Local self-government institutions and drinking water distribution. | The Committee recommended dropping the remark | |
| Performance review | 2013-14 | 5.1.5 (11) | of water sources Protection of Water Sources and Drinking Water Schemes - Local self-government institutions and drinking water distribution. | The Committee recommended dropping the remark | |
| Performance review | 2013-14 | 5.1.5 (11) | of water sources Protection of Water Sources and Drinking Water Schemes - Local self-government institutions and drinking water distribution - Drinking water schemes started without conducting a feasibility study fail. | The remark continues to hold. | |
| Performance review | 2013-14 | 5.1.5 (13) | Protection of Water Sources and Drinking Water Schemes - Implementation of drinking water schemes not handed over to the Beneficiary Committee - additional liability to local self-government institutions | The remark continues to hold. | |
| 2015-16 | 2-8 | 2016-17 | Chapter 2, Annexure 5 | Profession Tax | The remark continues to hold. |
| 2016-17 | 3-1 | 2017-18 | 1.8.9 | Purchase of land for various purposes - lapse in fixing the price of the land - loss of Rs. 3065811 | The remark continues to hold. |
4-9 Details of charge/surcharge proceedings
None
4-10 Audit Review
(A) Summary
| Opening balance | 5,60,73,707 |
| Total receipts for the audit year | 8,76,72,639 |
| Total receipts | 14,37,46,346 |
| Total expenditure for the audit year | 75,100,291 |
| Balance | 6,86,46,055 |
| Loss under receipt heads | None |
| Loss under expenditure heads/ amount not accepted in audit | None |
| Amount held under objection in audit | 19,300 |
*The information entered in the table is as per the Receipts & Payments Statement of the annual accounts furnished by the Grama Panchayat. Grants received from the Government are not included in the receipts and expenditure shown herein.
(B). Details of clear loss sustained to the Panchayat Fund
None
(C) Amount held under objection in audit
| Paragraph number | Amount | Name and designation of the person responsible |
| 1-23 | 19,300 | Dr. Siji.S ICDS Supervisor |
| Total | 19,300 |
D) Details of loss sustained to the Central and State Governments and other institutions
None
(E) Cases requiring further enquiry to ascertain the loss
None
(F) Name and permanent address of the persons responsible for the loss/objection dealt with in the report
| Name and designation | Present (at the time audit was conducted) Official address | Permanent address |
| Dr. Siji S ICDS Supervisor | ICDS Supervisor, Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | Siji, address N S Nagar, Padappakkara P.O., 691503 Phone No.--8547401577 Email ID--sijijohanna@ |
4-11 Paragraphs remaining to be settled
| Sl. No. | Audit Report year | Audit Report number | Total number of paragraphs remaining to be settled | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | Remarks (CAR/CASE/ CH/SCH) |
| 1 | 1997-98 (Expenditure) | LFT 12-1559/99 dt.6.3.99 | 4 | 1, 4, 5, 6 | |
| 2 | 1997-98 (Receipt) | LFT 10-306/08 dt. 25.4.09/9.7.09 | 1 | 2-1 | |
| 3 | 1999-2000 to 2001-02 (People's Plan) | LFT 10-1079/03 dt.09.04.04/14.09.04 | 7 | 7, 8, 14, 15 (2), 16, 18 (2to5), 20 (1,2,3) | Paragraph 8 - CAR |
| 4 | 1998-99 (Expenditure) | LFT 12-291/2001 dt.18.5.01/09.7.01 | 21 | 4, 8, 12, 13, 14 D1, 14 E3, 14F, 15 B,15 D2, 20, 21, 24,26, 30, 31, 34, 36 A2, 36 A3, 36 C2, 42, 32, 29, 9, 14A, 14B, 15A, 17(2) | |
| 5 | 2000-01 | LFT 10-309/08 dt. 25.04.09/14.7.19 | 1 | 3-3 | |
| 6 | 2001-02 | LFT 10-740/08 dt. 25.04.09 | 2 | 3-1, 3-3 | |
| 7 | 2002-03 | LFT 10-1265/08 dt. 07.09.09/5.12.09 | 1 | 3-13 | |
| 8 | 2003-04 | LFT 10-1266/08 dt. 7.09.09/05.12.09 | 4 | 3-11, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16 | |
| 9 | 2005-06 | LFT 10-1348/09 dt. 28.07.10/10.12.10 | 2 | 2-3, 3-3 | |
| 10 | 2007-08 | LFT(P4)956/12 dt. 19.7.12/5.11.12 | 2 | 3-2, 3-4 | |
| 11 | 2008-09 | LFT(P4)957/12 dt. 19.7.12 | 5 | 3-2, 3-3, 3-4, 3-5, 3-6 | |
| 12 | 2009-10 | LFT(P4)958/12 dt. 02.08.12/05.11.12 | 3 | 3-2, 3-7, 3-8 | |
| 13 | 2010-11 | LFT(P4)959/12 dt. 2.8.12 | 3 | 3-7, 3-9, 3-10 | |
| 14 | 2011-12 | LFT(P4)1151/13 dt. 4.12.13/05.2.14 | 9 | 2-3(5) (Sl. No. 1,2,4,6,10,11,12, 13,14) 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-4, 3-5, 3-21, 3-23, 3-25 | |
| 15 | 2012-13 | LFT(P4)-631/14 dt. 08.10.14/08.12.14 | 17 | 2-3(1)A, 2-3(1)B, 2-3(3), 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3(1), 3-3(3), 3-3(4), 3-3(5), 3-3(6), 3-4, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-14, 3-15 | |
| 16 | 2013-14 | LFT(P4)-186/15 dt. 7.5.15/5.6.15 | 18 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-5 A,D, 2-8, 3-9, 3-10, 3-11, 3-12, 3-14, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-21 (a,b), 3-22, 3-23, 3-24, 3-25, 3-27 | |
| 17 | 2014-15 | KSATSR(P4)-996/16 dt. 25.6.16 | 14 | 2-2, 2-6(1)to(5), 2-7, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-8, 3-11, 3-13, 3-16, 3-17 | |
| 18 | 2015-16 | KSATSR(P4)-1934/16 dt. 05.01.16/05.12.16 | 15 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-8, 2-10, 3-8, 3-9, 3-11, 3-12, 3-13, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-25 | 2-8 CAR |
| 19 | 2016-17 | KSATSR(P4)-1111/17 dt. 30.8.17 | 10 | 2-3, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-7(1)to(3), 3-8(1)(2), 3-9(1)(2), 3-12, 3-13, 3-14 | 3-1 CAR |
| 20 | 2017-18 | KSATSR(P4)771/19 dt. 01.06.19 | 16 | 2-3(1,2), 2-7, 2-9(1,2), 3-1, 3-3, 3-5, 3-19, 3-20, 3-25, 3-26, 3-27, 3-28, 3-29, 3-9, 3-11, | |
| 21 | 2018-19 | KSATSR(P4)1499/2019 dt. 06.12.2019 | 17 | 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26 | |
| 22 | 2019-20 | KSATSR(P12)61/2022 dt. 01.07.2022 | 34 | 1-11, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-45, 1-46, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1 | |
| 23 | 2020-21 | KSATSR(P12)62/2022 dt. 01.07.2022 | 33 | 1-11, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-48, 1-49, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1 | |
| 24 | 2021-22 | KSATSR(P12)208/2023 dt. 11.04.2023 | 21 | 1-10(1 to 13), 1-11, 1-12, 1-13, 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31 | |
| 25 | 2022-23 | KSATSR(P12)1832/2023 dt. 19.12.2023 | 21 | 1-1-1 to 1-1-14, 1-9, 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13,1-14,1-15, 1-16,1-17,1-18,1-19, 1-21,1-22,1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 4-1, 4-2, 4-6 | |
| 26 | 2023-24 | KSATSR(P12)1334 /2024 Date 14.11.2024 | 27 | 1-1, 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13, 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36 | |
| Total | 308 |
Deputy Director
Annexure-1
Audit Certificate
i. I have audited the attached Financial statements approved vide resolution number 1(1) dated dated 31-07-2025 and submitted on 02-08-2025 , comprising of Receipt and Payment statement,Income and Expenditure account for the year ended on March and Balance sheet as on 31-03- , with supporting forms, of the Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat as per section 215(4) of Kerala Panchayath Raj act 1994, Kerala Panchayath Raj Accounts rules 2011, KSAD Audit Manual chapters 4.2.1 & 11.3 and as per guidelines and compliance instructions issued by State /Central Government, Finance Commission and other funding agencies from time to time. Preparation of these accounts is the responsibility of the PRI’s management. My responsibility is to express an opinion on these accounts based on my Financial Audit.
ii. I have conducted my Financial Audit in accordance with auditing standards issued by C&AG of India and Guidelines for Financial Audit of PRIs issued by C&AG. These standards/guidelines require that I plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial statements are free from material misstatements. An audit includes examining evidences supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of accounts. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
iii. On the basis of the information and explanations that I required and have obtained, and according to the best of my information as a result of Financial Audit of the accounts and on consideration of explanations given,
I certify that, subject to my observations in the appended report, except for the matters described in the basis for qualified opinion in the appended report and subject to other observations therein, the Annual Financial Statements give a true and fair view of financial result for the year 2024-2025 and Financial position of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat as on 31-03-2025
Date: 19/02/2026
Deputy Director
Kerala State Audit Department
Audit Report appended to the Audit Certificate of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the Year 2024-2025.
1.Major Observations Major Observations The amount to be repaid in the loan account is not accurate due to the fact that the two installments deducted from the SCP grant as per the government order were not deducted correctly. Only Rs. 2,10,167 has been deducted from the SCP grant as per Annual Financial Statement and loan register . The actual amount deducted from source as per government order is 4,72,667 . Details given below.
| AFS | Register | Actual amount | |
| Opening Balance | 24513784 | 24513784 | 24513784 |
| Development fund (General) | 3200888 | 3200888 | 3200888 (Actual amount deducted at source as per Govt. Orders) |
| Development fund (SCP) | 210167 | 210167 | 472667 (Actual amount deducted at source as per Govt. Orders) |
| Development fund (TSP) | 7000 | 7000 | 7000 (Actual amount deducted at source as per Govt. Orders) |
| Balance amount to be repaid | 2,10,95,729 | 2,10,95,729 | 2,08,33,229 |
2.Other Observations
a) Comments relating to Income and Expenditure Account
1. The preservation of authenticated vouchers and worksheets for prior period items was neglected,
which undermines the ability to verify the authenticity of journal entries in the schedules.
| Head(Income & Expenditure Account, Shedule I-18,I-19 ) | Ledger balance as on 31.3.2025 |
| 290800401-Prior period Expenses-Interest and finance charges | 63310 |
| 190100101-Prior period income-Property tax | 3036 |
2. The income and expenditure figures as per the register of the National Rural Employment Guarantee
Scheme do not match the income and expenditure figures in the annual financial statement. The details
are attached below.
| As per AFS | As per register | |
| Receipt | 3,45,89,000 | 3,71,38,000 |
| Expenditure | 3,45,89,000 | 3,52,95,920 |
| Opening Balance | 1 | 32 |
As per the B-4 , B-17 schedule of balance sheet the closing balance is 18,69,304 and 19,27,225 respectively .
b) Comments relating to Balance Sheet
1. The grant amount listed as a liability on the balance sheet does not align with the closing balance of
the bank account established for the specific grant. The details are as follows:
| Head | Balance on Shedule B-4 | Bank Account | Balance on Shedule B-17 |
| 320200104-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Basic Tax | 28,05,962 | 450210101- Punjab National (A/c 4335000100085560) | 1,26,48,058 |
| 320200113-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Tied Fund | 96,37,256 | ||
| Total | 1,24,43,218 |
2. As per the balance schedule B-12 of the annual financial statement, there is a deposit of Rs. 35,145,926.
Since the investment register is not maintained in writing and certified, it has not been possible to verify the
accuracy of the balance amount for the financial year 2024-25.
3. The advance of 2,20,000 provided to the medical officer for pre-monsoon expenses was recorded under the
account head 460500501 - Advance to Implementing Officers. The amounts advanced as per the aforementioned
ledger have not been adjusted against expenditure. Since the advance amounts were not recorded as
expenses in the annual accounts, it resulted in an excess balance under the title of assets.
c. Comments relating to Receipt and Payment Statement
Nil
d. Comments relating to Cashflow Statement
As per the cash flow statement, the net increase in cash and cash equivalents recorded for the
2024-25 period is Rs.1,25,72,348 . In the same statement the net cash generated by operating + investing +
financing activity for the 2024-25 period is recorded as Rs.2,52,59,531-. According to accepted accounting
standards, the above two amounts should tally, however the two amounts in the statement submitted by
the Panchayat do not match.
e) Comments relating to Ratios
The Annual Financial Statement did not include the mandatory Financial Statements as prescribed by
the Accounting Rules such as ratios(Rule 62 E).
f) Comments relating to Notes to accounts
Notes to the accounts are not included within the accounts (Rule 62 F of Kerala panchayath Raj Accounting rules).
g) Comments relating to Receipt Vouchers
Nil
h) Comments relating to Payment Vouchers
Nil
i. Comments relating to Journal Vouchers
Transactions that are not related to cash or bank/treasury accounts must be recorded in the journal book
(Panchayati Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 7). For all journal vouchers, duly certified vouchers and
worksheets must be authenticated and kept on record. At present, such control is absent, and journal
entries are being recorded without it. Mainly, journal entries for writing off, adjusting, or manually
reconciling in the DCB register (as per Sanchaya software) amounts related to property tax collections,
arrears, advances, outstanding demands, arrear collections, and arrear balances as well as for increasing
advance amounts are being made without keeping any vouchers on record. For all journal vouchers,
duly certified vouchers and worksheets must be authenticated and kept on record.
j. Comments relating to Contra Vouchers
Nil
k. Comments relating to Bank Reconciliation Statement
No follow-up action appears to have been taken to address the issue of directly debited by Bank at various banks.
| Bank Account No | Voucher No | Date | Instrument No | Date | Amount |
| CANARA BANK-OWN FUND PAZHAYANNUR( 4667101002064 ) | 1240108813 | 26-03-2025 | 182296 | 29-03-2025 | 293.00 |
| 01-10-2024 | 01-10-2024 | 43,390.00 | |||
| 21-02-2025 | 21-02-2025 SERVICE CHARGE | 36.00 | |||
| 18-02-2025 | 89680 | 18-02-2025 | 7,500.00 | ||
| 19-02-2025 | 19-02-2025 SERVICE CHARGE | 42.00 | |||
| 18-02-2025 | 18-02-2025 SERVICE CHARGE | 118.00 |
l. Comments relating to Demand, Collection and Balance Register
DCB statement of property tax ( both residential and non residential) does not match with the accounts.
Property Tax residential (Arrear)
| Demand | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya | 4,23,077 | 1,48,449 |
| As per AFS | 4,16,473 | 1,48,864 |
Property Tax Non residential( Arrear)
| Demand | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya | 23,60,965 | 20,59,453 |
| As per AFS | 23,65,016 | 20,59,800 |
m. Comments relating to Asset Register
Asset register was not kept up to date.
n. Comments relating to Inventory and other Registers
1. It has not been possible to verify the accuracy of the balance sheet balance as per Schedules B7 and B-18 as the Advance Register and Deposit Register are not recorded and maintained. 2. Since the ACR was not written and certified, it was not possible to verify the availability of various grants by the Gram Panchayat.
DEPUTY DIRECTOR
Annexure-2
Utilisation Certificate of Grants
The utilisation of various grants for the year 2024-2025 by Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, has been verified, based on the information in the Grant Statement certified and furnished by the institution as per G.O.(Rt) 16/2021/LSGD dated 23.01.2021, in the manner set out in Annexure-1, and, subject to the observations regarding the utilisation of grants included in this report, the utilisation of grants by the institution is hereby certified.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department
| Annexure - 3 Summary of Annual Accounts |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() DEPUTY DIRECTOR |

Government of Kerala
Kerala State Audit Department
www.ksad.kerala.gov.in
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Audit Report
2023-2024
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone : 0487-2331249
(Registered with acknowledgement due)
No: KSA-TSR(P12)-1334/2024
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
Date: 14/11/2024
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone: 0487-2331249
Deputy Director
President (through the Secretary)
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Sir,
Subject: Regarding the Audit Report of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2023-2024.
In accordance with the provisions of Section 13 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, Rule 18 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996 (and Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994), the Audit Report resulting from the examination of the Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2023-2024 is herewith forwarded for further action as prescribed under Rule 23(1) of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996.
Attention is invited to the paragraphs in Part 1 of this report. Immediately on receipt of this report, the persons responsible for the irregularities mentioned therein shall be informed of the same, along with copies of the relevant paragraphs.
Within one month of receiving this report, a special meeting shall be convened to discuss the Audit Report in detail, and copies of the Audit Report and the decision taken thereon shall be published for public information. (See Rules 14 and 15 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules.)
Within two months of receiving the report, necessary action shall be taken to remove the audit remarks/objections contained herein, and a report to that effect shall be sent to this office within the said period. (See Local Fund Audit Act Section 15(1), Rules 20, 23, and Rule 21(1)(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules, 1997.)
Yours faithfully,
Deputy Director
Copy to:
1) The Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Thiruvananthapuram (for information),
2) The Joint Director, Department of Local Self Government, Thrissur.
3) Office copy.
No: KSA-TSR(P12)-1334/2024
Date: 14/11/2024
Audit Report on the Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, for the financial year 2023-2024.
(1994 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, Section 13 , 1996 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, Rule 18, (1994 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act - Section 215(4)) issued in accordance with the above provisions.)
The Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, for the financial year 2023-2024 was subjected to audit. The money collected under various heads by the institution from 09-11-2023 to 01-04-2023, its remittance, and the withdrawals made from various accounts from 01-04-2023 to 31-03-2024 were also examined.
The irregularities found in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Of the 30 enquiries issued, replies have been received for 14. The institution shall take follow-up action on the audit enquiries not included in this report.
The irregularities found in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Although 30 enquiries were issued, no reply has been received.
This report has been prepared on the basis of the registers, records, information and clarifications made available by the institution. Only the significant observations remaining after the audit remarks were presented at the audit closing meeting held on 02-09-2024 and the replies were considered have been included in the Audit Report. The Kerala State Audit Department bears no responsibility whatsoever for the analyses and observations included in this report where they are based on incorrect information or details furnished by the institution, or for any irregularities subsequently detected by another audit agency/inspection wing on the basis of records that were not made available to audit by the institution.
(A) Details of Audit Conducted
Officer in charge of audit:
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shri. Rafi John | Deputy Director | 23-08-2024 | 02-09-2024 |
Time spent on audit:
| Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|
| 23-08-2024 | 02-09-2024 |
Officers who conducted the audit:
Shri. Prasad.P, Audit Officer
Shri. Sharafudheen S H, Assistant Audit Officer
Shri. Sunilkumar.K.C, Assistant Audit Officer
Shri. Kandaswamy.I, Senior Grade Auditor
Smt. Ramya.K.K, Auditor
(B) Implementing Authorities
| Name | Official Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shri. P.K Muralidharan | President | 01-04-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Smt. Ambika M S | Secretary | 01-04-2023 | 17-09-2023 |
| Shri. Sreejith.K.R | Secretary-in-Charge | 18-09-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
Implementing Officers
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shri. Sunilkumar M.A | Assistant Secretary | 01-04-2023 | 11-07-2023 |
| Vacant | Assistant Secretary | 12-07-2023 | 17-09-2023 |
| Shri. Sreejith.K.R | Assistant Secretary | 18-09-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Dr. Juvel M.S | Medical Officer (Homeo) | 01-04-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Dr. Joby C.L | Medical Officer (F.H.C.) | 01-04-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Dr. Unnikrishnan A.K | Medical Officer (Ayurveda) | 01-04-2023 | 12-02-2024 |
| Dr. Blessy.K.Dixon | Medical Officer (Ayurveda) | 13-02-2024 | 31-03-2024 |
| Dr. Sujith M.S | Senior Veterinary Surgeon | 01-04-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Smt. Girija | Headmistress, GLPS, Pazhayannur | 01-04-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Smt. Siji.S | ICDS Supervisor | 01-04-2023 | 14-11-2023 |
| Smt. Divya Unni.T | ICDS Supervisor | 15-11-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Smt. Jisha. K.G. | Dairy Farm Instructor | 01-04-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Shri. Sunilkumar K | Assistant Engineer | 01-04-2023 | 24-07-2023 |
| Shri. Alan Jose | Assistant Engineer | 25-07-2023 | 15-08-2023 |
| Shri. Ashok Kumar | Assistant Engineer | 16-08-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Shri. Anu.A.J | Fisheries Officer | 23-03-2024 | 31-03-2024 |
| Smt. Ramya K | VEO (Elanad Circle) | 01-04-2023 | 26-08-2023 |
| Shri. Suchithran | VEO (Elanad Circle) | 27-08-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Smt. Ramya K | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 01-04-2023 | 27-09-2023 |
| Smt. Manju.P.M | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 28-09-2023 | 03-11-2023 |
| Smt. Shinsa | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 04-11-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Shri. P.K. Shibukumar | Assistant Fisheries Extension Officer | 01-04-2023 | 31-05-2023 |
| Shri. Manoj.C.K | Assistant Fisheries Extension Officer | 01-06-2023 | 06-06-2023 |
| Shri. Shan | Assistant Fisheries Extension Officer | 07-06-2023 | 31-03-2024 |
| Shri. Baiju Baby | Agricultural Officer | 01-04-2023 | 07-06-2023 |
| Smt. Nayana | Agricultural Officer | 08-06-2023 | 11-03-2024 |
| Shri. Krishna.V.R | Agricultural Officer | 12-03-2024 | 31-03-2024 |
Contents
| Sl. No. | Part 1 | Paragraph Number |
|---|---|---|
| Part 2 | ||
| Part 3 | ||
| Part 4 | ||
| Annexure | ||
| 1 | Not all statements required under the Accounting Rules have been included in the annual accounts | 1-1-1 |
| 2 | Audit Certificate | 1-1 |
| 3 | Audit does not certify the accuracy of the Cash Flow Statement | 1-1-2 |
| 4 | Discrepancies noticed in the Bank Reconciliation Statement | 1-1-3 |
| 5 | Unspent amounts shall be refunded | 1-1-4 |
| 6 | Accumulated depreciation amount exceeds the balance of the related asset | 1-1-5 |
| 7 | Amounts given as advance have not been adjusted as expenditure | 1-1-6 |
| 8 | Property Tax - Annual Accounts and DCB Register do not tally | 1-1-7 |
| 9 | Library Cess - the annual accounts and the DCB Register do not tally | 1-1-8 |
| 10 | Amounts given as advance remain unadjusted for a long time | 1-1-9 |
| 11 | Advance amounts given were not booked under the appropriate advance head | 1-1-10 |
| 12 | The unspent grant balances and the closing balance as per the bank/treasury accounts in which they are deposited do not tally | 1-1-11 |
| 13 | "Prior Period item" - approved vouchers or worksheets not maintained | 1-1-12 |
| 14 | Authentic certified vouchers and worksheets should be maintained for journals | 1-1-13 |
| 15 | Lapsed deposits were not credited to revenue | 1-1-14 |
| 16 | Demand entry not recorded at the time of accrual | 1-1-15 |
| 17 | Vehicle maintenance - registers not properly maintained | 1-1-16 |
| 18 | Budget | 1-2 |
| 19 | Fund Utilisation | 1-3 |
| 20 | Plan Review | 1-4 |
| 21 | MGNREGS | 1-5 |
| 22 | Welfare pensions | 1-6 |
| 23 | Cash Balance Verification | 1-7 |
| 24 | Internal control system | 1-8 |
| 25 | Waste management - review | 1-9 |
| 26 | Health Grant amount not utilised | 1-10 |
| 27 | Governing Body meeting minutes - not closed within the time limit | 1-11 |
| 28 | Working Group functioning needs to be made efficient | 1-12 |
| 29 | Irregularities in collection of Profession Tax | 1-13 |
| 30 | Paramedical institutions functioning without renewing licence | 1-14 |
| 31 | Paramedical institutions functioning without registration | 1-15 |
| 32 | Property tax on telephone towers, along with arrears, has not been collected | 1-16-1 |
| 33 | Property tax on commercial buildings assessed at a lower rate | 1-16-2 |
| 34 | Regarding levy of property tax on unaided educational institutions | 1-16-3 |
| 35 | Regarding irregularity in rent | 1-17 |
| 36 | Property tax on unauthorised constructions, along with arrears, has not been collected | 1-18 |
| 37 | Amount paid in advance but medicines not received | 1-19 |
| 38 | MGNREGS - details | 1-20 |
| 39 | Ashraya Scheme share - Utilisation Certificate not available | 1-21 |
| 40 | House construction not continuing | 1-22 |
| 41 | Study room for Scheduled Tribe girl students | 1-23 |
| 42 | Annual AMC of street lights - irregularities | 1-24 |
| 43 | Arrear amount paid to KSEB - details not available | 1-25 |
| 44 | Completion certificate not available for deposit works | 1-26 |
| 45 | Payment of Grama Panchayat share to IKM - Utilisation Certificate not available | 1-27 |
| 46 | Study room not completed | 1-28 |
| 47 | Special Calf Rearing Scheme (Women) - Utilisation Certificate not received | 1-29 |
| 48 | Samagra Shiksha Kerala - payment of share - Utilisation Certificate not available | 1-30 |
| 49 | LIFE - Housing Scheme (General) | 1-31 |
| 50 | Completion of Chakkathukunnu Cultural Centre - the scheme remains an idle asset | 1-32-1 |
| 51 | Day Care Centre (Pakal Veedu) construction, though completed, remains an idle asset | 1-32-2 |
| 52 | Women's Hostel remains an idle asset without being made functional | 1-32-3 |
| 53 | Completion of Mattinmukal Community Hall - follow-up action needs to be taken | 1-32-4 |
| 54 | Community Hall at Thirumani ST Colony - work not completed to date | 1-32-5 |
| 55 | Buildings that are assets of the Grama Panchayat lie idle without being made functional | 1-32 |
| 56 | Penalty not levied when the completion period was extended for contractors in civil works | 1-33 |
| 57 | Civil work - penalty not levied for delay in signing the agreement | 1-34 |
| 58 | Drinking water schemes run directly by the Grama Panchayat - water charge should be collected properly | 1-35 |
| 59 | Street light maintenance needs to be made efficient | 1-36 |
| --- No records found --- | ||
| --- No records found --- | ||
| 1 | Utilisation of funds received for joint projects | 4-1 |
| 2 | Details of amount given for deposit works | 4-2 |
| 3 | Details of Mobilisation Advance | 4-3 |
| 4 | Loan/loan repayment | 4-4 |
| 5 | Fixed Deposit | 4-5 |
| 6 | Audit Recovery | 4-6 |
| 7 | Details of charge/surcharge proceedings | 4-7 |
| 8 | Consolidated Audit Report | 4-8 |
| 9 | Audit Retrospect | 4-9 |
| 10 | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | 4-10 |
| 1 | Audit Certificate | |
| 2 | Utilisation Certificate of Grants | |
| 3 | Summary of annual accounts | |
Part - 1
General Overview
1-1-1 Not all statements required under the Accounting Rules have been included in the annual accounts
Basic ratios and notes have not been included in the Annual Financial Statement.
A) Rule 62E - Notes on accounts - significant accounting policies, contingent liabilities, grant-in-aid reports, etc.
B) Rule 62 F - Basic ratios.
1-1 Audit Certificate
1. As per Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, and in accordance with the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, KSAD Audit Manual Chapters 4.2.1 & 11.3, and the guidelines and compliance instructions issued from time to time by the State Government/Central Government, the Finance Commission and other funding agencies, I have audited the financial statements, prepared as per Committee Decision No. 6(1) dated 28.06.2024 and submitted on 02.07.2024 along with supporting forms, of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat's Receipts & Payments Statement and Income & Expenditure Statement for the year ended March 2024, and the Balance Sheet as on 31.03.2024, comprising the financial statements. Preparation of these accounts is the responsibility of the management of the Panchayat Raj Institution. My responsibility is to express an opinion on these accounts based on the financial audit.
1. I have conducted my financial audit in accordance with the auditing standards issued by the C&AG of India and the guidelines issued by the C&AG for the financial audit of Panchayat Raj Institutions. These standards/guidelines require that I plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance as to whether the financial statements are free from factual misstatement. The audit includes examining the evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. The audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and the significant estimates made, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the accounts. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
On the basis of the information and explanations that were necessary and that I received, and on the basis of the best information and explanations obtained by me as a result of the financial audit of the accounts, and subject to my observations in the accompanying report, I hereby certify as follows.
Qualified Opinion
Except for the matters described in the Basis for Qualified Opinion in the Annexure Report, and subject to the other observations therein, Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat's annual financial statements for the year 2023-24 present a true and fair view of the financial results and the financial position.
Place: Thrissur
Date : 13.11.2024
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
1-1-2 Accuracy of the Cash Flow Statement is not certified in audit
Since the Cash Flow Statement submitted along with the annual accounts has the deficiencies noted below, its accuracy is not certified in audit.
As per the Cash Flow Statement, the amount recorded as "Net increase in cash and cash equivalents" for the period 2023-24 is Rs. 27386328. However, in the same statement, the amount recorded as "Net cash generated by Operating+Investing+Financing Activity" for the period 2023-24 is Rs. -10844971. As per accepted accounting standards the above two amounts should match; however, the two amounts in the statement submitted by the Panchayat do not match.
1-1-3 Discrepancies noticed in the Bank Reconciliation Statement
Under the head "Cheque deposited but not Cleared", a cheque deposited long ago but still not cleared is included. No steps have been taken to verify from whom this receipt is due and to collect the amount, if recoverable. Details of the cheque are furnished below.
| Voucher number | Voucher Date | Instrument Number | Instrument Date | Amount | |
| CANARA BANK-UPI PAYMENT PAZHAYANNUR( 120024199263 ) | 1230106794 | 20.03.2024 | 11111 | 20.03.2024 | 328 |
| FARMERS SERVICE CO OP BANK, PAZHAYANNUR ( 840 ) | 1230103067 | 02.11.2023 | 941270 | 05-08-2023 | 1201 |
| STATE BANK OF INDIA PAZHAYANNUR( 37121561057 ) | 1220000008 | 08.04.2022 | 5 | ||
| 1220000010 | 11.04.2022 | 120 | |||
| 1220000017 | 13.04.2022 | 120 | |||
| 1220000019 | 13.04.2022 | 120 | |||
| 1220000021 | 18.04.2022 | 220 | |||
| 1220000118 | 13.05.2022 | 120 | |||
| 1220000119 | 13.05.2022 | 120 | |||
| 1220000120 | 13.05.2022 | 5 | |||
| 1220000121 | 13.05.2022 | 120 | |||
| 1220000123 | 16.05.2022 | 120 |
The following cheque, which has not been cleared, is included under "Cheque issued but not presented into bank (P)".
| Voucher number | Voucher Date | Instrument Number | Instrument Date | Amount | |
| CANARA BANK-OWN FUND PAZHAYANNUR (4667101002064 ) | 22100934 | 20.11.2021 | 708154 | 18.11.2021 | 9,990 |
| SUB TREASURY OWN FUND CHELAKKARA (799013000000652) | 22300765 | 07.12.2023 | 3043903 | 05.12.2023 | 2500 |
A reply shall be furnished.
1-1-4 Unspent amounts shall be refunded
On examination of the Balance Sheet (B-4), it is seen that amounts received from various agencies for the Panchayat's development activities remain unspent to date. Where the amount is not spent, it shall be refunded to the respective heads.
| Sl. No. | Head (320300199) | Unspent amount |
| 1 | M.N.Laksham veedu | 3,10,000 |
| 2 | Vimukthi | 47,797 |
| 3 | Corpus Fund (ST) | 3,47,987 |
| 4 | Premonsoon Campaign | 1,51,602 |
1-1-5 Accumulated depreciation amount exceeds the balance of the related asset
As per the Balance Sheet as on 31.03.2024, assets under the head 410800101 - Other Fixed Asset have been valued at Rs. 32,73,276. However, as per the Balance Sheet, the Accumulated Depreciation of these assets as on 31.3.2024 is Rs. 72,01,157. No reply has been furnished regarding depreciation being provided for in excess of the value of the assets.
1-1-6 Amounts given as advance have not been adjusted as expenditure
1. Under the head 460500501-Advance to implementing officers, an advance of Rs. 2,20,000 has been given during the current year for pre-monsoon cleaning expenses in devolved institutions. Details of the advance given are furnished below.
| Name of Implementing Officer | Amount given as advance |
| Medical Officer, Family Health Centre, (Pre-monsoon expenses) | 2,20,000 |
As per the above ledger, the amounts given as advance have not been adjusted as expenditure. Since these expenses have not been recorded as expenditure in the annual accounts, an excess balance amount remains under the asset head.
2. As per the ledger of the asset head "460500306- Advance to Community Development Society", Rs. 25,000 has been paid. Although the utilisation certificate for this has been received, the said amount has not been adjusted as expenditure. Hence it remains as an excess balance in the asset head. Reply to the irregularities has not been furnished.
1-1-7 Property Tax - Annual accounts do not tally with the D.C.B. Register
The property tax demand amount obtained from the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the demand register for property tax, is the amount added as demand in the "Finance Module of ILGMS", the software used to prepare the accounts. Collection of property tax, issue of receipts and preparation of the ledger are done using the "Finance Module of the ERP called ILGMS". It is the receipt collection recorded here that is automatically posted to the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the demand register for property tax. Since this is how it is prepared, the amounts under demand, collection and balance as per the D.C.B. Register and as per the statements in the annual accounts ought to tally. However, the year-end summary amounts as per the D.C.B. Register for property tax and library cess prepared in the "Sanchaya" software do not tally with the amounts in the annual accounts prepared in the "Finance Module of ILGMS". In the above circumstances, the reason for the annual accounts and the D.C.B. Register not tallying should be identified and rectified.
Current year
Property Tax - Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 2945561 | 2572331 | 18205 | 359246 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 2945561 | 2568209 | 18993 | 359671 |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-45) | (Ledger of 350410101-Advance collection-PT on Res. bldg) | *(377655/105X100)= (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A minor difference in amount; treating it as a rounding-off amount, the figure in Sanchaya is adopted |
Property Tax - Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 5083148 | 4281220 | 13284 | 814394 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 5083148 | 4255548 | 12683 | 898027 |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-45) | (Ledger of 350410104-Advance collection-PT on NR bldg) | *(855263/105X100) (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) |
Arrears
Property Tax - Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 84125 | 27429 | 56706 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 82559 * | 27429 | 56802 ** |
*(For 2022-23 (29527+57159= | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-45) | **(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15)(59642/105X100) |
Property Tax - Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 1584323 | 34088 | 1550242 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 1584577 | 34088 | 1550480 |
(For 2022-23 *(294767+1369038= | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-45) | **(1628004/105X100) (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) |
1-1-8 Library Cess - Annual accounts do not tally with the D.C.B. Register
| Demand | Collection | Advance adj us ted | Demand reduced | Balance | ||||||||
| Current Year | arr ears | Total | Current Year | arr ears | Total | Current Year | arr ears | Total | ||||
| As per "Sanchaya" software | Resi dential | 150630 | 4343 | 154973 | 131334 | 1397 | 132731 | 1047 | 18409 | 2936 | 21348 | |
| Non-Resi dential | 255479 | 79482 | 334961 | 215133 | 1713 | 216846 | 678 | 40869 | 77762 | 118632 | ||
| Total | 489934 | 349577 | 139980 | |||||||||
| Annual accounts' various statements as per | 489936 | 349577 | 349577 | 139976 | ||||||||
| 83708+ 406228=(2022-23 Balance Sheet Schedule, B-15, 431910101 -State govt. Cess/levies. Ledger 2023-24) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-35 (Receipts)) | (431910101-State govt. Cess/levies. Ledger 2023-24) | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) | |||||||||
1-1-9 Advances paid remain unadjusted for a long period
Amounts paid as advance to Implementing Officers/others for various purposes are not seen to have been adjusted so far. Details of the amounts remaining unadjusted for a long period are given below.
1. Amounts remaining unadjusted for a long period under the head 460100103 - Temporary Advance for Official Purpose.
| Date | Voucher No. | Person who received the advance | Item | Amount |
| 28.09.2017 | 21700619 | Secretary | Keralolsavam | 25000 |
| 23.03.2021 | 22001719 | Sheeja E.M | Honorarium for Sakshartha Preraks (Literacy Motivators) | 16896 |
| 23.03.2021 | 22001720 | Prasanna K | Honorarium for Sakshartha Preraks (Literacy Motivators) | 16512 |
| 13.04.2021 | 2210055 | Sheeja E.M | Honorarium for Sakshartha Preraks (Literacy Motivators) | 8832 |
| 13.04.2021 | 2210056 | Prasanna K | Honorarium for Sakshartha Preraks (Literacy Motivators) | 8832 |
| 06.05.2021 | 22100179 | Sheeja E.M | Honorarium for Sakshartha Preraks (Literacy Motivators) | 9600 |
| 06.05.2021 | 22100179 | Prasanna K | Honorarium for Sakshartha Preraks (Literacy Motivators) | 9600 |
| 18.08.2021 | 22100505 | Gokul Das | Refreshment charge | 450 |
| 18.08.2021 | - | Gokul Das | Refreshment charge | 975 |
| 18.08.2021 | 22100613 | Gokul Das | Refreshment charge | 675 |
| Total | 97372 |
2. Amounts remaining unadjusted under the head 460100199 - Other advances
| Date | Voucher number | Person who received the advance | Item | Amount |
| 24.08.2019 | 21800508 | Deputy director Of Panchayat | Flood Relief | 10000 |
| 12.09.2023 | 22300457 | Clean Pazhayannur, Green Pazhayannur | - | 500000 |
3. Amounts remaining unadjusted under the head 460500399 - Advance to other Authorised agencies
| Date | Voucher number | Person who received the advance | Item | Amount |
| 14.09.2022 | 22200465 | Clean Pazhayannur, Green Pazhayannur | - | 300000 |
If the above amounts cannot be adjusted, they should be recovered and the fact intimated.
1-1-10 Advance amounts paid were not booked under the appropriate advance head
Under various projects implemented during 2023-24, advance amounts have been transferred to the Homoeo Dispensary/FHC for purchase of medicines. However, instead of recording the amount under the appropriate advance head when the advance is paid and adjusting it as expenditure only when the goods are received, the advance amount paid has been recorded directly under the expenditure head. Details are given below.
| Project number and name | Amount | Voucher number / date | Head under which expenditure was booked | Head under which expenditure should have been recorded |
69/24 (Purchase of medicine and dispensary items for the Homoeo Dispensary) | 2,50,000 | 42300873/ 06-02-2024 | 251110208Medical InstitutionHomoeo-Purchase of medicines in health institutions | 460500501- Advance to implementing Officers- |
| 41/24 (Purchase of medicine for the FHC) | 2,27,379 | 42300874/ 06-02-2024 | 251110008Medical InstitutionAlloppathy-Purchase Of Medicines For Hospitals | 460500501- Advance to implementing Officers- |
| 41/24 (Purchase of medicine for the FHC) | 1,02,787 | 42300985/14.03.24 | 251110008Medical InstitutionAlloppathy-Purchase Of Medicines For Hospitals | 460500501-Advance to implementing Officers- |
The amount has been transferred as per the above projects implemented by the Medical Officer Homoeo and the FHC, but the medicines have not been received to date. Though the advance amount ought to have been booked under the head "Advance remaining to be adjusted", it was wrongly recorded under the expenditure head.
1-1-11 The grant amounts remaining to be spent do not tally with the balance as per the bank/treasury accounts in which they are deposited
The balance as per Balance Sheet Schedule B-4 of unspent amounts out of funds received for special purpose schemes must equal the balance as per Schedule B-17 of the bank accounts in which such amounts are held. However, the balance of the special purpose grants shown below does not tally with the balance in the bank accounts of the said funds. Details are given below.
| Head | Balance as per Schedule B-4 | Bank Account | Balance as per Schedule B-17 |
| 320200104-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Basic Tax | 24,95,269 | 450210101- Punjab National Bank CFCPFMS (A/c 4335000100085560) | 1,28,97,330 |
| 320200113-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Tied Fund | 1,03,53,563 | ||
| Total | 1,28,48,832 |
A reply should be furnished regarding the non-tallying of the special purpose grant balances and the bank account balances.
1-1-12 "Prior Period Item" - Approved vouchers or worksheets not maintained
As per the Income & Expenditure Account (I-18, I-19), approved vouchers or worksheets supporting the amounts written off, the amounts adjusted as income, and the correction entries made through journal vouchers in the following ledgers have not been made available to audit. Hence it has not been possible to ascertain whether the entries in the ledger given below are lawful or accurate.
| Head (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-18, I-19) | Ledger balance as on 31/3/2024 |
| 290800101-Prior period Expenses-Establishment Expenses | 4112 |
| 190100101-Prior period income-Property tax | 1663 |
| 190100102-Prior period income-Profession tax | 13000 |
| 190200101-Prior period income-Rent from Building | -45114 |
| 190200201--Prior period income-Licence Fees | 4500 |
| 190200401-Prior period income-Other income | 85222 |
1-1-13 Authoritative attested vouchers and worksheets should be maintained for journal entries
Transactions not connected with cash or bank/treasury accounts should be recorded in the journal book (Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 7). Authoritative attested vouchers and worksheets should be maintained and preserved for all vouchers, including journal vouchers. At present, journal entries are recorded without any such control. It is seen that no vouchers are maintained for journal entries made mainly to write off collection, balance, advance, arrear demand, arrear collection and arrear balance under property tax, to adjust them, to manually reconcile them with the amount in the D.C.B. Register as per the Sanchaya software, and to increase the advance amount. Authoritative attested vouchers and worksheets should be maintained and preserved for all journal vouchers.
1-1-14 Deposits that have lapsed were not credited to the fund
As per Article 282 of the Kerala Financial Code, Volume I, and Rule 79 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, it is clearly provided that amounts such as deposits not refunded even after their period of validity and cheques not encashed from the Panchayat account in Local Self Government Institutions should be credited to the own fund of the respective institution on the very next day of completion of three years of validity. However, on scrutiny of the Grama Panchayat's Deposit Register, it is seen that there are deposit amounts that have not been refunded even after 3 years.
Details of deposits more than 3 years old are given below.
| Sl. No. | Item | Amount |
| 1 | Suppliers Earnest Money Deposit | 45,216 |
| 2 | Bidder’s Earnest Money Deposit | 52,000 |
| 3 | Suppliers Security Deposit | 8,500 |
| 4 | Bidder’s Security Deposit | 14,225 |
| 5 | Contractor’s Retention | 83,453 |
| 6 | Auction Deposit | 14,000 |
| 7 | Deposit of Rent & Halls | 2,000 |
| 8 | Other Deposits | 17,058 |
| 2,36,452 |
Steps should be taken to credit these to the own fund of the Panchayat.
1-1-15 Demand entry not recorded at the time of accrual
Income on accrual basis ought to have been entered through a monthly demand journal entry based on the summary statement prepared monthly by the Secretary, the Assessment Register and the Assessment/Demand Notice (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 17(2)). Reduction of demand/writing off/grant of remission should also be done through journal entries based on the monthly summary statement prepared by the Secretary. This recording should be based on the journal voucher, worksheet and lawful sanction. However, on scrutiny of the ledger of tax and non-tax income on accrual basis for the year 2023-24 of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, it is seen that the demand for the financial year has been recorded only once. There are also no vouchers validating these demand entries. Details are given below.
| Income head | Journal voucher number/date | Amount for which demand was recorded as a single entry |
| 110100101-Property tax on Residential buildings | 42301486/31.03.24 | 2945561 |
| 110100102-Property tax on Non Residential buildings | 42301487/31.03.24 | 5083148 |
| 110200105-Profession tax- Traders | 42301521/31.03.24 | 499150 |
| 130100101-Rent from buildings | 42301508/31.03.24 | 2407613 |
1-1-16 Vehicle maintenance - Registers not properly maintained
As per the Annual Financial Statement, the following amounts have been spent towards fuel expenses and maintenance of vehicles.
| Fuel expenses (230100201 & 230100202) | 193300 |
| Maintenance expenses (230500902) | 29023 |
However, as the Fuel Register and Maintenance Register have not been properly written up, attested and maintained, it has not been possible to verify the correctness of the above expenditure.
1-2 Budget
The Budget has been prepared following the procedures to be observed for preparation of the budget as laid down in the 'Manual for Preparation of Budget for Grama Panchayats in Kerala' approved as per G.O.(Rt) No. 3291/2016/LSGD dated 02.12.2016, and Sections 175 and 214 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994.
The Budget has been approved as per Decision (1) of the Governing Body meeting held on 30.03.2023.
The Budget has been revised as per Decision (1) of the Governing Body meeting held on 08.02.2024. A summary of the budget is given below.
| Budget summary | Revised budget summary | |
| Opening Balance | 37,52,782 | 8,51,245 |
| Current year receipts | 43,27,64,750 | 39,17,93,675 |
| Total receipts | 43,65,17,532 | 39,26,44,920 |
| Expenditure | 43,04,30,616 | 39,19,16,519 |
| Balance | 60,86,916 | 7,28,402 |
1-3 Fund Utilisation
Based on the Annual Financial Statement and the ACR, details of receipts and expenditure of funds available to the Panchayat are given.
A)
| Fund Head | Previous Balance | Current year Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Lapsed amount |
| Development Fund - General | 0 | 38234000 | 38234000 | 33735912 | 4498088 |
| Development Fund - SCP | 0 | 16246000 | 16246000 | 12543963 | 3702037 |
| Development Fund - TSP | 0 | 819000 | 819000 | 142023 | 676977 |
| Maintenance, Road | 0 | 17610000 | 17610000 | 15591719 | 2018281 |
| Maintenance, Non-Road | 0 | 4074000 | 4074000 | 2893778 | 1180222 |
| Total | 7,69,83,100 | 7,69,83,100 | 6,49,07,395 | 1,20,75,605 |
Out of Rs. 7,69,83,100 received for the development activities of the Panchayat, Rs. 1,20,75,605 has lapsed unspent.
B)
| Fund Head | Previous Balance | Current year Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance |
| Central Finance Commission Grant (Basic grant) | 3661053 | 6660594 | 10321647 | 7826378 | 2495269 |
Central Finance Commission Grant (tied) | 8390975 | 4748500 | 13139475 | 2785912 | 10353563 |
| Grants for Specific Purposes - Health Grant twards conversion of PHCs and Subcentres in to Health and Wellness Centres | 281095 | 500323 | 781418 | 272451 | 508967 |
| Grants for Specific Purposes - Health Grant Towards support for diagnostic InfraStructure to the PHCs | 501508 | 1232050 | 1733558 | 290835 | 1442723 |
| Grants for Specific Purposes - Health Grant towards buildingless Subcentres, PHCs and CHCs | 0 | 8416501 | 8416501 | 0 | 8416501 |
| ICDS | 999768 | 3114754 | 4114522 | 1984684 | 2129838 |
| Jeevadhara | 26520 | 0 | 26520 | 0 | 26520 |
| TSC | 310870 | 10000 | 320870 | 6000 | 314870 |
| Grants, Funds &Contributions For Specific Purposes - Other Government Agencies. | 2960305 | 1944374 | 4904679 | 3857390 | 1047289 |
| Contributions For Joint Venture Projects (For Revenue Expenditure) -Block Panchayats | 1249015 | 4486300 | 5735315 | 4486300 | 1249015 |
| Fund For Transferred Institutions - Homoeopathy- Capital | 450000 | 0 | 450000 | 398192 | 51808 |
| Jalanidhi | 1181205 | 0 | 1181205 | 0 | 1181205 |
| Hariyali | 319587 | 8741 | 328328 | 0 | 328328 |
| Life Mission State Share | 0 | 3600000 | 3600000 | 0 | 3600000 |
| Other schemes (CIAAK, Bhavananidhi) | 53702 | 0 | 53702 | 0 | 53702 |
| Grants, Funds &Contributions For Specific Purposes-Other Purposes | 1418108 | 1140000 | 2558108 | 299798 | 2258310 |
1-4 Plan Review
A) Details of implementation of projects approved during the audit year are given below.
Appr (Number) | Plan outlay | Implem (Number) | Plan expenditure | Parti (Number) | Implem (Number) | Compl eted project s percentage |
| 257 | 211799137 | 157 | 99813318 | 0 | 116 | 61.08 |
B) Details of implementation of projects sanctioned by various Implementing Officers are given below.
| Implementing Officer | Number of appr oved projects | Estimate | Number of projects implemented and amount spent | Expenditure | Expenditure percentage |
| Agricultural Officer | 8 | 9463390 | 7 | 5872983 | 62.06 |
| Veterinary Surgeon | 5 | 3370000 | 5 | 2102330 | 62.38 |
| Medical Officer - FHC | 15 | 6114576 | 13 | 3196366 | 52.27 |
| Medical Officer - Ayurveda | 3 | 1050000 | 2 | 1019878 | 97.13 |
| Medical Officer - Homoeo | 2 | 270000 | 2 | 270000 | 100 |
| Sub Inspector of Fisheries | 3 | 324000 | 3 | 77860 | 24.03 |
| V.E.O | 10 | 69816213 | 8 | 32199813 | 46.12 |
| ICDS Supervisor | 8 | 9094050 | 8 | 6911338 | 76 |
| Dairy Extension Officer | 1 | 2500000 | 1 | 2500000 | 100 |
| Grama Panchayat Secretary | 42 | 14039726 | 29 | 12702084 | 90.47 |
| Assistant Engineer | 139 | 88119114 | 66 | 29526794 | 33.51 |
| Head Master | 6 | 1700000 | 3 | 443512 | 26.09 |
| Assistant Secretary | 15 | 5938068 | 10 | 2990360 | 50.36 |
| Total | 257 | 211799137 | 157 | 99813318 | 47.13 |
Out of 257 approved projects, 157 (61.08%) have been implemented. Only 47.13% of the amount allotted has been spent. Preparing and implementing projects for economic development and social justice is a constitutional duty of Local Self Government Institutions. Care should be taken to maintain the time schedule in formulating projects and obtaining approval so as to utilise the fund to the maximum extent. Plan activities should be planned in such a way that the maximum amount is spent within the respective financial year itself. Monitoring should be made effective and fund utilisation ensured by evaluating the progress of the plan.
1-5 MGNREGS
| Item | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance |
| Administrative Expenses | 0 | 1084746 | 1084746 | 1084746 | 0 |
| Given directly to beneficiaries | 0 | 57694424 | 57694424 | 57694424 | 0 |
| Total | 0 | 58779170 | 58779170 | 58779170 | 0 |
Administrative expenditure is Rs. 1604582 as per I 14(f) of the Income & Expenditure Statement, but Rs. 1084746 as per the NREGA Cash Book. The reason for the difference should be explained.
1-6 Welfare Pensions
| Name of Scheme | Expenditure Amount | Number of Beneficiaries |
| Agricultural Labourer Pension | 649 | 75,76,000 |
| Widow Pension | 1933 | 2,03,29,600 |
| Old Age Pension | 3860 | 3,95,65,500 |
| Disability Pension | 492 | 54,21,800 |
| For unmarried women aged 50 and above - Pension | 227 | 25,64,000 |
| Marriage assistance for daughters of widows | 9 | 2,70,000 |
1-7 Cash Balance Verification
Verification of cash balance under Section 6(4) of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, was conducted on 31.08.2024 at 2.15 pm in the presence of the Panchayat Accountant. On verification, the accuracy of the cash balance of Rs. 41,147 was confirmed.
1-8 Internal Control System
Deficiencies in internal control have been incorporated in the various paragraphs of Part 1 of this report.
1-9 Waste Management - Review
Waste management is a subject included among the mandatory functions of the Grama Panchayat as specified in the Third Schedule under Section 166 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994. Procedures for the formation of Haritha Karma Sena have been issued as per G.O.(Rt) No.2420/17/LSGD dated 15.07.2017, and the operational guidelines of Haritha Karma Sena have been issued as per G.O.(Rt) No.1496/2020/LSGD dated 12.8.2020. In order to achieve the goal of a Waste-Free Navakeralam, and since the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016 can be implemented across the State in a time-bound manner only through a campaign with public participation, the Government launched the campaign 'Malinya Mukta Navakeralam' (Waste-Free Navakeralam) by coordinating all activities being carried out in this sector. As per G.O.(Rt) No.1068/2023/LSGD dated 20.05.2023, the Government directed that the campaign be launched statewide, and the Grama Panchayat has taken steps to implement the order.
The main responsibility entrusted to the Haritha Karma Sena is to collect washed and cleaned inorganic waste from houses and commercial establishments, segregate it at fixed intervals and store it at the MCF. The information obtained through data collection and from the documents produced regarding the biodegradable and non-biodegradable waste management systems and the functioning of the Haritha Karma Sena in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat is given below.
1. Basic information
The total population of the Grama Panchayat, which has 22 wards, is 40256. There are 10433 occupied houses and 998 establishments across the various wards. 44 Haritha Karma Sena members are working across the 22 wards. All houses and establishments are availing of the services of the Haritha Karma Sena.
2. Efficiency of waste collection
A calendar has been prepared and distributed in advance for waste collection. The authorities have informed that waste is collected from houses and establishments as per the prepared schedule and that it has been possible to make all establishments and houses participants in door-to-door waste collection.
3. Compliance with waste segregation
The method currently followed is to collect waste from houses and commercial establishments in all wards, segregate it on the spot and transport it to the MCFs. 100% of the waste is segregated at source itself.
4. Recycling
It has been reported that it has been decided to implement schemes such as distribution of ink pens, distribution of steel plates, distribution of steel glasses, and cloth bags in place of plastic covers, to encourage the use of reusable items.
5. Community engagement
Door-to-door classes are being conducted to create awareness among the public about waste management practices.
6. Employment generation
3000 employment days have been created for Haritha Sena members during 2023-24. It has not been possible to ensure an average monthly income of Rs. 10,000 for Haritha Karma Sena members. There are no facilities such as organic manure production enterprises/swap shops in the Grama Panchayat for increasing the income of Haritha Karma Sena members. At present, the Viability Gap Fund is not being utilised for payment of wages.
7. Infrastructure development
There is one waste treatment plant in the Grama Panchayat. As per G.O.(Rt) No. 1068/2023/LSGD dated 20.05.2023, it is stipulated that every Grama Panchayat should have an MCF, every ward a Mini MCF, and Block/Municipal level an RRF. However, it has not been possible to set up Mini MCFs in all wards. The Panchayat has set up ten Mini MCFs and one MCF. A total of Rs. 8,00,000 has been spent on waste management related schemes during the financial year 2023-24.
8. Environmental impact
A Vigilance Squad has been formed to take legal action against those who violate waste management rules. Four complaints have been received by the Grama Panchayat regarding unauthorised dumping of waste in public places. Inspections were conducted at four establishments, action was taken against these establishments, and a fine of Rs. 32,750 was collected.
Training and development
Two training programmes have been conducted for Haritha Karma Sena members under the aegis of Keltron on door-to-door collection, segregation, QR code and interaction with the public.
Compliance with regulations
It has been reported that the Green Protocol is being implemented in public functions and celebrations, in order to comply with waste management rules and standards, and that awareness programmes and enforcement measures are being undertaken in this regard.
11. Functioning of Haritha Karma Sena members.
A review meeting is held every month to evaluate the functioning of the Haritha Karma Sena. Special meetings and discussions are also held for this purpose.
12. MCF - Basic information
| A) Number of MCFs and Mini MCFs (separately). | MCF- 1, Mini MCF-10 |
| B) Basic facilities in the MCFs (washing & bathing area, etc.). | Available |
| C) Has a fire-fighting system been provided in the MCFs? | Available |
| D) Other machinery (baling, shredding units). | Shredding unit |
| E) Does the MCF have adequate area commensurate with the waste handled? | Available |
| F) Do the MCFs have a tipping area, storage area, sorting area, machine area and final storage area? If so, what percentage each of the total area. | Available. |
| G) How many days can inorganic waste be stored in the final storage area | 2 months |
| H) Is cleanliness maintained in the MCF and are hygiene standards being complied with? | Available. |
| I) Are there any social problems related to the MCF? (Such as disputes with the public relating to bad odour, pest infestation, water pollution, etc.) | None |
| J) Are waste management protocols and safety measures being followed at the MCF to ensure worker safety and environmental protection during segregation of waste? | Available |
13). Efficiency of waste transfer
Waste is collected from all wards once a month. The collected waste is transferred to the MCF on the same day or the following days. Waste collected at the Mini MCFs is transferred to the MCF. Waste stored and segregated at the MCF is collected and transported by a company called Muvan Pro. It has been reported that proper removal of waste is currently being achieved.
Audit Recommendations
1. Inspection should be intensified to ensure that establishments operating under the Grama Panchayat's licence segregate waste, collect biodegradable waste separately, and treat it at source itself.
2. Steps should be taken to collect the user fee regularly.
3. Steps should be taken to provide the necessary facilities at the MCF.
4. In order to ensure the dignity of labour of Haritha Karma Sena members, projects granting financial assistance to start income-generating enterprises may be included in the Annual Plan of the Local Self Government Institution. Training and financial assistance for organic manure production, recycling of waste materials through Kudumbashree, and other enterprises may be considered so as to provide a better income.
5. Penal measures under Section 220(C) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, should be enforced strictly against those who dump waste in public places.
1-10 Health Grant amount not utilised
As per the 2023-24 annual accounts, receipts and expenditure under the Health Grant head are as given below.
| Fund | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance |
| Health Grant At the Community Health Centre Providing diagnostic facilities | 501508 | 1232050 | 1733558 | 290835 | 1442723 |
| Health Grant towards conversions of PHC’s and subcentres into Health wellness centres | 281095 | 500323 | 781418 | 272451 | 508967 |
| Health Grant towards buldingless Subcentres,PHCs and CHCs | 0 | 8416501 | 8416501 | 0 | 8416501 |
| 782603 | 10148874 | 10931477 | 563286 | 10368191 |
During the current year, only Rs. 290835 has been spent from the Health Grant for setting up diagnostic facilities at the Community Health Centre, and only Rs. 272451 for PHC, Health and Wellness activities. Rs. 84,16,501 allotted for PHCs, CHCs and Sub Centres without buildings remains unspent. No reply was received to Audit Enquiry No. 26/02.08.24 which called for details of the projects envisaged for utilising the fund allotted for these specific purposes and their progress/current status. Steps should be taken to utilise the available amount in a time-bound manner.
1-11 Governing Body meeting minutes - Not closed within the time limit
The Sakarma application developed by IKM for making the Governing Body meetings of Local Self Government Institutions online was deployed in the Grama Panchayat pursuant to G.O.(Rt) No.3630/2015/LSGD dated 3.12.2015. However, on scrutiny of the procedures for Governing Body meetings through the Sakarma application, it was found that the time limit under Rule 26 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Procedure for Meetings of Panchayats) Rules, 1995, is not being observed in the completion of minutes. As per Rule 26(8), the Secretary is required to prepare the minutes within three days of the meeting and submit them for the President's approval. However, there is a delay of several months in preparing the minutes. Details of meetings held and minutes prepared during 2023-24 are given below.
| Date of meeting | Secretary's minutes prepared and forwarded for approval Date sent | Date on which the President approved the minutes |
| 12/04/23 | 21/04/23 | 21/04/23 |
| 17/05/23 | 22/08/23 | 22/08/23 |
| 20/06/23 | 02/01/24 | 08/01/24 |
| 21/07/23 | 09/03/24 | 09/03/24 |
| 05/08/23 | 09/03/24 | 09/03/24 |
| 21/08/23 | 09/03/24 | 09/03/24 |
| 16/09/23 | 11/05/24 | 12/06/24 |
| 29/09/23 | 19/06/24 | 19/06/24 |
| 21/10/23 | 11/07/24 | 11/07/24 |
| 18/11/23 | 22/08/24 | 23/08/24 |
| 16/12/23 | 21/08/24 | 27/08/24 |
| 29/12/23 | 21/08/24 | 27/08/24 |
| 04/01/24 | 11/03/24 | 11/03/24 |
| 09/01/24 | 22/08/24 | 27/08/24 |
| 30/01/24 | 22/08/24 | 27/08/24 |
| 08/02/24 | 12/07/24 | 12/07/24 |
| 29/02/24 | 27/08/24 | 27/08/24 |
| 14/02/24 | 11/03/24 | 11/03/24 |
| 15/02/24 | 11/03/24 | 11/03/24 |
| 02/03/24 | 11/05/24 | 12/06/24 |
The minutes of the following meetings have not been completed to date.
| Sl. No. | Meeting number | Meeting date | Nature of meeting |
| 1 | 09 | 13/03/2024 | Ordinary meeting |
| 2 | 10 | 30/04/2024 | Ordinary meeting |
| 3 | 11 | 22/05/2024 | Ordinary meeting |
| 4 | 12 | 19/06/2024 | Ordinary meeting |
| 5 | 14 | 23/07/2024 | Emergency meeting/ Special meeting |
| 6 | 15 | 14/08/24 | Ordinary meeting |
No reply was received to Audit Enquiry No. 27/02-08-24 which called for the reason for not preparing meeting minutes and obtaining approval within the time limit prescribed under the Rules. Given that the online system was introduced to ensure transparency in procedures, such a long delay in completing the minutes of meetings is inappropriate. Care should be taken to prepare meeting minutes and obtain approval within the time limit prescribed under the Rules.
1-12 Functioning of Working Groups should be made efficient
G.O.(MS) No.84/2022/15 dated Thiruvananthapuram, 19-04-2022, Paragraph 3.1.2 of the guidelines for preparation of Annual Plans within the 14th Five Year Plan of Grama, Block and District Panchayats deals with the reorganisation and duties of the Working Groups of the Grama Panchayat. Accordingly, findings on scrutiny of the minutes of the Working Groups conducted to evaluate the functioning of the Working Groups of the Grama Panchayat are given below.
1. Working Group meeting - Minutes not closed with the signature of the Chairperson recorded.
All Local Self Government Institutions should reorganise the existing Working Groups before 1st November each year, prior to commencing the plan preparation process. The quorum for a Working Group shall be one-third of the total members, and the presence of the Convener is mandatory at the Working Group meeting. Convening the Working Group meeting, recording the minutes, maintaining the minutes book, and properly handing over the relevant records on demitting office are the duties of the Working Group Convener. However, on scrutiny of the minutes, it is seen that the quorum was not met in many meetings. The minutes have not been closed with the signature of the Chairperson recorded.
2. Monitoring report is not prepared.
After the Annual Plan is approved by the District Planning Committee, the Working Groups should function as Monitoring Committees and effectively monitor the projects. However, on scrutiny of the minutes and projects, the Working Groups are not seen to have functioned as Monitoring Committees or prepared monitoring reports.
3. Expenditure accounts of projects are not presented at the Grama Sabha meeting
It is the responsibility of the Working Groups to prepare the information required to be printed and furnished to the Grama Sabha (Forms 4, 5, 6) and the information required to be included in the plan document, and, on completion of a financial year, to prepare the expenditure accounts of the projects implemented in the previous Annual Plan in Form 4 and present them at the very first Grama Sabha meeting held thereafter. However, on scrutiny of the Grama Sabha minutes and the Working Group minutes, the above information is not seen to have been prepared or presented at the Grama Sabha meetings.
4. Project proposals are not submitted to the Standing Committees.
It is the duty of the working groups to give the advice necessary for formulating projects based on the status report, taking into account the general guidelines issued by the Government and the instructions issued by the District Planning Committee, to the concerned Standing Committees and, if necessary, to other working groups, and to assist the Standing Committees in preparing the project proposals to be placed for discussion at the Grama Sabha meeting. However, on examination of the minutes, it is seen that no such instructions have been recorded as having been given to the Standing Committees. No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (28/02.09.24) issued in this regard.
1-13 Irregularities in the collection of Profession Tax
As per Sections 204 and 205 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, Profession Tax may be levied on the employees of every institution that transacts business for not less than a total of sixty days in a half-year within a Panchayat area, and on any person, whether residing within the Panchayat area or outside it, who is engaged in a profession, art or employment, or who carries on business, or who holds a public or private appointment, within or outside the Panchayat area.
1. The applications submitted to the Panchayat by commercial/trading establishments operating within the Panchayat limits for a licence record the number of employees. Accordingly, Profession Tax has been collected only from the employees of a few establishments that have obtained a licence and are operating from the Grama Panchayat. Two or more employees are working in the majority of establishments that have obtained a licence. Because Profession Tax has not been collected from the employees of the majority of the establishments, the Grama Panchayat has suffered a large loss of revenue. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Name of establishment owner/establishment | Number of employees. | Half-year |
| 1 | Akshaya Garments | 13 | 1st & 2nd |
| 2 | Amazing Apparels | 4 | 1st & 2nd |
| 3 | Kelsa Interiors, Pazhayannur | 7 | 1st & 2nd |
| 4 | Veda Herbals | 4 | 1st & 2nd |
| 5 | New Variety Bazar | 4 | 1st & 2nd |
| 6 | Thriveni Supermarket | 3 | 1st & 2nd |
| 7 | Helio Industries | 5 | 1st & 2nd |
| 8 | N.S.A. Fuels | 5 | 1st & 2nd |
| 9 | Bharat Automobiles | 5 | 1st & 2nd |
| 10 | CC Fashion Pazhayannur | 6 | 1st & 2nd |
| 11 | CC Dress World Pazhayannur | 10 | 1st & 2nd |
| 12 | Auto Mark Service Centre | 6 | 1st & 2nd |
| 13 | Chacko Group | 8 | 1st & 2nd |
| 14 | Vishal Fuels | 6 | 1st & 2nd |
| 15 | Star Motors | 3 | 1st & 2nd |
| 16 | Al Shifa Match Company | 6 | 1st & 2nd |
| 17 | Keraleeya Ayurveda Samajam Agency & Nursing Home, Pazhayannur | 4 | 1st & 2nd |
| 18 | N.S. Agencies | 3 | 1st & 2nd |
| 19 | Punyam Enterprise | 4 | 1st & 2nd |
| 20 | Great Motors | 8 | 1st & 2nd |
| 21 | Sona Cement Bricks | 5 | 1st & 2nd |
| 22 | Hotel New Light Palace & Bakes | 8 | 1st & 2nd |
| 23 | Sreevari Automotives | 8 | 1st & 2nd |
2. Profession Tax has not been collected from the following contractors who undertook and executed public works of the Grama Panchayat during the financial year 2023-24.
| Sl. No. | Name of Contractor |
| 1 | Lipin M.V. |
| 2 | Muhammed Basheer K.A. |
| 3 | Prasad T.N. |
| 4 | Rajan C. |
| 5 | Rasheed P.M. |
| 6 | Ratheesh T. |
| 7 | Ravi R. |
| 8 | Roy K.M. |
| 9 | Shameer K.M. |
| 10 | Sreejith K.S. |
| 11 | Surendran R. |
| 12 | Vavachan Joseph |
| 13 | Vijayakumar A.G. |
| 14 | Abbas K.M. |
| 15 | Abdul Kareem |
| 16 | Abdul Khader K.M. |
| 17 | Abhilash P. George |
| 18 | Anwar Hussain P.H. |
| 19 | Biju M. Mathew |
| 20 | P.C. George |
| 21 | Hakeem N. |
| 22 | Hamsa K.M. |
| 23 | Harinarayanan V.P. |
| 24 | Krishnadas P.S. |
In reply to the audit enquiry (09/29.08.2024) issued for the above irregularities, it has been intimated that notices have been issued to the above establishments for payment of Profession Tax.
requiring the employer to submit returns covering all employees of the establishments, and collecting Profession Tax from all employees as per the returns. The Grama Panchayat should take effective steps to correctly assess Profession Tax and to demand and collect the assessed tax amount, on the basis of the Panchayat Raj Act and the Profession Tax Rules. Profession Tax due under the rules should be urgently collected from the above-mentioned defaulters and the records produced for audit. The matter is brought to the notice of the Finance Standing Committee.
1-14 Paramedical establishments operating without renewing their licence
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act and the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trading Establishments, Industrial Undertakings and Other Services) Rules, 1996, none of the items included in the schedule to the said Rules shall be operated within the panchayat limits without the permission of the panchayat.
On verification of the Registration Register and the FATEOS Licence Register of paramedical establishments for the financial year 2023-24, it is seen that the following establishments, though they have renewed their registration, are operating without renewing their licence.
| Sl. No. | Establishment | Name of establishment owner |
| 1 | Pulse Homistic Health Care & Rehabilitation Centre, Vadakkethara | Muhammed Fazalur Rahman K., Kolathuparambil, Paruthippara |
| 2 | Arul Clinical Laboratory & Digital X-Ray, Vadakkethara | Sivaprasad K.V. Koziattil House, Vadakkanchery |
| 3 | Arul Clinical Laboratory, Pazhayannur | Usha O.M. Kottiattil House Vadakkethara, Pazhayannur |
| 4 | Arul Clinical Laboratory, Thekkethara, Pazhayannur | Usha O.M., Kottiattil House Vadakkethara, Pazhayannur |
| 5 | Ambadi's Confidential Care, Pazhayannur | Dr. Preethi N. Preethi Mandir, Thiruvilwamala |
| 6 | Krupa Hi-Tech Laboratory, Elanad | Sally Baby Kodiyath House, Kumbalakode |
| 7 | Krupa Hi-Tech Laboratory, Vadakkethara | Sally Baby Kodiyath House, Kumbalakode |
| 8 | Navodaya Medical Centre, Pazhayannur | Abdul Jaleel P.M. Rahmania Manzil, Vandazhi |
| 9 | Sudharma Specialty Laboratory, Pazhayannur | Ameer Ali M. Malavattath House Pulamanthol, Perinthalmanna |
| 10 | Hi-Tech Laboratory, Elanad | Mini Jose Marangolil House, Elanad |
| 11 | Jeeva Hi-Tech Laboratory, Elanad | Reena Kuriakose Manakkadanpillil Thekkethil, Elanad |
| 12 | Vinayaka Metro Medical Lab, Pazhayannur | Krishnanunni M., Villadath House, Chelakkode |
| 13 | Smile Care Dental Clinic, Pazhayannur | Ashwin Kumar S.G. Madayakkappilly, Thodupuzha |
| 14 | Trust Care Homoeopathic Clinic, Pazhayannur | Sajna Nellikunnan Puthenpeedikayil House, Chelakkode |
| 15 | Elanad Emergency Care Centre | Leo Joseph Adampukulam House Poothrayikkal, Cherpu |
| 16 | Homoeopathic Clinic, | Dr. Aneesha Kurian Mekattil House, South Kondazhy |
| 17 | Holy Care Diagnostics Clinical Laboratory | Sneha Mary George Kollannur House, Alathur |
| 18 | Karunya Dental Clinic, Pazhayannur | K.M. Basheer Kunnathumkara |
| 19 | Karunya Institute of Paramedical Technology | Dr. Vanaja Haridas Kunnath House |
| 20 | Karunya Dental Clinic | K.M. Shamseen Ollukkara |
| 21 | Smitha Dental Care, Elanad | Manju Palakkathadathil House, Elanad |
In reply to the audit enquiry (10/29.08.2024) seeking an explanation regarding the operation of establishments without a licence, it has been intimated that notices have been issued to the above establishments. All establishments operating within the Panchayat area that require a licence under the rules should be brought within the ambit of licensing, and the licence fee should be collected from all establishments liable to pay it. The attention of the Finance Standing Committee is invited to this matter. Information on further action taken should be intimated.
1-15 Paramedical establishments operating without registration
On verification of the Registration Register and the FATEOS Licence Register of paramedical establishments for the financial year 2023-24, it is seen that the following establishment, though it has obtained a licence, is operating without obtaining/renewing its registration. All private hospitals and paramedical establishments operating within the Panchayat limits were required to obtain registration under the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Registration of Private Hospitals and Paramedical Establishments) Rules, 1997 for the financial year 2023-24.
| Sl. No. | Ward/Building number | Establishment. | Name of establishment owner |
| 1 | 4/920 | Keraleeyam Ayurveda Samajam Agency & Nursing Home | Babu M.K., Muthalangattu House, Kallepadam |
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (11/29.08.2024) issued regarding the above matter. Rule 3(1) of the aforesaid rules stipulates that no private hospital or private paramedical establishment shall be run within the Panchayat limits without prior registration with the Grama Panchayat. Under Rule 8, a fine of up to Rs. 5,000 may be levied on private hospitals and private paramedical establishments that operate without registration and unlawfully, and an additional fine at the rate of Rs. 500 per day may be levied if the unlawful operation continues. Steps should therefore be taken to ensure that the above establishment has obtained registration as required by the rules.
1-16-1 Property tax of telephone towers, including arrears, has not been collected
Although the property tax (for various years) of the following telephone towers within the Grama Panchayat limits has been demanded as per Sanchaya, the tax has not been collected. Rs. 1,78,821 remains to be collected as arrears of property tax of telephone towers as per Sanchaya for 2023-24.
| Sl. No. | Ward No. | Building number | Owner/establishment | Period for which payment is due | Arrears |
| 1 | 4 | 255 | Reliance Mobile Tower, Pazhayannur | 2020- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 36434 |
| 2 | 4 | 598 | Manager, Aircel, Dishnet Wireless Limited, Pazhayannur | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 47453 |
| 3 | 8 | 464 | Indus Towers Limited | 2022- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 19373 |
| 4 | 9 | 163 | India Telecom Infra Limited | 2020- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 18388 |
| 5 | 14 | 535 | Reliance Communications Limited | 2018- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 57173 |
| Total | 1,78,821 | ||||
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (12/29.08.2024) seeking an explanation for not collecting the property tax of the above telephone towers, including arrears. The arrear amount of Rs. 1,78,821 should be collected in full. Details should be furnished to audit.
1-16-2 Property tax assessed for commercial buildings at a lower rate
On verification of the files and software relating to property tax in the Panchayat, it is found that the tax assessment of the following buildings is deficient. For buildings assessed before the 2023 revision of property tax, the base rate for hotels, restaurants, shops and godowns used for commercial purposes with a plinth area up to 100 sq. metres is Rs. 30, and the base rate for hotels, restaurants, shops and godowns with a plinth area exceeding 100 sq. metres is Rs. 50. On verification of the Sanchaya data, it is seen that the total area of the following buildings exceeds 100 sq. metres. However, in assessing the property tax, the base rate has been taken as Rs. 30 instead of Rs. 50.
| Sl. No. | Ward number | Building number | Building owner | Plinth area (sq. m.) |
| 1 | 1 | 804 | Rajan (Plavilayil House) | Ground floor (154 sq. m.) |
| 2 | 3 | 585 | Radhakrishnan, Kalangattuparambil House | Ground floor (122.5 sq. m.) |
| 3 | 4 | 892 | Ramesh K, Gokulam House | Ground floor (156.28 sq. m.) |
| 4 | 7 | 1A | Prakash, Padinjare Veedu | Ground floor (218.87 sq. m.) |
| 5 | 22 | 1067 | Vidarbha, Kodavampadath House, | Ground floor (134.15 sq. m.) |
| 6 | 22 | 1069 | Vidarbha, Kodavampadath House | First floor (120.6 sq. m.) |
The Secretary has not furnished a reply to the audit enquiry (12/29.08.2024) seeking an explanation for the irregularities in assessing property tax. The irregularities in assessing the tax of the said buildings should be rectified and the tax reassessed, and the arrears, along with the tax for the current financial year, should be collected and details furnished to audit.
1-16-3 Regarding levy of property tax on unaided educational institutions
The relevant section of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act (Section 207 BA), which exempts buildings of unaided institutions used for educational purposes and ancillary purposes up to the higher secondary level, and hostel buildings in which students of the educational institution reside, from the levy of property tax, has been inserted through the 18th Amendment Act, 2023, with effect from 1.4.2023. The following unaided educational institutions are functioning within the limits of the Grama Panchayat.
| Sl. No. | Establishment |
| 1 | Saraswathi Vidya Niketan School, Pazhayannur |
| 2 | Bevernic English Medium School, Kallepadam |
| 3 | St. Thomas Convent L.P. School, Pazhayannur |
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (12/29.08.2024) as to whether property tax has been collected from the above institutions for the financial year 2023-24 after excluding the exemption on property tax. If property tax has not been collected, it should be collected and the fact intimated to audit.
1-17 Regarding irregularities in rent
The irregularities noticed on verification of the Rent Register for 2023-24 are given below.
1. Shop rooms lying vacant
As per the Rent Register, it is seen that 15 of the Panchayat's 83 shop rooms were lying vacant during the financial year 2023-24. These shop rooms have not been put up for auction. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Room No. | Location |
| 1 | 110 | Bus Stand Building |
| 2 | 7 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 3 | 8 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 4 | 12 | Mini Shopping Complex |
| 5 | 15 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 6 | 16 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 7 | 17 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 8 | 18 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 9 | 19 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 10 | 20 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 11 | 22 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 12 | 24 | Ambalanada Complex |
| 13 | 1 | Ambalanada Complex Upstairs |
| 14 | 2 | Ambalanada Complex Upstairs |
| 15 | 1 | Ambalanada Complex South Block |
2. Rent has not been increased
Although the rent of the shop rooms owned by the Panchayat was increased in the financial year 2019-20 as per the decision of the Governing Body dated 30.01.2019, the rent does not appear to have been increased in the subsequent years. The rent currently being collected for the shop rooms is the same as the rent for the financial year 2019-20.
3. A rent bye-law has not been prepared and got approved.
Panchayats should prepare a bye-law incorporating the conditions relating to the rent of shop rooms and obtain the approval of the Government. However, the Panchayat has not prepared a rent bye-law and obtained approval. In the absence of a bye-law, the legal validity of the advance and deposit collected under these heads is liable to be questioned. The Panchayat should take steps to prepare a bye-law and obtain the Government's approval.
As part of increasing the Panchayat's own income, steps should be taken to auction the shop rooms and to increase the rent of the shop rooms by a fixed percentage every year. No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (18/31.08.2024) issued regarding the above matters. The special attention of the Finance Standing Committee is invited to this matter.
1-18 Property tax of unauthorised constructions, including arrears, has not been collected
Section 235AA of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 specifies the action that may be taken if any building is constructed or reconstructed unlawfully. Property tax equal to the tax that would have been payable had the building been lawfully constructed, together with an amount equal to twice that tax, shall be levied as property tax for the period from the date of completion of the building, or its use for any of the purposes mentioned in Section 203, sub-section 2, whichever is earlier, up to the date on which the building is demolished.
Although the property tax of the following buildings, constructed unauthorisedly within the Panchayat limits, has been assessed as above, Rs. 7,62,660 remains to be collected as arrears as per Sanchaya for the period up to 2023-24.
| Sl. No. | Ward/Building number | Name of owner | Manner of use | Period for which payment is due | Arrears |
| 1 | 22/888UA | C.P. Aboobacker Siddique, C.P. Ummer & P.K. Abdul Junaid Chandana Parambil Pandika Shalayakkal, Manohari Complex, Pazhayannur, | Commercial | From 2013 to 2023 | 149234 |
| 2 | 22/888UB | From 2020 to 2023 | 4837 | ||
| 3 | 22/888UC | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 8614 | ||
| 4 | 22/888UD | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 19500 | ||
| 5 | 22/888UE | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 10758 | ||
| 6 | 22/888UF | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 11041 | ||
| 7 | 22/888UG | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 7318 | ||
| 8 | 22/888UH | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 7810 | ||
| 9 | 22/888UI | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 30013 | ||
| 10 | 22/888UJ | 2013- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 191192 | ||
| 11 | 4/710 UA | Vasanthan, P.K.B. Nivas, Kallepadam | Residential purpose | 2023- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 1909 |
| 12 | 15/198UA | China, Thottungal, Paruthippara, Elanad | Residential purpose | 2019- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 5348 |
| 13 | 19/567UA | Ramadevadathan, Kattilakode Mana, Pazhayannur | Commercial | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 18481 |
| 14 | 19/567UA | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 12318 | ||
| 15 | 19/567UC | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 12318 | ||
| 16 | 19/567UD | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 12318 | ||
| 17 | 19/567UE | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 11295 | ||
| 18 | 19/567UF | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 12318 | ||
| 19 | 19/567UG | 2015- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 12318 | ||
| 20 | 19/649UA | Achuthanand, Angalur House, Pazhayannur, | Commercial | 2023- 1st Half onwards, 2023 2nd Half to | 223720 |
| Total | 7,62,660 | ||||
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No. 19/31.08.2024) issued regarding the above matter. Until the said unauthorised buildings are regularised or demolished, the property tax of the said buildings, including arrears, should be collected and the fact intimated to audit.
1-19 Amount paid in advance but medicines not received
1. Medicines not received from Homco
The Medical Officer (Homoeo), the Implementing Officer, transferred Rs. 2,50,000 in 2023-24 to the account (a/c no. 34306403911) of the Managing Director, Kerala State Homoeopathic Co-operative Pharmacy Limited, for purchase of medicines for the Homoeo Dispensary. However, the medicines have not been received to date. Details are given below.
| Project number | 69/24 (Purchase of medicines and dispensary items for the Homoeo Dispensary) |
| Implementing Officer | Medical Officer (Homeo) |
| Estimate | ₹2,50,000 (Maintenance Fund - Non-road) |
| Expenditure | ₹2,50,000 |
| Bill number/date | S.O No. 275/23-24, dated 14.01.2024, amount 2,50,000 |
| Voucher number/date | 42300873/06.02.2024 |
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (08/29.08.24) issued in this regard.
2. Medicines not received from Kerala Medical Services Corporation (KMSCL)
The Medical Officer (FHC), the Implementing Officer, transferred Rs. 3,30,166 in 2023-24 to the account of KMSCL for purchase of medicines for the FHC. However, the medicines have not been received to date. Details are given below.
| Project number | 41/24 (Purchase of medicines for Elanad FHC) |
| Implementing Officer | Medical Officer (F.H.C.) |
| Estimate | ₹4,50,000 (Finance Commission Award) |
| Expenditure | ₹4,50,000 |
| Voucher number/date | 42300874/06.02.2024 – Rs. 2,27,379 42300985/14.03.24 – Rs. 1,02,787 |
The matter is brought to the notice of the Health & Education Standing Committee for taking urgent steps to procure the medicines. The fact should be intimated to audit as and when the medicines are received.
1-20 MGNREGS - Information
Information regarding the implementation of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme for the year 2023-24 is as follows.
| Information regarding the implementation of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme for the year 2023-24 - Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | |||
| Sl. No. | 2023-24 | ||
| 1 | Estimate of schemes envisaged in 2023-24 | 86,57,70,000 | |
| 2 | Opening balance for 2023-24 | 0 | |
| 3 | Total expenditure for 2023-24 | 5,87,79,170 | |
| 4 | Closing balance at the end of 2023-24 | 0 | |
| 5 | Number of schemes envisaged under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 4541 | |
| 6 | Number of schemes completed in 2023-24 | 231 | |
| 7 | Number of job cards issued under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 8072 | |
| 8 | Person-days of employment generated in 2023-24 | 164286 | |
| 9 | 2023-24 | ||
| Female | Male | Total | |
| 153570 | 10716 | 164286 | |
| Scheduled Caste | Scheduled Tribe | Others | |
| 46214 | 1263 | 116809 | |
| 10 | Number of families provided employment in 2022-23 | 3651 | |
| 11 | Number of families that completed 100 days of employment in 2023-24 | 118 | |
| 12 | Information on disbursement of unemployment wages, if any, under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme in 2022-23 | NIL | |
| 13 | Wages disbursed in 2023-24 under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 5,76,94,424 | |
| 14 | Information on conduct of Social Audit | Social Audit has been conducted | |
1-21 Ashraya Scheme share - Utilisation Certificate not available
| Name and number of project | Payment of Ashraya Scheme share Project number 100/24 |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
| Estimate | 400000 Development Fund - General |
| Expenditure | 400000 Vr.No. 42301395 dated 25.03.24 |
In her letter dated 25.03.2024 (letter no. PZR/433/2024), the Chairperson, Kudumbashree CDS, Pazhayannur, requested that the Panchayat's share of Rs. 4,00,000 be given for Agathirahitha Keralam (Destitute-free Kerala). Accordingly, the Panchayat's share of Rs. 4,00,000 has been paid as shown in the above table. However, the Utilisation Certificate has not yet been received from Kudumbashree CDS. In the reply, received on 02.09.2024, to the audit enquiry (audit enquiry no. 3/23-24 dated 29.08.2024) issued requesting that the Utilisation Certificate be produced for audit if received, it was intimated that the Utilisation Certificate would be produced for audit. The Utilisation Certificate should be obtained from Kudumbashree CDS and produced for audit.
1-22 House construction not proceeding
On verification of the register of the LIFE Mission scheme implemented with the Village Extension Officer as Implementing Officer, it is seen that Rs. 40,000 was paid on 10.03.2021 to the beneficiary Smt. Viji, W/o. Pradeep, Thiruvani Colony, Elanad, belonging to the Scheduled Tribe category. It is seen that she has not continued the construction. No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No. 14/29.8.2024) issued requesting a reply in this regard. Further action should be taken and the fact intimated to audit.
1-23 Study room for Scheduled Tribe girl students
Details of the scheme 'Study Room for Scheduled Tribe Girl Students', implemented with the Assistant Secretary as Implementing Officer, are given below.
| Name and number of project | Study room for Scheduled Tribe girl students Project number 177/24 (Previous year's project number 237/2022-23) |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
| Estimate | ₹1,01,406 Development Fund - TSP ₹197972 Own Fund ₹299378 |
| Expenditure | ₹101406 Vr.No.42301178 dated 01.08.23 ₹72972 Vr.No.22300663 dated 10.11.23 ₹174378 |
As per the vouchers shown in the above table, financial assistance of Rs. 99,378 was given to the student Girija M.C. (D/o. Kamalam, Mangulampu Colony, Kallamkulam) and Rs. 75,000 to the student Sanoosha M.K. (D/o. Kumaran, Mangulampu Colony, Kallamkulam), under the scheme 'Construction of Study Room for Scheduled Tribe Girl Students', for the financial year 2023-24. For the student Girija M.C., Rs. 50,000 was paid as the first instalment on 03.03.2023 and Rs. 50,622 as the second instalment on 29.03.2023 in the financial year 2022-23, and Rs. 99,378 as per the above table in the financial year 2023-24, making a total of Rs. 2,00,000. The Overseer has certified that the student Girija M.C. has completed the study room. (The completion certificate does not bear a date.) For the student Sanoosha M.K., Rs. 50,000 was paid as the first instalment on 13.03.2023, and Rs. 75,000 as the second instalment as per the above table in the financial year 2023-24, making a total of Rs. 1,25,000. However, the student Sanoosha M.K. had not completed the study room even up to the audit period. The file does not contain documents proving in which school the above two beneficiaries are studying and that they belong to the Scheduled Tribe category. No reply has been received from the Implementing Officer to the audit enquiry (audit enquiry no. 14/23-24 dated 30.08.2024) issued requesting that the list of beneficiaries, including the above students, and information on any financial assistance received from the Scheduled Tribes Department for construction of the study room, if received, be produced for audit. Steps should be taken to ensure that the student Sanoosha M.K. completes the study room. An explanation should be furnished for the irregularities in implementation of the scheme.
1-24 Irregularities in the annual AMC of street lights
Rs. 3,00,000 was spent in the financial year 2023-24 towards the annual AMC of street lights. Details of the scheme are given below.
| Name and number of project | Annual AMC of street lights. (Project number 169/24) |
| Implementing Officer | Secretary |
| Estimate | ₹3,00,000 (Own Fund) |
| Expenditure | ₹300000 (Vr.No.22300754 dated 30.11.2023) |
As per the certificates given by the 22 Ward Members regarding replacement of bulbs, it is seen that the contractor replaced 185 ordinary LED bulbs, 175 automatic LED bulbs and 10 tubes across the various wards. However, the list of replaced bulbs submitted by the contractor to the Panchayat shows that 192 ordinary LED bulbs (192 x ₹390/bulb = ₹74,880), 168 automatic LED bulbs (168 x ₹450/bulb = ₹75,600) and 10 tubes (10 x ₹390/tube = ₹3,900) were replaced. It is seen that bulbs/tubes worth a total of Rs. 1,54,380 were repaired/replaced.
Following the contractor's claim that a total of Rs. 3,16,270, comprising the balance amount of Rs. 1,61,890 in the first bill and the AMC amount of Rs. 1,54,380 for the newly repaired/replaced bulbs, was due from the Panchayat towards the annual AMC, the Panchayat paid the contractor Rs. 3,00,000 (Vr. No. 22300754 dated 30.11.2023).
Irregularities noticed on verification of the scheme
1. There is a discrepancy between the number of bulbs shown in the certificates of the Ward Members and the number of bulbs shown by the contractor. The discrepancy should be examined and the reason for it intimated to audit.
2. The file does not contain information on the tender/quotation invited for the annual AMC of street lights, or the agreement executed with the contractor. These should be furnished.
3. The contractor claims that a balance amount of Rs. 1,61,890 in the first bill is due to be paid. However, the file does not contain details of this.
No reply has been received from the Implementing Officer to the audit enquiry (enquiry no. 23/2023-24 dated 31.08.2024) issued seeking an explanation for the above irregularities. A reply to the irregularities should be furnished.
1-25 KSEB - Information on arrear amount paid not available
Rs. 3,95,440 was paid to KSEB as arrears in the financial year 2023-24. Details of the scheme are given below.
| Name and number of project | Payment of arrears to KSEB Project number 298/24 |
| Implementing Officer | Secretary |
| Estimate | ₹4,00,000 Own Fund. |
| Expenditure | ₹3,95,440 (Vr.No. 22301065 dated 27.02.2024) |
The order dated 06.12.2023 (R.B-2/OTS-2023/Pazhayannur/2023-24/1539) of the Deputy Chief Engineer, Thrissur Electrical Circle, shows that, on an inspection conducted on 2 March 2017 under the leadership of the Regional Audit Officer, tariff misuse was found in respect of Consumer No. 1157197001662, LT IV A, Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, at the drinking water pump house (connected & status, DOC 01.04.2008), and that a surcharge notice for Rs. 3,67,080 was issued along with the regular electricity bill dated 01.10.2022. Accordingly, as per the calculation sheet given by KSEB, a surcharge of 367080 x 6% x 470/365 = 28,360 + 3,67,080, totalling Rs. 3,95,440, was levied, and the surcharge amount was paid to KSEB as per Vr. No. 22301065 dated 27.02.2024. The file does not contain information regarding the circumstances of the tariff misuse. No reply has been received from the Implementing Officer to the audit enquiry (No. 15/23-24 dated 30.08.2024) issued requesting that information on the tariff misuse and the reason for it be furnished to audit. Detailed information on the scheme should be furnished to audit.
1-26 Completion certificate not available for deposit works
In the financial year 2023-24, the Grama Panchayat paid amounts to KSEB, PWD Electronics Wing and ANERT for implementation of various schemes. However, the scheme completion certificate has not been received to date.
| Sl. No. | Name and number of scheme | Estimate | Expenditure | Remarks |
| 01 | Various KSEB posts in the Panchayat Replacement - Project number 36/- Amount paid in advance to KSEB | ₹4,00,000 Own Fund | ₹72,769 Voucher number 22300753 dated 30.11.2023 | The scheme should be completed and the completion certificate furnished. It is seen that Rs. 72,769 payable to KSEB Pazhayannur Electrical Section, as per the Grama Panchayat's letter No. SC.2-7334/24 dated 20.12.2023, was wrongly transferred to the account of Chelakkara Electrical Section. If the Rs. 72,769 has been transferred back to the account of Chelakkara Electrical Section, the fact should be intimated. |
| 02 | Restoration of Town CCTV cameras - Project number 296/24 Amount paid in advance to PWD Electronics Wing | ₹1,50,000 Own Fund | ₹1,30,000 Voucher number 22301185 dated 22.03.2024 | Completion certificate not available. |
| 03 | Energy conservation - Installation of 50 kW on-grid solar plant. Given to ANERT - A project is envisaged to install a 50 kW on-grid solar plant at the Pazhayannur Panchayat office and generate power to be supplied to K.S.E.B. | ₹35,00,000 Finance Commission Award | ₹31,00,000 Voucher number 22301011/ 21.02.24 ₹4,00,000 Voucher number 22301151/ 13.03.2024 | The agreement executed with K.S.E.B., the amount payable to the Panchayat per unit supplied to K.S.E.B., how many units of electricity have so far been supplied to K.S.E.B., and the amount received from K.S.E.B. towards the electricity supplied. Completion certificate not available. |
No reply has been received from the Implementing Officer to the audit enquiry issued (Audit Enquiry No. 6/2023-24 dated 29.08.2024) stating that the completion certificate, if available, should be produced for audit. The works given as advance should be completed and the fact intimated to audit.
1-27 Payment of Grama Panchayat share to IKM - Utilisation Certificate not available
Details of the project titled "Payment of Grama Panchayat share to IKM", implemented by the Grama Panchayat Secretary during the financial year 2023-24, are given below.
| Name and number of project | Payment of Grama Panchayat share to IKM (Project No. 2/24) |
| Implementing Officer | Secretary |
| Estimate | ₹215140 (Development Fund - General) |
| Expenditure | ₹189053 (Voucher No. 42301132 dated 02.06.2023) |
As seen in the table above, Rs. 189053 has been paid to IKM as the Panchayat's share during the financial year 2023-24. However, the utilisation certificate does not appear to have been received from IKM. No reply has been received from the Implementing Officer to the audit enquiry issued (Audit Enquiry No. 5/2023-24 dated 29.08.2024) requesting that the utilisation certificate be produced for verification. The utilisation certificate for the share paid by the Panchayat to IKM should be made available to audit.
1-28 Study room not completed
| Project number and name | 175/24 Study room for Scheduled Caste students |
| Implementing Officer | V.E.O., Pazhayannur |
| Estimate amount | ₹4,97,213 |
| Amount spent | ₹4,47,213 (Development Fund - SCP) |
| Voucher number/date/amount | 42301129/24.05.23/₹247213 42300290/26.07.23/₹200000 |
It is seen that the beneficiary who was given financial assistance under the above project has not completed the construction of the study room.
| Sl. No. | Beneficiary | Amount to be recovered | Amount given |
| 1 | Arya K.R., D/o. Radhakrishnan, Kandamkulam House, Kallepadam | ₹2,00,000 | ₹50,000 08.02.2023 ₹1,00,000 24.05.2023 |
A reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry issued requesting information in this regard. It has been informed that the beneficiary was bedridden due to illness, and that the remaining amount will be sanctioned under a new project once the work for the amount already given is completed.
Audit should be informed once the construction of the study room is completed.
(Audit Enquiry 7/29.8.2024)
1-29 Special Calf Rearing Project (Women) - Utilisation Certificate not received
| Implementing Officer | Veterinary Surgeon |
| Project | 241/24 - Special Calf Rearing Project (Women) |
| Fund | Development Fund - General Sector |
| Estimate | ₹1250000 |
| Expenditure | ₹1250000 |
| Voucher number, amount | 42201141/13.062023 |
| Institution that received it | Deputy Director, SLBP, Thrissur |
Under the project implemented by the Veterinary Surgeon, Rs. 12,50,000 has been handed over to the Deputy Director, SLBP, at the rate of Rs. 12,500 per calf (including the State share) for 100 calves. The utilisation certificate should be made available to audit.
1-30 Samagra Shiksha Kerala - Payment of share - Utilisation Certificate not available
The details of the project "Payment of share to Samagra Shiksha Kerala", implemented by the Grama Panchayat Secretary during the financial year 2023-24, are added below.
| Name and number of project | Samagra Shiksha Kerala - Payment of share (Project No. 1/24) |
| Implementing Officer | Secretary |
| Estimate | ₹500000 (Development Fund - General) |
| Expenditure | ₹500000 (Vr.No.42301184 dated 16.08.2023) |
As seen in the table above, Rs. 5,00,000, being the share of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, has been paid to SSK during the financial year 2023-24. However, the utilisation certificate showing how the amount was spent does not appear to have been received from SSK. No reply has been received from the Implementing Officer to the audit enquiry issued (Audit Enquiry No. 4/2023-24 dated 29.08.2024) requesting that the utilisation certificate received from SSK be made available to audit. The utilisation certificate should be made available to audit.
1-31 LIFE - Housing Scheme (General)
Project No. - 129/24
LIFE - Housing Scheme (General)
Implementing Officer - V.E.O., Pazhayannur
It is seen that the following beneficiaries, who were given financial assistance under the above project, have not completed house construction.
| Sl. No. | Beneficiary | Amount to be recovered | Amount given |
| 1 | Parukutty, Kundukattil House, Kumbalakkode | ₹400000 | ₹40,000 17.03.2022 ₹1,60,000 22.3.2022 ₹1,00,000 15.12.2022 |
| 2 | Khadeeja, Menakath House, Kallamkulam | ₹400000 | ₹40,000 17.03.2022 ₹1,60,000 15.02.2022 ₹1,00,000 08.02.2022 ₹60,000 24.06.2023 |
| 2 | Nabeesa, Kattamkulam, Thrikkanaya | ₹400000 | ₹40,000 07.01.2022 ₹1,60,000 01.01.2022 ₹40,000 17.03.2022 ₹60,000 22.03.2022 |
A reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry issued requesting information on the steps taken regarding the house construction of the beneficiaries listed in the table. It has been informed that the above beneficiaries are in the final stage of house construction and that the remaining financial assistance will be given once the house construction is completed.
Steps should be taken to complete the house construction.
1-32-1 Completion of Chakkathukunnu Cultural Centre - Project continues to remain an idle asset
During the financial year 2023-24, Rs. 9,80,167 was spent from the Development Fund as a spillover project for the completion of the Chakkathukunnu Cultural Centre. Details of the project are added below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher number |
| 236/24, Completion of Chakkathukunnu Cultural Centre | ₹11,66,139 (Development Fund-SCP) | ₹9,80,167 (Development Fund-SCP) | 1) 2) 42301145/16.06.2023 3) 42301149/23.06.2023 4) 42301286/22.01.2024 ₹196108 |
However, although the building construction has been completed, the building has not been made operational to date. In reply to the audit enquiry issued (No. 24/31.08.2024) requesting information on the steps taken to make it usable, it was informed that works such as electrification and a bore well to ensure water availability are yet to be completed.
In the site inspection carried out by the audit team in the presence of the Assistant Engineer and the Overseer, it was found that the works required for the building had not been carried out on a priority basis. A photograph of the building is added below.

Although electrification and ensuring water availability are works that ought to have been carried out immediately after the building was constructed, this was not done; instead, works such as truss work above the building and paving of the yard (Interlock paver blocks) were carried out during the year at a cost of Rs. 9,80,167. Since electrification and ensuring water availability were not accorded priority, the building has not been made usable to date. Steps should therefore be taken to complete these works and make the building operational. The attention of the Governing Body is invited to this.
1-32-2 Completed Day Care Home construction continues to remain an idle asset
In continuation of the day care home construction completed in previous years, amounts have been spent during the financial year 2023-24 under the project given below for the construction of a compound wall and paving around the building (Interlock paver blocks). Details are added below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher number |
| 236/24, Providing infrastructure facilities for the day care home | ₹565110 (265110 - Development Fund - General, 300000 - Own Fund) | ₹426701 (265110 - Development Fund - General, 161591 - Own Fund) | 1) 42301416/25.3.24 2) 22301204/29.3.24 |
It has been more than 15 years since construction of the building began. Although the building has now completed all works, the objective of a day care home has not been achieved. In reply to the audit enquiry issued (No. 24/31.08.2024) requesting information on the steps taken to make it operational, the reply received was that electrification work remains to be done. However, the Grama Panchayat is paying electricity charges to K.S.E.B. for the day care home. A photograph of the building is added below.

Without making the building operational to date, works such as a compound wall and paving of the yard have been carried out during the year at a cost of Rs. 4,26,701. The practice of spending funds on further projects for completion purposes, without the building achieving its intended objective, needs to be examined. Steps should therefore be taken to make the building operational at the earliest. The attention of the Governing Body is invited to this.
1-32-3 Women's Hostel continues to remain an idle asset without being made operational
Amounts have been spent on a project for the repair works of the Women's Hostel as given below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate | Expenditure | Voucher number |
| 255/24, Women's Hostel Maintenance | ₹500000 (Own Fund) | ₹497405 (Own Fund) | 22301205/29.3.24 |
The building constructed for the Women's Hostel was used in earlier years for purposes such as a temporary K.S.E.B. office and a tailoring unit. Hence, the purpose for which the building was constructed has not been achieved to date. Funds have been spent as stated above under a project for carrying out repair works to make the presently vacant building available for hostel purposes. The hostel has 6 bedrooms (of which 3 rooms have attached bathrooms), a kitchen, a dining room, a work area, and 2 common toilets. Although the repair works have now been completed, it has not been made operational to date. A photograph of the building is added below.

In reply to the audit enquiry issued regarding the above matter (No. 24/31.08.2024), the Implementing Officer stated that the Governing Body has been informed that the repair works of the building have been completed. The Governing Body should take steps as a matter of urgent priority to make the building operational.
1-32-4 Completion of Mattinmukal Community Hall - Follow-up action should be taken
In connection with the completion of the Mattinmukal Community Hall, amounts have been spent on a project as given below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate (₹) | Expenditure (₹) | Voucher number |
| 215/24, Completion of Mattinmukal Community Hall - Spillover (246/23) | 750000 (Corpus Fund-ST) | 412202 | 42301517/31.03.2024 |
The community hall has not been made operational to date. In reply to the audit enquiry issued (No. 24/31.08.2024) seeking information on the present status of the building, it was informed that the construction works of the community hall have been completed and that basic amenities such as painting the compound wall and installing a pump set in the bore well to ensure water availability remain to be completed. A photograph of the building is added below.
The special attention of the Governing Body is invited to completing the basic amenities of the building and making it operational.
1-32-5 Community Hall at Thirumani ST Colony - Construction not completed to date
Details of the expenditure on the project "Construction of Community Hall at Thirumani ST Colony" are added below.
| Number and name of the scheme | Estimate (₹) | Expenditure (₹) | Voucher number |
| 204/24, Community Hall at Thirumani ST Colony (Spillover Nos. 148/21, 145/22, 246/23) | 19,74,873 (Corpus Fund-TSP) | 19,13,016 | 42300433/12.09.2023 42300838/31.01.2024 |
Of the total amount of Rs. 3774573 spent on the above project, Rs. 1913016 was spent during the financial year 2023-24. However, the building construction has not been completed and made operational to date. The construction period for the building, whose construction began after execution of the agreement on 11.09.2020, was one year. Accordingly, the building construction should have been completed on 10.09.2021. However, the contract period was extended four times, and the work was completed only on 30.06.2023. A photograph of the building is added below.

In reply to the audit enquiry issued (No. 24/31.08.2024) seeking information on the present status of the building, it was informed that the construction works of the community hall have been completed on the basis of the funds available for the construction works, but that during construction, a higher amount had to be spent to complete the RCC structure owing to site conditions, and hence it has not been possible to achieve the intended objective. It has further been replied that works such as first-floor flooring, construction of toilets, drinking water facility, water tank and waste disposal facility remain to be carried out, and that an estimate for these has been prepared and sent to the ST Department for obtaining administrative sanction.
The special attention of the Governing Body is invited to completing the entire infrastructure of the community hall and making it operational.
1-32 Buildings that are assets of the Grama Panchayat remain idle assets without being made operational
Buildings begun in earlier years for various purposes in the Grama Panchayat and whose construction was completed during the year have not achieved their intended objectives. In the site inspection conducted on 30.08.2024 by the audit team in the presence of the Assistant Engineer and the Overseer, it was found that the buildings continue to remain idle assets without being made operational, as indicated in the sub-paragraphs below.
1-33 No penalty was levied when the completion period was extended for contractors in works of public works
As per Section 2112 of the Kerala PWD Manual, 2012, the period of a work may be extended in two instalments up to 25 percent of the original period or six months, whichever is less. The period shall not be extended by more than 50 percent of the original period. Paragraph 2112.1 stipulates that when the contract period is extended for reasons attributable to the contractor, a specified amount shall be levied as penalty. For the first extension, a penalty of 1% of the PAC (minimum Rs. 1000, maximum Rs. 50000) shall be levied, and for any extension after the first extension, a penalty of 2% of the PAC (minimum Rs. 2000, maximum Rs. 100000) shall be levied.
The contractor did not submit an application for extension of time, nor did the Assistant Engineer communicate with the contractor in this regard. In the following works, no penalty was levied when the completion period was extended for the contractors.
1) 214/24, Laying of drain on Elanad Cinema Theatre Road (S.O.251/23)
| Estimate | 640200 (CFC) |
| Expenditure | 454818 (Voucher No. 22300987/08-02-2024) |
| PAC | 542381 |
| Contractor | Sri. Biju M. Mathew |
| Agreement number | 38/AE/LSGD/PZR/2022-23/ 13.03.2023 |
| Site handing over date | 14.03.2023 |
| Measurement Book number | eMBook |
| Completion period | 13.09.2023 (6 months) |
| Date of completion | 23.12.2024 |
| Penalty levied | 0 |
| Penalty that should have been levied | 16271 |
| Total amount to be levied | 16271 (3% of PAC) |
2) 194/24, Bhajanamadam - Vellappara Road (S.O.130/23)
| Estimate | 500000 {400000-MG-R, 100000-Own Fund} |
| Expenditure | 499887 (Voucher No. 42301213/20.10.23-400000,) |
| PAC | 423669 |
| Contractor | Sri. Hamza K. M. |
| Agreement number | 32/AE/LSGD/PZR/2022-23/ 09.03.2023 |
| Site handing over date | 19.03.2023 |
| Measurement Book number | eMBook |
| Completion period | 18.09.2023 (6 months) |
| Date of completion | 26.09.2023 |
| Penalty levied | 0 |
| Penalty that should have been levied | 4999 |
| Total amount to be levied | 4999 (1% of PAC) |
3) 224/24, Maintenance of various Anganwadis (S.O.202/23)
| Estimate | 350000 (MG-R) |
| Expenditure | 251323 |
| PAC | 296360 |
| Contractor | Sri. Shiyad S. |
| Agreement number | 60/AE/LSGD/PZR/2022-23/ 24.04.2023 |
| Site handing over date | 04.05.2023 |
| Measurement Book number | eMBook |
| Completion period | 03.08.2023 (3 months) |
| Date of completion | 14.02.2024 |
| Penalty levied | 0 |
| Penalty that should have been levied | 8891 |
| Total amount to be levied | 8891 (3% of PAC) |
4) 196/24, Maintenance of Potta Sub Centre (S.O.142/23)
| Estimate | 500000 (MG-R) |
| Expenditure | 298868+195901 |
| PAC | 423717 |
| Contractor | Sri. Shameer K. M. |
| Agreement No.: | 36/AE/LSGD/PZR/2022-23/ 09.03.2023 |
| Site handing over date | 19.03.2023 |
| Measurement Book No. | eMBook |
| Completion period | 18.11.2023 (8 months) |
| Date of completion | 22.01.2024 |
| Penalty levied | 0 |
| Penalty that should have been levied | 12712 |
| Total amount to be levied | 12712 (3% of PAC) |
5) 223/24, Venginamchira Road Side Protection (S.O.112/23)
| Estimate | 500000 (400000-CFC, 100000-Own Fund) |
| Expenditure | 367492+32508+88258=488258 |
| PAC | 423717 |
| Contractor | Sri. Prasad T. N. |
| Agreement No.: | 40/AE/LSGD/PZR/2022-23/ 13.03.2023 |
| Site handing over date | 23.03.2023 |
| Measurement Book No. | eMBook |
| Completion period | 22.11.2023 (8 months) |
| Date of completion | 15.01.2024 |
| Penalty levied | 0 |
| Penalty that should have been levied | 4237 |
| Total amount to be levied | 4237 (1% of PAC) |
In reply to the audit enquiry issued (No. 16/30.08.2024) requesting explanation for not levying a penalty when the completion period was extended for contractors in public works, it has been informed that the penalty amount will be paid. Accordingly, the penalty amount of ₹47110 (16271 + 4999 + 8891 + 12712 + 4237) should be recovered and credited to the Own Fund, and the records thereof should be made available to audit.
Care should be taken to avoid such irregularities in future.
1-34 Public works - No penalty levied for delay in signing agreement
As per Section 2009.6 of the Kerala Public Works Manual, 2012, a written notice of acceptance of the tender shall be given to the contractor within 7 days of accepting the tender or within the firm period, whichever is less. The notice shall specify that the agreement is to be executed within 14 days from the date of acceptance of the tender, and if the contract agreement is not executed within 10 days from the 14th day, a penalty of 1% of the contract amount shall be levied. The limit of the penalty has been fixed at a minimum of Rs. 1000 and a maximum of Rs. 25000.
However, for the following work implemented by the Assistant Engineer, no penalty as per the manual's provisions was levied from the contractor for the delay caused in signing the agreement. Details are given below.
| Details of the work | Date of Letter of Acceptance | Last date for executing the agreement without penalty | Date and number of agreement executed | Pen al ty to be recovered (1%) (₹) |
Project No. 215/24, Mattinmukal Community Hall (S.O.246/23) Estimate - 750000 Expenditure - 412202 (Voucher No. 42301517/31.03.2024) APAC-550834 Contractor - Agreement number - Governing Body decision No. 25/1, dated 24.02.23 | 05.04.2023 | 18.04.2023 | 04.05.2023 | 5508 |
In reply to the audit enquiry issued (No.17/30.08.2024) requesting explanation for not levying a penalty on the contractor for the delay caused in signing the agreement, it has been informed that the penalty amount will be paid. Accordingly, an amount of Rs. 5508 should be recovered from the contractor as penalty and credited to the Own Fund, and the records thereof should be made available to audit for verification. Care should be taken to avoid such irregularities in future.
1-35 Drinking water schemes run directly by the Grama Panchayat - Water charges should be collected properly
Drinking water is made available within the limits of the Panchayat both through drinking water schemes run directly by the Panchayat and through drinking water schemes handed over to Beneficiary Committees. There are currently no public taps under the control of the Kerala Water Authority in the Panchayat. The drinking water schemes handed over by the Kerala Water Authority to the Grama Panchayat in 2004 are being run directly by the Grama Panchayat for drinking water distribution.
Information from the records made available in connection with drinking water distribution is added below.
1. 3 drinking water schemes run directly by the Grama Panchayat
| Drinking water scheme | Wards covered |
| Cheerakuzhi Drinking Water Scheme | 1, 2, 4, 19, 21, 22 |
| Pazhayannur Town Drinking Water Scheme | |
| Mankulampu Drinking Water Scheme (ST) | 20 |
The present total number of beneficiaries is 559 (Domestic - 518, Non-domestic - 41). The figures for beneficiaries of the Mankulampu Drinking Water Scheme run by the Grama Panchayat were not available.
2. By-laws not prepared
The Panchayat has not prepared by-laws for the running of the drinking water schemes.
3.Water charge collected
Water charge is collected at the rate of Rs. 100 for domestic and Rs. 150 for non-domestic connections per month. During the financial year 2023-24, the total water charge collected, including arrears, was Rs. 4,95,690.
4. Expenditure on drinking water schemes
Amount spent from the Development Fund and Maintenance Fund during the financial year 2023-24 for running the drinking water schemes run directly by the Grama Panchayat.
| Project number | Amount spent (₹) |
| 184/24, Laying of pipeline for Cheerakuzhi Drinking Water Scheme | 7,71,802 |
| 231/24, Repair of Town Drinking Water Scheme | 81,706 |
| 211/24, Maintenance of Cheerakuzhi Drinking Water Scheme | 3,69,490 |
| 198/24, Maintenance of drinking water schemes | 95,150 |
| Total | 13,18,148 |
Rs. 2,72,520 has been spent from the Own Fund towards the wages of pump operators, and Rs. 6,11,420 towards electricity charges. In total, Rs. 8,83,940 has been spent from the Own Fund under this head during the year.
5. Water charge - Arrears
Information on the arrears to be collected as per the Annual Financial Statement for the financial year 2023-24 is added below.
| Item | Demand (₹) | Collection (₹) | Balance (₹) |
| Arrears | 3,69,776 | 64,860 | 3,04,916 |
| Current year | 6,98,864 | 4,30,830 | 2,68,034 |
| Total | 10,68,640 | 4,95,690 | 5,72,950 |
A substantial amount of the Own Fund is being utilised for running the drinking water schemes. During the current year, the Panchayat had to spend Rs. 3,88,250 more from the Own Fund for the maintenance of the schemes than the income from water charges. This practice will create a heavy liability on the Own Fund in subsequent years. In addition, Rs. 13,18,148 has been spent from the Development Fund and Maintenance Fund for running the drinking water schemes run directly by the Grama Panchayat.
Connections are currently being given to those in the Panchayat who apply for drinking water connections in the order of the consumer number series. Hence, ward-wise arrears data of beneficiaries is not available. The ward-wise number of beneficiaries is not available.
Although an audit enquiry (25/31.03.2024) was issued regarding this matter, no reply was received.
Audit Recommendations
1) The arrears payable should be assessed according to the number of beneficiaries under the drinking water schemes on the basis of the wards within the Panchayat's limits, the demand details should be made accurate, and the procedure for collecting arrears should be made efficient.
2) As per the instructions for running drinking water schemes in Paragraph 8.1.25 of the 14th Plan guidelines, G.O.(M.S.)84/2022/LSGD dated 19.04.2022, newly formed schemes should be handed over to Beneficiary Committees.
The attention of the Finance Standing Committee and the Panchayat Governing Body is invited to the above matter. Audit should be informed of the follow-up action taken.
1-36 Maintenance of street lights should be made efficient
As per Serial Number 15 of Schedule III of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, installation and maintenance of street lights is a mandatory function of Grama Panchayats. Information based on an examination of the efficiency of the maintenance of street lights in the Grama Panchayat and the steps taken with regard to the expenditure incurred on electricity charges and street light installation works is added below.
During the financial year 2023-24, the Grama Panchayat paid Rs. 11,13,686 towards electricity charges for street lights to the K.S.E.B. Pazhayannur and Chelakkara Electrical Sections.
During the audit period, the following expenditure has been incurred from the Own Fund for street light repairs and purchase of street light materials.
| Sl. No. | Project number and name | Expenditure amount (₹) |
| 1 | 169/24, Annual AMC of Street Lights | 3,00,000 |
| 2 | 32/24, Purchase of Street Lights | 4,89,000 |
The Grama Panchayat incurs an expenditure of Rs. 18,12,044 during the audit year towards electricity charges for street lights, and Rs. 7,89,000 towards street light maintenance-related repairs and purchase of street lights.
Of the total electricity charge, an amount of Rs. 5,01,376 has been paid as unmetered electricity charge (Consumer No. 1157195010692) without switching over to the metering system to date. Unmetered electricity charge is paid on the basis of calculated burning hours. Details of the street lights as per K.S.E.B.'s Demand are added below.
Sl No. | Lamp Details | Watts | Nos. | Rate |
| 1 | CFL Automatic 1*11 | 11 | 21 | 32 |
| 2 | CFL Automatic 1*18 | 18 | 5 | 20 |
| 3 | CFL Automatic 2*11 | 22 | 263 | 20 |
| 4 | Sodium Vapour Lamp 1*80 | 80 | 11 | 177 |
| 5 | Ordinary 1*40 | 40 | 291 | 82 |
| 6 | Fluorescent Tube 2*40 | 40 | 27 | 82 |
Sodium Vapour Lamps, Ordinary Bulbs, and Fluorescent Tubes are not currently in use in the Grama Panchayat. Further, a street light register is not maintained in the Grama Panchayat. The Government has directed that a joint inspection be conducted by the Grama Panchayat and K.S.E.B. regarding street light maintenance to verify the details of the street lights, and that a metering system be introduced to ensure accuracy in the payment of electricity charges for street lights. No reply has been received to the audit enquiry issued (No. 30/31.08.2024) requesting information on the status of implementation of the metering system for the street lights in the Grama Panchayat and the wards where metering has been fully implemented.
Recommendations
1) Steps should be taken to fully implement metering in all wards.
2) A joint inspection should be conducted by the Grama Panchayat and K.S.E.B. to verify the details of the street lights.
3) Steps should be taken to make the maintenance of street lights, which is a mandatory function of the Grama Panchayat, efficient.
Part -2
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the receipt side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(1) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -3
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the expenditure side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(2) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -4
General information and audit review
4-1 Utilisation of funds received for joint projects
No amount remains unspent out of the amount received during the current year. However, as per Schedule B4 of the Balance Sheet, Rs. 12,49,015 out of the amount received from the Block Panchayat for joint projects remains unspent. If the amount remains unspent, it should be refunded and audit informed.
4-2 Details of amount given for deposit works
Details of the amount spent on deposit works during the current year are added below.
| Implementing Agency | Name of the work | Voucher number/ Cheque number | Amount given as advance | Details of completion |
| ANERT | 33/23-24, Energy Conservation - Installation of 50 kW on-grid solar plant | 42300895/ 12.02.2024, 13.03.2024 | 35,00,000 | Not completed |
| K.S.E.B. | Project No. 35/24 Cable tagging charge for CCTV cameras installed in Pazhayannur Town | 22300390 dated 08.08.2023 | 22305 | Not completed |
| K.S.E.B. | Project No. 36/24 Relocation of various K.S.E.B. posts in the Panchayat | 22300753 dated 30.11.2023 | 72769 | Not completed |
| PWD Electronics Wing | Project No. 296/24 Restoration of Town CCTV cameras | 22301185 dated 22.03.2024 | 130000 | Not completed |
Rs. 15551 has been deposited with K.S.E.B. in earlier years for deposit works. The amounts should be adjusted as and when the completion certificate is received.
4-3 Details of mobilisation advance
None
4-4 Loan/loan repayment
| Name/purpose of the loan | Order number/date | Amount remaining to be repaid at the beginning of the year | Loan amount received during the current year | Total loan amount | Amount repaid during the current year | Amount remaining to be repaid at the end of the year | |
| Principal | Interest | ||||||
| Life KURDFC loan | 2,29,14,340 | 52,80,000 | 2,81,94,340 | 36,80,556 | 0 | 2,45,13,784 | |
4-5 Fixed deposits
Details of fixed deposits remaining at the end of the year are given below.
| Fixed deposit outstanding at the beginning of the year | 3,26,98,127 |
| Amount deposited during the current year | 24,61,292 |
| Total | 3,51,59,419 |
| Amount withdrawn during the current year | 0 |
| Fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year | 3,51,59,419 |
4-6 Audit recovery
| Report year | Part/ Paragraph | Amount recovered | Name of the person Name and designation | who remitted / Receipt number/date |
| 2021-22 | 1-28 | 576 | Assistant Engineer | 1230100733/08.05.23 |
4-7 Details of charge/surcharge proceedings
None
4-8 Consolidated Audit Report
Details of the paragraphs from the Panchayat's previous years' audit reports, included in the consolidated report under Section 23 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, that remain to be settled are given below.
| Audit Year | Paragraph | Consolidated Report Year | Paragraph | Subject | Present status |
| 2017-2018 | 2-1 | 2017-18 | For Kodathoor Industrial Park, the land was handed over to SIDCO | No.A4-8297/18 dated 14.08.2018 as per letter, from this office a reply has been furnished. The matter is under the consideration of the Legislative Committee. | |
| 2016-17 | 3-1 | 2016-17 | Land for various purposes purchase - a lapse occurred in fixing the land price | is under the consideration of the Legislative Committee | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(1) | 2016-17 | Employees of 3 institutions - Profession tax not collected | Information on payment of the amount has been furnished to the Legislative Committee. The remark is under the consideration of the Committee. | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(2) | 2016-17 | Profession tax of 4 institutions not collected | Information on payment of the amount has been furnished to the Legislative Committee. The remark is under the consideration of the Committee. | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(3) | 2016-17 | General irregularities In the year 2015-16, as being for commercial purposes, tax has been assessed on the buildings; the profession tax should be collected from the employees liable to pay it, so as to increase the Panchayat's revenue by collecting profession tax, and steps should be taken accordingly. In addition, to the buildings to which D & O licenses have been issued liable to pay profession tax of all individuals and institutions a register containing details should be prepared and steps should be taken to collect profession tax. | In the year 2015-16 commercial purposes assessed to tax as in all buildings, operations have not commenced. D & O Licence applicable profession tax of institutions Demand register has been kept up to date. The para is under the consideration of the Legislature Committee. |
4-9 Audit Review
(A) Summary
| Opening Balance | 2,86,87,379 |
| Receipts for the audit year | 8,52,56,616 |
| Total | 11,39,43,995 |
Total for the audit year Expenditure | 5,78,70,288 |
| Balance | 5,60,73,707 |
| Loss under receipt heads | 0 |
| Loss under expenditure heads / amount not accepted in audit | 0 |
Amount held under objection in audit Amount | 0 |
* The table contains information as per the Receipts & Payments Statement of the annual accounts furnished by the Grama Panchayat. Grants received from the Government are not included in the receipts and expenditure shown herein.
(B) Details of clear loss sustained to the Panchayat Fund
None.
(C) Central and State Governments, other institutions
details of the loss sustained by these
None.
(D) Cases requiring further investigation to make good the loss
None.
(E) Name and permanent address of the persons responsible for the loss/objection dealt with in the report
None.
4-10 Paragraphs remaining to be settled
| Sl. No. | Audit Report year | Audit Report number | Total number of paragraphs remaining to be settled | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | Remarks (CAR/CASE/ CH/SCH) |
| 1 | 1997-98 (Expenditure) | LFT 12-1559/99 dt.6.3.99 | 4 | 1, 4, 5, 6 | |
| 2 | 1997-98 (Receipt) | LFT 10-306/08 dt. 25.4.09/9.7.09 | 1 | 2-1 | |
| 3 | 1999-2000 to 2001-02 (People's Plan) | LFT 10-1079/03 dt.09.04.04/14.09.04 | 7 | 7, 8, 14, 15 (2), 16, 18 (2to5), 20 (1,2,3) | Paragraph 8 - CAR |
| 4 | 1998-99 (Expenditure) | LFT 12-291/2001 dt.18.5.01/09.7.01 | 21 | 4, 8, 12, 13, 14 D1, 14 E3, 14F, 15 B,15 D2, 20, 21, 24,26, 30, 31, 34, 36 A2, 36 A3, 36 C2, 42, 32, 29, 9, 14A, 14B, 15A, 17(2) | |
| 5 | 2000-01 | LFT 10-309/08 dt. 25.04.09/14.7.19 | 1 | 3-3 | |
| 6 | 2001-02 | LFT 10-740/08 dt. 25.04.09 | 2 | 3-1, 3-3 | |
| 7 | 2002-03 | LFT 10-1265/08 dt. 07.09.09/5.12.09 | 1 | 3-13 | |
| 8 | 2003-04 | LFT 10-1266/08 dt. 7.09.09/05.12.09 | 4 | 3-11, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16 | |
| 9 | 2005-06 | LFT 10-1348/09 dt. 28.07.10/10.12.10 | 2 | 2-3, 3-3 | |
| 10 | 2006-07 | L.F.T 10-1336/09 Dt. 29.7.10/10.12.10 | 1 | 3-7 | CAR |
| 11 | 2007-08 | LFT(P4)956/12 dt. 19.7.12/5.11.12 | 2 | 3-2, 3-4 | |
| 12 | 2008-09 | LFT(P4)957/12 dt. 19.7.12 | 5 | 3-2, 3-3, 3-4, 3-5, 3-6 | |
| 13 | 2009-10 | LFT(P4)958/12 dt. 02.08.12/05.11.12 | 3 | 3-2, 3-7, 3-8 | |
| 14 | 2010-11 | LFT(P4)959/12 dt. 2.8.12 | 3 | 3-7, 3-9, 3-10 | |
| 15 | 2011-12 | LFT(P4)1151/13 dt. 4.12.13/05.2.14 | 9 | 2-3(5) (Sl. No. 1,2,4,6,10,11,12, 13,14) 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-4, 3-5, 3-21, 3-23, 3-25 | |
| 16 | 2012-13 | LFT(P4)-631/14 dt. 08.10.14/08.12.14 | 17 | 2-3(1)A, 2-3(1)B, 2-3(3), 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3(1), 3-3(3), 3-3(4), 3-3(5), 3-3(6), 3-4, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-14, 3-15 | |
| 17 | 2013-14 | LFT(P4)-186/15 dt. 7.5.15/5.6.15 | 18 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-5 A,D, 2-8, 3-9, 3-10, 3-11, 3-12, 3-14, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-21 (a,b), 3-22, 3-23, 3-24, 3-25, 3-27 | |
| 18 | 2014-15 | KSATSR(P4)-996/16 dt. 25.6.16 | 14 | 2-2, 2-6(1)to(5), 2-7, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-8, 3-11, 3-13, 3-16, 3-17 | |
| 19 | 2015-16 | KSATSR(P4)-1934/16 dt. 05.01.16/05.12.16 | 15 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-8, 2-10, 3-8, 3-9, 3-11, 3-12, 3-13, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-25 | 2-8 CAR |
| 20 | 2016-17 | KSATSR(P4)-1111/17 dt. 30.8.17 | 10 | 2-3, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-7(1)to(3), 3-8(1)(2), 3-9(1)(2), 3-12, 3-13, 3-14 | |
| 21 | 2017-18 | KSATSR(P4)771/19 dt. 01.06.19 | 16 | 2-3(1,2), 2-7, 2-9(1,2), 3-1, 3-3, 3-5, 3-19, 3-20, 3-25, 3-26, 3-27, 3-28, 3-29, 3-9, 3-11, | |
| 22 | 2018-19 | KSATSR(P4)1499/2019 dt. 06.12.2019 | 17 | 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26 | |
| 23 | 2019-20 | KSATSR(P12)61/2022 dt. 01.07.2022 | 34 | 1-11, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-45, 1-46, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1 | |
| 24 | 2020-21 | KSATSR(P12)62/2022 dt. 01.07.2022 | 33 | 1-11, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-48, 1-49, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1 | |
| 25 | 2021-22 | KSATSR(P12)208/2023 dt. 11.04.2023 | 21 | 1-10(1 to 13), 1-11, 1-12, 1-13, 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31 | |
| 26 | 2022-23 | KSATSR(P12)1832/2023 dt. 19.12.2023 | 21 | 1-1-1 to 1-1-14, 1-9, 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13,1-14,1-15, 1-16,1-17,1-18,1-19, 1-21,1-22,1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 4-1, 4-2, 4-6 | |
| Total | 282 |
Deputy Director
Annexure-1
Audit Certificate
i. I have audited the attached Financial statements approved vide resolution number 6(1) dated dated 28-06-2024 and submitted on 02-07-2024 , comprising of Receipt and Payment statement,Income and Expenditure account for the year ended on March and Balance sheet as on 31-03- , with supporting forms, of the Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat as per section 215(4) of Kerala Panchayath Raj act 1994, Kerala Panchayath Raj Accounts rules 2011, KSAD Audit Manual chapters 4.2.1 & 11.3 and as per guidelines and compliance instructions issued by State /Central Government, Finance Commission and other funding agencies from time to time. Preparation of these accounts is the responsibility of the PRI’s management. My responsibility is to express an opinion on these accounts based on my Financial Audit.
ii. I have conducted my Financial Audit in accordance with auditing standards issued by C&AG of India and Guidelines for Financial Audit of PRIs issued by C&AG. These standards/guidelines require that I plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial statements are free from material misstatements. An audit includes examining evidences supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of accounts. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
iii. On the basis of the information and explanations that I required and have obtained, and according to the best of my information as a result of Financial Audit of the accounts and on consideration of explanations given,
I certify that, subject to my observations in the appended report, except for the matters described in the basis for qualified opinion in the appended report and subject to other observations therein, the Annual Financial Statements give a true and fair view of financial result for the year 2023-2024 and Financial position of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat as on 31-03-2024
Date: 14/11/2024
Deputy Director
Kerala State Audit Department
Audit Report appended to the Audit Certificate of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the Year 2023-2024.
1.Major Observations
1.The advance provided to the medical officer for pre-monsoon expenses was recorded under the account head 460500501 - Advance to
Implementing Officers, even though the amount has been utilized. The amounts advanced as per the aforementioned ledger have not
been adjusted against expenditure. Since the advance amounts were not recorded as expenses in the annual accounts, it resulted in
an excess balance under the title of assets.
2. The advance approved for the purchase of medicines was incorrectly recorded under the expenditure head, rather than under advances
to implementing agencies, even though the medicines were not received. The details are as follows.
| Project | Deposit Amount | Voucher number | Expenditure Head | Actual head to be booked |
69/24 (purchase of medicine to homeo dispensary) | 2,50,000 | 42300873/ 06-02-2024 | 251110208Medical InstitutionHomoeo-Purchase of medicines in health institutions | 460500501- Advance to implementing Agencies- |
| 41/24 (purchase of medicine to FHC) | 2,27,379 | 42300874/ 06-02-2024 | 251110008Medical InstitutionAlloppathy-Purchase Of Medicines For Hospitals | 460500501- Advance to implementing Agencies- |
| 41/24 (purchase of medicine to FHC) | 1,02,787 | 42300985/14.03.24 | 251110008Medical InstitutionAlloppathy-Purchase Of Medicines For Hospitals | 460500501-Advance to implementing Agencies- |
2.Other Observations
a) Comments relating to Income and Expenditure Account
1. The preservation of authenticated vouchers and worksheets for prior period items was neglected, which undermines the ability to verify the
authenticity of journal entries in the schedules..
b) Comments relating to Balance Sheet
1. The depreciation amount for fixed assets, Rs. 72,01,157 (account 410800101 - Other Fixed Asset), surpasses its actual value of Rs. 32,73,276.
2. The grant amount listed as a liability on the balance sheet does not align with the closing balance of the bank account established for the specific
grant. The details are as follows:
| Head | As per Schedule B of the Balance Sheet | Bank Account | Closing balance as per Schedule B-17 of the Balance Sheet |
| 320200104-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Basic Tax | 24,95,269 | 450210101- Punjab National Bank CFCPFMS (A/c 4335000100085560) | 1,28,97,330 |
| 320200113-Development Fund- Central Finance Commission Grant- Tied Fund | 1,03,53,563 | ||
| Total | 1,28,48,832 |
5. Deposits that are overdue and remain with the panchayat even after the legal period outlined in the KFC and Panchayatraj Accounts Rules
have not been credited to the own fund.
c. Comments relating to Receipt and Payment Statement
Nil
d. Comments relating to Cashflow Statement
"The net increase in cash and cash equivalents, amounting to 27,386,328, does not align with the "Net cash generated by
Operating+Investing+Financing Activities," which shows a figure of -108,449,711.
e) Comments relating to Ratios
The Annual Financial Statement did not include the mandatory Financial Statements as prescribed by the Accounting Rules.
f) Comments relating to Notes to accounts
Notes to the accounts are not included within the accounts.
g) Comments relating to Receipt Vouchers
Nil
h) Comments relating to Payment Vouchers
Nil
i. Comments relating to Journal Vouchers
1. There are inaccuracies and delays in recording demand entries for accrual-based income items.
2. Authenticated vouchers or worksheets were not kept to confirm the authenticity of the journal entries listed in the schedule.
j. Comments relating to Contra Vouchers
Nil
k. Comments relating to Bank Reconciliation Statement
No follow-up action appears to have been taken to clear the cheques that have been deposited but remain uncleared in the following bank accounts.
| Bank | Amount |
| CANARA BANK-UPI PAYMENT PAZHAYANNUR ( 120024199263 ) | 328 |
| FARMERS SERVICE CO OP BANK, PAZHAYANNUR( 840 ) | 1201 |
| STATE BANK OF INDIA PAZHAYANNUR( 37121561057 ) | 1070 |
| 2599 |
No follow-up action appears to have been taken to address the issue of cheques issued but not presented at various banks.
| Bank | Amount |
| CANARA BANK-OWN FUND PAZHAYANNUR (4667101002064 ) | 9,990 |
| SUB TREASURY OWN FUND CHELAKKARA (799013000000652 ) | 2500 |
l. Comments relating to Demand, Collection and Balance Register
DCB statement of property tax ( both residential and non residential) does not match with the accounts.
Property tax Register (Current and Arrear)
Property tax residential(Current)
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya | 2945561 | 2572331 | 18205 | 359246 |
| As per AFS | 2945561 | 2568209 | 18993 | 396538 |
Property tax Non residential(Current)
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya | 5083148 | 4281220 | 13284 | 814394 |
| As per AFS | 5083148 | 4255548 | 12683 | 898027 |
Property Tax residential (Arrear)
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya | 84125 | 27429 | 56706 |
| As per AFS | 82559 | 27429 | 56802 |
Property Tax Non residential( Arrear)
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya | 1584323 | 34088 | 1550242 |
| As per AFS | 1584577 | 34088 | 1550480 |
Library Cess - Figures in Annual Finance Statement and DCB register do not match
m. Comments relating to Asset Register
Nil
n. Comments relating to Inventory and other Registers
The Fuel Register and Maintenance Register have not been accurately recorded and certified.
DEPUTY DIRECTOR
Annexure-2
Utilisation Certificate of Grants
The utilisation of various grants for the year 2023-2024 by Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, has been examined, based on the details in the grant statement certified and furnished by the institution as per G.O.(MS) No. 16/2021/LSGD dated 23.01.2021, in the manner set out in Annexure-1, and subject to the observations on the utilisation of grants included in this report, the utilisation of grants by the institution is hereby certified.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department
| Annexure-3 Summary of annual accounts |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() DEPUTY DIRECTOR |

Government of Kerala
Kerala State Audit Department
www.ksad.kerala.gov.in
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Audit Report
2022-2023
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone : 0487-2331249
(Registered with acknowledgement due)
No: K.S.A.T.S.R.(P12)1832/2023
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
Date: 19/12/2023
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone: 0487-2331249
Deputy Director
President (through the Secretary)
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Sir,
Subject: Regarding the Audit Report of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2022-2023.
As per the provisions of Section 13 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, Rule 18 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996 (Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994), the Audit Report resulting from the examination of the financial statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2022-2023 is herewith forwarded for further action as prescribed under Rule 23(1) of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996.
Attention is invited to the paragraphs in Part 1 of this report. Immediately on receipt of this report, the persons responsible for the irregularities mentioned therein shall be informed of the same, along with copies of the relevant paragraphs.
Within one month of receiving this report, a special meeting shall be convened to discuss the Audit Report in detail, and copies of the Audit Report and the decision taken thereon shall be published for public information. (See Rules 14 and 15 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules.)
Within two months of receiving the report, necessary action shall be taken to remove the audit remarks/objections contained herein, and a report to that effect shall be sent to this office within the said period. (See Local Fund Audit Act Section 15(1), Rules 20, 23, and Rule 21(1)(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules, 1997.)
Yours faithfully,
Deputy Director
Copy to:
1) The Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Thiruvananthapuram (for information),
2) Deputy Director of Panchayats, Thrissur.
3) Office copy.
No: K.S.A.T.S.R.(P12)1832/2023
Date: 19/12/2023
Audit Report on the financial statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, for the financial year 2022-2023.
(1994 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, Section 13 , 1996 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, Rule 18, (1994 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act - Section 215(4)) issued in accordance with the above provisions.)
The financial statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, for the financial year 2022-2023 was subjected to audit. The money collected by the institution under various heads and its remittance from 01-01-2023 to 08-11-2023, and the withdrawal of money from various accounts from 01-04-2022 to 31-03-2023, were also examined.
The irregularities noticed in audit were brought to the attention of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Of the 20 enquiries issued, replies have been received to 4. The institution shall take further action on the audit enquiries not covered in this report.
The irregularities noticed in audit were brought to the attention of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Although 20 enquiries were issued, no reply has been received.
This report has been prepared on the basis of the registers, records, information and explanations made available by the institution. The Kerala State Audit Department bears no responsibility whatsoever, either for the analyses and observations included in this report where these were prepared on the basis of incorrect information or particulars furnished by the institution, or for irregularities subsequently found by another audit agency/inspection wing on the basis of records that were not made available to audit by the institution.
(A) Details of Audit Conducted
Officer in charge of audit:
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sabu P.S | Deputy Director | 07-11-2023 | 15-11-2023 |
Time spent on audit:
| Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|
| 07-11-2023 | 15-11-2023 |
Officers who conducted the audit:
Sri. Jayakrishnan S, Audit Officer
Sri. Sunil P.B, Asst. Audit Officer
Smt. Divya S, Asst. Audit Officer
Sri. Ranjith P.R, Auditor
Sri. Cijo Thomas, Auditor
(B) Implementing Authorities
| Name | Official Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| P.K Muraleedharan | President | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Ambika M S | Secretary | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
Implementing Officers
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Juvel M.S | Medical Officer (Homeo) | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Dr. Sujith M.S | Senior Veterinary Surgeon | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Dr. Unnikrishnan A.K | Medical Officer (Ayurveda) | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Sunilkumar K | Assistant Engineer | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| P.K Shibukumar | Assistant Fisheries Extension Officer | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Roni | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 01-04-2022 | 30-08-2022 |
| Soli | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 31-08-2022 | 14-10-2022 |
| Vacant | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 15-10-2022 | 18-10-2022 |
| Ramya K | VEO (Pazhayannur Circle) | 19-10-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Sonwin John | VEO (Elanad Circle) | 01-04-2022 | 30-08-2022 |
| Vacant | VEO (Elanad Circle) | 31-08-2022 | 31-08-2022 |
| Ramya K | VEO (Elanad Circle) | 01-09-2022 | 27-09-2022 |
| Sujithran | VEO (Elanad Circle) | 28-09-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Ginika P G | Dairy Farm Instructor | 01-04-2022 | 08-07-2022 |
| Anoop P A | Dairy Farm Instructor | 09-07-2022 | 31-07-2022 |
| Anila P R | Dairy Farm Instructor | 01-08-2022 | 25-11-2022 |
| Jisha K G | Dairy Farm Instructor | 26-11-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Girija | Headmistress, GLPS, Pazhayannur | 01-04-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Jayamol Baby | Assistant Secretary | 01-04-2022 | 28-10-2022 |
| Sunilkumar M.A | Assistant Secretary | 29-10-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Dr. Ajish C.Y | Medical Officer (F.H.C.) | 01-04-2022 | 12-06-2022 |
| Dr. Joby C.L | Medical Officer (F.H.C.) | 13-06-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Sreeja | ICDS Supervisor | 01-04-2022 | 04-07-2022 |
| Prinu Prasad | ICDS Supervisor | 05-07-2022 | 02-09-2022 |
| Vinitha Unnikrishnan | ICDS Supervisor | 03-09-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
| Dipin.M.N. | Agricultural Officer | 01-04-2022 | 05-06-2022 |
| Unnikrishnan Pillai. S. | Agricultural Officer | 06-06-2022 | 12-08-2022 |
| Baiju | Agricultural Officer | 13-08-2022 | 31-03-2023 |
Contents
| Sl. No. | Part 1 | Paragraph Number |
|---|---|---|
| Part 2 | ||
| Part 3 | ||
| Part 4 | ||
| Annexure | ||
| 1 | Audit Certificate | 1-1 |
| 2 | Fixed Deposits - Interest should be recorded as and when it accrues, and at the end of the financial year the interest should be calculated proportionately and included in the annual accounts | 1-1-1 |
| 3 | Fixed Deposits - Steps should be taken with the bank to obtain interest at the legally applicable rate | 1-1-2 |
| 4 | Amount not transferred to the 'Capital Contribution' head | 1-1-3 |
| 5 | The unspent grant balances and the closing balance as per the bank/treasury accounts in which they are deposited do not tally | 1-1-4 |
| 6 | The total cash flow for the current year in the Cash Flow Statement does not match the amount shown as the difference between the opening balance and closing balance in the schedule | 1-1-5 |
| 7 | Not all statements required under the Accounting Rules have been included in the annual accounts | 1-1-6 |
| 8 | Cheque deposited - not credited in bank | 1-1-7 |
| 9 | No steps taken to adjust amounts shown as 'Directly Debited by bank' | 1-1-8 |
| 10 | No demand entry made at the time of accrual | 1-1-9 |
| 11 | Prior Period Item - Supporting records not available to certify the journal vouchers | 1-1-10 |
| 12 | The Asset Register is not maintained in a manner that its accuracy can be certified | 1-1-11 |
| 13 | Property Tax - Annual Accounts and DCB Register do not tally | 1-1-12 |
| 14 | The amount shown as received in advance towards property tax but remaining to be adjusted as on 31.03.2023 does not match the amounts entered under this head in the 'Sanchaya' software | 1-1-13 |
| 15 | The expenditure as per the Grant Statement/Sulekha Statement does not match the expenditure in the annual accounts | 1-1-14 |
| 16 | Budget | 1-2 |
| 17 | Fund Utilisation | 1-3 |
| 18 | Plan Review | 1-4 |
| 19 | MGNREGS | 1-5 |
| 20 | Welfare Schemes | 1-6 |
| 21 | Cash Balance Verification | 1-7 |
| 22 | Internal control system | 1-8 |
| 23 | Efficiency of the Panchayat's Tax and Non-Tax Resource Mobilisation - Review | 1-9 |
| 24 | Paramedical institutions/hospitals functioning without licence | 1-10 |
| 25 | Profession tax not collected from employees | 1-11 |
| 26 | Profession tax not collected from contractors | 1-12 |
| 27 | Property Tax - Applicable enhancements not made | 1-13 |
| 28 | Ration shops functioning without licence and without paying profession tax | 1-14 |
| 29 | Property tax assessed at a lower rate for buildings | 1-15 |
| 30 | Profession tax not collected from institutions/traders | 1-16 |
| 31 | Social Security Pensions - Amount received ineligibly - Details of follow-up action should be furnished. | 1-17 |
| 32 | Annual accounts of the Hospital Management Committee - Details not furnished | 1-18 |
| 33 | Distribution of medicines - Details should be furnished | 1-19 |
| 34 | National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) | 1-20 |
| 35 | Anganwadi Supplementary Nutrition - GST TDS not deducted | 1-21 |
| 36 | Payment of PMAY share - Utilisation certificate not furnished | 1-22 |
| 37 | The Day Care Centre (Pakal Veedu) should be made usable. | 1-23 |
| 38 | The She Lodge remains unused. | 1-24 |
| 39 | Certificate proving the beneficiary's caste not produced for verification - the expenditure amount is held under objection | 1-25 |
| --- No records found --- | ||
| --- No records found --- | ||
| 1 | Utilisation of funds received for joint projects | 4-1 |
| 2 | Details of amount given for deposit works | 4-2 |
| 3 | Details of Mobilisation Advance | 4-3 |
| 4 | Loan/loan repayment | 4-4 |
| 5 | Fixed Deposit | 4-5 |
| 6 | Audit Recovery | 4-6 |
| 7 | Details of charge/surcharge proceedings | 4-7 |
| 8 | Consolidated Audit Report | 4-8 |
| 9 | Audit Retrospect | 4-9 |
| 10 | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | 4-10 |
| 1 | Audit Certificate | |
| 2 | Utilisation Certificate of Grants | |
| 3 | Summary of annual accounts | |
Part - 1
General Overview
1-1 Audit Certificate
1. As required under Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, KSAD Audit Manual Chapters 4.2.1 & 11.3, and the guidelines and compliance instructions issued from time to time by the State Government/Central Government, Finance Commission and other funding agencies, I have audited the financial statements of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the year ended March 2023, comprising the Receipts & Payments Statement, Income & Expenditure Statement and the Balance Sheet as on 31.03.2023, prepared as per Decision No. 14(1) dated 21.07.2023 of the Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat Committee and submitted on 21.07.2023 along with the supporting forms. The preparation of these accounts is the responsibility of the management of the Panchayat Raj Institution. My responsibility is to express an opinion on these accounts based on the financial audit.
2. I have conducted my financial audit in accordance with the Auditing Standards issued by the C&AG of India and the Guidelines for Financial Audit of Panchayat Raj Institutions issued by the C&AG. These Standards/Guidelines require that I plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance as to whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, the evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and the significant estimates made, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the accounts. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
3. On the basis of the information and explanations that I required and that were furnished to me, and on the basis of the best information and explanations obtained by me as a result of the financial audit of the accounts, and subject to my observations in the accompanying report, I hereby certify as follows.
Qualified Opinion
Except for the matters described on the basis of the qualified opinion in the accompanying report, and subject to the other observations therein, the annual financial statements of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the year 2022-23 present a true and fair view of the financial results and the financial position.
Place: Thrissur
Date: 19.12.2023
Deputy Director
District Office, Thrissur
1-1-1 Fixed Deposits - Interest should be recorded as and when it accrues, and at the end of the financial year the interest should be calculated proportionately and included in the annual accounts
1. As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-12, a fixed deposit of Rs. 32698127 has been recorded as on 31.03.2023 as shown below.
| Sl. No. | Bank | Fixed Deposit Number | Amount |
| 1 | Punjab National Bank, Pazhayannur | 433500 | 1228736 |
| 2 | Kerala Bank, Pazhayannur | 256007 | 500000 |
| 3 | Kerala Bank, Pazhayannur | 256073* | 969391 |
| 4 | Pazhayannur Farmers Service Co-operative Bank | 101140010143570 | 10000000 |
| 5 | Pazhayannur Farmers Service Co-operative Bank | 101140010143569 | 20000000 |
| Total | 32698127 | ||
As per Government Order No. 152/2011/LSGD dated 26.07.2011, interest on deposits should be recorded as and when it accrues, and at the end of the financial year the interest should be calculated proportionately and included in the annual accounts. However, interest has not been so calculated and included in the annual accounts in respect of the Panchayat's fixed deposits.
| Sl no. | Bank | FD No | Amount | Re newal/fd date | Interest rate | Interest for one month | Interest till 31.03. 23 | Total Amount | Amount as per AFS | Difference |
| 1 | PNB | 433500 | 1243217 | 30.10.22 | 6.3 | 6527 | 32635+ =33056 | 1276273 | 1228736 | 47537 |
| 2 | Kerala Bank | 256007 | 500000 | 17.01.23 | 6.75 | 2813 | 5626+ (2813* 15/31) =6987 | 506987 | 500000 | 6987 |
| 3 | PFSCB | 101140010143569 | 10000000 | 08.02.23 | 7.75 | 64583 | 64583+(64583* 21/28) =113020 | 10113020 | 10000000 | 113020 |
| 4 | PFSCB | 101140010143570 | 20000000 | 08.02.23 | 7.75 | 129167 | 129167+(129167* 21/28) =226042 | 20226042 | 20000000 | 226042 |
| Total | 32122322 | 31728736 | 393586 | |||||||
*As the interest rate for the period from 23.04.2022 to 22.04.2023 on Fixed Deposit No. 256073 held in Pazhayannur Kerala Bank was not furnished, it has not been included.
1-1-2 Fixed Deposits - Steps should be taken with the bank to obtain interest at the legally applicable rate
As per the records furnished, Fixed Deposit No. 256073 held in Pazhayannur Kerala Bank is recorded as having Rs. 969391 as on 31.03.2023. However, on verification of the bank statement of Account No. 80012284084 for the period from 23.04.2018 to 22.04.2022, it is seen that Rs. 969391 was already recorded as on 22.04.2022 itself.
On verification of the fixed deposit certificate, it is seen that on 11.07.2023, Rs. 969391 was renewed and deposited for one year at 7.25% interest with effect from 23.04.2023. The bank statement of the fixed deposit for the period from 23.04.2022 to 22.04.2023 and the interest rate for that period are not available. Steps should be taken, in consultation with the bank authorities, to renew the fixed deposit at the legally applicable interest rate for the said period and to obtain the amount accrued during that period.
1-1-3 Amount not transferred to the 'Capital Contribution' head
The ledgers of the various grants were verified. The amount equivalent to the capital works carried out using grants is not being transferred to the 'Capital contribution' head. This results in the grant amounts used for capital expenditure also being recorded as income of the institution, thereby increasing the surplus computed as per the Income and Expenditure Account. This is contrary to the accounting policies prescribed under G.O. No. 152/2011/LSGD dated 26/7/2011. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Fund Head | As per ledger capital works carried out Total amount | As per ledger " Capital contribution” to the head named Amount added | Difference |
| 1 | CFC - Basic Grant | 1433835 | 470400* | 963435 |
| 2 | CFC Tied Fund | 5237485 | 2180205 | 3057280 |
| 3 | Development Fund General | 988489 | 0 | 988489 |
*This amount was spent from the CFC Tied Fund under Project No. 38/23 for the installation of a water kiosk. However, it has been recorded, with the head changed, under CFC - Basic Grant.
In the financial year 2023-24, the amount equivalent to the grant amount used for the above-mentioned capital expenditure with discrepancy should be debited under the appropriate head in the 'Prior Period Income' schedule and credited under the appropriate 'Capital Contribution….' head. Further, as and when utilisation certificates are received for amounts given for investment works, the assets so created should be credited under the appropriate 'Capital Contribution….' head and debited under the appropriate head.
1-1-4 The unspent grant balances and the closing balance as per the bank/treasury accounts in which they are deposited do not tally
As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-4, the closing balance of unspent amounts received for special purpose schemes should be equal to the closing balance of the bank accounts in which such amounts are kept. However, the closing balance as per Schedule B-4 of the special purpose grants listed below does not match the closing balance as per Schedule B-17 of the bank accounts of those funds. Details are given below.
| Balance Sheet Schedule B-4 | Balance Sheet Schedule B-17 | |||||
| Sl. No. | Head | Item | Amount | Head | Bank Account | Amount |
| 1 | 320300102 | Jalanidhi | 1181205 | 450210101 | 40726101030415 | 26826 |
1-1-5 The total cash flow for the current year in the Cash Flow Statement does not match the amount shown as the difference between the opening balance and closing balance in the schedule
As the Cash Flow Statement submitted along with the annual accounts has the deficiencies noted below, its accuracy is not certified in audit.
As per the Cash Flow Statement, the 'Net increase in cash and cash equivalents' for the period 2022-23 is recorded as Rs. -10802537. However, in the same statement, the 'Net cash generated by Operating + Investing + Financing Activity' for the period 2022-23 is recorded as Rs. 23208255. Although, as per the accepted accounting standard, the above two amounts should match, the two amounts in the statement submitted by the Panchayat do not match.
1-1-6 All statements required under the Accounting Rules have not been included in the annual accounts
Basic ratios have not been included in the Annual Financial Statement (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 62(F)).
1-1-7 Cheque deposited - not credited in bank
As per the Bank Reconciliation Statement (SBI e-payment - 37121561057), an amount of Rs. 75487 has been included as 'Cheques deposited but not credited'. This includes cheques worth Rs. 8022 that have not been encashed even though more than a month has passed since they were deposited in the bank. The reason for the amount not being credited should be ascertained with the bank and follow-up action taken.
1-1-8 No steps taken to adjust amounts shown as 'Directly Debited by bank'
The debit amounts appearing in the bank account passbook noted below have been included every month up to 31/3/2023 in the Reconciliation Statement under the head 'Directly debited by bank'. It should be verified with the bank whether this expenditure relates to the Panchayat; if the bank has wrongly deducted the amount, steps should be taken to have it re-credited to the Panchayat's bank account, and if the debit does relate to the Panchayat, it should be accounted for and the expenditure recorded under the appropriate head. Although the annual accounts were finalised months after these entries appeared in the bank passbook, since the above action was not taken, these amounts were left out of the annual accounts for 2022-23.
| Bank | Date | Amount |
| ST Chelakkara-799013000000652 | 06.05.2022 | 2500 |
| Total | 2500 | |
1-1-9 No demand entry made at the time of accrual
Income assessed on accrual basis in 2022-23 was required to be entered through monthly demand journal entries on the basis of the Summary Statement prepared monthly by the Secretary, the Assessment Register, and the Assessment/Demand Notice (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 17(2)). Reduction of demand/write-off/grant of remission should also be carried out through journal entries on the basis of the monthly Summary Statement prepared by the Secretary. Such entries should be made on the basis of journal vouchers, worksheets and lawful sanction. However, without the Secretary preparing the monthly statement and connected accounts in writing as above, the details of the income heads for which demand/reduction of demand/write-off/grant of remission were made in a single instance through journal entries are given below.
| Sl. No. | Income head | Head under which demand is entered | Demand | Date recorded | Voucher |
| 1. | Rent from buildings | 130100101-Rent from Building | 2,482,301 | 31.03.23 | 42201433 |
| 2 | Profession Tax - Traders | 110200105-Profession tax- Traders | 506000 | 31.03.23 | 42201429 |
| 3 | Property Tax - Residential | 110100101 | 2787308 | 31.03.23 | 42201446 |
| 4 | Property Tax - Non-Residential | 110100102 | 4573064 | 31.03.23 | 42201447 |
Steps should be taken to make accrual entries at the time the demand legally arises, in the manner prescribed under the Rules, and to maintain vouchers and connected records validating demand entries/reduction of demand/write-off/grant of remission.
1-1-10 Prior Period Item - Supporting records not available to certify the journal vouchers
Under the head 'Prior Period Item' in the Income & Expenditure Account (I-19), approved vouchers or worksheets supporting the entries have not been made available to audit for the amounts written off through journal vouchers, the amounts adjusted as income, and the correction entries in the following ledgers. Hence it has not been possible to ascertain whether the entries as per the ledgers listed below are lawful or accurate.
| Head (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-19 & I-18) | Ledger balance as on 31/3/2023 |
| 190100101-Prior period -Property tax | -268966 |
| 190200401-Prior period income-Other income | -38482 |
| 290800701-Prior period- Miscellaneous expenses | -450478 |
1-1-11 The Asset Register is not maintained in a manner that its accuracy can be certified
The Asset Register has not been kept up to date. The Asset Register is not prepared in a manner that allows verification of the existence and value of the fixed assets mentioned in the Balance Sheet.
1-1-12 Property Tax - The annual accounts do not match the D.C.B. Register
The property tax demand amount obtained from the 'Sanchaya' software, which prepares the Demand Register for property tax, is entered as demand in 'ILGMS', the software used to prepare the accounts. Property tax is received, receipts are issued, and the ledger is prepared using the 'ILGMS' software. The receipt collection in this software is automatically posted to the 'Sanchaya' software, which prepares the Demand Register for property tax. Since this is how the two are prepared, the amounts under demand, collection and balance as per the D.C.B. Register and as per the statements in the annual accounts should match. However, the year-end summary amounts of property tax and library cess as per the D.C.B. Register prepared in the 'Sanchaya' software do not match the amounts in the annual accounts prepared in the 'ILGMS' software. In this situation, the reason for the mismatch between the annual accounts and the D.C.B. Register should be identified and rectified.
1. Current year
1.1 Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 2787030 | 2767274 | 20312 | 28008 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 2787308 | 2735349 | 12614 | *28008 |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipt & Payment Statement, Schedule R.P-45) | (Ledger of 350410101-Advance collection-PT on Res. bldg) | *(29527 /105X100)= 28120 (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A small difference in amount is treated as a rounding-off amount, and the amount in Sanchaya is adopted |
1.2 Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 4573756 | 4337989 | 10141 | 280697 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 4573064 | 4281844 | 4534 | *280697 |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipt & Payment Statement, Schedule R.P-45) | (Ledger of 350410104-Advance collection-PT on NR bldg) | *(294767 /105X100)= 280730 (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A small difference in amount is treated as a rounding-off amount, and the amount in Sanchaya is adopted |
2. Arrears
2.1 Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 582621 | 533031 | 54340 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | *806209 | 533031 | **54437 |
*(2021-22 Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) (373664+472856= | (Receipt & Payment Statement, R.P-45) | **(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) (57159/105X100)=54437, |
2.2 Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 1576682 | 273641 | 1303631 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 1613396 | 273641 | 1304845 |
(2021-22 Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) *(405587+1288479= | (Receipt & Payment Statement, Schedule R.P-45) | **(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) (1369038/105X100)= 1303845, A minor difference in amount; treating it as a rounding-off amount, the figure in Sanchaya is adopted. |
1-1-13 The amount shown as received in advance towards property tax but remaining to be adjusted as on 31.03.2023 does not match the amounts entered under this head in the 'Sanchaya' software
The amount shown, under the head 'Other liabilities' in Balance Sheet Schedule B-9, as received in advance towards property tax but remaining to be adjusted as on 31.03.2023, does not match the amounts entered under this head in the 'Sanchaya' software.
| Sl. No. | Head | Amounts as per Balance Sheet Schedule B-9 | Amounts as per Sanchaya software |
| 1 | 350410101-Advance collection of revenues -Property tax on Residential building | 31925 | 31815 |
| 2 | 350410101-Advance collection of revenues -Property tax on Non-Residential building | 56145 | 55453 |
1-1-14 The expenditure as per the Grant Statement/Sulekha Statement does not match the expenditure in the annual accounts
For the items listed below, the expenditure for the financial year 2022-23 as per the Grant Statement/Sulekha Statement does not match the expenditure in the annual accounts.
| Item | Expenditure as per Grant Statement/Sulekha Statement | Expenditure as per annual accounts | Difference |
| CFC Tied | 6131096 | 5433642 | -697454 |
| CFC Basic Grant | 1397239 | 1817835 | 420596 |
| Total | 7528335 | 7251477 | 276858 |
1-2 Budget
| Date of passing | 23/03/2022 | ||
| Committee decision | Panchayat Committee 1(1) | ||
| Expected receipts and expenditure | Receipts | Expenditure | |
| 202662922 | 195953000 | ||
| Revised Budget | |||
Date of passing Committee decision | 27/03/2023 1(1) | ||
| Expected receipts and expenditure | Receipts | Expenditure | |
| 211299382 | 204770000 | ||
1-3 Fund Utilisation
| Fund Head | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance / lapsed amount |
| Development Fund - General | 0 | 30212000 | 30212000 | 28476404 | 1735596 |
| Development Fund - SCP | 0 | 16281000 | 16281000 | 14571216 | 1709784 |
| Development Fund - TSP | 0 | 819000 | 819000 | 732770 | 86230 |
| Maintenance, Road | 0 | 17037000 | 17037000 | 5337083 | 11699917 |
| Maintenance, Non-Road | 0 | 9578000 | 9578000 | 6903616 | 2674384 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - CFC Tied Fund (Bank) | 5851206 | 7973411 | 13824617 | 5433642 | 8390975 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - CFC Tied Fund (Treasury) | 0 | 3391385 | 3391385 | 0 | 3391385 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - CFC Basic Grant (Bank) | 77932 | 5400956 | 5478888 | 1817835 | 3661053 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - CFC Basic Grant (Treasury) | 0 | 4923432 | 4923432 | 0 | 4923432 |
| Hariyali | 311089 | 8498 | 319587 | 0 | 319587 |
| Total Sanitation - Performance Incentive Grant | 310870 | 0 | 310870 | 0 | 310870 |
| ICDS | 1059909 | 1903226 | 2963135 | 1963367 | 999768 |
| TSP CORPUS FUND | 2589834 | 0 | 2589834 | 328840 | 2260994 |
| MN laksham veedu | 310000 | 0 | 310000 | 0 | 310000 |
| Vimukthi | 50797 | 0 | 50797 | 3000 | 47797 |
| Pre-monsoon Campaign | 151602 | 0 | 151602 | 0 | 151602 |
| Health Grant towards support of diagnostic infrastructure | 0 | 501508 | 501508 | 0 | 501508 |
| Health Grant towards conversion of PHCs and subscentres into Health &Wellness centres | 0 | 281095 | 281095 | 0 | 281095 |
| Fund for transferred institutions -Homeopathy | 0 | 450000 | 450000 | 0 | 450000 |
| Jeevadhara | 26520 | 0 | 26520 | 0 | 26520 |
| Jalanidhi | 1176666 | 4539 | 1181205 | 0 | 1181205 |
| Chiyak | 16848 | 0 | 16848 | 0 | 16848 |
| Bhavananidhi | 0 | 72676 | 72676 | 35822 | 36854 |
If amounts remaining unspent for a long period are not to be used, they should be refunded and the matter intimated to audit.
1-4 Plan Review
Approved (Number) | Approved plan outlay amount | Implemented (Number) | Scheme implemented Expenditure Amount | Percentage of Implemented Scheme Amount | Percentage of the number of projects implemented |
| 215 | 178931124 | 139 | 80794824 | 45% | 65% |
1-5 MGNREGS
| Item | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Closing Balance |
| Administrative Expenses | 0 | 1620583 | 1620583 | 1620583 | 0 |
| Given directly to beneficiaries | 0 | 87384109 | 87384109 | 87384109 | 0 |
| Material Cost | 0 | 32644599 | 32644599 | 32644599 | 0 |
| Total | 0 | 121649291 | 121649291 | 121649291 | 0 |
*Note: As per letter No. DD2/355/2022/LSGD dated 22.10.2022, the expenditure of Rs. 30924/- incurred under the head of conducting a watershed walk has not been included in the total expenditure in the annual accounts.
1-6 Welfare Schemes
| Name of Scheme | Expenditure Amount | Number of Beneficiaries |
| Agricultural Labourer Pension | 747 | 8253400 |
| Widow Pension | 1871 | 20630500 |
| Old Age Pension | 3944 | 40074800 |
| Disability Pension | 495 | 5509000 |
| For unmarried women aged 50 and above - Pension | 232 | 2586000 |
| Marriage assistance for daughters of widows | 6 | 180000 |
1-7 Cash Balance Verification
The cash balance verification under Section 6(4) of the Local Fund Audit Act, 1994 was conducted on 09.11.2023 at 3.30 pm in the presence of the Panchayat Accountant. On verification, the accuracy of the cash balance of Rs. 28442/- was ascertained.
1-8 Internal Control System
Deficiencies in internal control have been incorporated in the various paragraphs of Part 1 of this report.
1-9 Efficiency of the Panchayat's Tax and Non-Tax Resource Mobilisation - Review
1) Functioning of the Finance Standing Committee
On verification of the Finance Standing Committee minutes, no suggestions or decisions regarding increasing tax revenue were found in the Finance Standing Committee meetings. Measures such as organising camps and adopting publicity methods including notices for the recovery of arrears of own revenue have been implemented. Revenue recovery has been recommended for the arrears of own revenue. An Arrears Register is maintained as per G.O.(MS) No. 117/2022/LSGD dated 01.06.2022. Review of tax collection and non-tax revenue is not carried out once every three months in Grama Sabhas and ward meetings. However, the Governing Body has discussed the D.C.B. Statement Report of tax revenue and given instructions to the officials (Audit Enquiry No. 02/07.11.2023).
2) Property Tax
As per Order G.O.(MS) No.77/2023/LSGD of the Local Self Government Department dated 22.3.23, regarding the revised property tax rates effective 01.04.2023, a draft notification was published as per Decision Nos. 2(1) and 3(1) of the Panchayat Committee dated 17/05/2023, and the final notification was approved as per Decision No. 2(2) dated 21/08/2023. The basic rate for each category of building has been fixed considering the financial position and other special features of the Local Self Government Institution, while remaining within the limits fixed by the Government. Software updation has been carried out with regard to the revision of property tax. Tax is currently being collected at the revised rates. Updation regarding the revised tax details has been carried out in the Sanchaya software. Information regarding zones, as prescribed under Rule 7 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax, Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, has not been recorded and maintained on a ward-wise map. A road map has not been prepared. Although field visits were conducted to check unauthorised building constructions encroaching on open spaces and parking areas, no unauthorised construction was noticed. Revenue recovery has been recommended for buildings in respect of property tax arrears from unauthorised buildings of previous years (Audit Enquiry No. 02/07.11.2023).
3) Service Cess
Service cess can be levied and collected for various services rendered by the Panchayat (water supply, sanitation maintenance, street lights, drainage, etc.). However, the Panchayat has not collected service cess to date. Although Central Government institutions are located within the limits of the Grama Panchayat, service charges are not collected from them.
4) Profession Tax
Although a complete database of institutions, employees, self-employed persons (advocates, private doctors, other professionals, contractors who have undertaken various construction works, engineers who prepare building plans in the Grama Panchayat, supervisors, vehicle owners, ration dealers within the limits of the Grama Panchayat, etc.), private schools/colleges and others liable to pay profession tax is maintained, profession tax is not being collected from contractors and ration shops. Profession tax should therefore be demanded and collected from those liable to pay it within the limits of the Panchayat.
5) Entertainment Tax
No amusement park, indoor club/stadium, swimming pools, zip line (ropeway) with tourism potential, glass bridge, or houseboat is functioning within the limits of the Panchayat. No trade fairs were held within the limits of the Panchayat during the financial year 2022-23.
6. Non-Tax Revenue
(1) Licence fee is being collected properly from institutions within the panchayat limits in connection with granting licences to industries, factories, trades, entrepreneurial activities and other services. Inspection has been carried out as per Rules 18, 21 and 24 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Industries, Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Amendment Rules, 2017.
(2) Inspection regarding income from auctions, fruit trees, etc.
The panchayat has three shopping complexes. Rent is being collected from them, and Revenue Recovery proceedings have been initiated against those who have fallen into arrears. Inspection has been carried out regarding the auctioning of outdated assets. Among these, the auction of the aged vehicle has been conducted in time. The panchayat receives no rent from ambulances, agricultural machinery, etc.
(3) Other items
Income obtainable according to local/environmental conditions (currently being received / that can be made a source of income in future) has not been identified. Steps should be taken for a feasibility study in this regard.
1-10 Paramedical institutions/hospitals functioning without licence
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, no place shall be used for any purpose without a licence. Further, as per Sl. Nos. 142 & 143 of Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, private hospitals and paramedical institutions respectively require the panchayat's licence to function within the panchayat limits.
However, on verification of the panchayat's licence register and the paramedical licence register, it was found that the institutions mentioned below have obtained registration with the panchayat but have not obtained the licence required to function.
1. NSA Clinic
2. Pulse Holistic Health Care Rehabilitation
3. Arul Clinical Laboratory & Digital X-Ray
4. Arul Clinical Laboratory
5. Sudharma Speciality Laboratory
6. Krupa Hitech Laboratory, Elanad
7. Krupa Hitech Laboratory, Pazhayannur
8. Hitech Lab
9. Jeeva Hitech Laboratory
10. Vinayaka Metro Medical Lab
11. Smile Care Dental Clinic
Trust Care Homoeopathy Clinic
Therefore, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.13/14.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding the above institutions functioning without a licence. Hence the above institutions should be made to obtain a licence and the information intimated.
1-11 Profession tax has not been collected from employees
Every person who resides within the Grama Panchayat area for a total of not less than 60 days in a half-year and, outside it, is engaged in any profession, art or employment, or carries on business, or holds any office, public or private, or derives any income from investments, is liable to pay profession tax (Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, Section 204).
However, on verifying the Profession Tax Demand Register for the financial year 2022-23 and the applications submitted by institutions for FTEOS licence, it was found that although the institutions mentioned below, having more than one employee, had recorded in their applications the number of employees required for the institution to function, profession tax has not been demanded and collected from these employees.
| Sl. No. | Establishment | Building number | Number of employees |
| 1. | Great Motors | 4/904 | 10 |
| 2. | N.S Agencies | 19/360 | 4 |
| 3. | Phoenix Ice Cubes | 2/142B | 8 |
| 4. | Sona Cement Bricks | 13/519 | 5 |
| 5. | Keraleeya Ayurveda Samajam Agency & Nursing Home | 4/920 | 4 |
| 6. | Chirackal Sawmill | 5/624 | 3 |
| 7. | Fathima Modern Rice Mill | 4/57,58,59 | 9 |
| 8. | Mekkattil Fuels | 12/272 | 2 |
| 9. | Vishal Fuels | 19/776 | 5 |
| 10. | Madeena Hollow Bricks | 4/843 | 4 |
| 11. | Ellora Designers | 22/1037 | 3 |
Therefore, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.12/14.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding non-collection of profession tax from the employees of the above institutions. Hence profession tax should be collected from the employees of the said institution and the information intimated.
1-12 Profession tax has not been collected from contractors
As per the records made available by the Local Infrastructure Department & Engineering Wing, profession tax has not been collected from the contractors mentioned below who undertook and carried out various works within the panchayat limits during the period 2022-23.
1. Ibrahimkutty
2. Abdul Rasheed
3. Ravi R
4. Rajan C
5. Roy K.M
6. Basheer K.M
7. T.N Prasad
8. Venkitaramanan P.S
9. K.M Hamsa
10. Muhammed Basheer
11. Rasheed P.M
12. Prakashan K.V
13. Babu E
14. Ayoob K.M
15. Biju M Mathew
16. Muhammed Ali
17. Sahad
18. P.K Krishnadas
19. Ziyad S
20. Surendran R
21. Muhammed Basheer
The amount should be collected from the above-mentioned contractors, or, if they have paid profession tax to other local self-government institutions, a copy of the same should be made available. Otherwise, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.12/14.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding non-collection of profession tax from the said contractors. Hence profession tax should be collected from the said contractors according to their income and the information intimated to the Kerala State Audit Department.
1-13 Property tax - applicable increases were not made
I. Property tax - access route of buildings wrongly determined
As per Rule 6 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax and Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, rebates and increases may be allowed on the basic property tax based on various factors. Accordingly, if there is a road facility of more than 5 metres in width, an additional increase of 20% may be made in the property tax. However, on scrutiny of the files of buildings numbered during the financial year 2022-23 made available for audit, it was found that although, as per the documents submitted by the applicants, access to the buildings mentioned below was from a road more than 5 metres wide, access from a road more than 1.5 metres wide was recorded for them and no increase or rebate was given in property tax. Details are given below.
| Building number | Floor area (sq.m) | Manner of use | Basic property tax rate fixed by the panchayat (Rs./sq.m) | Property tax assessed | Tax that ought to have been assessed |
| 15/133C | 618.69 | For industrial use Required - handloom shed, coir-twisting shed - storage shed | 10 | 5198(4950+LC 248) (Secondary sector - 10% rebate, Roofing - 10% rebate) | 6496 (when including the 20% increase based on road access) |
| 12/266A | 278.77 | For residential purpose | 5 | 1317 (Secondary sector - 10% rebate) | 1610 (when including the 20% increase based on road access) |
II. Property tax of auditorium - increase not given
As per Rule 6 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax and Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, rebates and increases may be allowed on the basic property tax based on various factors. Accordingly, if there is a road facility of more than 5 metres in width, an additional increase of 20% may be made in the property tax, and if centralised air-conditioning is present, an increase of 15% may be made. However, on scrutiny of the file numbered 1/29A for the financial year 2022-23, for the auditorium owned by Gopakumar, made available for audit, it was found that although the documents submitted by the applicant showed that the building, situated in the primary sector, was air-conditioned, and that access to the building was from a road more than 5 metres wide, access from a road more than 1.5 metres wide was recorded and no increase or rebate was given in property tax. Along with this, the 15% increase for air-conditioning was also not given. Details are given below.
| Building number | Floor area (sq.m) | Manner of use | Basic property tax rate (Rs./sq.m) | Property tax assessed | Tax that ought to have been assessed |
| 1/29A | 787.89 | Auditorium | 35 | 26060(24819+LC 1241) (Secondary sector - 10% rebate) | 39089 (Primary sector - no rebate and no increase, 20% increase based on road access, 15% increase for air-conditioning) |
Loss has occurred in property tax as the legitimate increase in property tax was not given for the above buildings. Therefore, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.11/14.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding the failure to give the legitimate increase while assessing property tax for the said buildings. Hence changes should be made in the Sanchaya software relating to the property tax of the said buildings, the increase in property tax effected, and the information intimated.
1-14 Ration shops functioning without licence and without paying profession tax
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, no place shall be used for any purpose without a licence. As per Sl. No.149 of Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, a ration shop requires the panchayat's licence to function within the panchayat limits. The Director of Civil Supplies has, vide letter (C.S)A9-764/2019 dated 22.01.2019, clarified that ration shops cannot be exempted from licence fee and profession tax under the existing rules. However, on verification of the FTEOS Licence Register for the financial year 2022-23, it was found that none of the ration shops had obtained a licence. Therefore, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.17/15.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding ration shops functioning without obtaining a licence and without paying profession tax. Hence the total number of ration shops within the panchayat limits should be ascertained, licences obtained from them, profession tax collected, and the information intimated.
1-15 Property tax assessed for buildings at a lower rate
Tax for various buildings in the Grama Panchayat has been fixed at the following rates.
| Sl. No. | Item | Rate (Rs./sq.m) |
| 1. | Building up to 100 sq.m for commercial use (hotels, restaurants, shops, godowns) | 30 |
| 2. | Building above 100 sq.m for commercial use (hotels, restaurants, shops, godowns) | 50 |
On verification of the Sanchaya software relating to property tax, it was found that although the area of the buildings mentioned below in Ward 22 exceeds 100 sq.m, property tax has been assessed by treating them as buildings up to 100 sq.m for commercial use, calculating the basic rate as Rs.30 instead of Rs.50.
| Sl. No. | Building number | Owner | Area (sq.m) |
| 1 | 22/614 | Moidu Ali and Abdul Nazar and others | 118 |
| 2. | 22/615 | Moidu Ali and Abdul Nazar and others | 118 |
| 3. | 22/824 | Shanmukhan, Kallamparambil | 121 |
| 4. | 22/825 | Shanmukhan, Kallamparambil | 121 |
| 5. | 22/826 | Shanmukhan, Kallamparambil | 121 |
| 6. | 22/914 | C.Rajeev and C.Preethi | 102.9 |
| 7. | 22/915 | C.Rajeev and C.Preethi | 137.73 |
| 8. | 22/925 | C.Rajeev and C.Preethi | 197.73 |
| 9. | 22/926 | C.Rajeev and C.Preethi | 197.73 |
| 10. | 22/927 | C.Rajeev and C.Preethi | 167.21 |
| 11. | 22/930 | C.Rajeev and C.Preethi | 110 |
| 12. | 22/970 | Subhadra, Mozhikulangara | 110 |
| 13. | 22/1067 | Vidarbha, Kodavampadath House | 134.15 |
| 14. | 22/1068 | Vidarbha, Kodavampadath House | 127 |
| 15. | 22/1069 | Vidarbha, Kodavampadath House | 120.6 |
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.18/15.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding the property tax of the above buildings being collected at a lower rate. Hence the usage pattern of the above buildings should be correctly determined, changes made in the Sanchaya software, property tax reassessed and collected along with arrears. In the above table, details of buildings in Ward 22 alone have been recorded. In this situation, if there are buildings in the remaining wards whose usage pattern has been similarly wrongly recorded, they should be identified, property tax reassessed and the information intimated. Since property tax is the panchayat's own revenue, care should be taken to avoid such lapses and loss of revenue should be avoided.
1-16 Profession tax not collected from institutions/traders
Every person who resides within the Grama Panchayat area for a total of not less than 60 days in a half-year and, outside it, is engaged in any profession, art or employment, or carries on business, or holds any office, public or private, or derives any income from investments, is liable to pay profession tax. (Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, Section 204).
I. Traders' profession tax not collected
On verification of the register of payment of traders' profession tax for the financial year 2022-23, it was found that the owners of the institutions mentioned below have not paid traders' profession tax. Therefore, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.19/15.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding non-collection of traders' profession tax from the said institutions. Hence profession tax should be collected from the owners of the said institutions.
1. Nila Metals Private Limited
2. Quarry owned by P.O Varghese
3. Quarry owned by Shinto Abraham
4. Supplyco Supermarket, Elanad
II. Institution profession tax not collected
On verification of the Profession Tax Demand Register, it was found that institution profession tax has not been collected from the institutions mentioned below. No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.19/15.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding non-collection of institution profession tax from the owners of the said institution. Hence institution profession tax should be collected from the owners of the said institutions.
1. Toddy shop TS No.10
2. Toddy shop TS No.12
3. Toddy shop TS No.13
4. Toddy shop TS No.14
5. Toddy shop TS No.15
6. Toddy shop TS No.16
7. Toddy shop TS No.24
8. Toddy shop TS No.28
9. Toddy shop TS No.29
10. Toddy shop TS No.30
III. Institution profession tax of auditoriums not collected.
As per the Sanchaya software relating to property tax, the auditoriums/marriage halls mentioned below are functioning within the panchayat limits, but institution profession tax has not been collected from them. Therefore, no reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.19/15.11.2023) issued seeking a reply regarding non-collection of institution profession tax from the owners of the said auditoriums. Hence institution profession tax should be collected from the owners of the said institutions.
| Sl. No. | Building number | Owner | Manner of use |
| 1. | 3/108 | N.S.S Karayogam Building | Auditorium |
| 2. | 3/579 | Aravindakshan | Auditorium |
| 2. | 4/273 | Parish Hall | Marriage hall |
| 4. | 12/53A | Badaruddin | Marriage hall |
| 5. | 12/67 | Badaruddin | Marriage hall |
| 6. | 12/68 | Badaruddin | Marriage hall |
| 7. | 19/530 | Chellamma | Marriage hall |
| 8. | 19/787 | M.E.Abdul Majeed | Marriage hall |
| 9. | 21/447 | Muhammed Shereef | Auditorium |
1-17 Social security pensions - amounts drawn without entitlement - information on follow-up action should be furnished.
Information regarding persons who have received social security pensions without entitlement while also receiving Service Pension/Family Pension has been intimated vide letter PAN/2566/2020-DBT1(DP) dated 04.03.2021 of the Director of Panchayats. In the said list, it has been intimated that the following persons in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat have received social security pension without entitlement.
| Sl. No. | Pension ID | Pension | Aadhaar number | Name | Pension disbursement Date of commencement |
| 1 | 107380100308 | Agricultural Worker Pension | 877830293274 | Karthyayani Krishnan | 1/1/2008 |
| 2 | 107380201642 | Old Age Pension | 457650906488 | Narayanankutty | 2/1/2014 |
| 3 | 107380400450 | Disability Pension Scheme - Physical | 818748949775 | Manoj.P.R | 12/1/2014 |
| 4 | 107380500080 | Unmarried persons above 50 years of age Pension for women | 516958566411 | Kallyanikkutti | 1/1/2008 |
| 5 | 107380500232 | Unmarried persons above 50 years of age Pension for women | 714288936118 | Annam | 5/1/2016 |
| 6 | 107380601621 | Widow pension | 839025959403 | Kunjamma | 1/1/2016 |
| 7 | 107380601635 | Widow pension | 377232122740 | Rugmini | 2/1/2016 |
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (16/15.11.23) issued seeking, if the amount drawn without entitlement by the said persons has been recovered, details of the same, and if not recovered, information regarding the steps taken for the same.
The amount drawn without entitlement by the persons listed in the above table should be recovered and the information intimated to audit.
1-18 Annual accounts of Hospital Management Committee - information not furnished
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.3/10.11.23) issued seeking information regarding the functioning of the Hospital Management Committee and the audit of annual accounts of the hospitals under the Grama Panchayat, constituted as required under the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Managing Committees for Public Health Institutions) Rules, 2010. The annual accounts of the Hospital Management Committee, pending audit, of the PHC, Ayurveda and Homoeo Dispensaries under Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat should be forwarded to the District Audit Office of the Kerala State Audit Department, Thrissur.
1-19 Distribution of medicines - information to be furnished
| Project No/ Name | 40/23 Purchase of medicines for FHC |
| Implementing Officer | Medical Officer, FHC |
| Voucher number/ Date | 42201147/27.09.22 - Amount Rs.1,39,833 42201171/16.11.22 - Amount Rs.84,672 42201294/26.03.23 - Amount Rs.19,813 |
| Estimate | 4,50,000 Maintenance Fund (Road type) |
| Expenditure | 2,44,318 |
| Head | 251110012 Medical InstitutionAllopathy-Health RelatedActivities |
Under the above project, Rs.2,44,318 has been given in advance to KMSCL, Thiruvananthapuram. Medicines have been distributed to date as follows.
| Proforma Invoice No/Date | Invoice No/Date | Total amount |
| PRF1385/17.09.22 | 18884/28.11.22 – 28560 18942/5.11.22— 1216 20567/21.12.22— 18098 22076/6.1.23— 4401 22230/9.1.23— 13519 /20.4.23— 12788 11279/1.7.23— 18877 13356/19.7.23 – 14448 15800/11.8.23 --13216 | 125123 |
| PRF2009/16.11.22 | 22384/7.1.23- 75264 8859/13.6.23— 9408 | 84,672 |
| PRF5234/19.03.23 | 6433/27.5.23-17612 | 17,612 |
| Total | 2,27,407 |
No reply has been received to the audit enquiry (No.4/10.11.23) issued in this regard.
Steps should be taken to obtain medicines worth the remaining Rs.16,911, and when the medicines are received, they should be taken into stock and produced to audit along with records.
1-20 Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme
Details regarding the implementation of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme for the year 2022-23 are as follows.
| Details regarding the implementation of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme for the year 2021-22 - Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | |||
| Sl. No. | 2022-23 | ||
| 1 | Number of works envisaged in the year 2022-23 | 2387 | |
| 2 | Value of works envisaged in the year 2022-23 | 642887800 | |
| 3 | Number of works completed in the year 2022-23 | 137 | |
| 4 | Value of works completed in the year 2022-23 | 27793830 | |
| 5 | Number of job cards issued under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 8057 | |
| 6 | Person-days of employment generated in the year 2022-23 | 266582 | |
| Female | Male | Total | |
| 251135 | 15447 | 266582 | |
| Scheduled Caste | Scheduled Tribe | Others | Total |
| 73967 | 3114 | 189501 | 266582 |
| 11 | Number of families provided employment in 2022-23 | 4288 | |
| 12 | Number of households that completed 100 days of employment in the year 2022-23 | 1268 | |
| 13 | Information on disbursement of unemployment wages, if any, under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme in 2022-23 | NIL | |
| 14 | Wages disbursed in the year 2022-23 under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | Total - 8,73,84,109 & | |
| 15 | Wages due for disbursement as on 31-03-2023 under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | NIL | |
| 15 | Details of Social Audit conducted | Social Audit has been conducted | |
| 16 | Details regarding integrated/joint projects (convergence schemes) undertaken in the year 2022-23 in collaboration with other sections of the Grama Panchayat (number) | NIL | |
| 17 | Details regarding integrated/joint projects (convergence schemes) undertaken in the year 2022-23 in collaboration with other sections of the Grama Panchayat (value) | NIL | |
| Details regarding projects for 2022-23 | |||
| Sl. No. | Category of projects | Number of projects implemented | Amount spent |
| 1 | Soil and water conservation | 107 | 3,25,41,680 |
| 2 | Drought proofing, afforestation | 19 | 5,99,608 |
| 3 | Renovation of traditional water bodies | 10 | 23,82,882 |
| 4 | Land development | 140 | 3,33.73,162 |
1-21 GST TDS not deducted on Anganwadi Supplementary Nutrition
In the projects 15/23 Anganwadi Supplementary Nutrition (General) and 16/23 Anganwadi Supplementary Nutrition (SCP), with the ICDS Supervisor as Implementing Officer, the products 'Amrutham Food' and 'Kumari Plus' were purchased for the 38 anganwadis of the Grama Panchayat from the institution Natural Amrutham Food Supplement, Erumapetty Grama Panchayat, Kottappuram-680584, paying 2.5% CGST and 2.5% SGST, as follows.
Sl. No | Name of product | Invoice number | Date | Quantity (kg) | Bill amount | GST | Voucher number |
| 1 | Amrutham Food | 3 | 26.04.22 | 1846.500 | 135717.75 | 6462.75 | 42000573/03.11.22 Amount: Rs.5,00,705 |
| 2 | Amrutham Food | 7 | 24.05.22 | 1846.500 | 135717.75 | 6462.75 | -do- |
| 3 | Amrutham Food | 11 | 18.06.22 | 1816.500 | 133511.00 | 6356.00 | -do- |
| 4 | Kumari Plus | 4 | 26.04.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 5 | Kumari Plus | 8 | 24.05.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 6 | Kumari Plus | 12 | 18.06.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 7 | Amrutham Food | 28 | 16.07.22 | 1404.000 | 98280.00 | 4914.00 | 42201196/27.12.22 Amount: Rs.5,86,098 |
| 8 | Amrutham Food | 32 | 19.08.22 | 1525.500 | 112123.00 | 5338.00 | -do- |
| 9 | Amrutham Food | 42 | 26.09.22 | 1674.000 | 123039.00 | 5859.00 | -do- |
| 10 | Amrutham Food | 16 | 21.10.22 | 1633.000 | 120062.25 | 5717.25 | -do- |
| 11 | Kumari Plus | 29 | 16.07.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 12 | Kumari Plus | 33 | 19.08.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 13 | Kumari Plus | 43 | 26.09.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 14 | Kumari Plus | 17 | 21.10.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| 15 | Amrutham Food | 20 | 19.11.22 | 1633.500 | 114345.00 | 5716.00 | 42201018/30.03.23 Amount: Rs.10,08,670 |
| 16 | Amrutham Food | 28 | 28.01.23 | 1242.000 | 91287.00 | 4346.00 | -do- |
| 17 | Amrutham Food | 32 | 22.02.23 | 1620.000 | 119070.00 | 5670.00 | -do- |
| 18 | Amrutham Food | 35 | 20.03.23 | 1606.500 | 118077.00 | 5622.00 | -do- |
| 19 | Kumari Plus | 21 | 1911.22 | 380.000 | 31920.00 | 1520.00 | -do- |
| Total | 15,56,590 | ||||||
As per Section 51(1) of the CGST Act, 2017, TDS of 1% is required to be deducted from the bills of contractors for goods or services or both where the total value of supply exceeds Rs.2½ lakh. Section 51(1) of the SGST Act, 2017 contains a similar provision. Hence a total of 2% tax - 1% each under CGST and SGST - is required to be deducted at source from bills whose total value exceeds Rs.2½ lakh. However, as tabulated above, no reply has been received to Audit Enquiry No.9 dated 14.11.23, issued seeking the reason for not deducting TDS under CGST and SGST while purchasing the products 'Amrutham Food' and 'Kumari Plus' from the institution Natural Amrutham Food Supplement, Erumapetty Grama Panchayat, Kottappuram-680584. Steps should be taken to sanction amounts in future years only after deducting GST TDS as required by law.
1-22 Disbursement of PMAY share - utilisation certificate not produced
In the project 160/23 Disbursement of PMAY share, with the Village Extension Officer as Implementing Officer, the amount has been handed over to the Secretary, Pazhayannur Block Panchayat, as follows.
| Sl. No. | Voucher number | Date | Amount | Fund Head |
| 1 | 42201202 | 30.12.22 | 22,40,000 | Development Fund - SCP |
| 2 | 42201295 | 28.03.23 | 6,21,497 | Development Fund - SCP |
| 3 | 42201020 | 31.03.23 | 78,503 | Own Fund |
As per the utilisation certificate of the Secretary, Pazhayannur Block Panchayat dated 27.07.2023, although the utilisation certificate has been given for Rs.28,61,497/- allotted from the Development Fund-SCP as tabulated above, the utilisation certificate has been given for only Rs.70,000 out of the Rs.78,503 given from the Own Fund. No reply has been received to Audit Enquiry No.20 dated 15.11.23, issued seeking that the utilisation certificate for Rs.8,503 be produced for verification. The utilisation certificate for the entire amount should be obtained from the implementing agency and produced for verification.
1-23 Day Care Centre should be made fit for use.
Implementing Officer - Assistant Engineer
Project No.-- 43/23 - Construction of Day Care Centre for the elderly (spillover)
Development Fund General Category - Rs.7,10,524 (estimate)
Expenditure - Rs.4,98,581.
Voucher No - 42201069/12-05-2022
M-Book No.246/20-21
Construction of the Day Care Centre was completed on 06.05.22. However, it was found, during the site inspection conducted on 14.11.23, that it has not yet been made useful for the elderly. Since the objective of the scheme is achieved only when assets are created, made fit for use and maintained, urgent attention of the Governing Body and the various Standing Committees is invited to this matter. (Audit Enquiry No.10/14.11.23)
1-24 She Lodge remains unused.
Implementing Officer - Assistant Engineer
1. Project No.44/23 Construction of She Lodge.
Development Fund General Category - Rs.3,53,082/-.
Voucher No - 42201305/28.03.23
Expenditure - Rs.2,14,067.
2. Project No.72/23 Completion of She Lodge.
Development Fund General Category - Rs.8,26,732/-.
Voucher No - 42201306/28.03.23
Expenditure - Rs.8,26,732.
As stated above, two projects were implemented for the construction of She Lodge in 2022-23. During the site inspection conducted on 14.11.23, the above building was found lying unused. Along with creation of the asset, its continued maintenance is necessary for fulfilling the objective of the scheme. By accounting for assets, they can be maintained constructively. (Audit Enquiry No.14/14.11.2023)
1-25 Certificate proving the beneficiary's caste not produced for verification - expenditure amount held under objection
As per Paragraph 2.17 of Government Order (Kai) No.115/2022/LSGD dated 28.05.2022, being the guidelines regarding preparation of annual plans from 2022-23 to 2026-27 of Grama, Block and District Panchayats and Urban Local Bodies, and subsidy, financial assistance and related matters, either the SSLC/school certificate or a caste certificate obtained from Revenue authorities within a period of three years is required to be produced along with the application to prove the caste of beneficiaries. However, in Project 158/23 House-Making-Habitable SC, implemented utilising Development Fund-SCP with the Village Extension Officer (Pazhayannur Circle) as Implementing Officer, financial assistance of Rs.75,000 (Voucher No.42201185/19.12.22 Amount: Rs.37,500 & Voucher No.42201270/18.03.23 Amount: Rs.37,500) has been sanctioned and given to the beneficiary Smt. Seetha W/o. Kunjunni, Meledath Parambu, Kodathoor, Kallepadam (P.O), Pazhayannur. However, the certificate proving the beneficiary's caste has not been produced for verification. No reply has been received to Audit Enquiry No.20 dated 15.11.23 issued in this regard. The certificate proving the beneficiary's caste should be produced for verification. The expenditure amount of Rs.75,000 is held under objection until the caste certificate is produced.
Part -2
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the receipt side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(1) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -3
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the expenditure side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(2) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -4
General information and audit review
4-1 Utilisation of funds received for joint projects
No funds have been received for joint projects during the current year. However, as per Schedule B4 of the Balance Sheet, out of the amount received from the Block Panchayat for joint projects, Rs.12,49,015 remains unspent. If the amount is not spent, it should be remitted back and audit intimated.
4-2 Details of amount given for deposit works
No amount has been spent on deposit works during the current year. However, as per Schedule B18 of the Balance Sheet, Rs.15,551 has been deposited with KSEB for deposit works. The amounts should be adjusted as and when the completion certificate is received.
4-3 Details of mobilisation advance
None
4-4 Loan/loan repayment
| Name/purpose of the loan | Order No / Date | Loan amount | Amount remaining to be repaid at the beginning of the year | Amount repaid during the current year | Amount remaining to be repaid at the end of the year | |
| Principal | Interest | |||||
| Life KURDFC loan | 26594895 | 3680555 | 0 | 22914340 | ||
4-5 Fixed deposits
| Fixed deposit existing at the beginning of the year | 2577496 | |
| Amount deposited during the current year | 30120631 (including interest) | |
| Total | 32698127 | |
| Amount withdrawn during the current year | 0 | |
| Fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year | 32698127 | |
| Details of the fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year | Details of deposit | Amount |
| 433500 | 1228736 | |
| 256007 | 500000 | |
| 256073 | 969391 | |
| 101140010143569 | 10000000 | |
| 101140010143570 | 20000000 |
4-6 Audit recovery
| Report year | Part/ Paragraph | Amount recovered | Name of the person Name and designation | Receipt No / Date |
| 2011-12 | 3-23 | 678 | Muhammed Bashir K M | 1220100006/04.04.22 |
| 2007-08 | 3-3 | 90000 | Member Secretary | 1220100183/12-04-22 |
| 2011-12 | 2-3(1) | 150 | Secretary | 1220100423/21-04-22 |
| 2018-19 | 1-17 | 103088 | Sunit Rahman | 1220100431/22-04-22, 1220101122/19-05-22, 1220101854/22-06-22, 1220102702/17-08-22 |
| 2017-18 | 2-3(3) | 3190 | Headmaster | 1220100544/26.04.2022 |
| 2018-19 | 1-16 | |||
| 1998-99 | 569 | Secretary | 1220102766/20-08-22 | |
| 2020-21 | 3-3 | 18535 | Roy K M | 1220103138/14-09-22 |
| 2020-21 | 3-4 | 3989 | Prakashan | 1220103243/22-09-22 |
| 2020-21 | 1-45 | 3109 | Shameer | 1220103301/26-09-22 |
The information given in the above table is that furnished by the panchayat. As per it, Rs.2,23,308 has been received under Audit Recovery. However, as per Receipts & Payments Schedule RP-30, Rs.2,36,527/- has been recorded as received under this head.
4-7 Details of charge/surcharge proceedings
None
4-8 Consolidated Audit Report
Details of the paragraphs from the Panchayat's previous years' audit reports, included in the consolidated report under Section 23 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, that remain to be settled are given below.
| Audit Year | Paragraph | Consolidated Report Year | Paragraph | Subject | Present status |
| 2017-2018 | 2-1 | 2017-2018 | For Kodathoor Industrial Park, the land was handed over to SIDCO | No.A4-8297/18 dated 14.08.2018 as per letter, from this office a reply has been furnished. The matter is under the consideration of the Legislative Committee. | |
| 2016-17 | 3-1 | 2016-17 | Land for various purposes purchase - a lapse occurred in fixing the land price | is under the consideration of the Legislative Committee | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(1) | 2016-2017 | Employees of 3 institutions - Profession tax not collected | Information on payment of the amount has been furnished to the Legislative Committee. The remark is under the consideration of the Committee. | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(2) | 2016-2017 | Profession tax of 4 institutions not collected | Information regarding remittance of the amount has been intimated to the Legislature Committee. The remark is under the consideration of the Committee.. | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(3) | 2016-2017 | General irregularities In the year 2015-16, as being for commercial purposes, tax has been assessed on the buildings; the profession tax should be collected from the employees liable to pay it, so as to increase the Panchayat's revenue by collecting profession tax, and steps should be taken accordingly. In addition, to the buildings to which D & O licenses have been issued liable to pay profession tax of all individuals and institutions a register containing details should be prepared and steps should be taken to collect profession tax. | In the year 2015-16 commercial purposes assessed to tax as in all buildings, operations Not started. D & O Licence applicable profession tax of institutions Demand register has been kept up to date. The para is under the consideration of the Legislature Committee. |
4-9 Audit Review
(A) Summary
| Opening Balance | 39489916 |
| Receipts for the audit year | 74931968 |
| Total | 114421884 |
Total for the audit year Expenditure | 85734505 |
| Balance | 28687379 |
| Loss under receipt heads | 0 |
| Loss under expenditure heads / amount not accepted in audit | 0 |
Amount held under objection in audit Amount | 75000 |
*The information entered in the table is as per the Receipts & Payments Statement of the annual accounts furnished by the Grama Panchayat. Grants received from the Government are not included in the receipts and expenditure shown herein.
(B)Details of clear loss sustained to the Panchayat Fund
None.
Held under objection in audit
| Paragraph No | Amount | Name and designation of the person responsible |
| 1-25 | 75000 | Ramya K, VEO Pazhayannur Circle |
(C)Central and State Governments, other institutions
details of the loss sustained by these
None.
(D)Cases requiring further investigation to make good the loss
None.
(E)Name and permanent address of the persons responsible for the loss/objection dealt with in the report
| Name and designation of the person responsible | Current address | Permanent address |
| Ramya K, VEO Pazhayannur Circle | Ramya K, VEO Kadangode Grama Panchayat | Kaippampulackal House, Varavoor |
4-10 Paragraphs remaining to be settled
| Sl. No. | Audit Report year | Audit Report number | Total number of paragraphs remaining to be settled | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | Remarks (CAR/CASE/ CH/SCH) |
| 1 | 1997-98 (Expenditure) | L.F.T12-1559/99 dt.6.3.99 | 4 | 1, 4, 5, 6 | |
| 2 | 1997-98 (Receipt) | L.F.T10-306/08 dt. 25.4.09/9.7.09 | 1 | 2-1 | |
| 3 | 1999-2000 to 2001-02 (People's Plan) | L.F.T10-1079/03 dt.09.04.04/14.09.04 | 7 | 7, 8, 14, 15 (2), 16, 18 (2to5), 20 (1,2,3) | Paragraph 8 - CAR |
| 4 | 1998-99 (Expenditure) | L.F.T12-291/2001 dt.18.5.01/09.7.01 | 21 | 4, 8, 12, 13, 14 D1, 14 E3, 14F, 15 B,15 D2, 20, 21, 24,26, 30, 31, 34, 36 A2, 36 A3, 36 C2, 42, 32, 29, 9, 14A, 14B, 15A, 17(2) | |
| 5 | 2000-01 | L.F.T10-309/08 dt. 25.04.09/14.7.19 | 1 | 3-3 | |
| 6 | 2001-02 | L.F.T10-740/08 dt. 25.04.09 | 2 | 3-1, 3-3 | |
| 7 | 2002-03 | L.F.T10-1265/08 dt. 07.09.09/5.12.09 | 1 | 3-13 | |
| 8 | 2003-04 | L.F.T10-1266/08 dt. 7.09.09/05.12.09 | 4 | 3-11, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16 | |
| 9 | 2005-06 | L.F.T10-1348/09 dt. 28.07.10/10.12.10 | 2 | 2-3, 3-3 | |
| 10 | 2006-07 | L.F.T10-1336/09 Dt. 29.7.10/10.12.10 | 1 | 3-7 | CAR |
| 11 | 2007-08 | LFT(P4)956/12 dt. 19.7.12/5.11.12 | 2 | 3-2, 3-4 | |
| 12 | 2008-09 | LFT(P4)957/12 dt. 19.7.12 | 5 | 3-2, 3-3, 3-4, 3-5, 3-6 | |
| 13 | 2009-10 | LFT(P4)958/12 dt. 02.08.12/05.11.12 | 3 | 3-2, 3-7, 3-8 | |
| 14 | 2010-11 | LFT(P4)959/12 dt. 2.8.12 | 3 | 3-7, 3-9, 3-10 | |
| 15 | 2011-12 | LFT(P4)1151/13 dt. 4.12.13/05.2.14 | 9 | 2-3(5) (Sl. No. 1,2,4,6,10,11,12, 13,14) 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-4, 3-5, 3-21, 3-23, 3-25 | |
| 16 | 2012-13 | LFT(P4)-631/14 dt. 08.10.14/08.12.14 | 17 | 2-3(1)A, 2-3(1)B, 2-3(3), 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3(1), 3-3(3), 3-3(4), 3-3(5), 3-3(6), 3-4, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-14, 3-15 | |
| 17 | 2013-14 | LFT(P4)-186/15 dt. 7.5.15/5.6.15 | 18 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-5 A,D, 2-8, 3-9, 3-10, 3-11, 3-12, 3-14, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-21 (a,b), 3-22, 3-23, 3-24, 3-25, 3-27 | |
| 18 | 2014-15 | KSATSR(P4)-996/16 dt. 25.6.16 | 14 | 2-2, 2-6(1)to(5), 2-7, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-8, 3-11, 3-13, 3-16, 3-17 | |
| 19 | 2015-16 | KSATSR(P4)-1934/16 dt. 05.01.16/05.12.16 | 15 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-8, 2-10, 3-8, 3-9, 3-11, 3-12, 3-13, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-25 | 2-8 CAR |
| 20 | 2016-17 | KSATSR(P4)-1111/17 dt. 30.8.17 | 10 | 2-3, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-7(1)to(3), 3-8(1)(2), 3-9(1)(2), 3-12, 3-13, 3-14 | |
| 21 | 2017-18 | KSATSR(P4)771/19 dt. 01.06.19 | 16 | 2-3(1,2), 2-7, 2-9(1,2), 3-1, 3-3, 3-5, 3-19, 3-20, 3-25, 3-26, 3-27, 3-28, 3-29, 3-9, 3-11, | |
| 22 | 2018-19 | KSATSR(P4)1499/2019 dt. 06.12.2019 | 17 | 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26 | |
| 23 | 2019-20 | KSATSR(P12)61/2022 dt. 01.07.2022 | 35 | 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36, 1-37, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-45, 1-46, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1 | |
| 24 | 2020-21 | KSATSR(P12)62/2022 dt. 01.07.2022 | 45 | 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36, 1-37, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-45, 1-46, 1-47, 1-48, 1-49, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-4 | |
| 25 | 2021-22 | KSATSR(P12)208/2023 dt. 11.04.2023 | 22 | 1-10(1 to 13), 1-11, 1-12, 1-13, 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31 | |
| Total number of paragraphs considered | 275 | ||||
Deputy Director
District Audit Office,
Thrissur
Annexure-1
Audit Certificate
i. I have audited the attached Financial statements approved vide resolution number 14(1) dated dated 21-07-2023 and submitted on 21-07-2023 , comprising of Receipt and Payment statement,Income and Expenditure account for the year ended on March and Balance sheet as on 31-03- , with supporting forms, of the Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat as per section 215(4) of Kerala Panchayath Raj act 1994, Kerala Panchayath Raj Accounts rules 2011, KSAD Audit Manual chapters 4.2.1 & 11.3 and as per guidelines and compliance instructions issued by State /Central Government, Finance Commission and other funding agencies from time to time. Preparation of these accounts is the responsibility of the PRI’s management. My responsibility is to express an opinion on these accounts based on my Financial Audit.
ii. I have conducted my Financial Audit in accordance with auditing standards issued by C&AG of India and Guidelines for Financial Audit of PRIs issued by C&AG. These standards/guidelines require that I plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial statements are free from material misstatements. An audit includes examining evidences supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of accounts. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
iii. On the basis of the information and explanations that I required and have obtained, and according to the best of my information as a result of Financial Audit of the accounts and on consideration of explanations given,
I certify that, subject to my observations in the appended report, except for the matters described in the basis for qualified opinion in the appended report and subject to other observations therein, the Annual Financial Statements give a true and fair view of financial result and Financial position of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the year 2022-2023
Date: 19/12/2023
Deputy Director
Kerala State Audit Department
Audit Report appended to the Audit Certificate of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the Year 2022-2023.
1.Major Observations
1.Interest on investments is not recognised as and when due which lead to the discrepancy in the outcome of Income & Expenditure statement and also affect the financial status of institution as per the Balance Sheet. As a result balance sheet schedule B-12 shows a deficit of 393586/-.
2.No interest accrued for the investment amount 969391/- (Investment number 256073, Kerala Bank, Pazhayannur) from 23.04.22 to 22.04.23. Non disclosure of interest rate and account statement during the same period.
2.Other Observations
a. Comments relating to Income & Expenditure Account
1. A sum of Rs. 7251477/- was expended as Central finance commission grant as per financial statements. But the total expenditure as per Sulekha expenditure statement/ Grant statement is 7528335/-.
b. Comments relating to Balance Sheet
1.The value of the works done for creating assets with the Specific Purpose Grants is not
included under the Capital contribution head.
C. Comments relating to Receipt & Payment
Nil.
d. Comments relating to Cashflow statement
1. Cash Flow statement-Net increase/decrease in cash flow Rs.-10802537/-/- does not match with difference between opening balance and closing balance of cash and cash equivalents 23208255.
e. Comments relating to Ratios
1. Key ratios are not included as part of Annual Financial statement.
f. Comments relating to Notes to Accounts
Nil
g. Comments relating to Receipt Vouchers
Nil
h. Comments relating to Payment Vouchers
Nil.
i. Comments relating to Journal Vouchers
1. Lapses in making timely and accurate demand entries in respect of accural
based income items.
2.Prior period item-Authenticated vouchers or worksheets are not maintained to verify
the authenticity of the journal entries in the schedule.
k. Comments relating to Bank Reconciliation Statement
1. Directly debited by bank- Transaction amount of Rs 2500/- is not recorded in bank book-
(ST Chelakkara-799013000000652 )
2. An amount of Rs.8022/- is shown as cheques deposited but not credited in the
bank reconciliation statement even after the elapse of one month after depositing the cheques.
(SBI- E-Payment 37121561057 )
l. Comments relating to Demand, Collection and Balance Register
1. DCB Statement of Property Tax (Both Residential and Non-residential) does not match with accounts. Details are given below.
Current
Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per sanchaya software | 2787030 | 2767274 | 20312 | 28008 |
| As per AFS | 2787308 | 2735349 | 12614 | 28120 |
| (Income & Expenditure Statement I-1) | (Receipt&Payment RP-45) | ( 350410101-Advance collection-PT on Res. Bldg- ledger) | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 (29527*100/105) |
Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya software | 4573756 | 4337989 | 10141 | 280697 |
| As per AFS | 4573064 | 4281844 | 4534 | 280730 |
| Income & Expenditure Statement I-1) | (Receipt&Payment RP-45) | ( 350410104-Advance collection-PT on NR bldg-Ledger) | *(294767/105X100 ) |
Arrear
Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya Software | 582621 | 533031 | 54340 |
| As per AFS | 806209 | 533031 | 54437 |
*(2021-22 Balalnce sheet Schedule B-15) (373664+472856=846520/105*100 | (Receipt&Payment RP-45) | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) 57159/105X100 |
Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per Sanchaya Software | 1576682 | 273641 | 1303631 |
| As per AFS | 1613396 | 273641 | 1304845 |
(2021-22 Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) 405587+1288479=1694066/105*100 | (Receipt&Payment RP-45) | (1369038/105X100)= 1303845, (Balance Sheet Scheduel B-15) Rounded off. |
2. Property Tax -Advance registers are not tallied with AFS. Details are given below.
| Sl.No. | Head Code | As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-9 | As per Sanchaya Software |
| 1 | 350410101-Advance collection of revenues -Property tax on Residential building | 31925/- | 31815/- |
| 2 | 350410104-Advance collection of revenues -Property tax on Non-Residential building | 56145/- | 55453/- |
m. Comments relating to Asset Register
1. The Asset value shown in Balance sheet is not traceable to Asset Register due to
unsupported design of existing asset register.
n. comments relating to Inventory and other registers
Nil
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Annexure-2
Utilisation Certificate of Grants
The utilisation of various grants for the year 2022-2023 by Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, has been examined as detailed in Annexure-1, on the basis of the details in the Grant Statement certified and furnished by the institution as per G.O.(Kai) 16/2021/LSGD dated 23.01.2021, and, subject to the observations regarding the utilisation of grants included in this report, the utilisation of grants of the institution is hereby certified.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department
| Annexure-3 Summary of annual accounts |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Deputy Director |

Government of Kerala
Kerala State Audit Department
www.ksad.kerala.gov.in
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Audit Report
2021-2022
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone : 0487-2331249
(Registered with acknowledgement due)
Number: K.S.A.T.S.R (P12)208/2023
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
Date: 11/04/2023
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone: 0487-2331249
Deputy Director
President (through the Secretary)
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Sir,
Subject: Regarding the Audit Report of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2021-2022.
In accordance with the provisions of Section 13 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, Rule 18 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996, and (Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994), the Audit Report resulting from the examination of the financial statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2021-2022 is forwarded herewith for further action as prescribed under Rule 23(1) of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996.
Attention is invited to the paragraphs in Part 1 of this report. Immediately on receipt of this report, the persons responsible for the irregularities mentioned therein shall be informed of the same, along with copies of the relevant paragraphs.
Within one month of receiving this report, a special meeting shall be convened to discuss the Audit Report in detail, and copies of the Audit Report and the decision taken thereon shall be published for public information. (See Rules 14 and 15 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules.)
Within two months of receiving the report, necessary action shall be taken to remove the audit remarks/objections contained herein, and a report to that effect shall be sent to this office within the said period. (See Local Fund Audit Act Section 15(1), Rules 20, 23, and Rule 21(1)(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules, 1997.)
Yours faithfully,
Deputy Director
Copy to:
1) The Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Thiruvananthapuram (for information),
2) Deputy Director of Panchayats, Thrissur.
3) Office copy.
Number: K.S.A.T.S.R (P12)208/2023
Date: 11/04/2023
Audit Report on the financial statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, for the financial year 2021-2022.
(1994 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, Section 13 , 1996 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, Rule 18, (1994 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act - Section 215(4)) issued in accordance with the above provisions.)
The financial statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur district, for the financial year 2021-2022 was subjected to audit. The collection of money under various heads made by the institution from 01-04-2021 to 31-12-2022 and its remittance, as well as the withdrawal of money from various accounts from 01-04-2021 to 31-03-2022, were also examined.
The irregularities detected in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Of the 32 audit enquiries issued, replies have been received for 2. The institution shall take further action on the audit enquiries not included in this report.
The irregularities detected in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. 32 audit enquiries were issued, but replies have not been received.
This report has been prepared on the basis of the registers, records, information and explanations made available by the institution. The Kerala State Audit Department bears no responsibility whatsoever, either for the analyses and observations included in this report where these were prepared on the basis of incorrect information or particulars furnished by the institution, or for irregularities subsequently found by another audit agency/inspection wing on the basis of records that were not made available to audit by the institution.
(A) Details of Audit Conducted
Officer in charge of audit:
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sathisan N | Deputy Director (Higher Grade) | 17-01-2023 | 25-01-2023 |
Time spent on audit:
| Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|
| 17-01-2023 | 25-01-2023 |
Officers who conducted the audit:
1) Baby. P.V, Audit Officer
2) Sunil P.B, Assistant Audit Officer
3) Joyson. C.J, Auditor
4) Sijo Thomas, Auditor
(B) Implementing Authorities
| Name | Official Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| P.K. Muraleedharan | President | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Ambika. M.S | Secretary | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
Implementing Officers
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jayamol Baby | Assistant Secretary | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Nisha. K.R | Medical Officer, Homoeo | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Dr. Unnikrishnan. A.K | Medical Officer, Ayurveda | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Sujatha. K | Headmistress, G.L.P.S, | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Sunilkumar. K | Assistant Engineer | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Sujith M S | Senior Veterinary Surgeon, Veterinary Dispensary, Pazhayannur | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Smisha | Veterinary Surgeon, Veterinary Hospital, Elanad | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Ginika P G | Dairy Farm Instructor | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Shibukumar P K | Fisheries Extension Officer | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Aditya Mohan | Agricultural Officer | 01-04-2021 | 07-10-2021 |
| Dipin M N | Agricultural Officer | 08-10-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Sunvin John | Village Extension Officer (Pazhayannur Circle) | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Peter C G | Village Extension Officer (Elanad Circle) | 01-04-2021 | 30-09-2021 |
| Ronnie M Y | Village Extension Officer (Elanad Circle) | 01-10-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
| Dr. Ajeesh. C.Y | Medical Officer, P.H.C. | 01-04-2021 | 31-03-2022 |
Contents
| Sl. No. | Part 1 | Paragraph Number |
|---|---|---|
| Part 2 | ||
| Part 3 | ||
| Part 4 | ||
| Annexure | ||
| 1 | Budget | 1-1 |
| 2 | Annual Financial Statement | 1-2 |
| 3 | Financial Analysis | 1-3 |
| 4 | Fund Utilisation | 1-4 |
| 5 | Plan Review | 1-5 |
| 6 | MGNREGS | 1-6 |
| 7 | Welfare Pensions | 1-7 |
| 8 | Cash Verification | 1-8 |
| 9 | Internal control system | 1-9 |
| 10 | Basic ratios not included in the Annual Financial Statement | 1-10-1 |
| 11 | Property Tax - Residential (current year) - Demand register and annual accounts do not tally | 1-10-2 |
| 12 | Accrual-based income - monthly demand journal entry not recorded | 1-10-3 |
| 13 | Provision not recorded. | 1-10-4 |
| 14 | 280000000-Prior Period item - neither approved vouchers nor worksheets supporting the entries have been made available for audit | 1-10-5 |
| 15 | Journal vouchers should also be kept supported by authentic certified vouchers and worksheets | 1-10-6 |
| 16 | Cash Flow Statement - accuracy not certified in audit | 1-10-7 |
| 17 | Closing Stock | 1-10-8 |
| 18 | No corresponding liability head in the Balance Sheet for special-purpose bank accounts | 1-10-9 |
| 19 | Annual Accounts Verification | 1-10 |
| 20 | Stale cheques have not been transferred to the liability head "Liability in respect of stale cheque" to adjust the Bank Book balance. | 1-10-10 |
| 21 | Capital work in progress - the accounts produced by the Assistant Engineer do not tally with the annual accounts | 1-10-11 |
| 22 | Amounts given as advance recorded in accounts as expenditure | 1-10-12 |
| 23 | Asset Register not updated. | 1-10-13 |
| 24 | Irregularities in Profession Tax | 1-11 |
| 25 | Farms operating without licence | 1-12 |
| 26 | Paramedical institutions/hospitals operating without registration and licence | 1-13 |
| 27 | Mobile towers in arrears of property tax | 1-14 |
| 28 | Social Security Pension sanctioned even after death | 1-15 |
| 29 | Irregularities in collection of property tax | 1-16 |
| 30 | Collection of licence fee - Government Order should be complied with | 1-17 |
| 31 | Irregularities in shopping complex rent | 1-18 |
| 32 | Establishments operating without licence for factories, trades and enterprises | 1-19 |
| 33 | Medicines not made available | 1-20 |
| 34 | Computer and printer not received till date though the amount was remitted | 1-21 |
| 35 | Cots received from Artco not distributed to beneficiaries | 1-22 |
| 36 | Irregularities in projects implemented by the V.E.O | 1-23 |
| 37 | Installation of surveillance cameras in Pazhayannur town - though the amount was remitted to the implementing agency years ago, the work has not been completed | 1-24 |
| 38 | Utilisation/completion certificates of projects in which the Secretary is the Implementing Officer not produced for verification | 1-25 |
| 39 | National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) | 1-26 |
| 40 | Irregularities in various schemes implemented by the Agricultural Officer. | 1-27 |
| 41 | Excess amount paid to the Electrical Engineer for preparation of estimate and supervision | 1-28 |
| 42 | Construction of Day Care Centre (Pakal Veedu) - implementing agency COSTFORD did not complete the work | 1-29 |
| 43 | Purchase of computer and printer required for the Assistant Engineer's office - not received till date though the amount was remitted | 1-30 |
| 44 | Asset mapping not completed | 1-31 |
| --- No records found --- | ||
| --- No records found --- | ||
| 1 | Utilisation of funds received for joint projects | 4-1 |
| 2 | Details of amount given for deposit works | 4-2 |
| 3 | Mobilisation advance given | 4-3 |
| 4 | Loan/loan repayment | 4-4 |
| 5 | Fixed Deposit | 4-5 |
| 6 | Audit Recovery | 4-6 |
| 7 | Details of charge/surcharge proceedings | 4-7 |
| 8 | Consolidated Audit Report | 4-8 |
| 9 | Audit Retrospect | 4-9 |
| 10 | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | 4-10 |
| 1 | Audit Certificate | |
| 2 | Utilisation Certificate of Grants | |
Part - 1
General Overview
1-1 Budget
| Date of passing | 20/02/2021 | |
| Committee Decision | 1(1) | |
| Anticipated receipts and expenditure | Receipts | Expenditure |
| 41,53,24,000 | 13,99,72,055 | |
| Revised Budget | ||
| Date of passing Committee Decision Revised Budget | 30-03-2022 | |
| Committee Decision | 1(1) | |
| Anticipated receipts and expenditure | Receipts | Expenditure |
| 41,75,24,000 | 41,52,50,000 | |
1-2 Annual Financial Statement
| Due date | Date of receipt |
| 31-07-2022 | 1.06.2022 |
1-3 Financial Analysis
| Opening Balance | 2,96,04,274 |
| Receipts | 15,25,84,644 |
| Total | 18,21,88,918 |
| Expenditure | 14,26,99,002 |
| Balance | 3,94,89,916 |
1-4 Utilisation of Funds
| Fund Head | O.B. | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | C.B |
| Development Fund - General | 0 | 2,23,65,654 | 2,23,65,654 | 2,21,00,599 | 2,65,055 |
| Development Fund - SCP | 0 | 1,45,38,067 | 1,45,38,067 | 1,42,02,333 | 3,35,734 |
| Development Fund - T.S.P (as per ACR) | 0 | 7,90,434 | 7,90,434 | 7,29,334 | 61,100 |
| Maintenance, Road (as per ACR) | 0 | 1,79,60,000 | 1,79,60,000 | 1,67,89,335 | 11,70,665 |
| Maintenance, Non-Road (as per ACR) | 0 | 1,09,02,707 | 1,09,02,707 | 56,88,816 | 52,13,891 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - Tied (as per ACR) | 0 | 1,09,99,385 | 1,09,99,385 | 17,56,794 | 92,42,591 |
| Central Finance Commission Grant - Untied (as per ACR) | 0 | 1,00,98,260 | 1,00,98,260 | 51,74,828 | 49,23,432 |
1-5 Plan Review
| Approval Received (Number) | Implemented (Number) | of completion Percentage | Approved Plan Estimate amount | Implemented Plan Expenditure amount | Scheme implemented of the amount Percentage |
| 209 | 170 | 81.34 | 17,56,70,480 | 10,34,60,362 | 58.89 |
1-6 MGNREGS
| Item | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance |
| Administrative expenses | 0 | 1214878 | 1214878 | 1214878 | 0 |
| Given directly to beneficiaries | 0 | 74354454 | 74354454 | 74354454 | 0 |
| Material cost | 0 | 23759668 | 23759668 | 23759668 | 0 |
| Total | 0 | 99329000 | 99329000 | 99329000 | 0 |
1-7 Welfare Pensions
| Name of Scheme | Of beneficiaries Number | Amount |
| Unemployment Wages | 0 | 0 |
| Agricultural Worker Pension | 216 | 1,27,42,700 |
| Widow Pension | 1899 | 2,90,37,600 |
| Old Age Pension | 3763 | 5,42,54,600 |
| Disability Pension | 507 | 78,52,900 |
| Aged above 50 years Pension for unmarried women | 243 | 36,89,200 |
| For daughters of widows Marriage assistance | 18 | 5,40,000 |
1-8 Cash Verification
Verification of cash balance as per Section 6(4) of the Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, was conducted on 18-01-2023 at 3:00 PM in the presence of the head of the institution/the officer responsible. On verification, the accuracy of the cash balance of Rs. 50945/- was confirmed.
1-9 Internal Control System
The vouchers and registers of the Grama Panchayat are maintained with more or less accuracy. However, in some registers the Secretary does not verify and certify them. The Annual Financial Statement has not been made available for audit examination within the stipulated time limit. The front office system is functioning in a satisfactory manner. A token system, display system, drinking water and seating facilities have been provided. An account for the Relief Fund in the name of the Secretary/President, for the period including the audit period, has not been opened. The monthly summary has not been recorded and kept in the log book of the Panchayat vehicle. A fuel efficiency test has not been conducted during the audit period. Many Implementing Officers do not maintain the TR.7A Cash Book (e.g. Assistant Engineer, Headmaster/Headmistress). Efficient involvement of working groups is not seen during the formulation, execution and completion of projects. Street lights have not been fully brought under the metering system. The urgent attention of the Governing Body is invited to make the internal control system efficient.
1-10-1 Basic ratios not included in the Annual Financial Statement
Basic ratios have not been included in the Annual Financial Statement (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 62(F)).
1-10-2 Property Tax - Residential (current year) - Demand register and annual accounts do not tally
The property tax demand amount obtained from the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the property tax demand register, is the one added as demand in "Sankhya", the software used for preparing the accounts. Collection of property tax, issue of receipts and preparation of the ledger are done using the "Sankhya" software. The receipt collection in this is automatically posted to the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the demand register of property tax. Since it is prepared in this manner, the amounts under demand, collection and balance as per the D.C.B register and as per the statements in the annual accounts should tally. However, the year-end summary amounts of property tax and library cess as per the D.C.B register prepared in the "Sanchaya" software do not tally with the amounts in the annual accounts prepared in the "Sankhya" software. In the above circumstances, the reason for the annual accounts and the D.C.B register not tallying should be found out and rectified.
10.2.1 Current Year
10.2.1.1 Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 27,64,078 | 23,96,173 | 30,575 | 3,55,296 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 27,64,078 | 23,96,173 | 6,399 | 3,55,296* |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule R.P-43) | (Ledger of 350410101-Advance collection-PT on Res. bldg) | *(373664 /105X100)= 3,55,870 (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A small difference in amount is treated as a rounding-off amount, and the amount in Sanchaya is adopted |
10.2.1.2 Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 40,38,170 | 36,36,356 | 22215 | 386173 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 40,38,170 | 36,36,356 | 3,901 | 386173* |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule R.P-43) | (Ledger of 350410104-Advance collection-PT on NR bldg) | *(405,587 /105X100)= 386273 (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A small difference in amount, considered as a round-off amount; the amount in Sanchaya is taken |
10.2.2 Arrears
10.2.2.1 Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 16,30,175 | 12,04,842 | 4,48,228 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 16,33,857 * | 11,97,175 | 4,50,339 |
| *(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 of 2020-21) (1158647+556903=1715550/105*100) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule R.P-43) | **(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) (472856/105X100) |
10.2.2.2 Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 29,24,957 | 1700610 | 12,26,693 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 29,67,870 | 1700610 | 12,27,123 |
| (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 of 2020-21) *(1838585+1277679=31,16,264/105*100) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule R.P-43) | **(1288479/105X100)= 1227122.85 (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) |
10.2.3 Library Cess (Current Year + Arrears)
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Demand reduced | Balance | ||||||||
| Current Year | Arrears | Total | Current Year | Arrears | Total | Current Year | Arrears | Total | ||||
| As per "Sanchaya" software | Residential | 141388 | 88315 | 229703 | 61637 | 122211 | 183848 | 1616 | 18368 | 24628 | 41673 | |
| Non-Residential | 202934 | 148039 | 350973 | 182681 | 85419 | 268100 | 1118 | 19414 | 61786 | 81019 | ||
| Total | 5,80,676 | 451948 | 2734 | 122692 | ||||||||
| In the annual accounts Various statements as per | 5,84,046 | 451948 | 451948 | 124196 | ||||||||
| 239724+141388+202934 = (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 of 2020-21, 431910101-State govt. Cess/levies...... Ledger 2021-22) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule R.P-36 (Receipts)) | (431910101-State govt. Cess/levies...... Ledger 2020-21 | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) | |||||||||
10.2.4. In the year-end summary amounts as per the D.C.B register of property tax and library cess prepared in the "Sanchaya" software, a discrepancy is seen to have crept into the calculation of the balance itself. The correct balance amount, as per the formula Demand - (Collection + Book Adjustment) = Balance, is not calculated in the software. (e.g.: the tables in paragraphs 2.1.1, 2.1.2, 2.2.1, 2.2.2, 2.3).
2.5 The amount received in advance under property tax and remaining to be adjusted as on 30/3/2019, entered under the head "Other liabilities" in Balance Sheet Schedule B-9, does not tally with the amounts entered under this head in the "Sanchaya" software.
| Sl. No. | Head | Amounts as per Balance Sheet Schedule B-9 | Amounts as per Sanchaya software |
| 1 | 350410101-Advance collection of revenues -Property tax on Residential building | 12,614 | 7,77,843 |
| 2 | 350410104-Advance collection of revenues -Property tax on Non-Residential building | 4,534 | 16,09,216 |
10.2.6 The property tax demand amount (residential/non-residential) of buildings existing as on 1/4/2021 should have been recorded as the demand amount at the beginning of the year, and accrual-based income, including property tax assessed in 2021-22, should have been entered through monthly demand journal entries on the basis of the summary statement prepared monthly by the Secretary, the assessment register, and the assessment/demand notice (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 17(2)). Demand reduction/write-off/grant of remission should also be done through journal entries, based on the same monthly summary statement prepared by the Secretary. This recording should be made on the basis of a journal voucher, worksheet and lawful sanction. In the year 2021-22, 246 new buildings were assessed to tax in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat. However, on examining the ledgers of the heads "110100101-Property tax on residential building" and "110100103-Property tax on non residential building" for 2021-22, it is seen that the demand for the financial year 2021-22 has been recorded as a single lump-sum entry only. There are also no vouchers validating these demand entries. It is clear from this that entries are being made by adjusting the amount in the annual accounts to the demand amount at the end of the year as per the "Sanchaya" software. As a result, remission, write-off, etc. permissible under law go unrecorded in the accounts. Steps should be taken to make entries at the very time the property tax demand arises as per law, in the manner prescribed in the Rules, to carry out monthly reconciliation with the registers so as to make the internal control system effective, and to maintain vouchers and connected records validating the demand entries.
10.2.7. The current year's property tax advance ledger account was examined. It is seen that of this, Rs. 9482 was not received as a receipt in cash or through bank, and that the advance amount was notionally increased through a journal voucher under the nominal account "Prior period items". No sub-vouchers, worksheets or procedures recording and validating the reason for such increase through a journal voucher have been maintained. Hence such a notional increase is not accepted in audit. Details of the voucher through which such an increase was made are given below.
10.2.7.1 Residential
| Journal Voucher | Date | Amount |
| 42100419 | 31.03.22 | 5,799 |
10.2.7.2 Non-Residential
| Journal Voucher | Date | Amount |
| 42100420 | 31.03.22 | 3683 |
10.2.8 As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-15, the total amount receivable under property tax (including 5% library cess) is Rs. 2540586. Accordingly, the amount that should appear in this same schedule under the head "431910101-State govt levies in property tax" is Rs. 120980 (2540586/105X5). However, an amount of Rs. 124196 has been entered under this head. The difference should be reconciled.
1-10-3 Accrual-based income - monthly demand journal entry not recorded
Accrual-based income assessed in 2021-22 should have been entered through monthly demand journal entries on the basis of the summary statement prepared monthly by the Secretary, the assessment register, and the assessment/demand notice (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 17(2)). Demand reduction/write-off/grant of remission should also be done through journal entries, based on the same monthly summary statement prepared by the Secretary. This recording should be made on the basis of a journal voucher, worksheet and lawful sanction. However, without the Secretary preparing the monthly statement and connected accounts in writing as above, details of income heads for which demand/demand reduction/write-off/grant of remission was done as a single lump-sum entry through journal entries are given below (details of property tax are given in paragraph 10.2.6).
| Sl. No. | Income head | Head under which demand is entered | Demand | Date recorded | Voucher |
| 1. | Rent from buildings | 130100101-Rent from Building | 27,64,078.00 | 01.04.2021 | 42100410 |
Steps should be taken to make accrual entries at the time the demand legally arises, in the manner prescribed under the Rules, and to maintain vouchers and connected records validating demand entries/reduction of demand/write-off/grant of remission.
1-10-4 Provision not recorded.
As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-15, there are arrears under property tax and under rent. However, tax and non-tax arrears have not been assessed on a year-wise basis, and the amount doubtful of recovery, as required under Government Order 152/2011/LSGD dated 26/7/2011 and the Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011 (Rule 58(4)H), has not been assessed and a provision has not been recorded in the Income & Expenditure Account.
1-10-5 280000000-Prior Period item - neither approved vouchers nor worksheets supporting the entries have been made available for audit
As per Income & Expenditure Account (I-18), for the amounts written off through journal vouchers, the amounts adjusted as income, and the correction entries in the following ledgers coming under the head "280000000-Prior Period item", neither approved vouchers nor worksheets supporting the entries have been made available for audit. Hence it has not been possible to ensure that the entries as per the ledgers listed below are lawful or accurate.
| Head (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-18) | As on 31/3/2022 Ledger Balance |
| 280100101-Prior period income -Property tax on residential buildings | 12,818 |
| 280100102-Prior period income -Profession Tax- Instituitions/Professionals/Traders | (-)2500 |
| 280100104-Prior period income-Property tax on non residential buildings | 33997 |
| 280200101-Prior period income-Rent from Building | 385095 |
| 280200401-Prior period income-Other income | (-)88,300 |
| 280800101-Prior period-Establishment expenses | (-)1,01,660 |
| 280800701-Prior period- Miscellaneous Expenses | 8,36,590 |
1-10-6 Journal vouchers should also be kept supported by authentic certified vouchers and worksheets
Transactions not connected with cash or bank/treasury accounts should be recorded in the Journal Book (Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules 2011, Rule 7). All vouchers, including journal vouchers, should be kept supported by authentic certified vouchers and worksheets. At present, journal entries are being recorded without any such control. No vouchers whatsoever are maintained for journal entries made mainly to write off and adjust collection, balance, advance, arrear demand, arrear collection and arrear balance under property tax, to manually reconcile to the amount in the D.C.B register as per the Sanchaya software, and to increase the advance amount. All journal vouchers should be kept supported by authentic certified vouchers and worksheets.
1-10-7 Cash Flow Statement - accuracy not certified in audit
Since the Cash Flow Statement submitted along with the annual accounts has the deficiencies set out below, its accuracy is not certified in audit
As per the Cash Flow Statement, the amount recorded as "Net increase in cash and cash equivalents" for the period 2021-22 is Rs. 98,85,642. However, in the same statement, the amount recorded as "Net cash generated by Operating+Investing+Financing Activity" for the period 2018-19 is Rs. 2,02,20,111. Although the above two amounts should tally as per accepted accounting standards, the two amounts in the statement submitted by the Panchayat do not tally.
1-10-8 Closing Stock
As per Balance Sheet Schedule B-14, there is a closing stock of Rs. 1,94,000. The year-end value of the stock is calculated and entered in the Stock Register. However, when items are taken into stock, only their quantity is recorded; the price is not recorded. Hence it is not possible to verify the accuracy of the year-end value calculated.
8.1 Physical verification of the stock has not been carried out and a certificate recorded (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 58, 4(A)).
1-10-9 No corresponding liability head in the Balance Sheet for special-purpose bank accounts
There is no liability head equivalent to the special-purpose bank accounts as per Balance Sheet Schedule B-17 set out below, seen in Balance Sheet B-4.
| Sl. No. | Head | Bank Account | Amount |
| 1 | 450220101 | KGB Life Donation | 35822 |
| 2 | 450220102 | KGB Jalanidhi | 26,075 |
1-10 Annual Accounts Verification
The irregularities noticed on verification of the annual accounts submitted by the Grama Panchayat for the year 2021-22 are set out below. The irregularities should be rectified and the matter reported to audit.
(Audit Enquiry No. 6/20.01.2023)
1-10-10 Stale cheques have not been transferred to the liability head "Liability in respect of stale cheque" to adjust the Bank Book balance.
The stale cheques listed below have not been transferred to the liability head "Liability in respect of stale cheque" to adjust the Bank Book balance (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules 2011 (Rule 46)). This should be rectified. Nationalised Bank - Canara Bank Own Fund (450210101) A/C.No.4667101002064, Pazhayannur Branch
| Voucher No. | Date | Cheque number | Date | Amount |
| 22100934 | 20.11.21 | 708154 | 18.11.21 | 9990 |
1-10-11 Capital work in progress - the accounts produced by the Assistant Engineer do not tally with the annual accounts
Among the projects implemented by the Assistant Engineer, the amount of works for which part bills were given up to 31/3/22 but which were not completed by 31/3/2022 is Rs. 15,43,532. However, as per the Balance Sheet Schedule as on 31/3/2019, the amount entered under the head Capital work in progress is Rs. 1,14,35,791. The reason for the discrepancy should be reported.
1-10-12 Amounts given as advance recorded in accounts as expenditure
It is seen that, instead of recording expenditure under the head "460500204-Advance to implementing Agencies" when advance is given to implementing agencies for the deposit works listed below, and recording expenditure under the respective expenditure/asset head only when the utilisation completion certificate is received from the agency, entries are made under the related expenditure/asset head at the very time the advance is given. Moreover, entries are not made in the Advance Register. Because of this, it becomes impossible to monitor the utilisation of advance amounts. Examples of such entries made are given below.
| Sl. No. | Project | Voucher number | Deposit amount | Head under which expenditure was recorded | Head under which expenditure should have been recorded |
| 1 | Expansion of solar plant at Panchayat Office - (ANERT) | 22100962/ 24.11.22 | 20,72,000 | 251620201 Energy Conservation - Non-Conventional Energy-General | 460500...-Advance to implementing Agencies- |
| 22100973/ 27.11.21 | 9,80,500 | ||||
| 2 | Completion of installation of Town CCTV (PWD Electronics) | 221001437/ 28.02.22 | 3,10,000 | 410710199 Movable Assets -Others |
Reply should be furnished to the irregularities.
1-10-13 Asset Register not updated.
The Asset Register has not been kept up to date. The Asset Register is not prepared in a manner that allows verification of the existence and value of the fixed assets mentioned in the Balance Sheet.
1-11 Irregularities in Profession Tax
I. Profession tax not collected from contractors
Every person who, residing within the Grama Panchayat area for not less than a total of 60 days in a half-year, is engaged, within or outside that area, in any profession, art or employment, or carries on business, or holds any public or private office, or is in receipt of any income from investments, is liable to pay profession tax (Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, Section 204).
Accordingly, maximum profession tax can be levied on registered contractors within the Grama Panchayat area. As per the profession tax demand register of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2021-22, profession tax has not been collected from contractors within the Grama Panchayat area. However, as per records obtained from the Engineering Wing of the Local Infrastructure Department, contractors are operating within the Panchayat area without remitting profession tax. Details thereof are given below.
| Sl. No. | Name of contractor | Profession tax to be collected |
| 1. | Abbas. K.K | 2500 |
| 2. | Anwar Hussain P.H | 2500 |
| 3. | Biju. M. Mathew | 2500 |
| 4. | Hakeem. N | 2500 |
| 5. | Hamsa. K.M | 2500 |
| 6. | Krishnadas P.K | 2500 |
| 7. | Muhammed Basheer K.A | 2500 |
| 8. | Prasad. T.N | 2500 |
| 9. | Rajan. C | 2500 |
| 10. | Rasheed. P.M | 2500 |
| 11. | Ravi. R | 2500 |
| 12. | Roy. K.M | 2500 |
| 13. | Shameer. K.M | 2500 |
| 14. | Surendran. R | 2500 |
| 15. | Sahad. N.M | 2500 |
| 16. | Siyad. S | 2500 |
| 17. | Ayoob. K.M | 2500 |
| 18. | Prakashan. K.V | 2500 |
| 19. | Babu. E | 2500 |
| 20. | Vavachan Joseph | 2500 |
| 21. | Suresh. K.S | 2500 |
| 22. | N.K Antony | 2500 |
| 23. | P.S Venkataramanan | 2500 |
| Total | 57500 | |
The amount should be collected from the above-mentioned contractors, or, if they have paid profession tax to other Local Self Government Institutions, copies thereof should be made available. Otherwise, no reply has been furnished to Audit Enquiry No. 03/21-22 dated 20.01.2023, which sought an explanation for not collecting profession tax from the said contractors. Hence profession tax should be collected from the said contractors under Section 204 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act and the Kerala State Audit Department informed.
II. Profession tax not correctly collected
Details of employees of various institutions, based on examination of the profession tax demand register for the financial year 2021-22, are given below.
| Name of institution | Financial Year | Half Year | Name of employee | 6 months' salary | Collected | Penalty that should have been levied |
| Milk Producers' Co-operative Society, Elanad | 2021-22 | II | Sindhu. R | 65080 | 450 | 600 |
| PNY Sabha Finance Limited | 2021-22 | II | Anu Baiju | 49800 | 300 | 450 |
| Pazhayannur Devaswom | 2021-22 | II | Subhash | 126720 | 1000 | 1250 |
| 2021-22 | II | Ajesh. K.U | 126216 | 600 | 1250 | |
| 2021-22 | II | Anoop Krishnan | 126720 | 1000 | 1250 |
.
On examination of the returns submitted by the said institutions for the financial year 2021-22, it is not seen that correct profession tax has been collected from the employees mentioned in the table above. No reply has been furnished to Audit Enquiry No. 4/21-22 dated 20.01.2023, which sought a reply on this. Hence the loss incurred in the collection of profession tax from the said employees should be assessed and recovered, and the matter reported to the Kerala State Audit Department.
III. Profession tax not collected from employees
a) On examining the profession tax demand register for the financial year 2021-22 and the applications submitted by institutions for FTEAOS licence, it is seen that although the institutions listed below have recorded, in their applications, the number of employees required for the institution to function, profession tax has not been demanded and collected from these employees. Hence, in reply to Audit Enquiry No. 5/21-22 dated 20.01.2023, which sought an explanation for not collecting profession tax from employees of the said institutions, a reply has been furnished stating that further action will be taken to collect profession tax from the employees of the said institutions. Hence profession tax should be collected from the employees of the said institutions under Section 204 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act and the Kerala State Audit Department informed. To prevent such lapses in future, when institutions apply for licence, the profession tax demand register may be prepared in accordance with the number of employees recorded in the application, profession tax demanded, and own income thereby increased.
| Sl. No. | Establishment | Number of employees |
| 1. | Butter Sponge | 6 |
| 2. | Cheerakuzhi Sawmill | 3 |
| 3. | Madeena Hollow Bricks | 3 |
| 4. | Sreevari Automotives | 8 |
| 5. | Hotel New Light Palace & Bakers | 8 |
| 6. | N.S Agencies | 4 |
| 7. | Fathima Modern Rice Mill | 9 |
| 8. | Sreeram Electricals | 3 |
| 9. | Janatha Fashion Jewellery | 3 |
| 10. | Vishal Fuels | 4 |
| 11. | Nila Metals | 15 |
| 12. | Great Motors | 10 |
| 13. | Best Hardware | 10 |
| 14. | Helio Industries | 5 |
| 15. | Punnakkathara Aqua Water Private Limited | 19 |
| 16. | Prestige Rock Products Private Limited | 40 |
B) On examining the profession tax demand register for the financial year 2021-22 and the statements submitted by institutions, it is seen that although profession tax has been demanded of employees of the institutions listed below, it was not found to have been collected from the said employees. Moreover, the profession tax return statements submitted by the heads of the said institutions are not available. Hence no reply has been furnished to Audit Enquiry No. 11/21-22 dated 23.01.2023, which sought an explanation, noting that the institutions are operating without a licence, for not collecting profession tax from employees of the said institutions. Hence profession tax may be collected from the employees of the said institutions and own income thereby increased. The details of the profession tax collected should also be reported to the Kerala State Audit Department.
| Sl. No. | Establishment | Financial Year |
| 1. | College of Technology, Kallepadam | I & II |
| 2. | Govt. Ayurveda Dispensary | II |
| 3. | Telephone Exchange, Elanad | I & II |
| 4. | Branch Post Office, Kallepadam | I & II |
| 5. | Branch Post Office, Kumbalakode | II |
| 6. | Branch Post Office, Elanad | I |
| 7. | Branch Post Office, Vennur | I & II |
| 8. | Milk Producers' Co-operative Society, Elanad | I |
| 9. | Canara (Bank), Pazhayannur | I |
| 10. | Navodaya Medicals | I & II |
| 11. | ICL Fincorp | II |
| 12. | BEWERNIC ENGLISH MEDIUM SCHOOL | II |
| 13. | Color Metal Coat | I & II |
| 14. | PERFECT EARTHINGS | II |
| 15. | Clearlac Paints | I |
| 16. | Ramla Supermarket | I & II |
| 17. | Milk Producers' Co-operative Society, Vadakkethara | I & II |
| 18. | Triveni Supermarket | I & II |
| 19. | Annapoorna Supermarket | I & II |
| 20. | Muthoot Finance Limited, Pazhayannur | I |
| 21. | ESAF Small Finance Bank, Pazhayannur | I |
| 22. | Police Station, Pazhayannur | I & II |
1-12 Farms operating without licence
As per Rule 3(1) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Livestock Farms) Rules, 2012, a licence from the Grama Panchayat under Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 is required to establish or run a livestock farm intended to keep more than the following number of animals or birds:
(i) Cattle farm : 5 animals
(ii) Goat farm : 20 animals
(iii) Pig farm : 5 animals
(iv) Rabbit farm : 25 animals
(v) Poultry farm : 100 birds
On verifying the Livestock Farm Register, it was found that a total of four livestock farms are operating with licences. However, on examining the various buildings and their usage patterns, property tax demand and collection in the Sanchaya software (Form 6), it was noticed that, apart from the licensed farms within the panchayat limits, other farms operating without a licence also exist. Details are furnished below.
| Sl. No. | Name of building owner | Building No. | Area (sq.m) | Usage pattern |
| 1. | Kunhumuhammed | 12/596 | 276 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 2. | Biju K. George | 15/300A | 239 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 3. | Abbas | 17/577A | 185 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 4. | Dileep K.M | 8/445 | 200 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 5. | Mathew | 10/405B | 207.93 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 10/405C | 207.93 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed | ||
| 6. | Shajahan | 10/205A | 385 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 7. | Varghese | 10/176A | 188.8 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - poultry shed |
| 8. . | Raghuvaran | 10/167A | 229.8 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed |
| 10/167B | 230.43 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed | ||
| 9. | Joseph V.K | 11/11A | 240 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed |
| 10. | Lakshmi and others | 11/30A | 192.5 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed |
| 11. | Antony Joseph | 11/157A | 82.1 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - livestock shed |
| 12. | Avira Pyli | 11/205A | 186 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed |
| 13. | Mathew Sebastian | 11/260B | 166 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed - livestock shed |
| 14. | Jiji Manuel | 11/495 B | 146.43 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed |
| 15. | 11/495C | 146.43 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed | |
| 16. | 11/495D | 146.43 | Those required for industrial purposes - handloom shed, coir-spinning shed -poultry shed |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.25/21-22, dated 25.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation as to why the above-mentioned livestock farms are operating illegally without a licence. Therefore, to prevent such lapses from recurring, field inspections shall be conducted at the ward level to identify farms operating illegally, and such farms shall either be made to obtain a licence, or, as per Rule 12 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Livestock Farms) Rules, 2012, such establishments operating in violation of the rules shall be punished with a fine not exceeding one thousand rupees, and, in the case of a continuing offence, an additional fine not exceeding fifty rupees for each day the offence continues shall be imposed.
1-13 Paramedical institutions/hospitals operating without registration and licence
I. Paramedical institutions operating without licence
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, no place shall be used for any purpose without a licence. Further, as per Sl. No.142 & 143 in Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, a panchayat licence is required for private hospitals and paramedical institutions respectively to operate within the panchayat limits. However, on examining the Registration Register of paramedical institutions and the FTEAOS licence register, it was found that though the following institutions have registered, they are operating without a licence. Therefore, an explanation
was sought for the said institutions operating without a licence, and no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.12/21-22, dated 23.01.2023) issued for this purpose. Therefore, follow-up action shall be taken in this regard and the Kerala State Audit Department shall be informed. To prevent such lapses in future, when paramedical institutions/private hospitals apply for renewal of registration, the institution concerned may be asked to submit an application for licence and pay the fee, and the licence may be granted along with registration of the institution.
1. Arul Clinical Laboratory
2. Arul Clinical Laboratory & Digital X-Ray
3. Palayakkathadathil Dental Clinic
4. Krupa Hi-Tech Laboratory, Elanad
5. Krupa Hi-Tech Laboratory, Vadakkethara
6. Matha Clinical Laboratory
7. Navodaya Medical Centre, Pazhayannur
8. Sudharma Speciality Laboratory
9. Pulse Holistic Healthcare & Rehabilitation, Vadakkethara
10. NSA Clinic
II. Paramedical institutions/hospitals operating without registration and licence
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, no place shall be used for any purpose without a licence. As per Sl. No.142 & 143 in Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, a panchayat licence is required for private hospitals and paramedical institutions respectively to operate within the panchayat limits. Further, under Section 270(1) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, no hospital or paramedical institution shall be established within the territorial area of a Grama Panchayat without prior registration with that Grama Panchayat. An establishment found guilty of operating a paramedical institution/private hospital within the panchayat limits without prior registration, or after cancellation of registration, shall be liable to be punished under Section 270(A) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 and Rule 8 of the Registration of Private Hospitals and Paramedical Institutions Rules, 1997, with a fine of up to five thousand rupees, and an additional fine of up to five hundred rupees for each day the offence continues. Although eight institutions had obtained licences during the financial year 2021-22, it was noticed during inspection that the following institutions, operating within a 400 m radius of the panchayat, are functioning without a licence and without prior registration.
1. Karunya Dental Clinic
2. Ambadees Confidential Care Dental Clinic
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.27/21-22, dated 25.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation as to why the said institutions are operating without prior registration and licence. Therefore, the said institutions shall be made to obtain registration and licence, and the Kerala State Audit Department shall be informed of the same.
1-14 Mobile towers falling into arrears of property tax
During the audit of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2021-22, on examining the Sanchaya software relating to property tax of buildings, it was found that 16 mobile towers are operating within the panchayat limits, and the owners of the following towers are in arrears of property tax payment.
| Sl. No. | Building No. | Owner | Basic property tax | Arrears |
| 1 | 4/255 | 7500 | 17061 | |
| 2. | 4/598 | Aircel | 9000 | 27900 |
| 3. | 9/163 | India Telecom Infra Ltd. | 5250 | 7086 |
| 4. | 14/535 | Reliance Communication Ltd. | 9000 | 37800 |
| Total | 89847 | |||
Since failure to properly collect property tax from mobile tower owners will result in a reduction of the panchayat's own income, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.14/21-22, dated 23.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation as to why the above-mentioned mobile towers are operating with arrears, along with a request to clarify who owns tower No. 4/255. Therefore, property tax arrears shall be collected from the mobile tower owners and the said information communicated to the Kerala State Audit Department.
1-15 Social security pension allowed even after death
On verifying, through the pension search facility on the Sevana website, the details of the report of deceased persons furnished by the Grama Panchayat for audit inspection, it was noticed that the following beneficiaries have had amounts credited to their pension accounts even after death, and that the accounts continue to remain active even after death. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.21/21-22, dated 24.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation as to why the accounts continue to remain active without being suspended after death, and why pension amounts were allowed to be credited to the accounts of the deceased even after death. Therefore, accounts that continue to remain active even after death shall be identified and steps taken to suspend them. Further, the amount allowed in excess after death shall be recovered and the Kerala State Audit Department shall be informed of the same.
| Sl. No. | Name of pensioner | Date of death | Pensioner ID | Type of pension | Present status | Period for which pension was allowed in excess | Amount allowed in excess |
| 1. | THANKAMMA VELAYUDHAN | 22.04.2021 | 107380200050 | Social Security Pension (Indira Gandhi National Old Age Pension) | ACTIVE (Amount credited to account) | 05/2021- 11/2022 | 30400 |
| 2. | VALLIYAMMA .I | 09.05.2021 | 107380201774 | Social Security Pension (Indira Gandhi National Old Age Pension) | ACTIVE (Amount credited to account) | 06/2021-11/2022 | 28800 |
| 3. | M.K RAVEENDRAN | 08.06.2021 | 107380200828 | Social Security Pension (Indira Gandhi National Old Age Pension) | ACTIVE (Amount credited to account) | 07/2021 – 11/2022 | 27200 |
| 4. | THANKAM RAMAN | 08.05.2021 | 107380600148 | Social Security Pension (Indira Gandhi National Widow Pension Scheme) | ACTIVE (Amount credited to account) | 06/2021 – 11/2022 | 28800 |
| Total | 115200/- | ||||||
1-16 Irregularities in the levy of property tax
As part of the audit, the New Building Register and related files were examined. It is seen that there are irregularities in the assessment of property tax for the following buildings.
I. Building No. 12/42E,42F,42G belonging to Sri. Badharudeen
Building No. 12/42E,F,G has been allotted to the building owned by Sri. Badharudeen. However, on examining the plan in the file relating to the allotment of number to the said building, it is seen that access to the building is from the 8-metre-wide Elanad-Chelakkara PWD Road. However, in the Sanchaya software, it has been recorded as a panchayat road of more than 1.5 metres width. As per Rule 6 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax, Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, rebates and increases based on various factors may be allowed on the basic property tax. Accordingly, if a road facility of more than 5 metres width exists, an additional increase of 20% may be levied on the property tax. However, no rebate or increase has been given to the said building for road facility. Further, the area through which the Elanad-Chelakkara Road passes falls within the primary zone. However, the said building has been included in the secondary zone and a rebate of 10% has been given. As per Rule 3(5) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax, Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, different parts of a building shall be treated as separate buildings, and separate property tax levied on each part, only if the different parts are used for the different usage patterns specified in sub-rule 1 of Rule 4. Section 203(9) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 stipulates that 'where, in the case of a building, two or more uses referred to in sub-section (2) or their sub-categories apply simultaneously, the property tax shall be assessed separately in the manner applicable to the respective part of the said building, and the total annual property tax of that building shall be determined accordingly.' Accordingly, a building used together for commercial purposes by a single building owner shall be assessed as one unit for tax purposes. That is, commercial buildings with a floor area exceeding 100 square metres, even if divided into small rooms, shall be assessed at the rate applicable to buildings with a floor area exceeding 100 square metres.
However, the area of the said numbered building is 147.58 (46.04+59.5+42.04) square metres. Accordingly, the said building ought to have been assessed for property tax by treating it as a commercial building with a floor area exceeding 100 square metres. However, property tax has been assessed by dividing the said building into 3 rooms and treating them as buildings with a floor area up to 100 sq. metres.
By granting the rebate in this manner, a total shortfall of Rs.5114 has occurred in the tax. The irregularities involved are furnished below.
| As currently collected - hotels, restaurants, shops, godowns for commercial purposes with floor area up to 100 sq. metres | |
| Area | 147.58 (46.04+59.5+42.04)m2 |
| Basic tax | 30 |
| Basic property tax | 4427.4 |
| Rebates (Secondary - 10%) | 442.74 |
| Increase | 0.0 |
| Annual property tax | 3984.66 |
| Library cess | 199.23 |
| Total tax amount | 4184/- |
| As ought to have been collected - hotels, restaurants, shops, godowns for commercial purposes with floor area above 100 sq. metres | |
| Area | 147.58 (46.04+59.5+42.04)m2 |
| Basic tax | 50 |
| Basic property tax | 7379 |
| Rebates | 0.00 |
| Increase (access road more than 5 metres - 20%) | 1475.8 |
| Annual property tax | 8854.8 |
| Library cess | 442.74 |
| Total tax amount | Rs.9298 |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.20/21-22, dated 24.01.2023) issued pointing out the above irregularity. Therefore, the property tax of the said building shall be reassessed after making the necessary changes in Sanchaya, and the amount collected along with arrears, and the Kerala State Audit Department informed of the same. Further, since irregularities in the assessment of property tax will affect own income, care shall be taken to prevent such lapses in future.
II. Different widths recorded for the same road
Numbers have been allotted during the financial year 2021-22 to building No. 4/437A owned by Smt. Geetha and building No. 4/458A owned by Sri. Shaji U. & Smt. Shamlath P.A. As per the plans submitted for numbering, both buildings are situated on the same road; however, in Sanchaya, the same road has been recorded under different names. Details are furnished below.
| Sl. No. | Owner | Building No. | Road as per Sanchaya | Width of road | Change in property tax |
| 1. | Geetha | 4/437A | Pazhayannur School Road | More than 1.5 metres | No increase or rebate |
| 2. | Shaji U. & Shamlath P.A | 4/458A | High School Road | 5 metres or more | 20% increase |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.20/21-22, dated 24.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation for the irregularities occurring in the assessment of property tax due to recording of differently named roads in Sanchaya for buildings situated on the same road. Therefore, the road on which building No. 4/437A is situated shall be properly ascertained, and if its width is above 5 metres, an increase of 20% shall be made in the property tax.
1-17 Levy of licence fee - Government Order to be complied with
As per G.O.(P) No.80/2017/LSGD dated 31.10.2017 of the Local Self Government Department, amendments have been issued to the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Dangerous and Offensive Trades and Factories) Rules, 1996. Accordingly, in Table-II of Rule 10, the maximum fee leviable for various trades, which had been fixed on the basis of daily turnover, has been replaced by classifying establishments into various tiers - micro, mini, small, medium and large enterprises - based on capital investment, with the maximum leviable fee fixed accordingly. As per Rule 7, the Grama Panchayat may levy an amount not exceeding that specified in Table-II. As per the said amendment, establishments with capital investment not exceeding Rs.25 lakh in the manufacturing sector and Rs.10 lakh in the service sector are classified as micro enterprises, for which the maximum annual licence fee leviable has been fixed at Rs.500. Similarly, establishments classified as mini, small, medium and large enterprises based on capital investment are subject to a maximum licence fee of Rs.1000, 5000, 10000 and 15000 respectively. However, on examining the panchayat's licence register and the applications submitted by owners, it was found that the amount collected as licence fee is not in accordance with the aforesaid order. For instance, details of establishments in the service sector with turnover below Rs.10 lakh are furnished below. Although the capital investment of all these establishments was below Rs.10 lakh, different amounts have been collected as licence fee. Therefore, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.7/21-22, dated 21.12.2022) issued seeking production of the Grama Panchayat Governing Body's decision, if any, to levy licence fee on the basis of G.O.(P) No.80/2017/LSGD dated 31.10.2017, and, if no such decision has been taken, seeking clarification of the basis on which licence fee is being collected from establishments within the panchayat limits. Therefore, the fee shall be fixed and collected in accordance with the Government Order.
| Sl. No. | Establishment | Licence fee |
| 1. | Ismail Vaidyasala | 200 |
| 2. | Amma Engineering Works | 500 |
| 3. | Haroon Duty Paid Shop | 200 |
| 4. | Hotel New Light Palace & Bakes | 300 |
1-18 Irregularities in shopping complex rent
I. Rooms let out on rent without entering into a rent agreement
The details as per examination of the shopping complex rent register and the rent agreements executed with tenants, produced for audit for the year 2021-22, are furnished below.
| Shopping complex | Rooms let out on rent | Number of those who have executed agreements | Those who have not executed agreements |
| Bus Stand Shopping Complex | 36 | 8 | 28 |
| Mini Shopping Complex | 13 | 0 | 13 |
| Ambalanada Shopping Complex | 21 | 1 | 20 |
Since the very legal validity of any action taken against a tenant of a room let out without executing an agreement would be called into question, an explanation shall be furnished as to why most of the rooms in the shopping complexes under the panchayat's control have been let out on rent without entering into rent agreements. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.28/21-22, dated 25.01.2023) issued for this purpose. Loss is being caused to the State Government due to non-execution of agreements on stamp paper of the prescribed value. Therefore, rent agreements shall be entered into every financial year with those to whom rooms have been let out on rent.
II. Rooms in shopping complexes lying vacant
Rooms in various shopping complexes of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat are lying vacant. Details are furnished below.
| Shopping complex | Total rooms | Vacant rooms |
| Bus Stand Shopping Complex | 36 | 8 |
| Mini Shopping Complex | 13 | 0 |
| Ambalanada Shopping Complex | 21 | 1 |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.28/21-22, dated 25.01.2023) issued seeking clarification as to whether any steps have been taken to let out the above vacant rooms on rent. Therefore, steps shall be taken to let out the vacant rooms on rent in order to increase revenue.
1-19 Establishments operating without licence for factories, trades and enterprises
I. Ration shops operating without licence
As per Section 232 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, no place shall be used for any purpose without a licence. Further, as per Sl. No.149 in Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, a panchayat licence is required for ration shops to operate within the panchayat limits. However, on examining the FTEAOS licence register for the financial year 2021-22, it was found that none of the ration shops have obtained a licence. Therefore, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.10/21-22, dated 23.01.2023) issued seeking information on the total number of ration shops operating in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, along with an explanation as to why they are operating without a licence. Therefore, field inspection shall be conducted to ascertain the number of ration shops within the panchayat limits, and licences got obtained on that basis. The information shall be communicated to the Kerala State Audit Department after the licences have been obtained.
II. Abkari (toddy) shops operating without licence
As per Sl. No.139 in Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, a panchayat licence is required for abkari (toddy) shops to operate within the panchayat limits. As per the Profession Tax Demand Register, the following abkari shops have paid profession tax for the financial year 2021-22. However, none of these abkari shops have obtained a licence. Therefore, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.10/21-22, dated 23.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation as to why these abkari shops are operating without a licence from the panchayat. Therefore, the following abkari shops shall be made to obtain a licence and the information communicated to the Kerala State Audit Department.
1. Toddy Shop TS No.10
2. Toddy Shop TS No.12
3. Toddy Shop TS No.13
4. Toddy Shop TS No.14
5. Toddy Shop TS No.15
6. Toddy Shop TS No.16
7. Toddy Shop TS No.24
8. Toddy Shop TS No.28
9. Toddy Shop TS No.29
10. Toddy Shop TS No.30
III. Persons who have taken shopping complex rooms on rent are operating without licence
On examining the rent register of the panchayat shopping complexes and the FTEAOS licence register produced for audit, it was found that out of a total of 81 rooms in the Bus Stand Shopping Complex, Mini Shopping Complex and Ambalanada Shopping Complex, 70 rooms had been let out on rent during the financial year 2021-22. Of these, only the tenants of 22 rooms have obtained a licence to operate. Therefore, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.29/21-22, dated 25.01.2023) issued seeking an explanation as to why tenants of buildings under the panchayat's control are operating establishments without obtaining a licence. Therefore, the said establishments shall be made to obtain a licence and the information communicated to the Kerala State Audit Department. It is evident that the panchayat is not paying attention to taking action under the KRR Rules against establishments operating in violation of the rules. Brought to the notice of the Standing Committee for Finance.
IV. Meat shops operating without licence
As per Sl. No.130 in Table I of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Licensing of Factories, Trades, Entrepreneurial Activities and Other Services) Rules, 1996, a panchayat licence is required for poultry, pig and goat storage/marketing shops to operate within the panchayat limits. On examining the FTEAOS licence register for the financial year 2021-22, it was found that none of the meat marketing shops have obtained the licence required to operate. However, inspection revealed that the following establishments are operating within a 600 m radius of the panchayat.
1. Bismilla Chicken Shop
2. P.S Chicken Centre
3. M.S Chicken Centre
If three meat marketing establishments are operating within a radius of just 600 m, it is evident that, apart from the above three establishments, numerous meat marketing shops are operating illegally without a licence in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, which comprises 22 wards. Therefore, no reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (Audit Enquiry No.26/21-22, dated 25.01.2023) issued seeking information on the total number of poultry, pig and goat storage/marketing shops operating within Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, along with an explanation as to why they are operating without a licence. Therefore, the above-mentioned establishments shall be made to obtain a licence and the said information communicated to the Kerala State Audit Department. Further, the number of meat marketing shops operating within the Grama Panchayat limits shall be ascertained through field inspection, and they shall be made to obtain licences so as to increase revenue. The above matters make it clear that the panchayat is lapsing in the implementation of laws and rules. The urgent attention of the Standing Committee for Finance is invited.
1-20 Medicines not received
Project No: 95/21-22-
Name: Palliative Care
Bill No: 283/21.3.22 Amount: Rs.40,000/-
Bill No: 287/21.3.22 Amount: Rs.1,38,260/-
Implementing Officer: Medical Officer (PHC)
As per the above bills, Rs.1,78,260/- has been paid to KMSCL for purchase of medicines. Of this, medicines worth Rs.91,810/- as per Proforma Invoice No.7244 and medicines worth Rs.30,870/- as per Proforma Invoice No.6698 have been received. Audit Enquiry 16/24.1.22 was issued seeking information as to whether the remaining medicines had been received. In reply, it was stated that intimation would be given once medicines worth Rs.55,580/- are received. Therefore, audit shall be informed as and when the medicines are received.
1-21 Computer, printer not received to date though the amount has been remitted
Project No: 247/21-22
Name: Purchase of computer, printer for Ayurveda Dispensary
Bill No: 3/21-22 Amount: Rs.39,797/-
Implementing Officer: Medical Officer (Ayurveda)
As per the above bill, Rs.39,797/- has been paid to Keltron for purchase of computer, printer for the Ayurveda Dispensary. It has not been received to date. Audit Enquiry 7/21.1.23 was issued in this regard. No reply has been furnished to it. Therefore, the computer and printer shall be taken into stock as and when received, and audit informed.
1-22 Cots received from Artco not distributed to beneficiaries
1. Project No: 74/21-22
Name: Cot for elderly persons (SC)
Bill No: 24/21-22 dt. 30.3.22 Amount: Rs.1,87,875/-
Bill No: 25/21-22 dt. 30.3.22 Amount: Rs.33,491/-
Bill No: 2/22-23 dt. 20.7.22 Amount: Rs.50,009/-
Implementing Officer: Assistant Secretary
As per the above project, Rs.2,71,375/- has been paid to Artco during the financial years 2021-22 and 2022-23. 65 cots have been received under the above scheme. As per the receipt register, 84 beneficiaries have received cots. It could be seen that 4 cots and 9 cot legs are kept in the Grama Panchayat. Audit Enquiry 30/25.1.23 was issued in this regard, but no reply was furnished. As per the receipt register, 35 cots appear to be due for distribution for the financial year 2020-21. The 84 beneficiaries included in the beneficiary list for the financial year 2021-22 are the ones who have received cots. Some beneficiaries have received cots twice. Of the total cots distributed, only 4 remain undistributed. As per the beneficiary list, all 84 persons have received cots; the receipt of 12 beneficiaries has not been recorded in the receipt register. Of the 100 cots received over the financial years 2021-22 and 2022-23, 84 cots have been distributed and 4 cots remain undistributed. Of the total 100 cots received, 65 were under the scheme for the financial year 2021-22 and 35 under the scheme for the financial year 2020-21. All 84 beneficiaries belong to the financial year 2021-22. It is not clear whether cots have been given to the 35 persons who were not given cots in the financial year 2020-21. The invoice bill or other records for the receipt of the 35 cots from Artco under the scheme for the financial year 2020-21 have not been produced for audit inspection. The receipt of 12 beneficiaries has not been recorded in the receipt register. Therefore, the cot distribution register shall be set right, and the remaining cots distributed at the earliest.
2. Under Project No: 75/21-22 - Marriage Assistance for SC Girls - implemented by the Assistant Secretary, Rs.75,000/- each has been disbursed to 19 beneficiaries. Copies of the passbook/UTR statement evidencing receipt of the amount by the beneficiary have not been obtained and kept on file. These shall be produced for verification.
1-23 Irregularities in projects implemented by the V.E.O
1. The following documents have not been obtained and kept on file for projects implemented by the V.E.O
| Sl. | Project No. | Name of project | Certificates |
| 1 | 71/21-22 | Study room for SC students | 1. Certificate that benefit is not available from the Scheduled Castes Department 2. Certificate that benefit is not available from the District Panchayat and Grama Panchayat |
| 2 | 70/21-22 | Making uninhabitable houses habitable (SC) | 1. Certificate that benefit is not available from the Scheduled Castes Department 2. Certificate that benefit is not available from the District Panchayat and Grama Panchayat |
| 3 | 93/21-22 | Study room for ST students | 1. Certificate that benefit is not available from the Scheduled Tribes Department 2. Certificate that benefit is not available from the District Panchayat and Grama Panchayat |
Audit Enquiry No. 8/21.1.23 was issued in this regard, but no reply has been received. Hence, steps should be taken to produce the necessary records for verification.
2. Project No.70/21-22 - Making Uninhabitable Houses Habitable (SC) - Under this scheme, benefit was sanctioned to 2 beneficiaries before their houses completed 8 years of age
| Sl. | Name of beneficiary | Building No. | Age of building | Amount allotted |
| 1 | Vesha, Chakkandi | 7/85A | Age one year | 75,000/- |
| 2. | Lakshmi Rajan, Kakkarakunnu | 22/22A | Age five years | 75,000/- |
Audit Enquiry No. 8/21.1.23 was issued in this regard, but no reply has been received. Care should be taken to select beneficiaries and grant benefits only in compliance with the norms.
1-24 Installation of Surveillance Cameras in Pazhayannur Town - Though the amount was remitted to the implementing agency years ago, the work has not been completed
As per Government Order (Ordinary) No.1695/2019/LSGD of the Local Self Government Department dated 07-08-19, special permission had been granted to utilise the Own Fund to install CCTV cameras in Pazhayannur town in order to avoid the waste problem and to ensure women's safety. In the project 'Installation of Surveillance Cameras in Pazhayannur Town' (Project No.172/20), with the Secretary as the Implementing Officer, on the basis of Estimate No. EDT1172/18 for Rs.25,60,000/- prepared and furnished on 23-10-18 by the Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur
Sl. No. | Voucher No. & Date | Amount | Fund details |
| 1 | 21900617/16.08.19 | 9,00,000 | Own Fund |
| 2 | 21900843/01.10.19 | 9,00,000 | Own Fund |
| 3 | 21900871/04.10.19 | 7,60,000 | Own Fund |
As tabulated above, a total of Rs.25,60,000/- and, in 2021-22, under Project No.111/22 'Completion of Town CCTV Installation', a further Rs.3,10,000/- vide Voucher No.22101437/28-02-22 have been remitted to the Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur. However, the utilisation/completion certificate for the completed project has not been produced for verification to date. The Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur should be requested to take necessary steps to complete the execution of the project at the earliest, and further information should be reported to Audit.
1-25 Utilisation/completion certificates of projects with the Secretary as Implementing Officer not produced for verification
The utilisation/completion certificates of the following projects with the Grama Panchayat Secretary as Implementing Officer should be produced for verification.
| Sl. No | Project details | Voucher number | Amount (₹) | Fund details | Implementing Agency |
| 1 | 2/22 Remittance of IKM share | 22101109/ 29-07-21 | 1,06,620 | Development Fund (General category) | Information Kerala Mission |
| 2 | 111/22 Completion of Town CCTV Installation | 22101437/ 28-02-22 | 3,10,000 | Own Fund | Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics, Thrissur |
The utilisation/completion certificates of the projects should be obtained from the implementing agencies and made available to Audit.
(Audit Enquiry No.19/24-01-23)
1-26 National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme
Details regarding the implementation of the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme for the year 2021-22 are given below.
| 1 | Number of schemes envisaged in the year 2021-22 | 2387 | ||
| 2 | Value of schemes envisaged in the year 2021-22 | 64,28,87,800 | ||
| 3 | Number of schemes completed in the year 2021-22 | 216 | ||
| 4 | Value of schemes completed in the year 2021-22 | 9,81,14,122 | ||
| 5 | Number of job cards issued under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 7,867 | ||
| 6 | Employment days generated in the year 2021-22 | 2,54,181 | ||
| Female | Male | Total | ||
| 2,40,432 | 13,749 | 2,541,81 | ||
| Scheduled Caste | Scheduled Tribe | Others | Total | |
| 73,877 | 1,926 | 1,78,378 | 2,54,181 | |
| 11 | Number of households provided employment in the year 2021-22 | 4,526 | ||
| 12 | Number of households that completed 100 days of employment in the year 2021-22 | 852 | ||
| 13 | Details of unemployment wages disbursed in the year 2021-22 under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | None | ||
| 14 | Wages disbursed in the year 2021-22 under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 7,39,94,327 | ||
| 15 | Wages in arrears for disbursement as on 31-03-2022 under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | None | ||
| 16 | Details of convergence/joint projects (convergence schemes) implemented in cooperation with other sections of the Grama Panchayat in the year 2021-22 (Number) | None | ||
| 17 | Details of convergence/joint projects (convergence schemes) implemented in cooperation with other sections of the Grama Panchayat in the year 2021-22 (Value) | None | ||
| Details regarding the schemes of 2021-22 | ||||
| Sl. No. | Category of projects | Number of projects implemented | Amount spent | |
| 1 | Creation of public assets | 23 | 76,48,984 | |
| 2 | Drought proofing, afforestation | 112 | 3,42,203,53 | |
| 3 | Renovation of traditional water bodies | 15 | 15,19,916 | |
| 4 | Land development | 118 | 3,41,91,533 | |
| 5 | Creation of assets implemented for individual beneficiaries | 126 | 81,45,655 | |
Steps should be taken to undertake and implement more schemes for the creation of public assets.
(Audit Enquiry No.9/23.01.23)
1-27 Irregularities in various schemes implemented by the Agricultural Officer.
The following irregularities are found in the various schemes implemented by the Agricultural Officer during the year 2021-22 - distribution statements, UTR statements and applications not produced,
certificates not produced, and other similar irregularities. Details are given below.
a) Promotion of banana cultivation - SO49/22.
Vr.No.22101728. Dtd.17.3.22. 194800/ -
Under the above project, an amount of Rs.194800/- has been disbursed as 50% subsidy to 47 beneficiaries for the purchase of chemical fertilizer. However, neither the copy of the bank passbook of the concerned beneficiaries nor the UTR statement has been produced for verification.
b) Kedaram - Comprehensive Coconut Cultivation Development. SO50/22.
Vr. No.22101158. Dtd.29.11.21. 200000/ -
Vr.No. 22101158. dtd.27.1.22. 130000/ -
Under the above project, an amount of Rs.200000/- has been given as subsidy to 92 beneficiaries under the scheme 'Comprehensive Coconut Cultivation Development' towards purchase of manure. However, the copy of the bank passbook and the UTR statement of the concerned beneficiaries have not been produced. As per Vr.No.22101158, an amount of Rs.130000/- has been paid. However, even the applications of the beneficiaries have not been produced for verification. Since the applications and the UTR statement have not been produced, an amount of Rs.130000/- is held under objection.
c) Subhiksha Keralam - Paddy Cultivation on Fallow Land. SO51/22.
Vr.No.22101312. Dtd. 30.12.21. 105200/ -
Benefit has been given to 11 beneficiaries under the above project. However, the copy of the bank passbook and the UTR statement of the concerned beneficiaries have not been produced for verification. As per paragraph 2-2.1 of Order (Ordinary) No.1009/2020/LSGD (DA) of the Local Self Government (DA) Department dated 29.5.20, land on which no agricultural operations have been carried out for more than three years should be treated as fallow land, and this has to be certified by the concerned Agricultural Officer. However, no such certification has been recorded by the Agricultural Officer as found in the verification of the project. Until the irregularities stated above are rectified, the expenditure amount of Rs.105200/- is held under objection in audit.
d) One Crore Fruit Sapling Distribution. SO198/22.
Vr.No.22101664.dtd. 30.3.22. 152130/ -
Under the project 'One Crore Fruit Sapling Distribution', a total amount of Rs.152130/- has been spent on purchase and distribution of various fruit saplings, including Rs.9000/- to the Cashew Research Station, Rs.114750/- to Professor & Head, Rs.3750/- to District I-Farm, Chelakkara, Rs.18600/- to Pazhayannur Block Agro Service Centre, Panjal, and Rs.6030/- to the Fruit Crops Research Station. All the fruit saplings have been taken into stock in bulk. However, the distribution statement showing that they were given to the beneficiaries has not been produced for verification. Until the distribution statement of the fruit saplings, as per the stock register, showing their distribution is produced, the expenditure amount of Rs.152130/- is held under objection in audit.
e) Comprehensive Vegetable Development (Women) - SO47/22.
Vr.No.22101313. Dtd. 30.12.21. 150000/ -
Vr.No.22101566. Dtd. 23.2.22. 150000/ -
Vr.No.22101727. Dtd. 17.3.22. 200000/ -
Under the above project, a total of Rs.150000/- has been paid to 77 beneficiaries under wage expenditure. However, the UTR statement and copy of the bank passbook have not been produced. An amount of Rs.350000/- has been spent on purchase of various vegetable seeds from VFPCK SPP. Although the seeds purchased have been taken into stock, the distribution statement showing distribution to the actual beneficiaries has not been produced. Until the records showing distribution as per the actual stock, along with the distribution statement, are produced, the expenditure amount of Rs.350000/- is held under objection.
f) Comprehensive Vegetable Development (General) - SO46/22.
Vr.No.22101311.dtd. 30.1.22. 300000/ -
Vr.No. 22101565. dtd. 23.2.22. 300000/ -
Under the above project, Rs.300000/- has been spent for seed distribution and Rs.300000/- has been spent under wage expenditure. Under wage expenditure, the amount has been transferred to the bank accounts of 139 beneficiaries. However, the UTR statement and copy of the bank passbook of the beneficiaries have not been produced. An amount of Rs.255000/- has been transferred to the bank account of the Professor & Head, and Rs.45000/- to the Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Thrissur, towards purchase of various vegetable seeds. However, the distribution statement showing distribution of the seeds has not been produced for verification. In the absence of the distribution statement, the expenditure amount of Rs.300000/- is held under objection.
g) Comprehensive Vegetable Development - SO168/22 (Block Share)
Vr.No.2210143. Dtd. 6.11.21. 405890/ -
Under the above project, the benefit under wage expenditure has been transferred to the bank accounts of the concerned 189 beneficiaries. However, the UTR statement and copy of the bank passbook have not been produced for verification. These should be produced.
h) Comprehensive Vegetable Development - SO170/22 (Spill Over) Block Share.
Vr.No.22101141. Dtd.5.11.21. 369150/ -
Vr.No.22101139. Dtd. 5.11.21. 416475/ -
Vr.No.22101140. Dtd. 5.11.21. 403050/ Vr.No. 22101142.dtd. 5.11.21. 311325/ -
Under the above project, an amount of Rs.15 lakh has been spent to pay wages to 853 beneficiaries, and the amount has been transferred to the accounts of the concerned beneficiaries. However, the UTR statement and copy of the bank passbook thereof have not been produced. These should be produced.
i) Comprehensive Paddy Cultivation Development - SO48/22.
Vr.No.22101130. Dtd. 8.10.21. 760650/- (Seed distribution)
Vr.No. 22101157. dtd. 29.10.21. 224100/- (Seed distribution)
Vr.No. 22101393. dtd. 27.1.22. 258300/- (Seed distribution)
Vr.No. 22101395. dtd.29.1.22. 418125/- (Wage expenditure)
Vr.No. 22101563. dtd. 23.2.22. 440808/- (Wage expenditure)
Vr.No. 22101725. dtd.17.3.22. 278929/- (Wage expenditure)
Vr.No. 22101721. dtd.17.3.22. 362138/- (Wage expenditure)
Under the above project, the amount has been spent on seed distribution and payment of wage expenditure. Under wage expenditure, Rs.15 lakh has been transferred to the bank accounts of the concerned 820 persons. Neither the UTR statement nor the copy of the bank passbook has been produced for verification. A total amount of Rs.760650/- has been spent, including Rs.608400/- towards purchase of various varieties of paddy seeds from the Assistant Director of Agriculture, Pazhayannur, and Rs.152250/- towards purchase of various varieties of paddy seeds by Professor & Head, ARS, Mannuthy. An amount of Rs.258300/- has been spent towards purchase of various varieties of paddy seeds from the National Seeds Corporation Limited. As per Voucher No.22101157, dtd.29.10.21, Rs.224100/- has been paid towards purchase of seeds (Rs.179100/- towards purchase of paddy seeds from ADA Pazhayannur and Rs.45000/- from National Seeds Corporation). Although the seeds purchased have been taken into stock, since the distribution statement showing distribution to the actual beneficiaries has not been produced, the amount of Rs.1243050/- spent under this head is held under objection in audit (760650*224100*258300 =1243050). The distribution statement and the UTR statement should be produced for verification.
1-28 Excess Amount Paid to Electrical Engineer for Preparation of Estimate and Supervision
As per Government Order (Ordinary) No. 2878/2015/LSGD dated 22.09.2015, it has been clarified that four percent of the estimate amount can be allowed as remuneration to the Electrical Engineer for preparation of estimates and supervision of the electrical works of Grama Panchayats. Paragraph 6 of Circular No.18/2019/fin dated 01.03.2019 of the Finance (Industries & Public Works-B) Department has clarified that, for this purpose, the amount excluding GST is to be considered as the estimate amount. However, in the following projects with the Assistant Engineer as Implementing Officer, excess amount has been paid to the Electrical Engineer for preparation of estimate and supervision, in violation of the circular. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Details of the project | Technical sanction number | Estimate amount of the work (excluding GST compensation) | Estimate to the Electrical Engineer for preparation and supervision | Voucher No./Date | ||
| Amount payable | Amount paid | Amount paid in excess | |||||
| 1 | 204/22 Electrification of 'Take a Break' Rest Centre | 52/EE/LSGD/Electrical Committee/2020-21 dt.04-08-21 | 120030 | 4801 | 5377 | 576 | Payment Voucher No.22101447/22-02-2022 (Central Finance Commission Award) |
The amount should be recovered back from Mr. N.T. Baby, the Engineer who carried out the supervision of the work, credited to the concerned account, and the information reported to Audit.
(Audit Enquiry No.31/25.01.23)
1-29 Construction of Day Care Home - Implementing Agency COSTFORD Did Not Complete the Work
Under the scheme 'Day Care Home Construction for the Elderly', taken up under the Grama Panchayat's plan for the year 2017-18 with the Assistant Engineer as Implementing Officer and being implemented through COSTFORD, an amount of Rs.1,89,476/- has been remitted in the audit year under Project No.157/22 'Day Care Home Construction for the Elderly' vide Voucher No.22101165/04-12-22; Rs.3,00,000/- under Project No.120/18 vide Voucher No.21701676/31.03.2018 for the same work in the year 2017-18; and Rs.3,00,000/- under Project No.206/20 vide Voucher No.21901667/08.11.19 in the year 2019-20 - a total of Rs.7,89,476/- has thus been transferred to COSTFORD.
In a letter dated 09.04.2021, the Grama Panchayat President wrote to the District Collector requesting that a directive be given to COSTFORD to complete the Day Care Home for the elderly. As per a letter dated 22.07.2021 from the Assistant Engineer to COSTFORD, it was communicated that the work begun in the year 2017-18 had not been completed to date, and COSTFORD was asked to complete it and submit the final bill. In a letter dated 14.01.2021 from the Assistant Engineer to the Grama Panchayat Secretary, it was communicated that COSTFORD had not taken any steps to complete the scheme.
As per Decision No. 2(10) dated 15-01-2022 of the Grama Panchayat Governing Body, it has been decided as follows: "COSTFORD has not, to date, completed the scheme 'Day Care Home Construction for the Elderly', taken up under Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat's plan for the year 2017-18 and being implemented through COSTFORD. Hence, the meeting assessed that this scheme cannot continue as a spillover into the next financial year as well. On this basis, it was decided to entrust the Assistant Engineer, LSGD, with the responsibility of paying the bill amount for the works done by COSTFORD to date and completing the remaining works."
On the basis of the decision to remove COSTFORD, the implementing agency that had defaulted in completing the work in time, from the implementation of the scheme, and to entrust the Assistant Engineer with the completion of the scheme, an estimate of Rs.5,00,000/- was prepared for completing the remaining works of the said building, namely construction of toilet wall, remaining plastering, construction of window shutters, laying of floor tiles, installation of sanitary fittings, construction of handrail and grill, and painting work, and technical sanction was obtained for the same as No. 93445/2021-22 dated 15-03-22. As per the decision of the Grama Panchayat Steering Committee meeting held on 18.03.22, the work was awarded by tender to the contractor Mr. Krishnadas P.K., and an agreement numbered 18/AE/LSGD/PZR/21-22 was signed on 31.03.22 for execution of the work. The work was completed on 06.05.22, and a total of Rs.4,98,581/- was spent for this in the year 2022-23.
No reply has been given to Audit Enquiry No.23 dated 25.01.23, which had asked for the details of the action taken against the implementing agency COSTFORD, which had taken up the work on 23.03.2018 (Agreement No.66(A)AE/LSGD/PZR/2017-18 dt.23.03.2018) but had not completed the work even after a period of four years, to be produced for verification.
On examination of the file relating to the work, it was found that the agreement document between the implementing agency and the Grama Panchayat Assistant Engineer, as kept in the file, is one that has not been signed by the Grama Panchayat Assistant Engineer. The agreement also does not incorporate any provision for recovering, from the implementing agency, any loss arising from a default by the implementing agency in the execution of the work. This itself makes it clear that the above agreement does not serve to safeguard the interests of the Grama Panchayat. Care should be taken to ensure that such a lapse does not recur when drawing up agreements with implementing agencies in future.
Under Development Fund (General category), amounts lapsed unspent as follows: Rs.60,22,165/- in 2018-19, Rs.35,43,361/- in 2019-20, Rs.5,30,109/- in 2020-21, and Rs.2,65,055/- in 2021-22. It is in such a situation that, even though the work undertaken has not been completed even after four years, and even though the amount required for the scheme was included in the plan outlay, the amount could not be released to the implementing agency, resulting in a situation where the amount available under Development Fund (General category) lapsed for the Grama Panchayat, and the work was dragged on till the year 2022-23. Because the work was not completed, the amount that could have been utilised for other development activities during these four years was instead set apart for this work every year, and its loss at the end of each year has operated against the development interests of the Grama Panchayat. As per Kerala Public Works Manual, Para 2116.1, if a contract is terminated due to the default of the contractor, the resulting loss and damage may be recovered from the contractor by way of penalty, and it is provided that an amount equal to 30% of the total value, at approved rates, of the portion remaining to complete the work is to be recovered from the contractor in this manner. However, the Grama Panchayat has, to date, taken no action to recover from the implementing agency, which partially executed the work, the loss sustained by the Grama Panchayat.
Legal action should be taken to recover the loss sustained by the Grama Panchayat due to the default of the implementing agency in executing the work, and the information should be reported to Audit.
1-30 Purchase of Computer and Printer Required for the Assistant Engineer's Office - Amount Remitted but Items Not Received to Date
Under Project No.240/22, 'Purchase of Computer and Printer Required for the Assistant Engineer's Office', with the Assistant Engineer as Implementing Officer, an amount of Rs.79,594/- has been remitted to the Kerala State IT Mission vide Voucher No.22101765/25.03.22. No reply has been given to Audit Enquiry No.24 dated 25.01.23, which had asked for the records of receipt of the computer and printer and of their being taken into stock to be produced for verification. However, it was orally informed that the equipment has not been received to date. The computer and printer should be obtained from the implementing agency, taken into stock, and the information reported to Audit. Until then, the amount of Rs.79,594/- spent for this purpose is held under objection in audit.
1-31 Asset Mapping - Not Completed
Under Project No.212/22, 'Asset Mapping', with the Assistant Engineer as Implementing Officer, the amount has been transferred as detailed below to the institution Centre For Social & Resource Development, 2nd Floor, Pulickan Hyper Bazar, Pudikkad, Thrissur-680301, has been transferred to the said institution.
| Sl. No. | Project number | Name of project | Fund details | Voucher number | Amount | |
| No. | Date | |||||
| 1 | 212/22 | Asset Mapping | Own Fund | 22101179 | 31.12.21 | 1,48,500 |
| 22101697 | 31.03.22 | 3,00,000 | ||||
However, information regarding completion of the scheme has not been produced for verification. The report and information on completion of the project should be obtained from the implementing institution and produced to Audit. Until the records are produced, the expenditure amount is held under objection in audit.
(Audit Enquiry No.32/25.01.23)
Part -2
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the receipt side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(1) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -3
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the expenditure side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(2) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
None.
Part -4
General information and audit review
4-1 Utilisation of Funds Received for Joint Projects
| Share Institution which released | Year in which amount received | Amount received | Name of the project | Expenditure | Balance |
| Block Panchayat | 2021-22 | 100000 | For dairy farmers Incentive for milk | 100000 | 0 |
| Block Panchayat | 2021-22 | 172970 | Physically and mentally challenged persons Payment of scholarship allowance | 172970 | 0 |
| Block Panchayat | 2021-22 | 340000 | LIFE Mission Housing Scheme - SC | 340000 | 0 |
| Block Panchayat | 2021-22 | 405890 | Comprehensive vegetable cultivation development - General | 405890 | 0 |
| Block Panchayat | 2021-22 | 150000 | Comprehensive paddy cultivation development - General | 150000 | 0 |
| District Panchayat | 2021-22 | 400000 | Physically and mentally challenges for those facing Scholarship payment of allowance | 400000 | 0 |
| District Panchayat | 2021-22 | 1220000 | LIFE Mission Housing Scheme - SC | 1220000 | 0 |
| District Panchayat | 2021-22 | 3760000 | LIFE Mission Housing Scheme - General | 3760000 | 0 |
The figures for the year 2021-22 furnished by the Grama Panchayat are included in the report
4-2 Details of Amounts Given for Deposit Works
None.
(The information furnished by the Grama Panchayat is included here; remarks regarding irregularities relating to the amounts given for deposit works are included in Paragraph 1-10-11)
4-3 Mobilisation Advance Given
None
4-4 Loan/loan repayment
| of loan Name/ Purpose | Order No./ Date | Loan Amount | Previous Balance | Receipt during the year | Amount repaid during the year | At the end of the year to be repaid outstanding Amount | ||
| Principal | Interest | |||||||
| KURDFC | G.O (MS) 68/2018 18/05/2018 | Not available | 2,73,20,019 | 33,96,210 | G.O (Rt) 3367/21/Fin 07.04.21 | 10,26,667 | 2,65,94,895 | |
| G.O (MS)100/2018 30/07/2018 | G.O (Rt) 5206/21/Fin 30.07.21 | 15,47,333 | ||||||
| G.O (MS) 110/2018 13/08/2018 | G.O (Rt) 22/22/Fin 01.01.22 | 15,47,334 | ||||||
| LSGD 34/2018 16/03/2018 | Total | 41,21,334 | ||||||
.
4-5 Fixed deposits
| 1 | Fixed deposit existing at the beginning of the year | 2502328 | |
| 2 | Amount deposited during the current year | 0 | |
| 3 | Interest | 75168 | |
| 3 | Total | 25,77,496 | |
| 4 | Amount withdrawn during the current year | 0 | |
| 5 | Fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year | 25,77,496 | |
| 6 | Details of fixed deposits remaining at the end of the year | Details of deposit | Amount |
| 1. Thrissur District Co-operative Bank - Pazhayannur | Account Number - 80012284084 | 9,12,368 | |
| 2. Thrissur District Co-operative Bank - Pazhayannur | Account Number - 80011867690 | 500000 | |
| 3. Punjab National Bank - Pazhayannur | Account Number - 433500PU00013231 | 11,64,128 | |
| Investment in Preference Shares | 1,000 |
4-6 Audit recovery
| Report Year | Part/ Paragraph | recovered Amount | remitted Name of the person and designation | Receipt Number/ Date |
| 2018-19 | 1-16 (D) | 120 | Athira Medicals | 121050106469, 31.12.2021 |
| 2018-19 | 1-16 | 300 | Navodaya Medicals | 121050106526, 03.01.2022 |
| 2018-19 | 1-16 | 160 | Principal, Narayana English Medium School | 121050500046, 10.01.2022 |
| 2018-19 | 1-16 | 14140 | Hotel Raj Regency | 121050106902, 14.01.2022 |
| 2017-18 | 2-9 (3) | 642 | Vicar, St. Mary's Jacobite Church | 12105010694, 07.01.2022 |
| 2017-18 | 2-3 (3) | 5890 | Principal, Narayana English Medium School | 121050500045, 10.01.2022 |
| Total | 21252 | |||
4-7 Details of charge/surcharge proceedings
None
4-8 Consolidated Audit Report
Details of the paragraphs from the Panchayat's previous years' audit reports, included in the consolidated report under Section 23 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, that remain to be settled are given below.
| Audit Year | Paragraph | Consolidated Report Year | Paragraph | Subject | Present status |
| 2017-2018 | 2-1 | 2017-2018 | For Kodathoor Industrial Park, the land was handed over to SIDCO | No.A4-8297/18 dated 14.08.2018 as per letter, from this office a reply has been furnished. The matter is under the consideration of the Legislative Committee. | |
| 2016-17 | 3-1 | 2016-17 | Land for various purposes purchase - a lapse occurred in fixing the land price | is under the consideration of the Legislative Committee | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(1) | 2016-2017 | Employees of 3 institutions - Profession tax not collected | Information on payment of the amount has been furnished to the Legislative Committee. The remark is under the consideration of the Committee. | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(2) | 2016-2017 | Profession tax of 4 institutions not collected | Information regarding remittance of the amount has been intimated to the Legislature Committee. The remark is under the consideration of the Committee.. | |
| 2015-2016 | 2-8(3) | 2016-2017 | General irregularities In the year 2015-16, as being for commercial purposes, tax has been assessed on the buildings; the profession tax should be collected from the employees liable to pay it, so as to increase the Panchayat's revenue by collecting profession tax, and steps should be taken accordingly. In addition, to the buildings to which D & O licenses have been issued liable to pay profession tax of all individuals and institutions a register containing details should be prepared and steps should be taken to collect profession tax. | In the year 2015-16 commercial purposes assessed to tax as in all buildings, operations Not started. D & O Licence applicable profession tax of institutions Demand register has been kept up to date. The para is under the consideration of the Legislature Committee. |
4-9 Audit Review
(A) Summary
| Total receipts for the audit year | 15,25,84,644 |
| Total expenditure for the audit year | 14,26,99,002 |
| Loss under receipt heads | 0 |
| Loss under expenditure heads/ amount not accepted in audit | 0 |
| Amount held under objection in audit | 28,08,474 |
(B) Details of clear loss sustained to the Panchayat Fund
None
Amount held under objection in audit
| Paragraph No. | Amount | Name and designation of the person responsible |
| 1-27-B | 1,30,000 | Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer |
| 1-27-C | 1,05,200 | Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer |
| 1-27-D | 1,52,130 | Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer |
| 1-27-E | 3,50,000 | Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer |
| 1-27-F | 3,00,000 | Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer |
| 1-27-I | 12,43,050 | Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer |
| 1-30 | 79,594 | Sunilkumar K, Assistant Engineer |
| 1-31 | 4,48,500 | Sunilkumar K, Assistant Engineer |
| Total | 28,08,474 |
(C) Details of loss sustained to the Central and State Governments and other institutions
None.
(D) Cases requiring further enquiry to ascertain the loss
None.
(E) Names and permanent addresses of those responsible for the loss referred to in the report
None.
(F) Names and permanent addresses of those responsible for the objection referred to in the report
| Name and designation of the person responsible | Present address | Permanent address |
| Dipin M N, Agricultural Officer | Agricultural Officer, Kondazhy Grama Panchayat | Mulanthanath House, Kattilappoovam PO, Pullamkandam - 680028 |
| Sunilkumar K, Assistant Engineer | Assistant Engineer, Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | Kizhakkevila House, Sreebuddha Lane, Kolazhy PO, Thrissur |
4-10 Paragraphs Remaining to be Settled
| Sl. No. | Audit Report year | Audit Report number | Total number of paragraphs remaining to be settled | Paragraphs remaining to be settled | Remarks (CAR/CASE/CH/SCH) |
| 1 | 1997-98 (Expenditure) | L.F.T12-1559/99 dt.6.3.99 | 4 | 1, 4, 5, 6 | |
| 2 | 1997-98 (Receipt) | L.F.T10-306/08 dt. 25.4.09/9.7.09 | 1 | 2-1 | |
| 3 | 1999-2000 to 2001-02 (People's Plan) | L.F.T10-1079/03 dt.09.04.04/14.09.04 | 7 | 7, 8, 14, 15 (2), 16, 18 (2to5), 20 (1,2,3) | Paragraph 8 - CAR |
| 4 | 1998-99 (Expenditure) | L.F.T12-291/2001 dt.18.5.01/09.7.01 | 21 | 4, 8, 12, 13, 14 D1, 14 E3, 14F, 15 B,15 D2, 20, 21, 24,26, 30, 31, 34, 36 A2, 36 A3, 36 C2, 42, 32, 29, 9, 14A, 14B, 15A, 17(2) | |
| 5 | 2000-01 | L.F.T10-309/08 dt. 25.04.09/14.7.19 | 1 | 3-3 | |
| 6 | 2001-02 | L.F.T10-740/08 dt. 25.04.09 | 2 | 3-1, 3-3 | |
| 7 | 2002-03 | L.F.T10-1265/08 dt. 07.09.09/5.12.09 | 1 | 3-13 | |
| 8 | 2003-04 | L.F.T10-1266/08 dt. 7.09.09/05.12.09 | 4 | 3-11, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16 | |
| 9 | 2005-06 | L.F.T10-1348/09 dt. 28.07.10/10.12.10 | 2 | 2-3, 3-3 | |
| 10 | 2006-07 | L.F.T10-1336/09 Dt. 29.7.10/10.12.10 | 1 | 3-7 | CAR |
| 11 | 2007-08 | LFT(P4)956/12 dt. 19.7.12/5.11.12 | 2 | 3-2, 3-4 | |
| 12 | 2008-09 | LFT(P4)957/12 dt. 19.7.12 | 5 | 3-2, 3-3, 3-4, 3-5, 3-6 | |
| 13 | 2009-10 | LFT(P4)958/12 dt. 02.08.12/05.11.12 | 3 | 3-2, 3-7, 3-8 | |
| 14 | 2010-11 | LFT(P4)959/12 dt. 2.8.12 | 3 | 3-7, 3-9, 3-10 | |
| 15 | 2011-12 | LFT(P4)1151/13 dt. 4.12.13/05.2.14 | 9 | 2-3(5) (Sl. No. 1,2,4,6,10,11,12, 13,14) 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-4, 3-5, 3-21, 3-23, 3-25 | |
| 16 | 2012-13 | LFT(P4)-631/14 dt. 08.10.14/08.12.14 | 17 | 2-3(1)A, 2-3(1)B, 2-3(3), 2-5, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3(1), 3-3(3), 3-3(4), 3-3(5), 3-3(6), 3-4, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-14, 3-15 | |
| 17 | 2013-14 | LFT(P4)-186/15 dt. 7.5.15/5.6.15 | 18 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-5 A,D, 2-8, 3-9, 3-10, 3-11, 3-12, 3-14, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-21 (a,b), 3-22, 3-23, 3-24, 3-25, 3-27 | |
| 18 | 2014-15 | KSATSR(P4)-996/16 dt. 25.6.16 | 14 | 2-2, 2-6(1)to(5), 2-7, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-8, 3-11, 3-13, 3-16, 3-17 | |
| 19 | 2015-16 | KSATSR(P4)-1934/16 dt. 05.01.16/05.12.16 | 15 | 2-3, 2-4, 2-8, 2-10, 3-8, 3-9, 3-11, 3-12, 3-13, 3-14, 3-15, 3-16, 3-17, 3-19, 3-25 | 2-8 CAR |
| 20 | 2016-17 | KSATSR(P4)-1111/17 dt. 30.8.17 | 10 | 2-3, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-7(1)to(3), 3-8(1)(2), 3-9(1)(2), 3-12, 3-13, 3-14 | |
| 21 | 2017-18 | KSATSR(P4)771/19 dt. 01.06.19 | 16 | 2-3(1,2), 2-7, 2-9(1,2), 3-1, 3-3, 3-5, 3-19, 3-20, 3-25, 3-26, 3-27, 3-28, 3-29, 3-9, 3-11, | |
| 22 | 2018-19 | KSATSR(P) Dt. | 17 | 1-10, 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26 | |
| 23 | 2019-20 | KSATSR(P) Dt. | 35 | 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36, 1-37, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-45, 1-46, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1 | |
| 23 | 2019-20 | KSATSR(P) Dt. | 45 | 1-11, 1-12, 1-13 , 1-14, 1-15, 1-16, 1-17, 1-18, 1-19, 1-20, 1-21, 1-22, 1-23, 1-24, 1-25, 1-26, 1-27, 1-28, 1-29, 1-30, 1-31, 1-32, 1-33, 1-34, 1-35, 1-36, 1-37, 1-38, 1-39, 1-40, 1-41, 1-42, 1-43, 1-44, 1-45, 1-46, 1-47, 1-48, 1-49, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3, 3-4 | |
| Total number of paragraphs considered | 253 | ||||
Deputy Director
District Audit Office,
Thrissur
Annexure-1
Audit Certificate
I certify that, in accordance with Section 4 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994 and Section 215 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, and subject to the Auditing Standards prescribed by the Comptroller & Auditor General for the audit of Panchayat Raj Institutions, the Annual Financial Statement for the year has been audited as per the audit methods and software arrangements approved by the Department at its meeting held on 12.02.2021, prepared by the special committee constituted to streamline the audit of Annual Financial Statements in accordance with the audit standards, laws and rules applicable to the Department. Except for the observations pointed out in my report, I certify that the Annual Financial Statement for the year 2021-2022 of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, presents the receipts and expenditure accounts in a proper manner.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department
Annexure-2
Utilisation Certificate of Grants
The utilisation of various grants for the year 2021-2022 by Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, has been verified on the basis of the information in the grant statement certified and furnished by the institution as per G.O.(Rt) No.16/2021/LSGD dated 23.01.2021, as detailed in Annexure-1, and subject to the observations regarding utilisation of grants included in this report, the utilisation of grants by the institution is hereby certified.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department

Government of Kerala
Kerala State Audit Department
www.ksad.kerala.gov.in
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Audit Report
2020-2021
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone : 0487-2331249
(Registered with acknowledgement due)
Number: KSATSR(P12) 62/2022
Kerala State Audit Department
District Audit Office
Thrissur – 680020
Date: 01/07/2022
E-mail: dotsr.ksad@kerala.gov.in
Phone: 0487-2331249
Deputy Director
President (through the Secretary)
Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat
Sir,
Subject: Regarding the Audit Report of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the Financial Year 2020-2021.
As per the provisions of Section 13 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994, Rule 18 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996 (Section 215(4) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994), the Audit Report resulting from the examination of the Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the financial year 2020-2021 is herewith forwarded for further action as prescribed under Rule 23(1) of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, 1996.
Attention is invited to the paragraphs in Parts 1 and 3 of this report. Immediately on receipt of this report, the persons responsible for the irregularities referred to herein should be informed of the matter, along with copies of the relevant paragraphs.
Within one month of receiving this report, a special meeting shall be convened to discuss the Audit Report in detail, and copies of the Audit Report and the decision taken thereon shall be published for public information. (See Rules 14 and 15 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules.)
Within two months of receiving the report, necessary action shall be taken to remove the audit remarks/objections contained herein, and a report to that effect shall be sent to this office within the said period. (See Local Fund Audit Act Section 15(1), Rules 20, 23, and Rule 21(1)(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Manner of Inspection and Audit System) Rules, 1997.)
Yours faithfully,
Deputy Director
Copy to:
1) The Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Thiruvananthapuram (for information),
2) Deputy Director of Panchayats, Thrissur.
3) Office copy.
Number: KSATSR(P12) 62/2022
Date: 01/07/2022
Audit Report on the Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, for the Financial Year 2020-2021.
(1994 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, Section 13 , 1996 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Rules, Rule 18, (1994 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act - Section 215(4)) issued in accordance with the above provisions.)
The Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, for the financial year 2020-2021 has been subjected to audit. The collection of money under various heads, their remittance, and the withdrawals of money from various accounts made by the institution from 01-04-2020 to 31-03-2021 were also examined.
The irregularities noticed in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Of the 64 enquiries issued, replies have been received to 8. The institution should take follow-up action on the audit enquiries not covered in this report.
The irregularities noticed in audit have been brought to the notice of the institution from time to time through audit enquiries. Although 64 enquiries were issued, no replies have been received.
This report has been prepared on the basis of the registers, records, information and explanations made available by the institution. The Kerala State Audit Department bears no responsibility whatsoever, either for the analyses and observations included in this report where these were prepared on the basis of incorrect information or particulars furnished by the institution, or for irregularities subsequently found by another audit agency/inspection wing on the basis of records that were not made available to audit by the institution.
(A) Details of Audit Conducted
Officer in charge of audit:
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smt. Bindu S. Nair | Deputy Director | 20-10-2021 | 30-10-2021 |
Time spent on audit:
| Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|
| 20-10-2021 | 30-10-2021 |
Officers who conducted the audit:
Shri V.K. Ram Manohar, Audit Officer (Hr. Gr.)
Smt. Sudha E.N., Assistant Audit Officer
Shri P.B. Sunil, Assistant Audit Officer
Shri Jeejo Job, Senior Grade Auditor
Shri Jayan V.S., Auditor
Shri Swalih C.P., Auditor
(B) Implementing Authorities
| Name | Official Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sobhana Rajan | President | 01-04-2020 | 18-11-2020 |
| Administrative Committee | President | 19-11-2020 | 29-12-2020 |
| P.K. Muraleedharan | President | 30-12-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| R. Shyamkumaran | Secretary | 01-04-2020 | 14-09-2020 |
| Jayamol Baby | Secretary-in-Charge | 15-09-2020 | 22-09-2020 |
| Prince T.M. | Secretary-in-Charge | 23-09-2020 | 30-09-2020 |
| Jayamol Baby | Secretary-in-Charge | 01-10-2020 | 15-10-2020 |
| R. Shyamkumaran | Secretary | 16-10-2020 | 08-02-2021 |
| Jayamol Baby | Secretary-in-Charge | 09-02-2021 | 11-02-2021 |
| Anitha Raman | Secretary | 12-02-2021 | 19-02-2021 |
| Jayamol Baby | Secretary-in-Charge | 20-02-2021 | 25-02-2021 |
| Ambika. M.S | Secretary | 26-02-2021 | 05-03-2021 |
| Jayamol Baby | Secretary-in-Charge | 06-03-2021 | 31-03-2021 |
Implementing Officers
| Name | Designation | Date (From) | Date (To) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Ajeesh. C.Y | Medical Officer, PHC | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Dr. Nisha K.R. | Medical Officer, Homoeo | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Dr. Unnikrishnan. A.K | Medical Officer, Ayurveda | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Sujatha. K | Headmistress | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Anoop P.A. | Dairy Extension Officer | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Sunilkumar. K | Assistant Engineer | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Jayamol Baby | Assistant Secretary | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
| Soumya.T.P | ICDS Supervisor | 01-04-2020 | 31-12-2020 |
| Sreeja.P.M | ICDS Supervisor | 01-01-2021 | 31-03-2021 |
| K.R.Arunkumar | Veterinary Surgeon | 01-04-2020 | 21-10-2020 |
| Binod.G | Veterinary Surgeon | 22-10-2020 | 26-10-2020 |
| Damodaran | Veterinary Surgeon | 27-10-2020 | 27-10-2020 |
| Binod.G | Veterinary Surgeon | 28-10-2020 | 13-12-2020 |
| Damodaran | Veterinary Surgeon | 14-12-2020 | 18-02-2021 |
| Smisha | Veterinary Surgeon | 19-02-2021 | 31-03-2021 |
| Joseph John Therattil | Agricultural Officer | 01-04-2020 | 09-09-2020 |
| Saranya.K.S | Agricultural Officer | 10-09-2020 | 07-10-2020 |
| Manju.P.S | Agricultural Officer | 08-10-2020 | 06-01-2021 |
| Dibin | Agricultural Officer | 07-01-2021 | 18-02-2021 |
| Manju.P.S | Agricultural Officer | 19-02-2021 | 03-03-2021 |
| Aditya Mohan | Agricultural Officer | 04-03-2021 | 31-03-2021 |
| Praveen.E | V.E.O (Pazhayannur Circle) | 01-04-2020 | 24-02-2021 |
| Sunvin John | V.E.O (Pazhayannur Circle) | 25-02-2021 | 31-03-2021 |
| Peter.C.G | V.E.O (Elanad Circle) | 01-04-2020 | 31-03-2021 |
Contents
| Sl. No. | Part 1 | Paragraph Number |
|---|---|---|
| Part 2 | ||
| Part 3 | ||
| Part 4 | ||
| Annexure | ||
| 1 | Budget | 1-1 |
| 2 | Provisions in the Panchayat Raj Act and Rules regarding budget proposals, and the Grama Panchayat. | 1-1-1 |
| 3 | Budget and Budgetary Control | 1-1-2 |
| 4 | Annual Financial Statement | 1-2 |
| 5 | Financial Analysis | 1-3 |
| 6 | Fund Utilisation | 1-4 |
| 7 | Plan Review | 1-5 |
| 8 | MGNREGS | 1-6 |
| 9 | Welfare pensions | 1-7 |
| 10 | Cash Balance Verification | 1-8 |
| 11 | Internal Control | 1-9 |
| 12 | Details of other audits conducted | 1-10 |
| 13 | Basic ratios not included in the Annual Financial Statement | 1-11-1 |
| 14 | Property tax - no demand entry at the time of accrual | 1-11-2 |
| 15 | Irregularities in property tax accounting | 1-11-3 |
| 16 | Property tax arrears - demand increased and adjusted as expenditure through journal entries; supporting records not furnished. | 1-11-4 |
| 17 | 280000000-Prior Period item - approved vouchers not furnished to audit | 1-11-5 |
| 18 | Journal vouchers not furnished to audit. | 1-11-6 |
| 19 | Time-barred deposits not written back | 1-11-7 |
| 20 | Advances not settled | 1-11-8 |
| 21 | Asset Register not updated | 1-11-9 |
| 22 | Cash Flow Statement - does not tally | 1-11-10 |
| 23 | Irregularities in depreciation of assets | 1-11-11 |
| 24 | Irregularities in the Annual Accounts | 1-11 |
| 25 | Amount deducted at source not included as part of annual expenditure. | 1-11-12 |
| 26 | Rent Register not maintained with reconciliation. | 1-11-13 |
| 27 | Loan Register not maintained. | 1-11-14 |
| 28 | Maintenance of receipts - irregularities | 1-12 |
| 29 | Irregularities in granting tax exemption to ex-servicemen | 1-13-1 |
| 30 | Tax exemption for vacant buildings - irregularities | 1-13-2 |
| 31 | Property tax assessed at a lower rate - loss of revenue | 1-13-3 |
| 32 | Action should be taken to recover the arrears of unauthorised buildings. | 1-13-4 |
| 33 | Cancelled Saankhya receipts not removed from Sanchaya | 1-13-5 |
| 34 | Property tax irregularities | 1-13 |
| 35 | Profession tax not collected from institutions. | 1-14-1 |
| 36 | Profession tax not collected in full. | 1-14-2 |
| 37 | Details of profession tax of BSNL establishments not furnished. | 1-14-3 |
| 38 | Details of profession tax of ration shops and contractors not furnished. | 1-14-4 |
| 39 | Profession tax - irregularities | 1-14 |
| 40 | Licence for factories, trades and enterprises - irregularities | 1-15-1 |
| 41 | Establishments are functioning in a building assessed to tax for residential purposes | 1-15-2 |
| 42 | Shop room rent - irregularities | 1-16 |
| 43 | Further action should be taken to make CSR activities beneficial | 1-17 |
| 44 | The possibility of forming a relief fund in the Grama Panchayat may be examined. | 1-18 |
| 45 | If the Citizens' Charter has been updated and made current, details along with the Governing Body's decision should be furnished. | 1-19 |
| 46 | Maintenance of street lights - the possibility of levying a service cess should be examined. | 1-20 |
| 47 | Newspaper advertisement - discount as per Government instructions not obtained | 1-21 |
| 48 | Social Security Pensions - collection of data on deceased beneficiaries - the order should be complied with. | 1-22 |
| 49 | Schemes implemented by the Medical Officer, PHC - irregularities | 1-23 |
| 50 | Schemes implemented by the Veterinary Surgeon - records incomplete | 1-24 |
| 51 | Viability Gap Fund - Development Fund spent contrary to Government instructions | 1-25 |
| 52 | Schemes implemented by the V.E.O - irregularities | 1-26 |
| 53 | Distribution of water tanks (SC) - entire amount spent from the Development Fund without spending the beneficiary contribution | 1-27 |
| 54 | Study room for Scheduled Caste students - work not completed even after receiving financial assistance. | 1-28 |
| 55 | Laptops for Scheduled Caste students - laptops remain undistributed. | 1-29 |
| 56 | Furniture for Kudumbashree canteen - records of handover to the Kudumbashree unit should be furnished. | 1-30 |
| 57 | Distribution statement of seeds purchased and distributed to farmers not produced for verification | 1-31 |
| 58 | Subhiksha Keralam - fallow land cultivation - certificate that the land is fallow not produced | 1-32 |
| 59 | Installation of surveillance cameras in Pazhayannur town - not completed even two years after the amount was paid | 1-33 |
| 60 | Shredding machine for the solid waste treatment plant - records of completion of work and commencement of operation not produced for verification | 1-34 |
| 61 | Utilisation certificate of projects for which the Secretary is the Implementing Officer not produced for verification | 1-35 |
| 62 | Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) - 2020-21 | 1-36 |
| 63 | Asset Management Manual - instructions not implemented | 1-37 |
| 64 | Public works - general irregularities - should be brought to the notice of the Government and resolved by seeking necessary instructions. | 1-38 |
| 65 | Public works - manual provisions, rule provisions and instructions are not being complied with. | 1-39 |
| 66 | Unimplemented projects - further action should be taken as per the provisions of the P.W.D Manual. | 1-40 |
| 67 | Further information on scheme works entered into contract is called for | 1-41 |
| 68 | Bill amount allowed without producing invoice as required under the GST Act. | 1-42 |
| 69 | Rs. 17655 drawn in excess from the Consolidated Fund should be refunded to the Consolidated Fund. | 1-43 |
| 70 | Work of laying slab for Pazhayannur town drain - irregularity - expenditure of Rs. 1,96,628 held under objection in audit. | 1-44 |
| 71 | Kunnampully Anganwadi - Thoppilkulam Road - excess amount allowed to the contractor. | 1-45 |
| 72 | Re-tarring of Parakkal-Kunnampully Road - excess expenditure as amount was allowed to the contractor without effecting tender rebate | 1-46 |
| 73 | Excess expenditure as bill amount was allowed to contractors without recovering the value of empty barrels | 1-47 |
| 74 | Construction of She Lodge - action taken to complete and regularise the scheme activity should be intimated. | 1-48 |
| 75 | Clean Pazhayannur Green Pazhayannur - audited income and expenditure accounts not produced for verification | 1-49 |
| 1 | Profession tax not collected in full. | 2-1 |
| 2 | Licence fee not collected in full | 2-2 |
| 1 | Rs. 17655 drawn in excess from the Consolidated Fund should be refunded to the Consolidated Fund. | 3-1 |
| 2 | Kunnampully Anganwadi - Thoppilkulam Road - excess amount allowed to the contractor. | 3-2 |
| 3 | Excess expenditure as bill amount was allowed to contractors without recovering the value of empty barrels | 3-3 |
| 4 | Re-tarring of Parakkal-Kunnampully Road - excess expenditure as amount was allowed to the contractor without effecting tender rebate | 3-4 |
| 1 | Utilisation of funds received for joint projects | 4-1 |
| 2 | Details of amount given for deposit works | 4-2 |
| 3 | Mobilisation advance given | 4-3 |
| 4 | Loan/loan repayment | 4-4 |
| 5 | Fixed Deposit | 4-5 |
| 6 | Audit Recovery | 4-6 |
| 7 | Details of paragraphs included in the Consolidated Audit Report | 4-7 |
| 8 | Details of Charge/Surcharge Proceedings | 4-8 |
| 9 | Audit Retrospect | 4-9 |
| 10 | Details of paragraphs remaining to be settled | 4-10 |
| 1 | Audit Certificate | |
| 2 | Utilisation Certificate of Grants | |
Part - 1
General Overview
1-1 Budget
As per decision 5(1) of the Finance Standing Committee of the Grama Panchayat dated 03.03.20, the preparation of the budget for the year 2020-21 was approved and recommended to the Panchayat Committee for passing. In the Governing Body meeting held on 13.03.20, the Vice President presented the draft budget for discussion and suggestions. Accordingly, adding the opening balance of Rs. 1,30,94,742/- and the anticipated revenue of Rs. 34,16,52,500/-, the total receipts came to Rs. 35,47,47,242/-, the total expenditure to Rs. 34,77,04,000/-, and the closing balance to Rs. 70,43,242/-. Subsequently, as per decision 1(1) of the Panchayat Governing Body dated 16.03.20, the budget for the year 2020-21 was approved without any change. As per decision 5(18) of the Governing Body meeting dated 20.02.21 (approved by the Finance Standing Committee as per decision 1(1) dated 17.02.21), the revised budget for the year 2020-21 was approved. As per the revised budget, adding the opening balance of Rs. 3,09,60,901/- and the anticipated revenue of Rs. 38,50,09,000/-, the total receipts came to Rs. 41,59,69,901/-, the total expenditure to Rs. 39,11,49,000/-, and the closing balance to Rs. 2,48,20,901/-.
The audit aimed at examining to what extent the statutory obligations to be observed in preparing, revising and passing the Panchayat budget have been fulfilled.
1-1-1 Provisions in the Panchayat Raj Act and Rules regarding budget proposals, and the Grama Panchayat.
1) As per Section 214 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, subject to the instructions issued by the Government from time to time and the rules prescribed, the budget proposals containing a detailed estimate of the income and expenditure likely to arise in the next year, including the expenditure on development schemes prepared and sanctioned under Section 175, shall be prepared by the concerned Standing Committees before the 15th of January every year, considering the estimates and suggestions furnished by the Secretary and the officers handling the respective subjects, and shall be submitted to the Finance Standing Committee.
It is not recorded in the minutes that the various Standing Committees of the Grama Panchayat sought budget proposals containing detailed estimates of income and expenditure relating to their respective subjects from the officers under them. However, it is recorded that details of Non-Plan expenditure were sought. At the same time, the details recorded in the minutes of the various Standing Committees having approved the budget proposals under them and submitted them to the Finance Standing Committee are tabulated below.
| Standing Committee | Date of recommendation | Remarks |
| Health & Education | 14.01.20 | Within time limit |
| Development | 13.01.20 | Within time limit |
| Welfare | 13.01.20 | Within time limit |
However, no other entries have been made in the minutes to confirm that budget proposals were fully received from all Implementing Officers. It can therefore reasonably be presumed that the budget was prepared by the Grama Panchayat in the absence of the necessary basic information.
2) Considering the proposals thus submitted and all the requirements under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, the Finance Standing Committee has to prepare from them a budget showing the income and expenditure of the Panchayat for the next year. It shall be submitted by the Chairman of the Finance Standing Committee to the Panchayat for approval at its special meeting in the first week of March. The Panchayat shall consider the proposals thus received and pass the budget, with amendments if any, before the commencement of the year to which the budget estimate relates.
The Grama Panchayat has considered and passed the budget estimate before the commencement of the year to which it relates.
3) As per Rule 71 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, the Panchayat shall prepare the budget on an accrual basis. The budget estimate shall also be accompanied by the following statements.
(i) Estimate of revenue income
(ii) Estimate of revenue expenditure
(iii) Estimate of capital receipts
(iv) Estimate of capital expenditure
(v) Estimate of loan repayment
(vi) Estimate of loans and advances
(vii) Estimate of deposits and recoveries
(viii) Estimate of investments
However, the budget recommended by the Finance Standing Committee and approved by the Panchayat does not include the estimate of deposits and recoveries and the estimate of investments. Therefore, the budget passed by the Panchayat is not in compliance with the rule provisions.
4) The provision under Section 214(7) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, that a copy of the budget shall be furnished to the auditors immediately after it is passed, has not been complied with.
1-1-2 Budget and Budgetary Control
(i) Monthly review
As per G.O.(Rt.) No.3291/16/LSGD dated 02.12.2016, the Government approved the Finance Management Manual concerning the budget of Grama Panchayats. Paragraph 4-3 of the Budget Manual stipulates that the Finance Standing Committee of the Grama Panchayat shall prepare and conduct a monthly review of the budget regarding income and expenditure, as per the tables specified in the manual [Table 4-1, Table 4-2]. Such a review has to be carried out by the Finance Standing Committee by the 1st of every month [Budget Manual paragraph 4-4(iii)]. Although it has been recorded (in the minutes) that the Finance Standing Committee considered the income and expenditure accounts (as per Saankhya) of the Grama Panchayat for every month, the monthly budget review as specified above has not taken place.
Paragraph 4-5 of the Budget Manual specifies that the Finance Standing Committee shall prepare annual data on income/expenditure in the format described above and conduct an annual review every April, and shall thereafter present the annual review report, along with the Standing Committee's recommendations, before the Grama Panchayat. However, the Grama Panchayat has not conducted any such budget review (for the financial year 2020-21).
Paragraph 4-5(xi) of the Budget Manual specifies that the Grama Panchayat shall, considering the monthly and annual reports, give necessary follow-up instructions regarding resource mobilisation to the Implementing Officers including the Secretary. No such budget review has been carried out.
(ii) Supplementary or revised budget
As per Rule 72 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, if expenditure not provided for in the budget, or in excess of that provided in the budget, becomes necessary, the Panchayat shall approve a supplementary budget or a revised budget before incurring such expenditure. Some instances where revision of the budget became necessary, as per various Governing Body decisions taken after the Grama Panchayat budget was passed, are given below.
Although it was decided, as per Governing Body decision 7(1) dated 22.04.20, to spill over more than 100 projects that had commenced in 2019-20 and were at various stages of implementation, the budget was not revised.
As per Government instructions, it had been decided, as per Governing Body decision 7(1) dated 05.06.20, to amend 25 projects and drop 9 projects in order to raise funds for the Subhiksha Keralam scheme. However, the budget was not revised.
It is without complying with the provisions regarding budgetary control described above that the Panchayat Governing Body, as per decision No. 5(18) of the meeting held on 20.02.21, accorded approval to the revised budget for 2020-21.
As per Rule 73 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules, 2011, it is provided that the responsibility for achieving proper budgetary control shall rest with the Secretary, the Implementing Officer and the Accountant. However, the provisions regarding budgetary control have not been complied with in the Grama Panchayat.
1-2 Annual Financial Statement
| Due date | Date of receipt |
| 31-07-2021 | 13-09-2021 |
1-3 Financial Analysis
(Summary)
| - | Amount (Rs.) |
| Opening Balance | 4,52,38,690 |
| Receipts for the audit year | 14,56,40,874 |
| Total | 19,08,79,564 |
| Expenditure during the audit year | 16,12,75,290 |
| Balance | 2,96,04,274 |
1-4 Utilisation of Funds
| Fund Head | O.B. | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | C.B | |
| Development Fund - General (as per ACR) | 0 | 23965763 | 23965763 | 23435654 | 530109 | |
| Development Fund - SCP (as per ACR) | 0 | 17567829 | 17567829 | 16896361 | 671468 | |
| Development Fund - TSP (as per ACR) | 0 | 596373 | 596373 | 200000 | 396373 | |
| Maintenance - Road (as per ACR) | 0 | 18981000 | 18981000 | 18981000 | 0 | |
| Maintenance - Non-Road (as per ACR) | 0 | 7242993 | 7242993 | 5655263 | 1587730 | |
| Central Finance Commission Grant (as per ACR) - Basic Grant | 0 | 23204443 | 23204443 | 8948865 | 14255578 | |
| Central Finance Commission Grant (as per ACR) - Tied | 0 | 10160000 | 10160000 | 6768615 | 3391385 | |
| Central Finance Commission Grant (as per ACR) - Total | 0 | 33364443 | 33364443 | 15717480 | 17646963 | |
| Centrally Sponsored Funds | ||||||
| MGNREGS | Wages of labourers/ Material Work | 0 | 110526152 | 110526152 | 110526152 | 0 |
| Administrative Expenditure | 0 | 1627950 | 1627950 | 1627950 | 0 | |
| Integrated Waste Land Development - Haryali (320100103) | 292839 | 9322 | 302161 | 0 | 302161 | |
| ICDS (320100121) | 1696550 | 2327433 | 4023983 | 1800000 | 2223983 | |
| CHIYAK (320100199) | 16848 | 0 | 16848 | 0 | 16848 | |
| State Sponsored Funds | Central Share for Child Friendly Toilet in Pazhayannur (320100299) | 12000 | 0 | 12000 | 12000 | 0 |
| Renovation of Veterinary Hospital (320200305) | 108 | 0 | 108 | 0 | 108 | |
| Fund from Tribal Development Officer - ST Development (320200305) | 120000 | 0 | 120000 | 0 | 120000 | |
| Funds from PIU - Jalanidhi towards Pipeline Shifting (320200399) | 114691 | 0 | 114691 | 114691 | 0 | |
| Amount from Jalanidhi (320300102) | 286526 | 1157778 | 1444304 | 282566 | 1161738 | |
| Donation towards LIFE Bhavana Padhathi (320200399) | 400000 | 0 | 400000 | 400000 | 0 | |
| Suchithwa Mission Fund for Community Toilet (320300103) | 746402 | 3799415 | 4545817 | 2434947 | 2110870 | |
| 329300199 - Grants, Funds & Contributions for Specific Purposes - Other Government Agencies | MN Laksham Veedu (320300199) | 310000 | 0 | 310000 | 0 | 310000 |
| Vimukthi (320300199) | 32700 | 25000 | 57700 | 6903 | 50797 | |
| Challenge Fund for Kudumbasree (State Poverty Eradication Mission) | 400428 | 1922847 | 2323275 | 989942 | 1333333 | |
| Amount from Tree Auction (Pattukottukavu) | 930 | 0 | 930 | 0 | 930 | |
| 2016-2017 Corpus Fund for Thirumani & Mattinmugal Community Hall Construction | 0 | 6912500 | 6912500 | 358089 | 6554411 | |
| Amount Given by KSFE for Online Vidya Sahayi Padhathi | 0 | 328712 | 328712 | 328695 | 17 | |
| Amount from District Mission Coordinator, Kudumbasree Mission, Thrissur | 0 | 200000 | 200000 | 0 | 200000 | |
| Amount from KILA for New Members Training | 0 | 13200 | 13200 | 13200 | 0 | |
| Pre Monsoon Campaign (Receipt No. 117010900036 dated 27.10.2017) (320300199) | 124036 | 0 | 124036 | 0 | 124036 | |
| Pre Monsoon Campaign (Receipt No. 117010900080 dated 31.03.2018) (320300199) | 27566 | 0 | 27566 | 0 | 27566 | |
| Amount from District Saksharatha Mission (Receipt No. 1180109000155 dated 31.03.2019) (320300199) | 212956 | 0 | 212956 | 24000 | 188956 | |
| Joint Venture Account | Block Panchayat (320700204) | 1586279 | 0 | 1586279 | 710000 | 876279 |
| District Panchayat (320700205) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | |
| Beneficiary Contribution (320800101) | 11550 | 52900 | 64450 | 24500 | 39950 | |
| Deferred Salary (350200301) | 0 | 635785 | 635785 | 0 | 635785 | |
| Amount Given by Government for Covid Expenses (320200324) | 0 | 19177 | 19177 | 19177 | 0 | |
| Chief Ministers Haritha Award from Haritha Mission (320900299) | 300000 | 0 | 300000 | 273480 | 26520 | |
1-5 Plan Review
| Approval Received (Number) | Estimate (Amount) | Implemented (Number) | Plan expenditure | Partially implemented | Not imple mented | Comple tion percentage |
| 305 | 27,14,93,830 | 200 | 11,84,61,027 | 25 | 80 | 66 |
1-6 MGNREGS
| Item | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance |
| Administrative expenses | 0 | 1627950 | 1627950 | 1627950 | 0 |
| Wage expenditure | 0 | 78122619 | 78122619 | 78122619 | 0 |
| Material Cost | 0 | 32403533 | 32403533 | 32403533 | 0 |
| Total | 0 | 11,21,54,102 | 11,21,54,102 | 11,21,54,102 | 0 |
1-7 Welfare Pensions
| Regarding Welfare Pensions | ||
| Name of Scheme | Expenditure Amount | Number of Beneficiaries |
| Unemployment Wages | 0 | 0 |
| Agricultural Worker Pension | 13553500 | 9955 |
| Widow Pension | 27464700 | 18736 |
| Old Age Pension | 46207400 | 34964 |
| Disability Pension | 7555100 | 5429 |
| Pension for unmarried women above 50 years of age | 3655800 | 2551 |
| Marriage assistance for daughters of widows | 180000 | 6 |
1-8 Verification of Cash Balance
Verification of cash balance under Section 6(4) of the Local Fund Audit Act, 1994 was conducted on 27.10.2021 at 3.30 PM in the presence of the Head of Office. On verification, the accuracy of the cash balance of Rs. 27,656/- was ascertained.
1-9 Internal Control
The deficiencies noticed in the internal control system of the Grama Panchayat have been dealt with under the respective audit headings in this Audit Report, under the various headings of Budget, Accounting, Levy of Tax and Exercise of Regulatory Powers, and Scheme Implementation.
1-10 Details of other audits conducted
| Audit | Last Audit Date conducted | Audit period | Report Date of receipt |
| Performance Audit | 19.01.2021 | 04/2020 to 12/2020 | Report not received |
| Accountant General's Audit | 15.07.2021 | 2015-16 to 2020-21 | 20-09-2021 |
1-11-1 Basic ratios not included in the Annual Financial Statement
Basic ratios have not been included in the Annual Financial Statement. (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 62(F)).
1-11-2 Property tax - no demand entry at the time of accrual
The property tax demand amount (residential/non-residential) of buildings existing as on 1/4/2020 should have been recorded as the demand amount at the beginning of the year, and the accrual-based income, including property tax assessed in 2020-21, should have been entered through monthly demand journal entries on the basis of the summary statement prepared monthly by the Secretary, the Assessment Register, and the Assessment/Demand Notice. (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 17(2)). Reduction of demand/writing off/granting of remission should also be done through journal entries, based on the same monthly summary statement prepared by the Secretary. This recording should be done on the basis of the journal voucher, work sheet and legally valid sanction. In 2020-21, tax was levied on 396 new buildings in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat. However, on scrutiny of the ledgers under the heads "110100101-Property tax on residential building" and "110100103-Property tax on non residential building" for 2020-21, it is seen that the demand for the financial year 2020-21 has been recorded only as a single entry each. There are also no vouchers to validate these demand entries. It is clear from this that the practice being followed is to adjust the amount in the annual accounts to match the demand amount at the end of the year as obtained from the "Sanchaya" software. Consequently, recording of legally due remissions, write-offs, etc. is left out of the accounts. Action should be taken to make entries at the very time the property tax demand legally arises, as prescribed in the rules, to carry out monthly reconciliation with the registers so as to make the internal control system effective, and to preserve vouchers and connected records that validate the demand entries.
1-11-3 Irregularities in property tax accounting
It is the property tax demand amount obtained from the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the Demand Register of property tax, that is entered as demand in "Saankhya", the software used for preparing the accounts. Receipt of property tax and issue of receipts, as well as preparation of the ledger, are done using the "Saankhya" software. The receipt collection in this is automatically posted to the "Sanchaya" software, which prepares the Demand Register of property tax. Since this is how it is prepared, the amounts under the heads Demand, Collection and Balance, as per the DCB Register and as per the statements in the annual accounts, should tally. However, the year-end balances of property tax and Library Cess as per the DCB Register prepared in the "Sanchaya" software do not tally with the amounts in the annual accounts prepared in the "Saankhya" software. In this situation, the reason for the annual accounts and the DCB Register not tallying should be identified and rectified.
3.1 Current year
3.1.1 Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjus ted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 26,86,101 | 15,34,997 | 56,365 | 11,00,852 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 26,86,101 | 15,34,997 | 58,265 | 11,03,473 |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-43) | (Ledger of 350410101-Advance collection-PT on Res. bldg) | *(1158647/105X100)= (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A minor difference in amount; treating it as a rounding-off amount, the figure in Sanchaya is adopted |
3.1.2 Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjus ted | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 38,65,912 | 21,02,749 | 17,381 | 17,49,509 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 38,65,912 | 21,02,749 | 18,047 | 17,51,033 |
| (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-1) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-43) | (Ledger of 350410104-Advance collection-PT on NR bldg) | *(1838585/105X100) (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) A small difference in amount is treated as a rounding-off amount, and the amount in Sanchaya is adopted |
3.2 Arrears
3.2.1 Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 7,46,621 | 2,19,771 | 5,26,850 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | *6,99,644 | 2,19,771 | 5,30,384 |
*(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 of 2019-20) (521792+212834= 734626/105*100) =6,99,644 | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-43) | **(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) (5,56,903/105X100) |
3.2.2 Non-Residential
| Demand | Collection | Balance | |
| As per "Sanchaya" software | 14,19,194 | 2,04,315 | 12,14,879 |
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 16,12,098 | 2,04,315 | 12,16,837 |
(Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 of 2019-20) 633302+1059401= 1692703*(/105*100) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-43) | **(12,77,679/105X100) (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) |
3.3 Library Cess (current year + arrears)
| Demand | Collection | Advance adjusted | Demand reduced | Balance | ||||||||
| Current year | Arrears | Total | Current year | Arrears | Total | Current year | Arrears | Total | ||||
| As per "Sanchaya" software | Residential | 1,37,462 | 41,236 | 1,78,698 | 78,053 | 11,183 | 89,236 | 1,900 | 57,795 | 30,053 | 87,848 | |
| Non-Residential | 195,256 | 72,902 | 2,68,158 | 1,05,688 | 10,102 | 1,15,790 | 666 | 89,076 | 62,800 | 1,51,876 | ||
| Total | 4,46,856 | 2,05,026 | 2,39,724 | |||||||||
| As per various statements in the annual accounts | 4,62,695 | 2,05,026 | 2,05,026 | 2,39,724 | ||||||||
| 1,29,977+3,32,718 = 4,62,695 (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15 of 2019-20, 431910101-State govt. Cess/levies ledger 2020-21) | (Receipts & Payments Statement, Schedule RP-36 (Receipts)) | (431910101-State govt Cess/levies ledger 2020-21) | (Balance Sheet Schedule B-15) | |||||||||
3.4 It is seen that there is a discrepancy in the very arithmetical calculation of the balance in the year-end summary amounts as per the DCB Register of property tax prepared in the Sanchaya software. The correct balance amount, arrived at as Demand - (Collection + Book Adjustment) = Balance, is not being computed in the software. (e.g., Tables 3.1.1, 3.1.2, 3.3)
1-11-4 Property tax arrears - demand increased and adjusted as expenditure through journal entries; supporting records not furnished.
As per the Property Tax Receivables ledger, the following amounts were adjusted as income or the demand was increased through journal entries under Prior Period Items. However, approved vouchers or work sheets supporting these journal entries have not been furnished to audit. It has therefore not been possible to ascertain that these entries are legally valid or accurate.
| Property Tax/Service Cess head | Amount by which demand was increased | Amount adjusted as income | Journal Voucher No. / Date |
| 431100102- Receivables for property tax on Residential Buildings (Arrears) | 53,231/- | 42000416/01.04.20 | |
| 431100104- Receivables for property tax on Non-Residential Buildings (Arrears) | 2,00,607/- | 42000417/01.04.20 |
1-11-5 280000000-Prior Period item - approved vouchers not furnished to audit
As per the Income & Expenditure Account (I-18), for the amounts written off, the amounts adjusted as income, and the correction entries in the following ledgers falling under the head "280000000-Prior Period item" through journal vouchers, approved vouchers or work sheets supporting the entries have not been furnished to audit. It has therefore not been possible to ascertain that the entries as per the ledgers given below are legally valid or accurate.
| Head (Income & Expenditure Account, Schedule I-18) | Ledger balance as on 31/3/2021 |
| 280100101 -Prior period income – Property tax on residential buildings | (53,485) |
| 280100104 – Prior period income-Property tax on Non Residential buildings | 1,82,916 |
| 280200401 – Prior period income – Other incomes | 1,00,800 |
| 280800201 – Prior period Expenses - Administrative Expenses | 24,000 |
| 280800701 – Prior period Expenses - Miscellaneous Expenses | 2,33,609 |
1-11-6 Journal vouchers not furnished to audit.
Transactions not connected with cash or bank/treasury accounts shall be recorded in the Journal Book (Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 7). For all vouchers, including journal vouchers, authentic certified vouchers and work sheets shall be preserved after certification. Currently, journal entries are being recorded without any such control. Journal entries made mainly to write off and adjust collection, balance, advance, arrears demand, arrears collection and arrears balance under property tax, to manually reconcile with the amount in the DCB Register as per the Sanchaya software, and to increase the advance amount, are not supported by any vouchers. Authentic certified vouchers and work sheets shall be preserved for all journal vouchers, duly certified.
1-11-7 Time-barred deposits not written back
As per the Deposit Register, time-barred deposits have not been written back. Details are given below.
| Head | Item | Date | Amount |
| 340100101 | Contractors EMD | 09.01.13 | 2500 |
| 09.01.13 | 5000 | ||
| 340100102 | Suppliers EMD | 08.07.16 | 5000 |
| 08.07.16 | 5000 | ||
| 23.09.16 | 5000 | ||
| 08.12.16 | 4000 | ||
| 04.08.17 | 1500 | ||
| 04.08.17 | 1500 | ||
| 08.10.17 | 1500 | ||
| 340100103 | Bidders EMD | 11.08.14 | 500 |
| 24.10.14 | 5000 | ||
| 24.10.14 | 5000 | ||
| 24.10.14 | 1000 | ||
| 12.12.17 | 5000 | ||
| 07.06.16 | 5000 | ||
| 17.09.16 | 15000 | ||
| 27.09.16 | 15000 | ||
| 01.08.17 | 2500 | ||
| 01.08.17 | 5000 | ||
| 01.08.17 | 1500 | ||
| 15.12.17 | 1500 | ||
| 15.12.17 | 1500 | ||
| 31.08.17 | 1500 | ||
| 340100202 | Suppliers Security Deposit | 26.09.17 | 3500 |
| 30.12.17 | 5000 | ||
| 340109901 | Other Deposits | 14.05.14 | 11000 |
| 12.10.15 | 500 | ||
| 12.10.15 | 500 | ||
| 12.10.15 | 1000 | ||
| 14.10.15 | 1000 | ||
| 14.10.15 | 1000 | ||
| 18.7.17 | 1500 | ||
| 340200102 | Auction Deposit | 11.03.14 | 1300 |
| 11.08.14 | 3500 | ||
| 18.08.14 | 10000 | ||
| 19.06.14 | 2750 | ||
| 26.11.14 | 14000 | ||
| 340200106 | Deposit Received For halls and Auditorium | 19.05.15 | 2000 |
| 03.11.16 | 2000 | ||
| 21.01.17 | 2000 | ||
| 340200199 | Other Deposits- Revenue | 04.04.14 | 720 |
| 24.04.14 | 600 | ||
| 29.04.14 | 720 | ||
| 13.05.14 | 1345 | ||
| 27.05.14 | 720 | ||
| 25.06.14 | 480 | ||
| 26.06.14 | 65 | ||
| 27.06.14 | 3780 | ||
| 26.08.14 | 120 | ||
| 31.03.14 | 8130 | ||
| 31.03.14 | 1895 | ||
| 31.03.14 | 2248 | ||
| 31.03.14 | 8892 | ||
| 29.09.14 | 65 | ||
| 11.11.14 | 540 | ||
| 30.12.14 | 840 | ||
| 24.02.15 | 1030 | ||
| 26.02.15 | 120 | ||
| 26.02.15 | 240 | ||
| 27.03.15 | 720 | ||
| 27.03.15 | 6142 | ||
| 27.03.15 | 510 | ||
| 02.01.15 | 360 | ||
| 28.12.15 | 720 | ||
| 30.12.15 | 20 | ||
| 13.06.15 | 2000 | ||
| 18.04.15 | 500 | ||
| 23.04.15 | 720 | ||
| 04.05.15 | 540 | ||
| 15.05.15 | 720 | ||
| 29.10.15 | 900 | ||
| 29.10.15 | 980 | ||
| 11.02.16 | 1440 | ||
| 09.09.16 | 1250 | ||
| 07.04.16 | 720 | ||
| 12.04.16 | 720 | ||
| 03.03.17 | 100 |
1-11-8 Advances not settled
The following advances remain unsettled even though a long time has elapsed since the amounts were paid. Details of the items remaining to be settled as per the Advance Register are given below.
| Head | Item | Voucher number and date | Agency/Officer who received the advance | Amount |
| 460100103- Temporary Advance for Official Purpose | Keralotsavam | 21700679/28.09.17 | Secretary | 25,000 |
| 460500202-Advance to Implementing Agencies – KSEB | Street Main Extension (Proj.No.232/18) | 21701406/25.07.17 | KSEB, Pazhayannur | 4,13,530 |
| Post Shifting Charge | 21800633/27.09.18 | KSEB, Pazhayannur | 15,551 | |
| 460500499- Advance to Other Accredited Agencies | Proj.No. 57/17- Solid Waste management plant | 21601369/25.03.17 | IRTC, Mundur, Palakkad | 10,00,000 |
1-11-9 Asset Register not updated
The Asset Register has not been kept up to date. The Asset Register is not prepared in a manner that allows verification of the existence and value of the fixed assets mentioned in the Balance Sheet.
1-11-10 Cash Flow Statement - does not tally
As the Cash Flow Statement submitted along with the annual accounts has the deficiencies noted below, its accuracy is not certified in audit.
As per the Cash Flow Statement, the amount recorded as "Net decrease in cash and cash equivalents" for the period 2020-21 is Rs. 1,56,34,416/-. However, the amount recorded in the same statement as "Net cash generated by Operating + Investing + Financing Activity" for the period 2020-21 is (Rs. 1,20,41,836)/-. Although, as per accepted accounting standards, these two amounts should tally, the two amounts in the statement submitted by the Panchayat do not tally.
1-11-11 Irregularities in depreciation of assets
(A) As per the Balance Sheet as on 31/3/2021, the asset "410800101-Other Fixed Assets" has been valued at Rs. 2,20,776. However, as per the Balance Sheet, the Accumulated Depreciation of these assets as on 31/3/2021 is Rs. 15,14,860. Since depreciation cannot be computed in excess of the value of the assets, the value of all assets included under this asset head should be adjusted in a manner that ensures a value of at least Re. 1 for each.
(B) The value of the asset has not been recorded under the head "Movable Assets - Vehicles". The value of assets under the vehicle category should be adjusted in a manner that ensures a value of at least Re. 1.
(C) The total value of assets, excluding the asset "410100199-Land Others" included in Balance Sheet Schedule B-11, is Rs. 20,29,31,697/-. However, as per the Depreciation Calculation Statement furnished to audit, depreciation has been calculated by considering the value of assets acquired up to 31.03.2021 as Rs. 21,11,12,492/-, and depreciation has been computed on that amount.
1-11 Irregularities in the Annual Accounts
Irregularities noticed on verification of the Annual Accounts are given below
1-11-12 Amount deducted at source not included as part of annual expenditure.
While allotting the second instalment of the Maintenance Grant (Road category) (as per GO(Rt.) No.4444/2020/Fin. dated 03.08.20), Rs. 74,007/- was deducted at source, being 50% of the amount required for purchase of voting machines for the three-tier Panchayats, for deposit into the bank account in the name of the State Election Commission. This expenditure has not been included in the Annual Accounts (in the Income & Expenditure Statement).
1-11-13 Rent Register not maintained with reconciliation.
To make internal control effective, all handwritten income registers shall have amounts calculated on a demand basis and a page basis, be closed at the end of each month and reconciled with the respective ledgers, have a summary recorded at the end of the year, and be preserved after certification by the Secretary (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, 2011, Rule 58(2)(e),(g)). However, the Rent Register for the year 2020-21 has not been maintained in this manner. It has therefore not been possible to ascertain the accuracy of the demand, collection and balance amounts under the rent head.
1-11-14 Loan Register not maintained.
A register showing, under the head 330500201 – Secured Loans – Loan from KURDFC, the amount of loan sanctioned to date, the repayment made to date, and the amount remaining to be repaid, was not made available to audit.
1-12 Maintenance of Receipts - Irregularities
On scrutiny of the various receipts, collection register and accounts relating to the receipts of the Panchayat, the following irregularities were noticed.
1. The receipt count has not been certified in receipt books numbered 6653, 6654, 49024, 49025, 49026, 49028 and 49029. (Kerala Panchayat Raj (Accounts) Rules 2011, Rule 83; K.T.C. Volume 1, Note 2 under Article 90(b))
2. The amount has been struck off and rewritten in receipts. E.g.: 6654/14-17, 59, which is against the Rules (Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules, Rule 11)
3. Receipt books numbered 6653, 49028, 49029 and 49038 were not cancelled at the end of the financial year.
4. The collection particulars in receipt book No. 49033 have not been entered in the collection register.
5. As per Kerala Panchayat Raj Accounts Rules 2011, Rule 83, except in unavoidable circumstances, a new receipt book shall not be issued unless the receipt book already issued has been fully used up and its counterfoil returned to the Panchayat. However, even though receipt book No. 49023 issued to Sri. Jijoy on 6.2.2020 had not been used, receipt book No. 49034 was issued to the said employee on 27.1.2021, and further new receipt books were issued to him as each was used up. Receipt books No. 49038 and 49039 were issued on 29.1.2021. Only 59 receipts of receipt book No. 49038 have been used. That is, as on 29.1.2021 the said employee was holding 3 receipt books, including 2 unused receipt books.
6. The amount collected as per Receipt No. 70/6654 dated 11.12.2019 is Rs. 1,399. However, as per the collection register, the amount collected under the said receipt is Rs. 829. On that date, the total amount collected as per Receipt Nos. 70-74/6654 was Rs. 6,174, whereas the amount remitted to the Panchayat as per the collection register is Rs. 5,604. Of the Rs. 1,399 collected as per Receipt No. 70/6654, Rs. 570 has neither been entered in the collection register nor remitted to the Panchayat. (It has been stated in the 2019-20 report that this amount is to be recovered.)
7. Receipt No. 39/49031 dated 25.8.2020 has been recorded as cancelled in the collection register. However, the said receipt has not been cancelled in the receipt book.
8. Although the following amounts appear as credited in the pass book, they have not been entered in the Day Book.
Sl. Number | Date | Amount |
| 1 | 30.9.2019 | 28250 |
| 2 | 3.10.2019 | 24350 |
| 3 | 4.10.2019 | 24750 |
| 4 | 5.10.2019 | 6250 (5000+1250) |
| 5 | 29.2.2020 | 87750 (59500+12500+15750) |
| 6 | 4.3.2020 | 26750 |
| 7 | 9.3.2020 | 6000 |
| 8 | 11.2.2021 | 255150 |
| 9 | 17.3.2021 | 392643 |
| 10 | 25.6.2021 | 817554 |
9. The following amounts collected as per the Day Book have not been remitted to the bank.
Sl. Number | Date | Amount |
| 1 | 25.2.2020 | 28000 (23000+ 1250*4) |
| 2 | 30.3.2020 | 720 |
| 3 | 11.6.2020 | 1510 |
| 4 | 24.6.2020 | 36981 (5404+5334+9569+8337*2) |
| 5 | 15.10.2020 | 8750 |
| 6 | 1.10.2021 | 49441 (8498+6180+6953+9270*3) |
| 7 | 12.10.2021 | 11594 |
10. As per Circular No. 58725/F.M.3.2008/LSGD/26.5.11, in addition to the Treasury account, Own Fund shall be deposited in only a single account, either in a nationalised bank or in a co-operative bank. More than one account shall not be maintained. The Panchayat has accounts for Own Fund in both the Pazhayannur Farmers' Service Co-operative Bank and Canara Bank. The balance in the said accounts as on 31.3.2021 is as follows.
| Pazhayannur Farmers' Service Co-operative Bank | Canara Bank |
| 6175103.6 | 21765275.16 |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.11/23.10.21) issued seeking a reply to the above irregularities. A reply to the irregularities shall be furnished, and follow-up action shall be taken to strictly comply with all the rules relating to the maintenance of receipts.
1-13-1 Irregularities in granting tax exemption to ex-servicemen
As per G.O.(Rt) No.106/17/LSGD dated 26.05.2017, when granting exemption in building tax to ex-servicemen/wives of ex-servicemen/widows, those eligible for building tax exemption shall submit a certificate in the prescribed format to the Grama Panchayat before 31st March of every year. In addition, a separate register of those eligible for the exemption shall be maintained with the necessary entries made. Since the applications/certificates of those eligible for the said exemption in the Panchayat and the register for the financial year 2020-21 were not made available for verification, the correctness of the exemption granted could not be verified. Follow-up action shall be taken to comply with the directions in the Government Order.
1-13-2 Tax exemption for vacant buildings - Irregularities
As per Rule 21 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax, Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, if any building has remained vacant for sixty days or more in a half-year, exemption may be granted in the annual tax proportionate to the number of days it remained vacant. As per Rule 21(2)(b), the tax exemption shall be reckoned from the date of the application submitted by the building owner or from the date the building became vacant, whichever is later. However, exemption in property tax has been granted for the following buildings without complying with the above Rule. Action shall be taken to assess and recover the property tax rightfully due as per the Rules.
| Sl. No. | Building No. | Building owner | File No./Date of application | Period exempted |
| 1 | 1/85,86,655,656,659, 660 A | Bindu, Hemakumar, Manaladi | B3/6549/20 9.11.2020 | 1.10.2020-31.3.2021 |
| 2 | 18/738-760 | Rajesh K. Ramachandra, Pachirikkattil | B1/7162/20 24.12.2020 | 1.10.2020-31.3.2021 |
| 3 | 18/719-737 | Rajesh K. Ramachandra, Pachirikkattil | B1/7162/20 18.12.2020 | 1.10.2020-31.3.2021 |
| 4 | 13/683,684 | Abdul Rahman, Cherikkathodi | B1/5964/20 12.10.2020 | 1.10.2020-31.3.2021 |
1-13-3 Property tax assessed at a lower rate - Loss of revenue
As per Sanchaya, the basic rate for hotels, restaurants, shops and godowns intended for commercial use with a plinth area up to 100 sq. metres is Rs. 30/-, and the basic rate for hotels, restaurants, shops and godowns with a plinth area above 100 sq. metres is Rs. 50/-. On verification of the Sanchaya data of Ward 22, it was found that in the tax assessment of the following establishments having a plinth area above 100 sq. metres, the basic rate has been reckoned as Rs. 30/- instead of Rs. 50/-.
| Sl. No. | Building No. | Area (Sq. metres) | Basic tax that ought to have been assessed (Area x 50) | Exemption/increase on basic tax as per Sanchaya | Demand as per Sanchaya | Amount that ought actually to have been demanded | Shortfall |
| 1 | 22/615 | 118 | 5900 | 10% exemption 20% increase | 4089 | 6815 | 2726 |
| 2 | 22/824 | 121 | 6050 | 20% increase | 4574 | 7623 | 3049 |
| 3 | 22/825 | 121 | 6050 | 20% increase | 4574 | 7623 | 3049 |
| 4 | 22/826 | 121 | 6050 | 20% increase | 4574 | 7623 | 3049 |
| 5 | 22/930 | 110 | 5500 | 20% increase | 4158 | 6930 | 2772 |
| 6 | 22/970 | 146 | 7300 | 40% exemption | 2760 | 4599 | 1839 |
| 7 | 22/1067 | 134.15 | 6708 | 20% increase | 5072 | 8453 | 3381 |
| 8 | 22/1068 | 127 | 6350 | 5% exemption 20% increase | 4562 | 7667 | 3105 |
| 9 | 22/1069 | 120.6 | 6030 | 10% exemption 20% increase | 4104 | 7281 | 3177 |
| Total | 26147 | ||||||
* Demand = ((Basic tax - Exemption) + Increase) + Library Cess (5%)
The property tax that has been short-collected to date shall be recovered using the authority conferred under Section 243(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act.
1-13-4 Action shall be taken to recover arrears of unauthorised buildings.
On verification of the particulars of unauthorised buildings available in Sanchaya, it was found that the property tax of the following buildings has been in arrears for more than 5 years.
| Sl. No. | Building No. | Owner | Arrears | |
| Period | Amount | |||
| 1 | 19/567 UA | Rama Devadathan | From financial year 2015-16 | 14294 |
| 2 | 19/567 UB,UC,UD,UF,UG | Rama Devadathan | 2015-16 From financial year | 47635 (9527*5) |
| 3 | 19/567 UE | Rama Devadathan | From financial year 2015-16 | 8736 |
| 4 | 18/307 UA | Secretary, President, Sree Ayyappa Swami Temple Committee, Vellappara | From financial year 2013-14 | 6948 |
| 5 | 16/1071 UA | Rajan | From financial year 2015-16 | 5720 |
| 6 | 14/219 UA | Hamsa & Sahira | From financial year 2013-14 | 6734 |
| Total | 90067 | |||
Steps shall be taken to recover the arrears at the earliest and ensure that the revenue due to the Panchayat is realised. If, for any reason, the arrear amount cannot be recovered, action shall be taken to recover the amount from those who failed to demand the tax in time.
1-13-5 Cancelled Sankhya receipts have not been removed from Sanchaya
Among the amounts collected under property tax as per Sankhya receipts, the following cancelled receipts have not been removed from Sanchaya, and consequently the amount is recorded as having been collected.
| Sl. No. | Ward/Building No. | Name/Address | Cancelled Sankhya Receipt No./Date | Period | Amount |
| 1 | 1/742 | Sreekumar, Pallippatta House, | 121050100812/17.6.2021 | 2021-22, First and Second half-years | 776 |
As per Sanchaya, there is currently no tax arrear for the said building. However, as shown above, the tax for the year 2021-22 has been recorded as paid through a cancelled receipt. Failure to remove cancelled receipts from Sanchaya is a serious lapse. This results in revenue not actually received by the Panchayat being recorded as received, thereby causing loss of revenue. The attention of the Finance Standing Committee is invited to this matter.
1-13 Property Tax - Irregularities
In the verification conducted relating to the property tax of the Grama Panchayat, the following irregularities were noticed. The various registers relating to property tax and the Sanchaya software were mainly used for the verification. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.24/28.10.21) issued in this regard. Property tax constitutes a major share of the Panchayat's own revenue. The attention of the Governing Body is therefore invited to resolving the irregularities relating to property tax at the earliest and to taking steps to increase the Panchayat's own revenue.
1-14-1 Profession tax not collected from establishments.
Profession tax for the year 2020-21 has not been collected from the employees of the following establishments. There is also no record of these establishments having submitted the profession tax return. Action shall be taken to recover the employees' profession tax using the authority conferred under Section 243(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act.
| Sl. No. | Name of institution | Remarks |
| 1 | Milk Producers' Co-operative Society, Ramanchetty | First half-year |
| 2 | Sree Medicals | First half-year |
| 3 | Raj Regency | First half-year |
| 4 | Bivinic English Medium School, Kallepadam | First half-year |
| 5 | Perfect Earthing | First half-year |
| 6 | Govt. Ayurveda Dispensary, Pazhayannur | Second half-year |
| 7 | Branch Post Office, Kallepadam | Second half-year |
| 8 | Canara Bank, Elanad | Second half-year |
| 9 | Kudumbashree Office, Pazhayannur | Second half-year |
| 10 | Annapoorna Super Market | Second half-year |
| 11 | SBI, Elanad | Second half-year |
| 12 | NSS English Medium School, Vadakkethara | First and second half-years |
| 13 | State Seed Farm, Pazhayannur | First and second half-years |
| 14 | Navodaya Medicals | First and second half-years |
| 15 | Colours Metal Coats | First and second half-years |
| 16 | Ramla Super Market | First and second half-years |
| 17 | Parasparasahaya Co-operative Society, Pazhayannur | First and second half-years |
| 18 | Triveni Super Market | First and second half-years |
| 19 | Milk Producers' Co-operative Society, Vadakkethara | First and second half-years |
| 20 | Branch Post Office, Vennur | First and second half-years |
1-14-2 Profession tax not collected in full.
Profession tax has not been collected in full from the following employees. Action shall be taken to recover the short-collected profession tax using the authority conferred under Section 243 of the Panchayat Raj Act.
| Sl. No. | Name | Establishment | Half Year | Income | Tax that ought to have been collected | Tax collected | Shortfall |
| 1 | Saroon M.S., M.R.A. | Madura Micro Finance, Pazhayannur | Second half-year | 76392 | 750 | 450 | 300 |
| 2 | Prasanth S., M.R.A. | Madura Micro Finance, Pazhayannur | Second half-year | 75356 | 750 | 180 | 570 |
| Total | 870 | ||||||
1-14-3 Particulars of profession tax of BSNL establishments not furnished.
In the final judgment in W.P.C. No. 16670/06, the Hon'ble Kerala High Court rejected the contention that BSNL establishments should be exempted from payment of establishment profession tax; hence, establishment profession tax shall be collected from BSNL establishments functioning within the limits of the Grama Panchayat. Details of the establishment profession tax collected from BSNL for the audit year were not furnished.
1-14-4 Particulars of profession tax of ration shops and contractors not furnished.
Although ration shops must certainly be functioning within the limits of the Panchayat, no reply was furnished to the audit enquiry seeking their number and the profession tax collected. Profession tax shall be collected from all ration shops functioning within the limits of the Panchayat, and audit shall be informed accordingly. In addition, particulars of the profession tax collected from the approved contractors within the limits of the Grama Panchayat shall also be furnished.
1-14 Profession Tax - Irregularities
In the verification conducted relating to the profession tax of the Grama Panchayat, the following irregularities were noticed. No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No. 21/28.10.2021) issued in this regard. The attention of the Finance Standing Committee and the Governing Body is invited to the following irregularities.
1-15-1 License for Factories, Trades and Enterprises - Irregularities
In connection with the licenses granted to factories, trades, entrepreneurial activities and other services, the following irregularities were noticed.
1. As per G.O.(P) No.80/2017/LSGD dated 31.10.2017 of the Local Self Government Department and the notification issued thereunder vide S.R.O. No.674/2017, license fee is to be collected by classifying establishments into different tiers - Micro, Mini, Small, Medium and Large - based on capital investment. As per the said order, the maximum amount that can be collected from establishments with the lowest capital investment has been fixed at Rs. 500. The Grama Panchayat is collecting differing rates such as Rs. 200 and Rs. 300 as license fee. The criteria adopted for levying the said rates shall be clarified. The Governing Body's decision fixing the rates was not furnished.
2. The full fee for granting license was not collected from the following establishments.
| Sl. No. | License Register No. | Establishment | Capital | Horse power of machinery | Fee to be collected | Fee collected | Shortfall |
| 1 | 129 | Nila Metals Private Limited | 40000000 | 1368 | 18680 | 13680 | 5000 |
| 2 | 277 | M.S. Angels Foams Private Limited | 1000000 | 106 | 2500 | 2000 | 500 |
3. As per the affidavit submitted by M/s. Nila Metals Private Limited, which was granted license under License Register No. 128, the capital of the establishment is Rs. 1 crore. However, as per page 2 of the Environment Clearance Order furnished by the said establishment, the capital of the establishment is Rs. 9.77 crore. Since the license fee was collected on the basis of the affidavit, only Rs. 5,000 was collected instead of the Rs. 10,000 that ought actually to have been collected.
4. The quarry owned by Sri. Shinto Abraham, Illickal House, has taken license for the financial years 2018-19 and 2020-21 (Audit Report Paragraph 1-18(5) for the year 2018-19; License Register Sl. No. 393 for the year 2020-21). No explanation was furnished as to why, if the said establishment was functioning during 2019-20, it was allowed to function without taking a license.
5. On verification of the License Register for the year 2020-21, it was found that of the applications from Sl. No. 1 to 432, only 20 are recorded in the register as having been disposed of. No explanation was furnished for the failure to maintain the register properly.
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.56/30.10.21) issued seeking a reply to the above matters. Along with furnishing a reply to the irregularities, since the license fee rightfully due to the Panchayat was not received, the short-collected fee shall be recovered using the authority conferred under Section 243(2) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act.
1-15-2 Establishments functioning in buildings assessed for residential purposes
1. On verification in Sanchaya of the particulars of buildings from Wards 11, 12 and 19 of the Grama Panchayat that have taken license under License Register Sl. Nos. 110 to 190 of the year 2020-21 for commercial and industrial purposes, it was found that the following buildings have been recorded as being for residential purposes, and tax has been fixed at a lower rate accordingly.
| Sl. No. | Establishment/Owner | License Register Sl. No. | Building Number |
| 1 | Handloom Hut | 116 | 19/510 |
| 2 | Shadow Touch | 171 | 12/105 |
| 3 | Shakti Hardware | 174 | 19/391 |
| 4 | N.S. Agency | 176 | 19/390 |
| 5 | Anikoodathil Rubber Processing Unit | 187 | 11/256 |
2. On verification in Sanchaya of the particulars of buildings from Wards 12, 14 and 22 of the Grama Panchayat that have taken license under License Register Sl. Nos. 30 to 250 of the year 2020-21 for commercial and industrial purposes, the particulars of the following buildings are not found in Sanchaya.
| Sl. No. | Establishment/Owner | License Register Sl. No. | Building Number |
| 1 | Palakkal Footwear | 38 | 14/501 I |
| 2 | VRS Industries | 137 | 12/353 A |
| 3 | Ramla Bakers & Cakes | 229 | 22/855 D |
| 4 | Ramla Super Market | 230 | 22/855 C,D |
| 5 | Sreekrupa | 246 | 22/477 |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.24/28.10.21) issued in this regard. A field inspection shall be conducted of the above establishments, or notice issued under Section 205B of the Panchayat Raj Act, and action taken as per the Rules against those functioning unauthorisedly. Entries in the License Register need to be accurate. Before granting license to industrial establishments, the occupancy of the building shall be ensured. License shall not be granted for trades or industries in unauthorised buildings.
1-16 Shop Room Rent - Irregularities
The following irregularities were noticed in connection with the letting out of shops of the Panchayat on rent.
1) Rent for the following buildings has not been collected during the financial year 2020-21.
| Sl. No. | Room, Building No. | Tenant |
| 1 | 101, 22/856 A | Abdul Kareem |
| 2 | 102, 22/856 B | Jayaraj, Kochipadavil |
| 3 | 103, 22/856 | Renuka Dasan, Koorkkaparambil |
| 4 | 109, 22/856 I | Manikandan, Poolakkal House |
| 5 | 113, 22/856 M | Afsal P.S., Fathima Manzil |
| 6 | 118, 22/984 | Abdul Hakeem, Pattekattu Valappil |
| 7 | 8, 4/346 | Afsal P.S., Fathima Manzil |
| 8 | 11, 4/349 | Manikandan, Karimpanakkal |
| 9 | 14, 19/735 | C.V. Sankardas, Cherakkuzhi |
| 10 | 23, 19/744 | Supriya Gopinath, Gopika Nivas |
| 11 | Upstairs, 19/748 | Joy Sebastian, Achanparambil |
| 12 | West Block, 19/750 | Ajeesh, Puthen House |
2) It is not clear whether the bye-law for letting out the Panchayat's buildings on rent has been approved by the Director of Panchayats. In the relevant file, the Secretary had submitted an application vide letter A3-4099/09 dated 9.7.2012 seeking approval of the bye-law. Subsequently, as per the Director of Panchayats' memo No. C5-20492/10 dated 14.8.2012, resubmission of the bye-law was directed, and in reply thereto, the Secretary has intimated, vide letter A3-8775/12 dated 27.08.2012, that the bye-law was submitted to the Office of the Deputy Director of Panchayats, Thrissur, for onward submission to the Director of Panchayats. No further particulars are available in the file after the said letter.
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry (No.58/30.10.21) issued seeking a reply to the above matters. If the bye-law has been approved by the Director of Panchayats, the particulars thereof shall be furnished to audit. Otherwise, the follow-up action taken in this regard shall be furnished. Steps shall be taken at the earliest to collect the rent rightfully due to the Panchayat as per the agreement, and the particulars shall be included in the first reply to this report.
1-17 Follow-up action shall be taken to make CSR activities useful
As per the License Register for 2020-21, 4 quarries are functioning in the Panchayat. As per the Environment Clearance Order furnished by the said quarries, the environment clearance has been granted on the condition that CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) activities as shown below shall be carried out during the license period (5 years from the date of the order).
| Sl. No. | License Register No. | Establishment/Owner | Environment Clearance Order No. | Amount of CSR activities proposed to be implemented |
| 1 | 128 | Nila Metals Private Limited | No 900/SEIAA/ECI/3461/2015 dtd 16.12.2016 | Rs. 8.9 lakh (Recurring expenditure) Rs. 12.9 lakh (Non-recurring expenditure) |
| 2 | 385 | Prestige Rock Products | No B1/16900/2017/DEIAA/TSR dtd 29.5.2018 | Rs. 4 lakh (Recurring expenditure) Rs. 5 lakh (Non-recurring expenditure) |
| 3 | 392 | Crown Aggregates | No 1/2016/DEIAA/TSR dtd 31.5.2017 | Rs. 3 lakh |
| 4 | 393 | Shinto Abraham | No B1/17435/2017/DEIAA/TSR dtd 29.5.2018 | Rs. 12 lakh |
No information is available on any mechanism set up to collect, verify, monitor or record particulars of the social responsibility activities carried out by these establishments. Consequently, the Panchayat has no mechanism to ensure that the regulatory authority exercised by it in granting licenses has been effective. No reply was furnished to the audit enquiry No.57/30.10.2021 in this regard.
In pursuance of the provisions of Section 135 of the Companies Act (Amendment), 2013, the Panchayat shall take steps to ensure that establishments utilising environmental resources are implementing the directions issued by the State/District Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority for carrying out CSR activities. Arrangements shall be made to coordinate such activities and utilise them efficiently in a manner beneficial to the public. Particulars of establishments presently required to be brought within the ambit of CSR may be collected and they too may be directed to carry out such activities. In this context, it is imperative that the Panchayat has a mechanism to ensure that the regulatory authority it exercises in granting licenses is effective.
1-18 The feasibility of constituting a Relief Fund in the Grama Panchayat may be examined.
As per Section 166 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, it is the duty of the Grama Panchayat to render the necessary services to the residents of the Grama Panchayat area in respect of the matters itemised in the Third Schedule of the said Act.
As per Section 177 of the same Act, a Panchayat may accept contributions and trusts relating only to the furtherance of any of the purposes for which its fund may be applied, and such contributions and trusts shall be utilised only for those purposes.
Using the authority conferred by these Sections, the State Government passed the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Constitution and Utilisation of Relief Fund) Rules in 2003. As per the said Rules (Rule 3), it has not been intimated that a Relief Fund has been constituted in the Grama Panchayat. Hence, if considered appropriate, the feasibility of constituting a Relief Fund in the Grama Panchayat may be examined.
(Audit Enquiry No. 13/25.10.21)
1-19 If the Citizens' Charter has been revised and updated, particulars thereof, along with the Governing Body's decision, shall be furnished.
As per Section 272A(1) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, every Panchayat shall publish a Citizens' Charter regarding the various services made available to citizens, the conditions thereof, and the time limit within which they are made available. As per Section 272A(2) of the said Act, the Citizens' Charter shall be revised and updated once a year. As per Rule 9 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Preparation of Citizens' Charter) Rules, 2004, the Citizens' Charter shall be revised and updated annually only after discussion by the Panchayat. In reply to the audit enquiry (Enquiry No. 15/25.10.21) issued seeking information (along with the Governing Body's decision) as to whether the Citizens' Charter was revised and updated in this manner during 2020-21, a copy of the Citizens' Charter published by the Grama Panchayat was furnished. However, the Governing Body's decision was not furnished. During the audit year and the preceding year, the Grama Panchayat has undertaken various activities to improve its services as part of ISO certification. However, since the Governing Body's decision to revise and publish the Citizens' Charter is not available, it was not possible to compare whether the duration of the services rendered by the Panchayat improved, before and after the revision, as part of the ISO certification. Hence, along with furnishing the Governing Body's decision fixing the revision and publication of the Citizens' Charter for the audit year, information comparing how the revised Citizens' Charter has affected the duration of the services rendered by the Panchayat (as against the immediately preceding year) shall be included in the first reply to this report.
1-20 Maintenance of street lights - The feasibility of levying service cess shall be examined.
During 2020-21, the following amount has been remitted to KSEB from the Grama Panchayat Fund towards electricity charges for street lights.
| Voucher No. | Date | Amount (Rs.) |
| Metered | ||
| 22000051 | 07.04.20 | 31653 |
| 22000054 | 07.04.20 | 3853 |
| 22000170 | 12.05.20 | 21233 |
| 22000173 | 12.05.20 | 6277 |
| 22000277 | 09.06.20 | 20288 |
| 22000296 | 10.06.20 | 5181 |
| 22000446 | 13.07.20 | 23357 |
| 22000450 | 10.07.20 | 4904 |
| 22000587 | 07.08.20 | 18744 |
| 22000645 | 13.08.20 | 4605 |
| 22000789 | 08.09.20 | 19382 |
| 22000840 | 06.10.20 | 4648 |
| 22000878 | 12.10.20 | 8606 |
| 22000880 | 12.10.20 | 21738 |
| 22001022 | 11.11.20 | 22451 |
| 22001068 | 24.11.20 | 300 |
| 22001146 | 02.12.20 | 308 |
| 22001194 | 17.12.20 | 24547 |
| 22001198 | 17.12.20 | 2780 |
| 22001288 | 06.01.21 | 21481 |
| 22001297 | 06.01.21 | 3060 |
| 22001316 | 13.01.21 | 1280 |
| 22001461 | 03.02.21 | 20312 |
| 22001522 | 06.02.21 | 4773 |
| 22001664 | 08.03.21 | 20880 |
| 22001730 | 19.03.21 | 861 |
| Unmetered | ||
| 22000053 | 07.04.20 | 37596 |
| 22000171 | 12.05.20 | 37596 |
| 22000279 | 09.06.20 | 37571 |
| 22000448 | 13.07.20 | 36843 |
| 22000588 | 07.08.20 | 36880 |
| 22000791 | 08.09.20 | 45244 |
| 22000881 | 12.10.20 | 36843 |
| 22001029 | 11.11.20 | 36856 |
| 22001195 | 17.12.20 | 36892 |
| 22001292 | 06.01.21 | 36928 |
| 22001463 | 03.02.21 | 36843 |
| 22001696 | 08.03.21 | 36843 |
| High Mast | ||
| 22001049 | 24.11.20 | 704 |
| 22001196 | 17.12.20 | 2053 |
| 22001291 | 06.01.21 | 115 |
| 22001293 | 06.01.21 | 265 |
| 22001296 | 06.01.21 | 2002 |
| 22001462 | 03.02.21 | 2006 |
| 22001665 | 08.03.21 | 2210 |
| Total | 7,79,792 | |
As tabulated above, the Grama Panchayat has spent a total of Rs. 7,79,792 from its Own Fund towards electricity charges for street lights during the financial year 2020-21.
In the circumstances described above, audit submits the following suggestions for the consideration of the Governing Body.
1. As per Section 200(2) of the Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, it has been clarified that the Grama Panchayat may levy service tax wherever it has provided street light and drinking water supply services. As per Rule 26 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Property Tax, Service Cess and Surcharge) Rules, 2011, it is provided that service cess may be levied for such services based on the property tax. It would therefore be appropriate to examine the feasibility of collecting service cess as per the Rules in the areas, or any of the areas, where street light and drinking water supply services have been provided.
2. Steps shall be taken to install metering for street lights that are not metered.
1-21 Newspaper advertisement - Discount as per Government instructions not availed
As per G.O.(Rt) 01/11/I&PRD dated 04.01.2011 and G.O.(Rt) 288/14/I&PRD dated 10.09.2014, it has been clarified that a 15% discount is admissible when Government institutions and local self-government institutions advertise in newspapers, whether through the Information & Public Relations Department or directly. However, when the Grama Panchayat paid advertisement charges for advertisements given in newspapers for various purposes during 2020-21, the discount was not availed. Details are given below.
| Sl. No. | Voucher No./Date | Amount | Newspaper |
| 1 | 22000297/10.06.20 | 6300 | Deshabhimani |
| 2 | 22000326/16.06.20 | 3864 | Deshabhimani |
| 3 | 22000332/22.06.20 | 6552 | Mathrubhumi |
| 4 | 22000520/27.07.20 | 6300 | Deshabhimani |
| 5 | 22000649/11.08.20 | 6300 | Deshabhimani |
| 6 | 22000721/25.08.20 | 4200 | Deshabhimani |
| 7 | 22000722/25.08.20 | 6300 | 60 Deshabhimani |
| 8 | 22000864/06.10.20 | 4200 | Deshabhimani |
| 9 | 22000939/28.10.20 | 6300 | Deshabhimani |
| 10 | 22000977/03.11.20 | 6300 | Deshabhimani |
| 11 | 22001026/11.11.20 | 6300 | Deshabhimani |
| 12 | 22001067/24.11.20 | 16800 | Deshabhimani |
| 13 | 22001515/05.02.21 | 5460 | Mathrubhumi |
No reply has been furnished to the audit enquiry No. 33/13.10.21 issued calling for the reason why no steps were taken to avail the 15% discount as per Government instructions. As described above, action shall be taken either to recover, from the establishment concerned, the amount excess-allowed contrary to the Government Order, or to adjust it against the bill amount to be allowed to these establishments in future.
1-22 Social Security Pensions - Collection of information of deceased beneficiaries - Order shall be complied with.
Social security pensions are currently disbursed either directly to the beneficiaries' bank accounts or through co-operative institutions. Co-operative institutions disbursing pension are required to intimate the particulars of deceased pensioners to the Local Government Secretaries after each pension disbursement, and the Local Government Secretaries are required to remove the deceased from the pension database. However, in the case of beneficiaries whose pension is transferred directly to the bank account, if death occurs, the pension disbursement to the deceased beneficiary can be stopped only at the time of the annual mustering in December. To avoid this, as per Order G.O.(Rt) No.97/2020/Fin. dated 23.09.2020, Panchayat Secretaries have been entrusted with the responsibility of collecting particulars of deceased persons and of widow pension beneficiaries who have remarried, through Anganwadi/ASHA workers, and removing them from the pension database in the respective month. However, no such process is currently taking place in the Grama Panchayat. It became evident, on verification of the pension database of pension beneficiaries whose deaths have been registered in the Grama Panchayat, that pension amounts continue to be deposited into the beneficiary's account even after death, because the particulars of deceased beneficiaries are not removed from the database. A few examples are given below.
| Sl. No. | Name of beneficiary | Aadhaar number | Type of pension | Date of death | Pension status |
| 1 | Moidu P.V. | 371796094950 | Old Age Pension | 12-12-2019 | Pension amount up to September 2021 deposited in the account. |
| 2 | Devaki Balakrishnan | 372461560957 | Old Age Pension | 29-11-2020 | Pension amount up to September 2021 deposited in the account |
| 3 | V.S. Ummar | 400199415146 | Old Age Pension | 24-01-2019 | The pension amount up to July 2019 was deposited in the account. |
The instructions in the Government Order must be followed to remove the details of deceased beneficiaries from the pension database in a time-bound manner, and situations likely to cause financial loss to the Government must be avoided. (Audit Enquiry No. 28/28.10.2021)
1-23 Projects implemented by the Medical Officer, PHC - Irregularities
1) Project No. 145/20-21, Salary of FHC Doctor and Staff (Expenditure – Rs. 4,46,129/-, Own Fund)
Attendance of the doctor and other staff has not been produced.
The sanctioned strength at the FHC, the Governing Body decision regarding the appointment of the doctor and other staff, and details of the appointment procedure were not made available.
2) Project No. 138/2020-21, Palliative Care (Expenditure – Rs. 7,34,420/-)
As per Proforma Invoice No. PRF-6046/09.03.2021, Rs. 2,50,000/- was paid to KMSCL (Voucher No. 22002021/06.03.2021). However, no medicines have been received. The NAC and Indent were not produced along with the file. Steps should be taken to obtain the medicines.
Equipment such as wheelchairs were purchased from KMSCL as per Invoice No. 6016/13.09.21, amount – Rs. 21,030/-, and Invoice No. 3508/08.07.21, amount – Rs. 13,720/- (Voucher No. 22002100/30.03.2021/amount – Rs. 34,750/-) (INV No.3508/08.07.2021/13720, INV No.6016/13.09.2021/21030). However, these have not been taken into stock. The stock register should be produced for verification.
No reply was furnished to Audit Enquiry No. 42/29.10.2021 issued in this regard. A reply to the irregularities should be furnished.
1-24 Projects implemented by the Veterinary Surgeon - Incomplete records
1) Project No. 134/20-21, Calf Care – GP (Expenditure amount – Rs. 6,25,000/-, General Ordinary Share)
Voucher No. 22002107/29.03.2021, Amount – Rs. 75,000/-
Voucher No. 22002109/29.03.2021, Amount – Rs. 5,50,000/-
Rs. 6,25,000/- was paid to the SLBP Director at the rate of Rs. 12,500/- for 50 beneficiaries. The register of distribution of cattle feed has not been produced. The distribution register should be produced for verification, and the utilisation certificate should be produced on completion of the project.
2) Project No. 205/20-21, Purchase of Medicines for the Veterinary Hospital (Expenditure amount – Rs. 4,50,000/-, Maintenance Fund Non-Road)
Voucher No. 22000669/12.04.2020, Amount – Rs. 4,50,000/-
The Indent and Non-Availability Certificate have not been produced.
No reply was furnished to Audit Enquiry No. 43/29.10.2021 issued in this regard. A reply should be furnished as to why the project was implemented in the absence of complete records.
1-25 Viability Gap Fund - Development Fund spent contrary to Government instructions
To make up the shortfall in the income of the Haritha Karma Sena, Local Self-Government Institutions are required to allocate funds for a Viability Gap Fund, subject to Government instructions. The amount may be credited either to the account of the Consortium or to the account of each Haritha Karma Sena. In 2020-21, the Panchayat allocated Rs. 5,06,000/- from the Development Fund and spent Rs. 3,32,832/- under Project No. 78/21, 'Kudumbashree Haritha Karma Sena Viability Gap Fund'. As per Order G.O.(Rt) No. 2111/2019/LSGD dated 27/09/2019 of the LSG(DC) Department, orders were issued permitting the amount required for the Operation & Maintenance of the solid waste treatment plant owned by Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat to be formulated and implemented as a project included within the ten percent amount that must compulsorily be set apart from the Panchayat's Development Fund for the solid waste management sector, and also permitting the amount in excess of the plant's income that is required to pay the wages of the four workers currently employed at the plant to be spent from the Panchayat's Own Fund until the said society becomes self-sufficient. However, the Rs. 2,84,832/- spent under the project in 2020-21 to pay the wages of the plant workers has been drawn from the Development Fund. As per Paragraph 8.10 of Government Order (Kai) No. 22/2018/LSGD dated 14/02/2018, restrictions have been placed on paying salary/honorarium from the Development Fund. Moreover, as per Order G.O.(Rt) No. 2111/2019/LSGD dated 27/09/2019, the amount in excess of the plant's income required to pay the workers' wages (until the said society becomes self-sufficient) is to be spent from the Panchayat's Own Fund. Contrary to this, Rs. 2,84,832/- was spent from the Development Fund in 2020-21 to pay the workers' wages. (Audit Enquiry No. 31/28-10-21). The said amount should be remitted from the Own Fund to the accumulated fund and the fact intimated to Audit.
1-26 Projects implemented by the VEO - Irregularities
The beneficiaries of the following projects implemented with the VEO as Implementing Officer have not completed the work to date.
1. Project No. 77/21 - Making Uninhabitable Houses Habitable (SC)
| Sl. No. | Name and Address | Voucher No./Date | Amount | Irregularities |
| 1 | Kali, Kumbalakkodu | Cheque No. 2584682/20.02.21 | 37500 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed to date. |
| 2. Project No. 165/21 - Renovation of Sanitary Latrines (SC) | ||||
| 1 | Narayanan, Nilampalliyal | 22001811/25.06.20 | 4620 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
| 2 | Kalyani, Elanad | 22001811/25.06.20 | 4620 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
| 3 | Chandran, Nilampalliyal | 22001811/25.06.20 | 4620 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
| 4 | Kalyani, Kallamkulam | 22001877/09.09.20 | 4620 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
| 3. Project No. 226/21 - Open Defecation Free Project (ODF) | ||||
| 1 | Viji Pradeep, Elanad | Cheque No. 184351/30.03.20 | 6000 | Although two instalments were received, the work has not been completed. |
| Cheque No. 098311/14.10.20 | 6000 | |||
| 2 | Kunjumani, Vennur | Cheque No. 184351/30.03.20 | 6000 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
| 3 | Kalyani, Kumbalakkodu | Cheque No. 184351/30.03.20 | 6000 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
| 4 | Ramankutty, Kallamparambu | Cheque No. 184351/30.03.20 | 6000 | Although the first instalment was received, the work has not been completed. |
4. On verification of the register of financial assistance disbursed to beneficiaries, it is seen that the first instalment of Rs. 25,000/- was paid on 19-11-2018 to the following beneficiaries in 2018-19 under the project 'Making Houses Habitable - General'.
1. Annamma, Palakkaparambil
2. Sasi, Poochappully
Even though spill-over projects were implemented — Project No. 160/20 in 2019-20 and Project No. 222/21 in 2020-21 — the construction of the above houses has not been completed.
5.A) As per the LIFE Mission beneficiary register, the beneficiary Sri. Shaji, Elanad (LIFE ID No. – 884133) received Rs. 40,000/- on 19/09/18, Rs. 1,20,000/- on 06.04.19 and Rs. 40,000/- on 13.02.20; however, the work has not been completed to date.
B) Sunitha, Vellappara (LIFE ID No. - 871004) received Rs. 40,000/- on 30/05/2018 and Rs. 1,60,000/- on 10/01/2019. However, the work has not been completed to date.
C) Haseena Koya, Kumbalakkodu (LIFE ID No. - 765381) received Rs. 40,000/- on 08/06/2018 and Rs. 1,60,000/- on 13/02/2020. However, the work has not been completed to date.
D) Subhash, Elanad (LIFE ID No. - 863993) received Rs. 40,000/- on 30/06/2018 and Rs. 1,60,000/- on 28/12/2018. However, the work has not been completed to date.
E) Parukkutty, Pazhayannur (LIFE ID No. - 913939) received Rs. 40,000/- on 17/03/2020. However, the work has not been completed to date.
In reply to the Audit Enquiry issued in this regard (29/28-10-21), it was intimated that follow-up action would be taken. Failing that, the amount should be recovered and the fact intimated to Audit.
1-27 Distribution of Water Tanks (SC) - The entire amount was spent from the Development Fund without utilising the beneficiary share
| Project | Distribution of Water Tanks (SC) (Spill Over) (Project No. - 308/21) |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
| Voucher number, amount | 22001897/19-10-20, 153000/- |
Under the above project implemented in 2020-21, 500-litre PVC water tanks were distributed to Scheduled Caste families. For this, Rs. 4,95,000/- was allocated from the Development Fund (SCP) and Rs. 1,65,000/- as beneficiary share. As per subsidy norms, 75% of the cost of the water tank is to be met from subsidy and 25% from the beneficiary share. 45 water tanks were purchased and distributed at the rate of Rs. 3,400/- per water tank from an establishment called Sithara Plastics. Instead of meeting 75% of the cost of the water tanks, i.e., Rs. 1,53,000/-, from the Development Fund and the remaining 25% from the beneficiary share, the entire amount was spent from the Development Fund. For the above project, Rs. 850/- each was collected from 44 beneficiaries and kept in the Own Fund. No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry issued regarding the failure to collect the beneficiary share from all beneficiaries and the spending of the Development Fund in place of the beneficiary share (Audit Enquiry No. 25/28.10.21). The balance beneficiary share yet to be collected should be collected, and the excess amount spent from the Development Fund should be repaid.
1-28 Study Room for Scheduled Caste Students - Although financial assistance was received, the work was not completed
| Project | Study Room for Students of the Scheduled Caste Category (Project No. 35/20, 172/21 (Spill Over)) |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
As per the financial assistance disbursement register made available to Audit, the following beneficiaries, who were granted financial assistance for construction of a study room under the above project — which was started in 2019-20 and implemented as a spill-over project in 2020-21 — have not completed the work to date.
| Sl. No. | Name and Address of the Beneficiary | Total Financial Assistance Sanctioned in 2019-20 and 2020-21 | Voucher number / date |
| 1 | Vijayan A., Meppadathu Parambu, Kumbalamkodu | 1,50,000 | 22000623/12.04.20 22001843/24.07.20 22001981/12.01.21 |
| 2 | Kumaran, Kunnampully, Pazhayannur | 1,50,000 | 22000623/12.04.20 22001827/15.07.20 22001936/15.12.20 |
| 3 | Sivasankaran, Perumbalapparambil, Kallamparambu | 1,50,000 | 22000623/12.04.20 22001828/15.07.20 22001981/12.01.21 |
| 4 | Sumathi W/o Chandran P.K., Pattiyathu Kunnu, Pazhayannur | 1,50,000 | 22000623/12.04.20 22001841/24.07.20 22001992/27.01.21 |
| 5 | Bindu A.G., Kizhakkethil Alumpetty, Kallepadam | 1,50,000 | 22000623/12.04.20 22001842/24.07.20 22001982/12.01.21 |
| 6 | Rugmini Chandran, Thekkinkad Colony House, Pazhayannur | 1,00,000 | 21901972/14.02.20 22001936/15.12.20 |
No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry regarding the non-completion of the work (Audit Enquiry No. 26/28.10.21). Steps should be taken to complete the above works.
1-29 Laptops for Scheduled Caste Students - Laptops remain undistributed
| Project | 1. Laptops for Scheduled Caste Students (Project No. 54/21) 2. Laptops for Scheduled Caste Students (Project No. 173/21 (Spill Over)) |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
| Voucher number, amount | 22002016/03-03-21 – 2,72,290/- 22000624/12-04-20 – 2,95,139/- |
Under the above projects implemented in 2020-21 for providing laptops to Scheduled Caste graduate/postgraduate/professional course students, 23 laptops (10+13) were purchased. In addition, 13 laptops were purchased in 2019-20 under the project 'Laptops for Students Pursuing Professional Courses' (Project No. 188/20). Thus, although 36 laptops were purchased in 2019-20 and 2020-21, only 34 laptops have been distributed during 2019-20 and 2020-21 as per the laptop distribution register and the applications made available for audit. However, since the distribution details are not recorded year-wise in the laptop distribution register, it is not clear which year's laptops remain to be distributed. No reply was furnished to the Audit Enquiry issued regarding the above matter (Audit Enquiry No. 27/28.10.2021). The circumstances that led to the purchase of laptops in excess of requirement, and the follow-up action on how the remaining laptops will be utilised, should be intimated to Audit.
1-30 Furniture for the Kudumbashree Canteen - Records of handover to the Kudumbashree unit should be made available
| Project | Providing Furniture and Related Facilities for the Kudumbashree Canteen (Project No. 303/21) |
| Implementing Officer | Assistant Secretary |
| Voucher number, amount | 22000327 /18-06-20 - 49,560/- (Unique Enterprises) 22000385 /10-07-20 – 146556/- ,, 22000934 /27-10-20 – 17,550/- Alankar Metals 22001208 /23-12-20 – 1,61,355/- ,, |
Rs. 3,75,021/- was spent from the Own Fund as per the above vouchers for the purchase of utensils, tables, chairs and kitchen equipment for the Kudumbashree Janakeeya Bhakshanashala (People's Canteen). Although the above equipment has been taken into stock (Stock Register pages 23, 26, 27, 28, 29), details of their handover to the Kudumbashree unit are not found in the stock register. The irregularities should be rectified and the fact intimated to Audit. (Audit Enquiry No. 60/30.10.21)
1-31 Distribution Statement for Purchase and Distribution of Seeds to Farmers was not produced for verification
In the following projects, with the Agricultural Officer as Implementing Officer, the distribution statement for seeds purchased from various agencies and distributed to farmers was not produced for verification. Details are tabulated below.
| Sl. No. | Name/Details of the Project | Voucher No. | Amount (₹) | Details of Seeds Distributed | Distributing Agency |
| 1 | 127/21 Comprehensive Vegetable Development | 22002113/ 29.03.21 | 5,69,100 | Vegetable Seeds | VFPCK, Alathur, Palakkad |
| Bitter gourd - 86 Kg | |||||
| Snake gourd - 60 Kg | |||||
| Watermelon - 10 kg | |||||
| Chilli - 8 kg | |||||
| Cucumber - 15 kg | |||||
| Pumpkin - 14 kg | |||||
| Amaranth - 5 kg | |||||
| Cowpea - 90 kg | |||||
| 2 | 129/21 Comprehensive Paddy Cultivation Development | 22001846/ 28.07.20 | 3,45,000 | Jyothi paddy seed - 19,800 Kg. | Kerala State Seed Development Authority, Bill No. 422/20-21 dt. 08.07.20 & No. 32/20-21 dt. 29.05.20 |
| 22001847/ 28.07.20 | 2,55,360 | Uma paddy seed - 4,980 Kg. | Kerala State Seed Development Authority, Bill No. 45/20-21 dt. 30.04.20 | ||
| Manuratna paddy seed - 3,000 Kg. | Kerala Agri. University Invoice No. STU/RF/20/20-21 dt.11.05.20 | ||||
| 22001917/ 05.11.20 | 4,55,400 | Ponmani paddy seed - 1,590 Kg | Kerala State Seed Development Authority, Bill No. 487/20-21 dt. 25.07.20 , | ||
| Jyothi paddy seed - 3,990 Kg. | Kerala State Seed Development Authority, Bill No. 950/20-21 dt. 12.10.20, | ||||
| Uma paddy seed – 9,600 Kg. | Kerala State Seed Development Authority, Bill No. 951/20-21 dt. 12.10.20 | ||||
| 22002114/ 29.03.21 | 90,000 | Uma paddy seed – 3,000 Kg. | Kerala State Seed Development Authority, Bill No. 1116/20-21 dt. 03.11.20 | ||
| 22002115/ 29.03.21 | 83,700 | Kanchana paddy seed - 450 kg | Kerala Agri. University Invoice No. STU/RF/97/20-21 dt.19.10.20 | ||
| Pournami paddy seed - 2,250 kg | Kerala Agri. University Invoice No. STU/RF/105/20-21 dt.11.05.20 | ||||
| 3 | 168/21 Comprehensive Vegetable Development (Women) Spill Over | 22000618/ 12.04.20 | 75,000 | Vegetable seed - Bitter gourd - 30 Kg | Kerala Agri. University Agri. Research Station Mannuthy Invoice No. 306/K/00467/2019-20 dt.20-01-21 & 306/K/00468/2019-20 dt.20-01-21 |
| 4 | 171/20 Distribution of Cowpea and Dhaincha Seeds - Spill Over | 22000620/ 12.04.20 | 1,00,000 | Cowpea seed - 500 kg | RAIDCO Kerala Ltd., Thrissur Branch Invoice No.TSR/1058/2019-20 dt.29-02-20 |
| Dhaincha seed - 500 kg | RAIDCO Kerala Ltd., Thrissur Branch Invoice No.TSR/1058/2019-20 dt.29-02-20 | ||||
| 5 | 301/21 Subhiksha Keralam - Distribution of Tuber Crop Planting Material to 12,000 Households | 22001848/ 28.07.20 | 1,80,000 | Tapioca Steam Cutting -12000 Nos. | VFPCK, Kodakara, Thrissur VFPCK/TSR/20-21/18 dt.09.07.20 |
| 6 | 169/21 Comprehensive Paddy Cultivation Development (Spill Over) | 22001793/ 18.05.20 | 6,10,440 | The project file was not produced for verification. Rs. 4,97,640/- was paid to the Kerala State Seed Development Authority and Rs. 1,12,800/- to the Kerala Agricultural University. | |
| Total | 27,64,000 | ||||
In the absence of records, the amount of ₹27,64,000/- tabulated above is held under audit objection.
(Audit Enquiry No. 19/27.10.21)
1-32 Subhiksha Keralam - Fallow Land Cultivation - Certificate certifying the land as fallow was not produced
Under the Subhiksha Keralam scheme, amounts as stated below have been spent on cultivating paddy, vegetables, tubers and banana on fallow land. As per the guidelines for providing financial assistance for fallow land cultivation (Government Order (Ordinary) No. 1009/2020/LSGD, Paragraph 2.2.1, of the Local Self-Government (DA) Department dated 29.05.20), land on which agricultural operations have not been carried out for more than three years is to be considered fallow land, and this must be certified by the concerned Agricultural Officer. However, on verification of the files of the following projects, it is seen that the Agricultural Officer has not made such a certification.
Sl. No. | Name/Details of the Project | Voucher No. | Amount | Number of Beneficiaries |
| 1 | 295/21 Subhiksha Keralam - Paddy Cultivation on Fallow Land | 22002091/20-10-20 | 1,76,715 | 17 |
| 2 | 22002140/18.02.21 | 5,01,285 | 52 | |
| 3 | 296/21 Subhiksha Keralam - Vegetable Cultivation on Fallow Land | 22002095/30.03.21 | 69,250 | 6 |
| 4 | 297/21 Subhiksha Keralam - Tuber Cultivation on Fallow Land | 22002144/10.03.21 | 50,300 | 8 |
| 5 | 298/21 Subhiksha Keralam - Banana Cultivation on Fallow Land | 22002094/30.03.21 | 67,200 | 3 |
| Total | 8,64,750 | |||
In the absence of records, the amount of ₹8,64,750/- tabulated above is held under audit objection.
(Audit Enquiry No. 44/29.10.21)
1-33 Installation of Surveillance Cameras in Pazhayannur Town - Not completed even two years after payment
As per Government Order (Ordinary) No. 1695/2019/LSGD dated 07-08-19 of the Local Self-Government Department, special permission was granted to install CCTV cameras utilising the Own Fund, in order to avoid the waste problem in Pazhayannur town and for the safety of women. Under the project 'Installation of Surveillance Cameras in Pazhayannur Town' (Project No. 172/20), with the Secretary as Implementing Officer, based on Estimate No. EDT1172/18 for ₹25,60,000/- prepared and furnished on 23-10-18 by the Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur, a total of ₹25,60,000/- has been paid to the Executive Engineer, PWD Electronics Division, Thrissur, from the Own Fund as follows: ₹9,00,000/- as per Voucher No. 21900617/16.08.19, ₹9,00,000/- as per Voucher No. 21900843/01.10.19, and 76,00,000 as per Voucher No. 21900871/04.10.19. The utilisation/completion certificate for the completion of the project has not been produced for verification.
Under the project 'Payment of CCTV Cable Rent to KSEB' (Project No. 68/21), with the Secretary as Implementing Officer, ₹24,180/- was paid to KSEB from the Own Fund as per Voucher No. 22000648/11.08.20, as rent for the poles on which the CCTV cable was drawn and cameras installed, based on Letter No. R.B/Cable TV/Wadakkanchery 2020-21/16 dated 13.07.20 of the KSEB Executive Engineer, Electrical Division, Wadakkanchery.
No reply has been furnished to Audit Enquiry No. 64/30-10-2021, which sought the reason for paying the rent of the pole on which the camera is installed before the completion of the project for installing the cameras. The amount of ₹24,180/- spent by preparing a separate project before the completion of the camera installation project is held under audit objection.
(Audit Enquiry No. 64/30-10-2021)
1-34 Shredding Machine for the Solid Waste Treatment Plant - Records of completion of work and commencement of operation not produced for verification
As per Government Order (Ordinary) No. 1568/2020/LSGD dated 24-08-20 of the Local Self-Government Department, special orders were issued for installing a low-capacity plastic shredding unit adjoining the solid waste treatment plant of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat. Under Project No. 119/21, 'Shredding Machine for the Solid Waste Treatment Plant', with the Secretary as Implementing Officer, a bio-shredding machine was purchased, utilising a total of ₹4,23,620/- comprising ₹68,450/- from the Central Finance Commission Grant as per Voucher No. 22002141/18.01.21 and ₹3,55,170/- from the Development Fund Performance Grant as per Voucher No. 22002092/18.01.21, as per Decision No. 6/01 of the Panchayat Governing Body dated 07-10-20, from an establishment named 'Horizon', Co-op. Bank Building, Pattanakkad (P.O), Alappuzha-688531 (Invoice No. 077/23.12.20).
Under Project No. 370/21, 'Shredding Machine for the Solid Waste Treatment Plant', with the Secretary himself as Implementing Officer, a shredding machine was purchased, utilising ₹2,73,480/- from the head '320900299 - Other Awards from State Government', as per the above decision of the Panchayat Governing Body, from the establishment 'Horizon', Co-op. Bank Building, Pattanakkad (P.O), Alappuzha-688531 (Invoice No. 078/23.12.20).
In addition, under Project No. 175/20, 'Installation of CCTV Camera at the Solid Waste Plant', with the Secretary himself as Implementing Officer, ₹1,76,818/- has been spent from the Own Fund.
Although details regarding the commencement of operation of the said machines were sought to be intimated to Audit through Enquiry No. 62/30.10.2021, details of the commencement of operation have not been produced for verification. Details of the commencement of operation of the shredding unit, along with the log book of the machines, should be produced for verification.
1-35 Utilisation Certificates for Projects with the Secretary as Implementing Officer not produced for verification
The utilisation certificates for the following projects, with the Secretary as Implementing Officer, have not been produced for verification.
Sl. No. | Name/Details of the Project | Voucher No. | Amount |
| 1 | 39/21 Payment of SSA Share (Development Fund (General)) | 22001985/18.01.21 | 2,00,000 |
| 2 | 40/21 Payment of IKM Share (Development Fund (General)) | 22001986/18.01.21 | 2,50,000 |
| 3 | 121/21 Payment of Ashraya Share (Development Fund (General)) | 22002096/30.03.21 | 2,00,000 |
| 4 | 333/21 Construction of Puratthipra Anganwadi (Amount paid to Mission Director, NREGS) - Own Fund | 22000995/03.11.21 | 4,00,000 |
The utilisation certificates should be produced for verification as and when obtained from the implementing agencies.
(Audit Enquiry No. 50/30-10-21 & 46/29.10.21)
1-36 Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme - 2020-21
A general overview of the implementation of the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme in Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat for the year 2020-21 is given below.
National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) -2020 - 2021
| 1 | Total Outlay for the Year | 113441182 | ||||||||
| 2 | Opening Balance | Receipts | Total | Expenditure | Balance | |||||
| For Administrative Expenses | 0 | 1627950 | 1627950 | 1627950 | ||||||
| Directly to Workers | 0 | 74119115 | 74119115 | 74119115 | ||||||
| Material | 0 | 36407037 | 36407037 | 36407037 | ||||||
| Total | 112154102 | 112154102 | 112154102 | |||||||
| 3 | Number of Projects Envisaged During the Year | 383 | ||||||||
| 4 | Number of Projects Completed | 141 | ||||||||
| 5 | Number of job cards issued under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme | 7324 | ||||||||
| 6 | Employment Days Generated During the Year | |||||||||
| Female | Male | Total | ||||||||
| 240296 | 9832 | 250128 | ||||||||
| Scheduled Caste | Scheduled Tribe | Others | Total | |||||||
| 73205 | 1649 | 175274 | 250128 | |||||||
| 7 | Number of Families Provided Employment During the Year | 4241 | ||||||||
| 8 | Number of Families Who Completed 100 Days of Employment During the Year | 929 | ||||||||
| 9 | Details, if Unemployment Wages were Disbursed During the Financial Year under MGNREGS | 0 | ||||||||
| 10 | Wages Disbursed During the Financial Year under MGNREGS | 7,41,19,115 | ||||||||
| 11 | Wages Pending Disbursement at the End of the Financial Year (31st March) under MGNREGS | 0 | ||||||||
| 12 | Detailed Information on Fixed Assets Completed During the Financial Year | 3,64,07,037 | ||||||||
Details of Projects Completed During the Financial Year
| Sl. No. | Category of projects | Number of projects implemented | Amount spent |
| 1 | Soil and Water Conservation | 79 | 2,68,80,447 |
| 2 | Drought Proofing, Afforestation | 17 | 23,00083 |
| 3 | Minor Irrigation | 0 | 0 |
| 4 | Water Conservation on Lands of Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes and Others | 13 | 36,98,309 |
| 5 | Renovation of traditional water bodies | 39 | 23,62,632 |
| 6 | Land development | 98 | 3,32,59,405 |
| 7 | Flood Control and Protection Works | 0 | 0 |
| 8 | Others (Record details if Water Kiosks have been installed) | 137 | 4,49,40,306 |
| 9 | Details of Convergence Projects Implemented | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 383 | 11,34,41,182 |
An inadequacy of works aimed at creating public social assets can be seen in the above activities. Greater emphasis should be given to works aimed at creating social assets.
1-37 Asset Management Manual - Instructions not implemented
As per Order G.O.(Rt) No. 166/17/LSGD dated 20.01.2017, the Government approved the Asset Management Manual for Local Self-Government Institutions. Although an Audit Enquiry (Enquiry No. 17, dated 26.10.21) was issued seeking clarification as to whether the following activities related to this had been implemented for the year 2020-21, no reply was received.
1) Had an Asset Management and Monitoring Committee (AMMC) been constituted in the Grama Panchayat? If so, the date of constitution and details of its composition.
2) Was the Annual Status Assessment of Assets Condition (ASAAC) subsequently carried out and a report prepared? If so, details.
3) Had the Grama Panchayat approved an Asset Management Plan (AMP)? If so, details.
4) In the absence of the above activities, what was the approach document adopted by the Grama Panchayat during 2020-21 with regard to the creation, maintenance and disposal of its assets?
On verification of the various minutes books of the Panchayat, it could not be seen that the Grama Panchayat had approved an Asset Management Plan or taken the steps required for it. It therefore appears that the Grama Panchayat functioned during 2020-21 with regard to the creation, maintenance and disposal of its assets in the absence of such an approach document. Some circumstances that make an approach document, including an Asset Management Plan, essential for the Panchayat are given below.
(i) The Government had issued guidelines for the preparation of the Grama Panchayat's Annual Plans as per Order G.O(Kai) No. 11/18/LSGD dated 29.01.18. As per Paragraph 7.13(12) of this Order, in order to promote quality and durable roads, each Local Self-Government Institution should endeavour to implement at least one road with a 5-year guarantee in one Annual Plan. However, the Grama Panchayat has not been able to carry out such an activity.
(ii) Panchayat Decision 1(12) dated 26.06.20 is given below.
"The residents of the surrounding area created an obstruction to the temporary dumping, on the cremation ground at Puratthipra owned by the Panchayat, of the silt and other waste removed from the public drain in the Elanad area of the Grama Panchayat, which had accumulated during the floods; and, accordingly, upon this matter being brought to the notice of the District Collector, the District Collector issued an order under the Disaster Management Act and granted permission for the temporary dumping of the removed silt and debris on the said land; on this basis, it was decided to do so and also to fix the value of the silt and other material dumped and to take auction proceedings." Details of follow-up action are not available.
In the circumstances described above, follow-up action should be ensured to implement the instructions of the Asset Management Manual.
1-38 Public Works - General Irregularities - These should be brought to the notice of the Government and resolved by seeking necessary directions
As per Rule 18 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Execution of Public Works) Rules, 1997, except in matters specifically stated in the Rules, the procedure for a public work in the Panchayat is the same as the procedure being followed at the time in the Government's Public Works Department.
As per Order G.O.(P) No. 13/12/PWD dated 01.02.2012, the Government approved the revised PWD Manual. As per Order G.O.(MS) No. 270/12/LSGD dated 17.10.2012, orders were issued implementing the revised PWD Manual in the Engineering Wing of the Local Self-Government Department also.
As per Order G.O.(P) No. 36/13/PWD dated 17.04.2013, orders were issued adopting the CPWD DATA, SOR, NBC guidelines and MORTH specifications in the Public Works Department with effect from 01.10.13. As per Order G.O.(MS) No. 74/14/LSGD dated 07.05.2014, detailed guidelines were issued for implementing the CPWD, MORTH and MORD specifications in the Local Self-Government Department.
As per Order G.O.(P) No. 375/15/Finance dated 24.08.2015, the Government ordered that estimates in all Engineering Departments should be prepared through PRICE software. Subsequently, as per Order G.O.(MS) No. 498/15/Finance dated 03.11.2015, orders were also issued allotting time limits to various departments in connection with preparing estimates in this manner.
As per Order G.O.(P) No. 30/16/Finance dated 29.02.2016, orders were issued to exclude the contractor's profit margin in works implemented through Beneficiary Committees and to allow overhead charges at 7.5% of the estimate.
Deficiencies noticed on scrutiny of the preparation of estimates for the civil works implemented by the Grama Panchayat are given below.
1) In the data prepared in PRICE software, 10% overhead charge is allowed
As per order dated 07.05.2014, G.O.(MS)No.74/14/LSGD, the data provides for only 15% total CP&OH. Hence, though asked to produce a Government Order sanctioning 10% OH and 10% CP separately in the LSGD PRICE software, none was furnished. In the absence of such a Government Order, allowing 10% overhead charge in addition to 10% CP in the MORD DATA is irregular.
2) In the data prepared in PRICE software, 10% CP is allowed over and above 10% overhead charge
The PWD Manual and the above-mentioned Government Orders provide for allowing only a 1% water charge and, in addition, 15% CP&OH in estimates prepared using DSR rates and CPWD data or other data. However, in the data prepared in LSGD PRICE software, 10% CP is being allowed over and above 10% overhead charge. Though asked to produce the Government Order sanctioning this, if any, it was not furnished. In the absence of a Government Order, allowing it in this manner is irregular.
Due to the above deficiencies, the estimate amount stands inflated without entitlement. The deficiencies should therefore be brought to the notice of Government and resolved by seeking necessary instructions.
(Audit Enquiry No. 53/30.10.21.)
1-39 Civil works -- Manual provisions, rule provisions and instructions are not being complied with.
As per Rule 18 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Execution of Public Works) Rules, 1997, except in matters specifically stated in the Rules, the procedure for a public work in the Panchayat is the same as the procedure being followed at the time in the Government's Public Works Department.
The revised PWD Manual was approved by Government vide order dated 01.02.2012, G.O.(P)No.13/12/PWD. As per order dated 17.10.2012, G.O.(MS)No.270/12/LSGD, the revised PWD Manual was ordered to be implemented in the Engineering Wing of the Local Self Government Department also.
As per order dated 17.04.2013, G.O.(P)No.36/13/PWD, the Public Works Department adopted CPWD DATA, SOR, NBC guidelines and MORTH specifications with effect from 01.10.13. As per order dated 07.05.2014, G.O.(MS)No.74/14/LSGD, detailed guidelines were issued for implementing CPWD, MORTH and MORD specifications in the Local Self Government Department.
Deficiencies noticed on scrutiny of the execution of the civil works implemented by the Grama Panchayat are given below
1) Work calendar - not submitted by contractors
As per Section 2112 of the PWD Manual, 2012, the contractor is required to prepare and submit a work calendar before the contract is finalised. This work calendar forms part of the contract. However, there is no record in the civil works files that such a work calendar was prepared and submitted.
2) Summary of public works not placed before the Grama Sabha
As per Rule 17 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj (Execution of Public Works) Rules, 1997, the summary of a public work is required to be placed before the Grama Sabha. However, no records are maintained in the civil works files to show that this statutory provision has been complied with.
3) In most of the works, the unique number of the asset is not entered in Project Formulation Form-2. Hence the existence of the asset cannot be ascertained.
Example 1) 158/21 Metalling and tarring of road at Achattupadi Kidakkunnu
2) 164/21 Re-tarring of Neelichira Road
Reply should be furnished to the deficiencies and follow-up action should be taken to ensure compliance with the manual provisions, rule provisions and instructions.
(Audit Enquiry No. 53/30.10.21.)
1-40 Projects not implemented --- Follow-up action as per the provisions of the PWD Manual should be taken.
The following projects, for which contracts were entered into in 2018-19 and which were carried over as spillover in 2020-21, have not been implemented to date.
| Sl. No. | Contract Number, Date | Name of the work | Project number | Contractor |
| 1 | 50/AE/LSGD/PZR/2018-19/29.09.18 | Kandamkulam Road Metalling and Tarring | 217/20, 230/21 | Sri. K.M. Hamsa |
| 2 | 49/AE/LSGD/PZR/2018-19/29.09.18 | Metalling and Tarring of Thiruthippally Road | 218/20, 231/21 | Sri. K.M. Hamsa |
Similarly, the following projects, for which contracts were entered into in 2019-20 and which were carried over as spillover in 2020-21, have also not been implemented to date.
| Sl. No. | Contract Number, Date | Name of the work | Project number | Contractor |
| 1 | 21/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20/31.10.19 | Malampathy Vazhod Drinking Water Scheme | 262/20, 254/21 | Sri. T.N. Prasad |
| 2 | 84/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20/31.03.20 | Haritha Keralam - Protection of Neelampalliyal public well | 135/20, 249/21 | Sri. T.N. Prasad |
As per Section 2102.1 of the PWD Manual, 2012, the contractor should take over the site and commence work within 10 days of entering into the contract. If the contractor fails to appear, it is sufficient for the Engineer to send, by registered post, a form for handing over the site to the contractor, and the contractor shall be deemed to have taken over the site as on the date of posting. There are no records in the files furnished to confirm that this procedure was followed. Section 2116.2.1 of the PWD Manual, 2012 requires that, on termination of the contract under Section 2116.1, an amount equal to 30% of the value of the work remaining to be completed be recovered from the contractor from the EMD/Security Deposit etc.; this statutory provision has also not been complied with.
Hence necessary follow-up action should be taken to fulfil the requirement under Section 2116.2.1 of the PWD Manual, 2012, of terminating the contract under Section 2116.1 and recovering from the contractor, from the EMD/Security Deposit etc., an amount equal to 30% of the value of the work remaining to be completed.
(Audit Enquiry No. 16/25.10.21)
1-41 Follow-up information on project works under contract is called for
No follow-up action appears to have been taken in respect of the contracted project works listed below. A reply to the Audit Enquiry issued in this regard (Enquiry No. 39/29.10.21) was not furnished. Hence, the present status of these project works should be intimated, and if they have been cancelled by decision of the Governing Body, the decision number and reason should be included in the first reply to this report. The need to subsequently cancel contracted project works by decision of the Governing Body indicates the absence of a clear Asset Management Plan. It is therefore essential to prepare a clear Asset Management Plan at the Panchayat level in compliance with the provisions of the Asset Management Manual. Steps for this should be taken in future.
If the contracted project works have not been cancelled by decision of the Governing Body, follow-up action should be taken under Section 2116.1 of the PWD Manual, 2012 and the details included in the first reply to this report.
| Sl. No. | Project number | Project | Agreement Number | Contractor |
| 1 | 133/20 | Maintenance of rainwater harvesting structures at constituent institutions | 23/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20 Dtd. 31.10.19 | Babu. E |
| 2 | 06/21 | Tarring of Kallamparambu Mosque Road | 29/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 20.11.20 | Shameer. K.M |
| 3 | 12/21 | Kallamkadu Road | 30/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 20.11.20 | Shameer. K.M |
| 4 | 22/21 | Metalling and Tarring of Kakkarakunnu Road | 22/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 28.10.20 | Shameer. K.M |
| 5 | 32/21 | Re-tarring of Thrikkanaya Colony Road | 05/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 30.06.20 | T.N. Prasad |
| 6 | 35/21 | Metalling and Tarring of Paruthippara Bridge Road | 20/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 28.10.20 | Biju. M. Mathew |
| 7 | 86/21 | Bunding of Kariyarkode stream | 32/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 20.11.20 | T.N. Prasad |
| 8 | 89/21 | Land protection at Kazhichappilly Colony | 33/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 01.01.21 | Ayoob. K.M |
| 9 | 91/21 | Re-tarring of Vadakkekkara Road | 12/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 05.08.20 | Siyad |
| 10 | 146/21 | LSGD Office Maintenance | 31/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 20.11.20 | Shameer. K.M |
1-42 Bill amount allowed without production of invoice as required under GST law.
In the following project works, a 12% GST share was allowed and paid to the contractors. However, since the amount was below Rs. 2.5 lakh, GST deduction at source was not made while allowing the bill amount. The contractors concerned did not furnish an invoice under Section 31 of the GST Act to the institution. Details are tabulated below.
| Project No. | Project | Contractor | Valuation (including 12% GST) | Voucher No./Date | Amount |
| 263/21 | Side protection of Vennur Manchadi stream | Rasheed. P.M. | 217212 | 22001907/28.10.20 | 217212 |
| 246/21 | Thendankavu Drinking Water Scheme | T.N. Prasad | 178469 | 22002020/06.11.20 | 178469 |
| 262/21 | Side protection of Kallepadam Thottupalam stream | Babu. E | 152727 | 22001918/06.11.20 | 152727 |
Allowing the bill amount with the addition of 12% GST share in the absence of the invoice is irregular. Reply should be furnished to this.
(Audit Enquiry No. 40/29.10.21.)
1-43 The amount of Rs. 17,655 drawn in excess from the Consolidated Fund should be refunded to the Consolidated Fund.
| Project number | 229/21 |
| Project | Footpath on Thiruvilwamala Road |
| Technical Sanction | 79755/2017-18 |
| Estimate Number | 2017/12863 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 14,54,680 |
| Contractor | Sri. K.A. Muhammed Basheer |
| Contract Rate | 12,52,258.18 |
| Contract Agreement | 61/AE/LSGD/PZR/2017-18 Dtd. 21.12.17 |
| M-Book | 26/2018-19 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22002127/29.03.21 = 5,63,684 ( CFC Grant) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work (after the first part bill) | 546029 | |
| (+) Retention (deducted from the part bill) | 17655 | |
| Total amount drawn | 563684 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 5460 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 5460 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 10920 | |
| Total deductions | 21840 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 541844 |
Details of the first part bill passed and paid to the contractor in 2018-19 are given below.
| Value of work (drawn from Treasury) | 706229 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 7062 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 7062 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 14124 | |
| (-) Retention 2.5% | 17655 | |
| Total deductions | 45903 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 660326 |
Thus, while passing and paying the first part bill to the contractor in 2018-19, the retention amount (Rs. 17,655) drawn from the Treasury (from the Consolidated Fund) was deposited in the Treasury account of the Secretary. While paying the final bill, this amount was again drawn from the Consolidated Fund and paid to the contractor. The Rs. 17,655 thus drawn in excess from the Consolidated Fund should be refunded to the Consolidated Fund and the details included in the first reply to this report.
(Audit Enquiry 37/29.10.21)
1-44 Slab work for Pazhayannur Town drain - deficiency - expenditure of Rs. 1,96,628 held under objection in audit.
In the financial year 2020-21, the project "Slab for Pazhayannur Town Drain" (Project No. 274/21) was implemented with the Assistant Engineer as Implementing Officer. Rs. 1,96,628 was spent for this work from the CFC Tied Fund as per Voucher No. 22002143/11.09.20 (M-Book Number 242/19-20). However, the roads passing through the Pazhayannur town area are PWD roads. Hence, carrying out construction on land that is not an asset of the Panchayat is irregular. Reply should be furnished to this deficiency, and if construction on land not belonging to the Panchayat was carried out with special permission, the relevant permission order should be produced. Until then, the expenditure of Rs. 1,96,628 incurred under this project is held under objection in audit.
(Audit Enquiry No.41/29.10.21)
1-45 Kunnampully Anganwadi-Thoppilkulam Road - excess amount allowed to contractor.
| Project number | 17/21 |
| Project | Kunnampully Anganwadi-Thoppilkulam Road |
| Technical Sanction | 9554/2020-21 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2020-21/52187 Dtd. 12.05.20 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 4,00,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Shameer. K.M |
| Contract Rate | Estimate Rate |
| Contract Agreement | 08/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 13.07.20 |
| M-Book | 346/19-20 |
| Voucher No., Amount | 22001958/11.01.21 = 3,99,401 ( MG R) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work | 356608 | |
| (+) GST 12% | 42793 | |
| Total | 399401 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 2566 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 2566 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 5132 | |
| (-) Value of 22 empty barrels @281 | 6182 | |
| Total deductions | 16446 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 382955 |
However, the final bill was paid without effecting the required deductions, resulting in excess payment to the contractor. Details are given below.
| Total value of work | 356608 | |
| (+) GST 12% | 42793 | |
| Total | 399401 | |
| (-) Income Tax 0.75% | 2675 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3566 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 7132 | |
| (-) Value of 22 empty barrels @281 | 6182 | |
| Total deductions | 19555 | |
| Amount payable to contractor | 379846 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 382955 | |
| Excess | 3109 |
This excess expenditure of Rs. 3,109 should be recovered either from the contractor or from the Engineer who wrongly passed and allowed the amount while sanctioning the final bill, and the details included in the first reply to this report.
(Audit Enquiry No.38/29.10.21)
1-46 Re-tarring of Parackal-Kunnampully Road - excess expenditure due to amount allowed to contractor without effecting tender rebate
| Project number | 200/21 |
| Project | Re-tarring of Parackal-Kunnampully Road |
| Technical Sanction | 75986/2019-20 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2019-20/44730 Dtd. 13.10.19 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 4,00,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Prakashan. K.V |
| Contract Rate | 1% less than estimate |
| Contract Agreement | 51/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20 Dtd. 18.12.19 |
| M-Book | 296/2019-20 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22001855/10.08.20 = 3,98,976 ( MG R) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work | 356229 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 42747 | |
| Total | 398976 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 3562 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3562 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 7124 | |
| Total deductions | 14248 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 384728 |
However, while allowing the amount to the contractor, the 1% tender rebate was not deducted. Details of the excess expenditure resulting from this are given below.
| Total value of work | 356229 | |
| (-) Tender rebate 1% | 3562 | |
| Balance | 352667 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 42320 | |
| Total expenditure permissible for the work | 394987 | |
| Total amount spent on the work | 398976 | |
| Excess expenditure | 3989 |
This excess expenditure should be recovered from the contractor or from the Assistant Engineer who wrongly allowed the amount, and the details intimated.
1-47 Excess expenditure due to bill amount allowed to contractors without recovering the value of empty barrels
Estimates for various road works in the Grama Panchayat have been prepared including the rate for packed bitumen. However, while allowing the final bill, the amount was allowed without either the empty barrels being returned or their value being recovered from the contractor. As a result of allowing the amount in this manner, the contractors came to receive more than what they were entitled to. Details of one such work are given below.
| Project number | 190/21 |
| Project | Re-tarring of Malampathy-Thirumani Road |
| Technical Sanction | 24145/2019-20 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2019-20/44171 Dtd. 23.07.19 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 3,40,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Roy. K.M |
| Contract Rate | Estimate Rate |
| Contract Agreement | 16/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20 Dtd. 25.10.19 |
| M-Book | 268/2019-20 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22000637/12.04.20 = 3,39,470 ( MG R) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work | 303098 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 36372 | |
| Total | 339470 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 6062 | |
| Total deductions | 12124 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 327346 |
As per the entry on Page 27 of the M-Book, 2605.32 kg of S65 bitumen and 238.86 kg of RS1 bitumen were used for this work. The estimate includes the market rate of Packed Bitumen. The value of the empty barrels should therefore have been recovered from the contractor while allowing the final bill. However, the amount was allowed to the contractor without recovering the value of the empty barrels (S65 bitumen 2605.32/156 = 17 barrels, RS1 bitumen 238.86/182 = 2 barrels, total 19 barrels). As a result, the contractor came to be allowed an excess amount. Details are tabulated below.
| Total value of work | 303098 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 36372 | |
| Total | 339470 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 6062 | |
| (-) Value of 19 empty barrels @ 238/each | 4522 | |
| (-) 18% GST on the value of empty barrels | 814 | |
| Total deductions | 17460 | |
| Amount payable to contractor | 322010 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 327346 | |
| Excess amount paid | 5336 |
As described above, since the amount was allowed to the contractors without recovering the value of empty Packed Bitumen barrels, an excess amount came to be paid to the contractors in each of the works tabulated below (including the above work). The excess amount paid should be recovered from the contractors or from the Assistant Engineer who wrongly allowed the amount, and the details intimated.
| Sl. No. | Project | Technical Sanction No. | Voucher number | Amount | M-Book | Bitumen Requirement | Number of Barrels | Value of barrel @238/each including 18% GST |
| 1 | 190/21 | 24145/19-20 | 22000637/12.04.20 | 339470 | 268/19-20 | VG30 = 2605.32 kg | 17+2 = 19 | 5336 |
| RS 1 = 238.86 kg | ||||||||
| 2 | 188/21 | 14800/19-20 | 22000636/12.04.20 | 299796 | 266/19-20 | VG30 = 2314.9 kg | 15+1 = 16 | 4493 |
RS1 = 207.23 kg | ||||||||
| 3 | 159/21 | 49075/18-19 | 22000659/12.04.20 | 349606 | 260/19-20 | VG30 = 2937.69 kg | 19+2 =21 | 5898 |
RS1 = 282.72 kg | ||||||||
| 4 | 164/21 | 113022/18-19 | 22000661/12.04.20 | 349624 | 282/19-20 | VG30 = 2686.35 kg | 17+2=19 | 5336 |
RS1 = 283.64 kg | ||||||||
| 5 | 201/21 | 66202/19-20 | 22000638/12.04.20 | 299698 | 267/19-20 | VG30 = 2512.03 kg | 16+2=18 | 5055 |
| RS1 = 248.72 kg | ||||||||
| 6 | 157/21 | 31864/18-19 | 22000658/12.04.20 | 279520 | 263/19-20 | VG30 = 2347.89 kg | 15+2=17 | 4774 |
RS1 = 223.09 kg | ||||||||
| 7 | 186/21 | 14877/19-20 | 22000657/12.04.20 | 498735 | 279/19-20 | VG30 = 1799.09 kg | 12+5=17 | 4774 |
RS1 = 724.75 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 234.47 kg | ||||||||
| 8 | 178/21 | 66416/19-20 | 22000660/12.04.20 | 297538 | 283/19-20 | VG30 = 1613.07 kg | 10+3=13 | 3651 |
RS1 = 181.43 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 302.35 kg | ||||||||
| 9 | 191/21 | 66463/19-20 | 22000653/12.04.20 22001792/ 12.05.20 | 155620 490000 | 292/19-20 | VG30 = 1864.55 kg | 12+4=16 | 4493 |
RS1 = 215.26 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 448.38 kg | ||||||||
| 10 | 182/21 | 14863/19-20 | 22000655/12.04.20 | 415000 | 274/19-20 | VG30 = 1589.67 kg | 10+5=15 | 4213 |
RS1 = 207.185 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 640.39 kg | ||||||||
| 11 | 158/21 | 17247/18-19 | 22000635/12.04.20 | 199922 | 265/19-20 | VG30 = 788.62 kg | 5+3=8 | 2247 |
RS1 = 102.77 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 317.68 kg | ||||||||
| 12 | 184/21 | 64350/19-20 | 22001789/ 12.05.20 | 300000 | 273/19-20 | VG30 = 632.22 kg | 4+2=6 | 1685 |
RS1 = 82.39 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 254.69 kg | ||||||||
| 13 | 193/21 | 75966/19-20 | 22000672 /11.05.20 | 587372 | 272/19-20 | VG30 = 1258.19 kg | 8+4=12 | 3370 |
RS1 = 163.98 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 506.86 kg | ||||||||
| 14 | 194/21 | 64348/19-20 | 22001780/ 11.05.20 | 599096 | 277/19-20 | VG30 = 2156.95 kg | 14+6=20 | 5617 |
RS1 = 281.12 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 868.91 kg | ||||||||
| 15 | 239/21 | 64347/19-20 | 22001961/ 26.02.21 | 1404470 | 344/19-20 | VG30 = 4431 kg | 28+13= 41 | 11514 |
RS1 = 577.5 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 1785 kg | ||||||||
| 16 | 192/21 | 79695/19-20 | 22001802/ 12.05.20 22001947/ 10.08.20 | 398799 400000 | 303/19-20 | VG30 = 1588.30 kg | 10+5=15 | 4213 |
| RS1 = 206.96 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 639.68 kg | ||||||||
| 17 | 189/21 | 49225/19-20 | 22001946/ 10.08.20 | 498873 | 294/19-20 | VG30 = 1325.92 kg | 9+4=13 | 3651 |
RS1 = 172.81 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 534.14 kg | ||||||||
| 18 | 183/21 | 66378/19-20 | 22001790/ 12.05.202222000656/12.04.20 | 400000 97542 | 287/ 19-20 | VG30 = 1020.50 kg | 6+3=9 | 2528 |
RS1 = 411.10 kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 133 kg | ||||||||
| 19 | 199/21 | 75991/19-20 | 22001861/ 10.08.20 | 399458 | 259/ 19-20 | VG30 = 3040.15 kg | 19+2=21 | 5898 |
RS1 = 291.60 kg | ||||||||
| 20 | 200/21 | 75986/ 19-20 | 22001855/ 10.08.20 | 398976 | 296/ 19-20 | VG30 = 3139.59 kg | 20+2=22 | 6178 |
RS1 = 282.41kg | ||||||||
| 21 | 179/21 | 60498/ 19-20 | 22001859/ 10.08.20 | 489489 | 281/ 19-20 | VG30 = 3671.24kg | 23+2=25 | 7021 |
RS1 = 342.81kg | ||||||||
| 22 | 180/21 | 71893/ 19-20 | 22001969/ 08.07.20 22001968/ 10.08.20 | 350000 345844 | 280/ 19-20 | VG30 = 1405.20kg | 9+4=13 | 3651 |
| RS1 = 183.15kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 566.10kg | ||||||||
| 23 | 185/21 | 14872/ 19-20 | 22001948/ 10.08.20 | 499201 | 286/ 19-20 | VG30 = 1930.65kg | 12+6=18 | 5055 |
| RS1 =251.63kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 777.75kg | ||||||||
| 24 | 198/21 | 75979/ 19-20 | 22001858/ 10.08.20 | 299812 | 271/ 19-20 | VG30 = 2384.06kg | 15+1=16 | 4493 |
RS1 = 221.85kg | ||||||||
| 25 | 235/21 | 66448/ 19-20 | 22001954/ 10.11.20 22001955/ 10.11.20 | 200000 488193 | 210/ 19-20 | VG30 = 1396.82kg | 9+4=13 | 3651 |
RS1 = 182.05kg | ||||||||
SS1 = 562.70kg |
Total excess amount paid = Rs. 1,18,795
(Audit Enquiry No.54/30.10.21)
1-48 Construction of She Lodge - action taken to complete and regularise the project work should be intimated.
| Project number | 286/21 |
| Project | She Lodge |
| Technical Sanction | 115510/18-19 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2018-19/8133 Dtd. 15.02.19 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 40,00,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Sahad. N.M |
| Contract Rate | Rs. 32,80,533.47 |
| Contract Agreement | 09/AE/LSGD/PZR/19-20 Dtd. 29.05.19 |
| M-Book | 375/19-20, 353/19-20 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22001951/30.10.20 = 6,80,379 (DF G) 22002057/26.03.21 = 3,00,000 (DF G) 22002120/29.03.21 = 6,01,875 (DF G) |
The State Government approved and issued guidelines for setting up She Lodges vide order G.O.(Rt) No.111/20/LSGD dated 24.07.2020. However, the Grama Panchayat appears to have conceived such a project as early as in the financial year 2018-19. The completion period of the project work was 12 months. The project work, for which a contract was entered into on 29.05.19, has not been completed to date. Action taken to complete the project work as per the contract and to regularise it within Government guidelines should be intimated in the first reply to this report.
(Audit Enquiry 55/30.10.21)
1-49 Clean Pazhayannur Green Pazhayannur - audited receipts and expenditure accounts not produced for verification
With the objective of ensuring healthy development in a hygienic environment, the society "Clean Pazhayannur Green Pazhayannur" was registered on 04.07.18 under Reg. No. TSR/TC/375/2018 Dt.04.07.18 under the provisions of the Travancore-Cochin Literary, Scientific and Charitable Societies Registration Act, 1955 (12th of 1955), and commenced functioning, with the aim of transforming Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat into a fully clean village and planning waste management and treatment programmes. As per the Memorandum of Association of the society, the President of the Grama Panchayat shall be the President of the society, the Vice President shall be the Vice President of the society, and the Secretary shall be the Convener of the society. The Memorandum of Association also states that the responsibility for carrying out the day-to-day affairs of the society, as directed by the Governing Body, shall vest in the Secretary of the Grama Panchayat, who is the Convener.
The above-mentioned by-laws stipulate that a person who is not a member of the Governing Body shall be elected as Auditor by the general body to audit the receipts and expenditure accounts of the society, and that the Auditor shall examine the receipts and expenditure accounts before the annual general meeting and hand them over to the Convener for presentation at the general meeting.
Accordingly, though the audited receipts and expenditure accounts of the society from 04.07.2018 to 31.03.21 were called for production for verification vide Audit Enquiry 47/29-10-2021, none of these records were produced for verification.
The activities of the society, which is under the direct control of the Grama Panchayat, are included among the duties fixed as mandatory functions of Grama Panchayats in the Third Schedule of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act. Hence the activity report of the society and its audited receipts and expenditure accounts from 04.07.2018 to 31.03.21 should be included in the first reply to this report and produced for verification.
(Audit Enquiry No.47/29-10-21)
Part -2
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the receipt side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(1) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
2-1 Profession Tax not collected in full.
Profession Tax has not been collected in full from the following employees. The shortfall in Profession Tax collected should be recovered by taking action using the powers conferred under Section 243 of the Panchayat Raj Act. Failing that, it will be treated as the liability of the officer concerned and charge proceedings initiated.
| Sl. No. | Name | Establishment | Half Year | Income | Tax that ought to have been collected | Tax collected | Shortfall |
| 1 | Saroon MS, M.R.A. | Madura Micro Finance, Pazhayannur | Second half-year | 76392 | 750 | 450 | 300 |
| 2 | Prasanth S, MRA | Madura Micro Finance, Pazhayannur | Second half-year | 75356 | 750 | 180 | 570 |
| Total | 870 | ||||||
2-2 Licence fee not collected in full
As per Schedule III, Rule (18) of the Rules under G.O(P) No.80/2017/LSGD dated 31.10.2017, S.R.O.No.674/2017 of the Local Self Government Department, the maximum fee leviable based on horsepower has been fixed for machines operated by electricity. The maximum licence fee leviable based on the horsepower of machines has not been collected from the following establishments. The shortfall in fee should be recovered and intimated to audit. Failing that, it will be treated as the liability of the officer concerned and charge proceedings initiated.
| Sl. No. | License Register No. | Establishment | Capital | Horse power of machinery | Fee to be collected | Fee collected | Shortfall |
| 1 | 129 | Nila Metals Private Limited | 40000000 | 1368 | 18680 | 13680 | 5000 |
| 2 | 277 | M.S. Angels Foams Private Limited | 1000000 | 106 | 2500 | 2000 | 500 |
| Total | 5500 | ||||||
Part -3
Audit observations relating to clear loss on the expenditure side
[Special part of the Audit Report under Section 16 of the KLFA Act 1994 and Rule 19(2) of the KLFA Rules 1996]
3-1 The amount of Rs. 17,655 drawn in excess from the Consolidated Fund should be refunded to the Consolidated Fund.
| Project number | 229/21 |
| Project | Footpath on Thiruvilwamala Road |
| Technical Sanction | 79755/2017-18 |
| Estimate Number | 2017/12863 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 14,54,680 |
| Contractor | Sri. K.A. Muhammed Basheer |
| Contract Rate | 12,52,258.18 |
| Contract Agreement | 61/AE/LSGD/PZR/2017-18 Dtd. 21.12.17 |
| M-Book | 26/2018-19 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22002127/29.03.21 = 5,63,684 ( CFC Grant) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work (after the first part bill) | 546029 | |
| (+) Retention (deducted from the part bill) | 17655 | |
| Total amount drawn | 563684 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 5460 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 5460 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 10920 | |
| Total deductions | 21840 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 541844 |
Details of the first part bill passed and paid to the contractor in 2018-19 are given below.
| Value of work (drawn from Treasury) | 706229 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 7062 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 7062 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 14124 | |
| (-) Retention 2.5% | 17655 | |
| Total deductions | 45903 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 660326 |
Thus, while passing and paying the first part bill to the contractor in 2018-19, the retention amount (Rs. 17,655) drawn from the Treasury (from the Consolidated Fund) was deposited in the Treasury account of the Secretary. While paying the final bill, this amount was again drawn from the Consolidated Fund and paid to the contractor. The Rs. 17,655 thus drawn in excess from the Consolidated Fund should be refunded to the Consolidated Fund and the details included in the first reply to this report.
(Audit Enquiry 37/29.10.21)
3-2 Kunnampully Anganwadi-Thoppilkulam Road - excess amount allowed to contractor.
| Project number | 17/21 |
| Project | Kunnampully Anganwadi-Thoppilkulam Road |
| Technical Sanction | 9554/2020-21 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2020-21/52187 Dtd. 12.05.20 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 4,00,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Shameer. K.M |
| Contract Rate | Estimate Rate |
| Contract Agreement | 08/AE/LSGD/PZR/2020-21 Dtd. 13.07.20 |
| M-Book | 346/19-20 |
| Voucher Number, Amount | 22001958/11.01.21 = 3,99,401 ( MG R) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work | 356608 | |
| (+) GST 12% | 42793 | |
| Total | 399401 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 2566 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 2566 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 5132 | |
| (-) Value of 22 empty barrels @281 | 6182 | |
| Total deductions | 16446 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 382955 |
However, the final bill was paid without effecting the required deductions, resulting in excess payment to the contractor. Details are given below.
| Total value of work | 356608 | |
| (+) GST 12% | 42793 | |
| Total | 399401 | |
| (-) Income Tax 0.75% | 2675 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3566 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 7132 | |
| (-) Value of 22 empty barrels @281 | 6182 | |
| Total deductions | 19555 | |
| Amount payable to contractor | 379846 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 382955 | |
| Excess | 3109 |
This excess expenditure of Rs. 3,109 should be recovered either from the contractor or from the Engineer who wrongly passed and allowed the amount while sanctioning the final bill, and the details included in the first reply to this report.
(Audit Enquiry No.38/29.10.21)
3-3 Excess expenditure due to bill amount allowed to contractors without recovering the value of empty barrels
Estimates for various road works in the Grama Panchayat have been prepared including the rate for packed bitumen. However, while allowing the final bill, the amount was allowed without either the empty barrels being returned or their value being recovered from the contractor. As a result of allowing the amount in this manner, the contractors came to receive more than what they were entitled to. Details of one such work are given below.
| Project number | 190/21 |
| Project | Re-tarring of Malampathy-Thirumani Road |
| Technical Sanction | 24145/2019-20 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2019-20/44171 Dtd. 23.07.19 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 3,40,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Roy. K.M |
| Contract Rate | Estimate Rate |
| Contract Agreement | 16/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20 Dtd. 25.10.19 |
| M-Book | 268/2019-20 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22000637/12.04.20 = 3,39,470 ( MG R) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work | 303098 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 36372 | |
| Total | 339470 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 6062 | |
| Total deductions | 12124 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 327346 |
As per the entry on Page 27 of the M-Book, 2605.32 kg of S65 bitumen and 238.86 kg of RS1 bitumen were used for this work. The estimate includes the market rate of Packed Bitumen. The value of the empty barrels should therefore have been recovered from the contractor while allowing the final bill. However, the amount was allowed to the contractor without recovering the value of the empty barrels (S65 bitumen 2605.32/156 = 17 barrels, RS1 bitumen 238.86/182 = 2 barrels, total 19 barrels). As a result, the contractor came to be allowed an excess amount. Details are tabulated below.
| Total value of work | 303098 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 36372 | |
| Total | 339470 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3031 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 6062 | |
| (-) Value of 19 empty barrels @ 238/each | 4522 | |
| (-) 18% GST on the value of empty barrels | 814 | |
| Total deductions | 17460 | |
| Amount payable to contractor | 322010 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 327346 | |
| Excess amount paid | 5336 |
As described above, since the amount was allowed to the contractors without recovering the value of empty Packed Bitumen barrels, an excess amount came to be paid to the contractors in each of the works tabulated below (including the above work). The excess amount paid should be recovered from the contractors or from the Assistant Engineer who wrongly allowed the amount, and the details intimated.
| Sl. No. | Project | Technical Sanction Number | Voucher number | Amount | M-Book | Bitumen Requirement | Number of Barrels | Value of barrel @238/each including 18% GST |
| 1 | 190/21 | 24145/19-20 | 22000637/12.04.20 | 339470 | 268/19-20 | VG30 = 2605.32 kg | 17+2 = 19 | 5336 |
| RS 1 = 238.86 kg | ||||||||
| 2 | 188/21 | 14800/19-20 | 22000636/12.04.20 | 299796 | 266/19-20 | VG30 =2314.9 kg | 15+1 = 16 | 4493 |
| RS1 =207.23 kg | ||||||||
| 3 | 159/21 | 49075/18-19 | 22000659/12.04.20 | 349606 | 260/19-20 | VG30 = 2937.69 kg | 19+2 =21 | 5898 |
| RS1 =282.72 kg | ||||||||
| 4 | 164/21 | 113022/18-19 | 22000661/12.04.20 | 349624 | 282/19-20 | VG30 = 2686.35 kg | 17+2=19 | 5336 |
| RS1 =283.64 kg | ||||||||
| 5 | 201/21 | 66202/19-20 | 22000638/12.04.20 | 299698 | 267/19-20 | VG30 = 2512.03 kg | 16+2=18 | 5055 |
| RS1 = 248.72 kg | ||||||||
| 6 | 157/21 | 31864/18-19 | 22000658/12.04.20 | 279520 | 263/19-20 | VG30 =2347.89 kg | 15+2=17 | 4774 |
| RS1 =223.09 kg | ||||||||
| 7 | 186/21 | 14877/19-20 | 22000657/12.04.20 | 498735 | 279/19-20 | VG30 =1799.09 kg | 12+5=17 | 4774 |
| RS1 =724.75 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =234.47 kg | ||||||||
| 8 | 178/21 | 66416/19-20 | 22000660/12.04.20 | 297538 | 283/19-20 | VG30 =1613.07 kg | 10+3=13 | 3651 |
| RS1 =181.43 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =302.35 kg | ||||||||
| 9 | 191/21 | 66463/19-20 | 22000653/12.04.20 22001792/ 12.05.20 | 155620 490000 | 292/19-20 | VG30 =1864.55 kg | 12+4=16 | 4493 |
| RS1 =215.26 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =448.38 kg | ||||||||
| 10 | 182/21 | 14863/19-20 | 22000655/12.04.20 | 415000 | 274/19-20 | VG30 =1589.67 kg | 10+5=15 | 4213 |
| RS1 =207.185 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =640.39 kg | ||||||||
| 11 | 158/21 | 17247/18-19 | 22000635/12.04.20 | 199922 | 265/19-20 | VG30 =788.62 kg | 5+3=8 | 2247 |
| RS1 =102.77 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =317.68 kg | ||||||||
| 12 | 184/21 | 64350/19-20 | 22001789/ 12.05.20 | 300000 | 273/19-20 | VG30 =632.22 kg | 4+2=6 | 1685 |
| RS1 =82.39 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =254.69 kg | ||||||||
| 13 | 193/21 | 75966/19-20 | 22000672 /11.05.20 | 587372 | 272/19-20 | VG30 =1258.19 kg | 8+4=12 | 3370 |
| RS1 =163.98 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =506.86 kg | ||||||||
| 14 | 194/21 | 64348/19-20 | 22001780/ 11.05.20 | 599096 | 277/19-20 | VG30 =2156.95kg | 14+6=20 | 5617 |
| RS1 =281.12 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =868.91 kg | ||||||||
| 15 | 239/21 | 64347/19-20 | 22001961/ 26.02.21 | 1404470 | 344/19-20 | VG30 =4431 kg | 28+13= 41 | 11514 |
| RS1 =577.5 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =1785 kg | ||||||||
| 16 | 192/21 | 79695/19-20 | 22001802/ 12.05.20 22001947/ 10.08.20 | 398799 400000 | 303/19-20 | VG30 =1588.30kg | 10+5=15 | 4213 |
| RS1 = 206.96 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =639.68 kg | ||||||||
| 17 | 189/21 | 49225/19-20 | 22001946/ 10.08.20 | 498873 | 294/19-20 | VG30 =1325.92 kg | 9+4=13 | 3651 |
| RS1 =172.81 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =534.14 kg | ||||||||
| 18 | 183/21 | 66378/19-20 | 22001790/ 12.05.202222000656/12.04.20 | 400000 97542 | 287/ 19-20 | VG30 =1020.50 kg | 6+3=9 | 2528 |
| RS1 =411.10 kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =133 kg | ||||||||
| 19 | 199/21 | 75991/19-20 | 22001861/ 10.08.20 | 399458 | 259/ 19-20 | VG30 =3040.15 kg | 19+2=21 | 5898 |
| RS1 =291.60 kg | ||||||||
| 20 | 200/21 | 75986/ 19-20 | 22001855/ 10.08.20 | 398976 | 296/ 19-20 | VG30 =3139.59 kg | 20+2=22 | 6178 |
| RS1 =282.41kg | ||||||||
| 21 | 179/21 | 60498/ 19-20 | 22001859/ 10.08.20 | 489489 | 281/ 19-20 | VG30 =3671.24kg | 23+2=25 | 7021 |
| RS1 =342.81kg | ||||||||
| 22 | 180/21 | 71893/ 19-20 | 22001969/ 08.07.20 22001968/ 10.08.20 | 350000 345844 | 280/ 19-20 | VG30=1405.20kg | 9+4=13 | 3651 |
| RS1 = 183.15kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =566.10kg | ||||||||
| 23 | 185/21 | 14872/ 19-20 | 22001948/ 10.08.20 | 499201 | 286/ 19-20 | VG30=1930.65kg | 12+6=18 | 5055 |
| RS1 =251.63kg | ||||||||
| SS1 =777.75kg | ||||||||
| 24 | 198/21 | 75979/ 19-20 | 22001858/ 10.08.20 | 299812 | 271/ 19-20 | VG30=2384.06kg | 15+1=16 | 4493 |
| RS1 =221.85kg | ||||||||
| 25 | 235/21 | 66448/ 19-20 | 22001954/ 10.11.20 22001955/ 10.11.20 | 200000 488193 | 210/ 19-20 | VG30=1396.82kg | 9+4=13 | 3651 |
| RS1=182.05kg | ||||||||
| SS1=562.70kg |
Total excess amount paid = Rs. 1,18,795
(Audit Enquiry No.54/30.10.21)
3-4 Re-tarring of Parackal-Kunnampully Road - excess expenditure due to amount allowed to contractor without effecting tender rebate
| Project number | 200/21 |
| Project | Re-tarring of Parackal-Kunnampully Road |
| Technical Sanction | 75986/2019-20 |
| Technical Sanction Order | LSGD/TS/2019-20/44730 Dtd. 13.10.19 |
| Technical Sanction Amount | Rs. 4,00,000 |
| Contractor | Sri. Prakashan. K.V |
| Contract Rate | 1% less than estimate |
| Contract Agreement | 51/AE/LSGD/PZR/2019-20 Dtd. 18.12.19 |
| M-Book | 296/2019-20 |
| Voucher number, amount | 22001855/10.08.20 = 3,98,976 ( MG R) |
Details of payment of the final bill of the above work are given below.
| Total value of work | 356229 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 42747 | |
| Total | 398976 | |
| (-) Income Tax 1% | 3562 | |
| (-) Welfare Fund contribution 1% | 3562 | |
| (-) GST 2% | 7124 | |
| Total deductions | 14248 | |
| Amount paid to contractor | 384728 |
However, while allowing the amount to the contractor, the 1% tender rebate was not deducted. Details of the excess expenditure resulting from this are given below.
| Total value of work | 356229 | |
| (-) Tender rebate 1% | 3562 | |
| Balance | 352667 | |
| (+) 12% GST | 42320 | |
| Total expenditure permissible for the work | 394987 | |
| Total amount spent on the work | 398976 | |
| Excess expenditure | 3989 |
This excess expenditure should be recovered from the contractor or from the Assistant Engineer who wrongly allowed the amount, and the details intimated.
Part -4
General information and audit review
4-1 Utilisation of funds received for joint projects
| Institution providing share | O.B. | Year in which amount received | Amount received | Name of the project | Expenditure | Balance |
| Block Panchayat | 1586279 | |||||
| Block Panchayat | 2020-2021 | 153600 | Comprehensive Vegetable Cultivation Development - General (Project Number 167/21) | 153600 | 0 | |
| 872 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart (Project Number 220/21) | 0 | 872 | |||
| 2020-2021 | 710000 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart (Project Number 225/21) | 710000 | 0 | ||
| 2020-2021 | 40000 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart - ST (Project Number 378/21) | 40000 | 0 | ||
| 2020-2021 | 880000 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart - SC (Project Number 143/21) | 880000 | 0 | ||
| 197000 | Making houses habitable - ST (Project Number 307/21) | 0 | 197000 | |||
| 72350 | Dairy Development (DFI) | 0 | 72350 | |||
| 174807 | Block TSP Share | 0 | 174807 | |||
| 90675 | Comprehensive Vegetable Cultivation Development (Project Number - 66/19) | 0 | 90675 | |||
| 100000 | Ashraya Block Contribution | 0 | 100000 | |||
| 240575 | Block Share - LIFE Mission Housing Scheme | 0 | 240575 | |||
| Total | 1586279 | 2659879 | 1783600 | 876279 | ||
| District Panchayat | 0 | |||||
| District Panchayat | 2020-2021 | 661650 | Incentive for milk to dairy farmers (Project Number 75/21) | 661650 | 0 | |
| 2020-2021 | 3160000 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart - General (Project Number 79/21) | 3160000 | 0 | ||
| 2020-2021 | 25000 | Palliative Care (Project Number 138/21) | 25000 | 0 | ||
| 2020-2021 | 1981556 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart (Project Number 225/21) | 1981556 | 0 | ||
| 2020-2021 | 424049 | LIFE Mission housing scheme - share set apart - SC (Project Number 143/21) | 424049 | 0 | ||
| Total | 0 | 3846650 | 3846650 | 0 |
4-2 Details of Amounts Given for Deposit Works
None.
4-3 Mobilisation Advance Given
None
4-4 Loan/loan repayment
| (i). Details of loan/utilisation/defaults | ||||||
| Loan received in 2017-18 | Purpose | Amount spent within the stipulated period | Loan amount | Balance remaining to be utilised | Information regarding achievement of objectives | |
| HUDCO Loan | To construct and provide houses for the houseless | 4000018 | 4062703 | 62685 | 60 houses constructed and handed over | |
| (ii). Loan/loan repayment | ||||||
| Name/Purpose of Loan | Order Number/Date | Loan amount (including interest) | Amount remaining to be repaid at the beginning of the year (including interest) | Amount repaid during the current year | Amount remaining to be repaid at year end (including interest) | |
| Principal | Interest | |||||
| HUDCO Loan | _ | 32722822 | 29504017 | _ | _ | 32722822 |
4-5 Fixed deposits
| 1 | Fixed deposit existing at the beginning of the year | 2442926 | |
| 2 | Amount deposited during the current year | 0 | |
| 3 | Interest | 58402 | |
| 3 | Total | 2501328 | |
| 4 | Amount withdrawn during the current year | 0 | |
| 5 | Fixed deposit remaining at the end of the year | 2501328 | |
| 6 | Details of fixed deposits remaining at the end of the year | Details of deposit | Amount |
| 1. Thrissur District Co-operative Bank - Pazhayannur | Account Number - 80012284084 | 850693 | |
| 2. Thrissur District Co-operative Bank - Pazhayannur | Account Number - 80011867690 | 500000 | |
| 3. Punjab National Bank - Pazhayannur | Account Number - 433500PU00013231 | 1150635 |
Details of Rs. 1000/- under Investment Preference Shares have not been furnished for verification.
4-6 Audit recovery
| Report year | Part/Paragraph | Amount recovered | Name and designation of the person who remitted | Receipt Number/Date |
| 2017-2018 | 2-3(3) | 1650 | Head Master Narayana English Medium School, Vadakkethara | 120050500010 26.08.2020 |
| 2017-2018 | 1-16 | 2700 | Head Master Narayana English Medium School, Vadakkethara | 120050500010 26.08.2020 |
| 2018-2019 | 3(1) | 25326 | Assistant Engineer LSGD Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | 120050103007 05.11.2020 |
| 2018-2019 | 3(1) | 14700 | Assistant Engineer LSGD Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | 120050103187 13.11.2020 |
| 2018-2019 | 3(2) | 14672 | Assistant Engineer LSGD Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | 120050103188 13.11.2020 |
| Total | 59048 | |||
4-7 Details of paragraphs included in the consolidated audit report
Not available
4-8 Details of charge/surcharge proceedings
Not available
4-9 Audit Review
A) Summary
| Total receipts for the audit year | 14,56,40,874 |
| Total expenditure for the audit year | 16,12,75,290 |
| Loss under receipt heads | 6370 |
| Loss under expenditure heads/ amount not accepted in audit | 1,43,548 |
| Amount held under objection in audit | 38,49,558 |
(B). Details of clear loss sustained to the Panchayat Fund
| Paragraph number | Amount lost | Name and designation of the person responsible | Permanent address of the person responsible | |
| Chargeable amount | Surchargeable amount | |||
| 2-1 | 870 | 55. R. Shyamkumaran, Secretary | Nellikkunnil House, Koliyakkode, Venjaramoodu P.O., Thiruvananthapuram | |
| 2-2 | 5500 | R. Shyamkumaran, Secretary | Nellikkunnil House, Koliyakkode, Venjaramoodu P.O., Thiruvananthapuram | |
| 3-1 | 17,655 | Sri. Sunilkumar. K, Assistant Engineer | Kizhakkevila House, Sreebuddha Line, Kolazhy P.O., Thrissur | |
| 3-2 | 3,109 | Sri. Sunilkumar. K, Assistant Engineer | Kizhakkevila House, Sreebuddha Line, Kolazhy P.O., Thrissur | |
| 3-3 | 1,18,795 | Sri. Sunilkumar. K, Assistant Engineer | Kizhakkevila House, Sreebuddha Line, Kolazhy P.O., Thrissur | |
| 3-4 | 3,989 | Sri. Sunilkumar. K, Assistant Engineer | Kizhakkevila House, Sreebuddha Line, Kolazhy P.O., Thrissur | |
| Total | 6370 | 1,43,548 | ||
Amount held under objection in audit
| Paragraph number | Amount (Rs.) | Name and designation of the person responsible |
| 1-31 | 15,65,800 | Sri. Joseph John Therattil, Agricultural Officer |
| 4,55,400 | Smt. Manju. P.S, Agricultural Officer | |
| 7,42,800 | Sri. Aditya Mohan, Agricultural Officer | |
| 1-32 | 1,76,715 | Smt. Manju. P.S, Agricultural Officer |
| 5,01,285 | Sri. Dibin, Agricultural Officer | |
| 1,86,750 | Sri. Aditya Mohan, Agricultural Officer | |
| 1-33 | 24,180 | Sri. R. Shyamkumaran, Secretary |
| 1-44 | 1,96,628 | Sri. Sunilkumar. K, Assistant Engineer |
| Total | 38,49,558 |
(C) Details of loss sustained to the Central and State Governments and other institutions
None
(D) Cases requiring further enquiry to ascertain the loss
None
(E) Name and permanent address of persons responsible for the objection mentioned in the report
| Name and designation of the person responsible | Present address | Permanent address |
| Sri. Joseph John Therattil, Agricultural Officer | District Soil Testing Lab, Agri Complex, Chembukkavu, Thrissur | Therattil House, Mundathikode West, Thrissur |
Smt. Manju. P.S, Agricultural Officer | Agricultural Officer, Maranchery Grama Panchayat | Pandiyattu House, Souparnika, Choolissery P.O |
| Sri. Dibin, Agricultural Officer | Agricultural Officer, Panjal Grama Panchayat | Moolanthanath House, Kattilappoovam, Pullamkandam, Thrissur. |
| Sri. Aditya Mohan, Agricultural Officer | Agricultural Officer, Avanoor Grama Panchayat | Elanjipillil House, Thiruvankulam P.O. |
| Sri. Sunilkumar. K, Assistant Engineer | Assistant Engineer, Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat | Kizhakkevila House, Sreebuddha Lane, Kolazhy PO, Thrissur |
| Sri. R. Shyamkumaran, Secretary | Secretary | Nellikkunnil House, Koliyakkode, Venjaramoodu P.O., Thiruvananthapuram |
4-10 Details of paragraphs pending settlement
| Audit Year | Details of the latest correspondence issued from this department |
| 77-78 | L.F.T.S.2-906/11/18.7.11 |
| 80-81 | -do- |
| 81-82 | -do- |
| 82-83 | -do- |
| 83-84 | -do- |
| 84-85 | -do- |
| 86-87& 87-88 | -do- |
| 88-89 | |
| 89-90 | -do- |
99-00 to 01-02 | L.F.T.10/1079/2003.Dt.9.4.04/14.9.04 |
90-91 to 95-96 | L.F.T.P.10/304/2008.Dt.9.7.09 |
| 96-97 Expenditure | L.F.T.P.4-185/14, 13.3.14/5.4.14, 10 |
| 97-98 Expenditure | L.F.T.P.4-185/14, 13.3.14/5.4.14, 16 |
| 97-98 Receipts | L.F.T.P.4-185/14, 13.3.14/5.4.14, 05 |
| 98-99 Receipts | L.F.T.P.4-185/14, 13.3.14/5.4.14, 03 |
| 98-99 Expenditure | L.F.T.P.4-185/14, 13.3.14/5.4.14, 42 |
| 99-2000, 2000-2001 (People's Planning) | L.F.T.P-4/185 Dt.13.3.14/5.4.14, 14 |
| 99-2000 | L.F.T.P-4/185 Dt.13.3.14/5.4.14, 10 |
| 2000-2001 | L.F.T.P-4/185 Dt.13.3.14/5.4.14, 11 |
| 2001-02 | L.F.T.P-4/185 Dt.13.3.14/5.4.14, 15 |
| 98-99 | L.F.T.P.10-307/08 Dt.14.7.09 |
| 99-2000 | L.F.T.P.10-308/08 Dt.14.7.09 |
| 2000-2001 | L.F.T.P.10-309/08 Dt.14.7.09 |
| 2001-2002 | |
| 2002-2003 | L.F.T.P.10-1265/08 Dt.7.9.09 |
| 2003-2004 | L.F.T.P.10-1266/08 Dt.7.9.09 |
| 2004-05 | L.F.T.P.10-195/09 Dt.25.6.10 |
| 2005-06 | L.F.T.P.10-1348/09 Dt.28.7.10 |
| 2006-2007 | L.F.T.P.10-1336/09 Dt.29.7.10/10.12.10 |
| 2007-08 | L.F.T.P.-4.956/12 Dt.2.8.12/5.11.12 |
| 2008-2009 | L.F.T.P.4-957/12 Dt.2.8.12/5.11.12 |
| 2009-2010 | L.F.T.P.4.958/12 Dt.2.8.12/5.11.12 |
| 2010-2011 | L.F.T.P.4.959/12 Dt.2.8.12/5.11.12 |
| 2011-12 | L.F.T.P.4.1151/13 Dt.4.12.13/5.2.14 |
| 2012-13 | L.F.T.P.4.631/14 Dt.8.10.14/8.12.14 |
| 2013-14 | L.F.T.(P4)186/15 Dt, 7-5-2015 |
| 2014-15 | K.S.A.T.S.R./P4/996/16, Dt.25.06.2016 |
| 2015-16 | K.S.A.T.S.R./P4/1934/16, Dt.5.11.16/5.12.16 |
| 2016-17 | K.S.A.T.S.R./P4/1111/2017, Dt.30.08.17 |
| 2017-18 | K.S.A.T.S.R./P4/771/2019, Dt.01.06.19 |
| 2018-19 | K.S.A.T.S.R.-P4-1499/2019, Dt.06.12.2019 |
| 2019-20 | K.S.A.T.S.R.-P12-61/2022, Dt.01.07.2022 |
Urgent action should be taken to settle the objections in the remaining reports.
Deputy Director,
District Audit Office,
Thrissur
Annexure-1
Audit Certificate
I certify that I have examined the Annual Financial Statement for the year, in accordance with the audit standards and laws and rules applicable to the department, subject to the auditing standards prescribed by the Comptroller & Auditor General for the audit of Panchayat Raj institutions under Section 4 of the Kerala Local Fund Audit Act, 1994 and Section 215 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, and following the audit methods and software arrangements prepared by the Special Committee constituted for streamlining the audit of Annual Financial Statements and approved by the department at its meeting held on 12.02.2021. I certify that, except for the observations pointed out in my report, the Annual Financial Statement of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, for the year 2020-2021 presents the receipts and expenditure accounts fairly.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department
Annexure-2
Utilisation Certificate of Grants
I certify the utilisation of grants of Pazhayannur Grama Panchayat, Thrissur District, for the year 2020-2021, subject to the observations on utilisation of grants included in this report, after verification as detailed in Annexure-1, based on the details in the Grant Statement furnished and certified by the institution as per G.O.(Rt) 16/2021/LSGD dated 23.01.2021.
Deputy Director
District Audit Office, Thrissur
Kerala State Audit Department

















